The Editor Issue (Or: What makes an editor “modified” [and, as a result, not able to have its projects uploaded onto Scratch]?)

YesterdaysTomSawyer

Up, up, and away! (EDIT: Oh wow, page 4.)

Last edited by YesterdaysTomSawyer (March 24, 2022 18:55:41)

tyjinw1

stop spamming

check out my fun games
just idle fun (my idle virus + my idle balls)
idle virus (VERY IMPROVED) <—- a remix
idle cells
generators
!!! <– cloud clicking game
live chat <– i want the length to go crazy
and also check out my profile
and put your url milestones here

Maximouse

tyjinw1 wrote:
stop spamming

If you're responding to the post above yours, it's a bump.

This is Maximouse's signature. Learn more about signatures.

YesterdaysTomSawyer

Maximouse wrote:
tyjinw1 wrote:
stop spamming
If you're responding to the post above yours, it's a bump.

Yes, thanks for clarifying. Nevertheless, maybe I should bump a bit less frequently.

YesterdaysTomSawyer

Le bump has arrived.

YesterdaysTomSawyer

Chalenge Complete! Great View From Up Here

YesterdaysTomSawyer

Fly me to the moon…

YesterdaysTomSawyer

Collide

YesterdaysTomSawyer

Push

RubiksRocker

sharkode wrote:
TheGlassPenguin wrote:
TOS 4.4 does not apply to feature mods (such as TurboWarp). Projects made in feature mods can be uploaded to the Scratch site as long as they don't contain blocks are anything that is not in the vanilla editor.
I don't think so, TurboWarp technically violates Terms of Use, however, it's highly unlikely that ST is going to take any actions against it because
There are no way of knowing if the project is created with TurboWarp, it's not like every TurboWarp games has the text “TurboWarp” stamped onto it with large font
Even if they know, they will likely ignore it as TurboWarp is mostly harmless

I agree. However, TurboWarp is made by Scratch user @GarboMuffin. But does this mean that Browser Extensions are technically banned? There is a separate discussion about this here
I don't think you can get banned for it though, because after all, it is an external tool.

Last edited by RubiksRocker (April 14, 2022 18:46:35)

RubiksRocker
Cool Nerd - Rocker - Cuber - Coder - Shark Activist - Footballer
Support this suggestion for new Flip Horizontal, Vertical, and Diagonal blocks here!
Support this suggestion for the absolutely-essential Pineapple emoji here!

Fun_Cupcake_i81

RubiksRocker wrote:
But does this mean that Browser Extensions are technically banned? There is a separate discussion about this here
I don't think you can get banned for it though, because after all, it is an external tool.

Naming them on Scratch is banned, but using them isn't.

I support #ConsiderCollabs! Help save Scratch's unshared projects feature before it's too late!

FACT: This is not pseudoscience.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Hi! I'm Fun Cupcake and I sometimes come to the forums to ask questions or try and help out.

YesterdaysTomSawyer

Move outwards

ScolderCreations

The ST has the right to decide what all and any rules in the ToS mean when deciding user content’s fate, so it’s possible they don’t enforce this because they don’t think it’s reasonable. However, this rule does allow them to remove projects containing XSS.

YesterdaysTomSawyer

p
m
u
p u m B u m p
u
m
p

(EDIT: Aw man, I realized I made a slight mistake. I'll fix it in the next bump)

Last edited by YesterdaysTomSawyer (April 29, 2022 20:34:14)

lolecksdeehaha

My take on this: A modified editor would be an editor like Snap! which has new blocks, and built off of Scratch's source code, haveing built new functionality in it. TurboWarp does not fit this description.

Beep boop. I am a robot, and this action was performed automatically. If you have any concerns, please contact the owner of this robot.

please stop hitting my ribcage with a metal bar

YesterdaysTomSawyer

lolecksdeehaha wrote:
My take on this: A modified editor would be an editor like Snap! which has new blocks, and built off of Scratch's source code, haveing built new functionality in it. TurboWarp does not fit this description.

That's an interesting approach. Whether or not Scratch Team shares it is something I'll be waiting to find out.

But how exactly does TurboWarp “not fit this description”?

YesterdaysTomSawyer

p
m
u
p m u B u m p
u
m
p

(Fixed the mistake.)

YesterdaysTomSawyer

p p
m m
u u
B
u u
m m
p p

YesterdaysTomSawyer

p p p
m m m
u u u
p m u B u m p
u u u
m m m
p p p

(EDIT: Wait, hold on, that didn't work for some reason.)

Last edited by YesterdaysTomSawyer (May 3, 2022 23:52:06)

YesterdaysTomSawyer

Let's try this again:

B u m p
u m
m u
p m u B

Discuss Scratch