The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

KangaCoder

Would something like this be important enough to be added onto 2.1 (or 7.1, for more general), or creating a new subtitle altogether? It basically is rejecting creating private accounts.

I guess I could see this being mentioned already in the Terms of Use against sharing accounts, but I think this gets suggested pretty often.

don't feed the trolls. feed yourself pizza cupcakez

.[1] [2] [3] [4]

KangaCoder • [he/him] • kæŋɡəˈ koʊdər

• Random Fun Facts: Male, Christian, US resident, EST time zone, Ravenclaw, likes Math and Science, learning German, knows HTML, Python and Java, loves chocolate, favorite color, possibly a kangaroo
• On the Main Site: Experienced Wikian, Camp Counselor, SWC Reviewer, SDS Helper, Forum Helper
• On the Forums: 2.65K+ forum posts
•

Project Ideas Directory 6.0 - need a project idea? Check it out!
• Check out some weird and cool Scratch pages!

CodingExpert2201

Reply for []

[* _ *]//This is Protecta, he protects my signature from evil qumunats.

(####)//This is Stickyer, he sticky’s my posts when necessary.

(ooooooooo)//This is BlockHelp, he answers posts when I’m away.

Elijah999999

ninjahanzo wrote:
I feel like “(insert something) upon warning/mute/ban” suggestions are getting more common.

As well as April Fools' pranks for the muted…

Pretty much only use the forums for save codes now.

Here is my Mario Maker (fan game) world code:
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/743192/?page=57#post-8009005

creeperyeettt

Elijah999999 wrote:
creeperyeettt wrote:
snipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnip
well im pretty sure its a majoraty (nice spelling mistake past me : D) thing
Pretty sure what is?

a person belives that scratch should not have LBTQ projects as it goes against their religious beliefs, though the majority of religions are fine with it so it makes sense to keep it

change [ IQ] by (-2)

potassium car: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/842403167/ (deltarune reference???)

<– click

creeperyeettt

KangaCoder wrote:
Would something like this be important enough to be added onto 2.1 (or 7.1, for more general), or creating a new subtitle altogether? It basically is rejecting creating private accounts.

I guess I could see this being mentioned already in the Terms of Use against sharing accounts, but I think this gets suggested pretty often.

private projects are already in the rejected list, and so is project collabs so i think we are fine as making a “private user that allows you to collab” has many red flags

change [ IQ] by (-2)

potassium car: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/842403167/ (deltarune reference???)

<– click

tpfoxcastro

"1.8 “Control mouse pointer” block
This block, and others, could be used to hide the mouse pointer or change the way the mouse pointer looks in a project. These blocks, however, do not significantly change the types of projects that can be created with Scratch; for more information, see this post. In addition, they may cause confusion to users, wondering where the mouse pointer went. A feature to control the mouse pointer, including freezing it or preventing it from leaving the project screen, poses similar confusing problems.

However, changing the look of the mouse pointer to one of the default mouse pointers is NOT rejected; you can discuss that on this topic.

hide mouse pointer :: looks

"
I agree with every rejected idea, except this one! If players are angry or confused because they don't see their mouse pointer just go play another game, scratch as thousands of them! I don't understand how having an oversized horrible custom mouse pointer is acceptable, but hiding it isn't! The worst part is that sometimes the custom mouse pointer goes bellow the original one, wich is terrible!

Elijah999999

tpfoxcastro wrote:
If players are angry or confused because they don't see their mouse pointer just go play another game…

But how? They don't know where their mouse-pointer is!

Pretty much only use the forums for save codes now.

Here is my Mario Maker (fan game) world code:
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/743192/?page=57#post-8009005

Za-Chary

KittyCatKayden wrote:
Add this to the thing about not changing the extension policy, stating that only trusting certain extensions is also rejected: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/7280265/

The existing description already takes this into account since it, and the browser extension policy itself, is very clear that there are no browser extensions are allowed to be mentioned. Alternatively, note that it is rejected to “improve” the extension policy — and allowing some browser extensions falls under “improving” the policy.

ninjahanzo wrote:
I feel like “(insert something) upon warning/mute/ban” suggestions are getting more common.

I'm confused as to what you mean. If they're rejected, feel free to elaborate further and/or post some links to bring it to my attention. If they're not rejected, let me know on my profile instead.

KangaCoder wrote:
Would something like this be important enough to be added onto 2.1 (or 7.1, for more general), or creating a new subtitle altogether? It basically is rejecting creating private accounts.

I guess I could see this being mentioned already in the Terms of Use against sharing accounts, but I think this gets suggested pretty often.

I feel like this lies under 2.1, 4.1, and 7.1 already. I'm not sure what about this suggestion is not already covered by those three entries.

Elijah999999 wrote:
tpfoxcastro wrote:
If players are angry or confused because they don't see their mouse pointer just go play another game…
But how? They don't know where their mouse-pointer is!

^ This.

This is my forum signature! On a forum post, it is okay for Scratchers to advertise in their forum signature. The signature is the stuff that shows up below the horizontal line on the post. It will show up on every post I make.

I was a Scratch Team member from May 10th 2019 to October 29th 2021.

my notebook | scratch team essay | accessibility essay

Sliverus

Sliverus wrote:
This could be a prominent new addition to the list. I have seen it many times in the forums.

And actually, upon further investigation, it seems it has been rejected by 2015.

Bumping this because I still think it should be added.

My Scratch Essays | Notebook | Generic Platformer Essay | Guide to Overcome Forum Addiction | Internets

Be moist

k7e

Sliverus wrote:
Sliverus wrote:
This could be a prominent new addition to the list. I have seen it many times in the forums.

And actually, upon further investigation, it seems it has been rejected by 2015.
Bumping this because I still think it should be added.

Aside from the posts you mentioned, it was suggested here, here, here, here, here, here, here. and here.

EDIT: Not all of them are closed, and the last one @Za-Chary actually rejected back in those glorious days when I could see that he removed part of a post.

Last edited by k7e (June 4, 2023 04:28:24)

@mythoslore was so much more obvious than @spookily

wikibro300000

theres a work around for when stop sighn clicked:

when [timer v] > (timer :: variables)
...
when green flag clicked
forever
set [timer v] to (timer)
end

l

Gamer_Logan819

What was so “difficult” to moderate about misc forums?

The forum boogeymen are out to get you

Sliverus

Gamer_Logan819 wrote:
What was so “difficult” to moderate about misc forums?

The purpose of the forum was kind of vague, so users would create plenty of topics that didn't fit the forum, like chat topics.

My Scratch Essays | Notebook | Generic Platformer Essay | Guide to Overcome Forum Addiction | Internets

Be moist

KittyCatKayden

creeperyeettt wrote:
(#7391)
private projects are already in the rejected list

How is it rejected? You can already create projects and never share them. Perfect if you don't want people looking at your stuff!

THIS THING NEEDS AN UPDATE-
Be high contrast

I have a little preference: Please don't make comments about my forum posts on my profile, projects or studios. However, it's fine if @Quackidee_, @Gamerules09 or @ImmortalJelly13 does that.
I use the browser Google Chrome, and I use the OS Windows 11.
Note that on my other accounts I (mostly) use Microsoft Edge.
Go to my profile
Go to my ocular profile
Go to my alt's profile
ฅ⁠^⁠•⁠ﻌ⁠•⁠^⁠ฅ
I LOVE Animal Crossing soooo much! I currently have every Animal Crossing game (including spin-offs) except the ones only in Japan.
I have a bunch of OCs, and most of them are based off my AC characters. However, I also have a (pretend) cat named Toodloo, and he's one of my main OCs(?) as well as Kitty Cat (from New Horizons), KittyCat (from New Leaf) and Meow.
New Leaf and Pocket Camp are my favorite AC games! (although I actually like all of them.) I wish I could have my real self move to the world of Animal Crossing!

when green flag clicked
Go to AC
define Go to AC
Escape the real world and move to AC

How did you find this? Tell me on my profile!
Anyways, here are some random links that used to be in a place where everyone could see them. I buried them here because I don't think everyone needs to see it.
Go to my postpercent profile
Go to my Scratch Forum Leaderboards page

Elijah999999

KittyCatKayden wrote:
creeperyeettt wrote:
(#7391)
private projects are already in the rejected list
How is it rejected? You can already create projects and never share them. Perfect if you don't want people looking at your stuff!

No, I think they mean private as in restricted sharing.

Pretty much only use the forums for save codes now.

Here is my Mario Maker (fan game) world code:
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/743192/?page=57#post-8009005

kinosaurs515

Za-Chary wrote:
-snip-

I have an update suggestion, the 1.11 does not count anymore, as it is now an option in . Please update it to state that!

Last edited by kinosaurs515 (June 10, 2023 04:32:46)

Hi! I'm kinosaurs515!

These are my trusty guardians who protect my signature from evil kumquats! If you want to create a guardian for me, tell me on my profile! I can creat one for you too!

(=I)()(K) // This is Kino. No one knows why, but he has a hole in his body. He is very protective and energetic, but just isn't brave.

-_- // This is Lance. Lance is tired all the time, but is still somewhat "helpful".

define AWAKE 
broadcast [ sleep] // This is Sleep. Just as the code says, as if he's awake, he will sleep.
(-_-)

when green flag clicked
forever
if <not <[bumped] = [true]>> then // This is Bump. He helps bump my posts. Because he is Bump, he has a bump on his head.
broadcast [ bump]
stop [ all]
end
say [Yay! It was bumped!] for (2) secs
C0-K
end

when I receive [ NOISE] // This is Nosy. He noses a lot with a long nose.
BE NOSY

define BE NOSY
Nose with nose until they say nose
o-----
|

medians

kinosaurs515 wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
-snip-
I have an update suggestion, the 1.11 does not count anymore, as it is now an option in (). Please update it to state that!

Do not name browser extensions, and that isn't affiliated with the Scratch Team, so no.
It's still rejected.

Medians bamboozled by 3.0 (version 3.0): https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/979822351/
hi875230163394: You're similar to valve in that you both hate a certain number…
Scratch 0.x, 1.x, 2.x, 3.x and LogoBlocks Archives
Bamboozlement: https://scratch.mit.edu/studios/33739789
Years on internet: 15 (soon 16)
medians: Oh god not this utc - 12 thing again..
Fun_Cupcake_i81: What, were you expecting not to see the utc - 12 thing again? THE UTC - 12 THIGN ALWAYS RETURNS. ALWAYS.
medians: I knew it would happen. I was the one who started it last year.
Fun_Cupcake_i81: Well then if you didn't want it back maybe you need to time travel to last year and fix that

Oh wait if you could time travel I think we all know exactly when you would go-
user1: That picture is from 2.0. Now he’s at my house and is my pet.
user2: But this is medians we're talking about, so “from 2.0” can mean the same thing as “from five seconds ago”.
Detect Scratch version here
My other accounts: @selfexplanatory @modesties @chaircard @fireflyhero @dividendyield @colloids @radians @skeuamorphism @dihectogon @anglebisector @aau- @EditBlockColors @AdamantOrb @MoongeistBeam @festively @Ampharos_ @straightforwardness
i trolled redcat LOL

if you see this

{what method did you use::control hat
answer on profile ::motion
} ::operators

;

KittyCatKayden

kinosaurs515 wrote:
(#7402)
Za-Chary wrote:
-snip-
I have an update suggestion, the 1.11 does not count anymore, as it is now an option in (censored so I don't get banned). Please update it to state that!

That doesn't count as not rejected. Also you are sadly not allowed to name browser extensions

THIS THING NEEDS AN UPDATE-
Be high contrast

I have a little preference: Please don't make comments about my forum posts on my profile, projects or studios. However, it's fine if @Quackidee_, @Gamerules09 or @ImmortalJelly13 does that.
I use the browser Google Chrome, and I use the OS Windows 11.
Note that on my other accounts I (mostly) use Microsoft Edge.
Go to my profile
Go to my ocular profile
Go to my alt's profile
ฅ⁠^⁠•⁠ﻌ⁠•⁠^⁠ฅ
I LOVE Animal Crossing soooo much! I currently have every Animal Crossing game (including spin-offs) except the ones only in Japan.
I have a bunch of OCs, and most of them are based off my AC characters. However, I also have a (pretend) cat named Toodloo, and he's one of my main OCs(?) as well as Kitty Cat (from New Horizons), KittyCat (from New Leaf) and Meow.
New Leaf and Pocket Camp are my favorite AC games! (although I actually like all of them.) I wish I could have my real self move to the world of Animal Crossing!

when green flag clicked
Go to AC
define Go to AC
Escape the real world and move to AC

How did you find this? Tell me on my profile!
Anyways, here are some random links that used to be in a place where everyone could see them. I buried them here because I don't think everyone needs to see it.
Go to my postpercent profile
Go to my Scratch Forum Leaderboards page

k7e

kinosaurs515 wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
-snip-
I have an update suggestion, the 1.11 does not count anymore, as it is now an option in forbidden word. Please update it to state that!

It's talking about regular Scratch, as some other rejected suggestions such as 2.3, 5.4, 9.1, 9.5, and 10.2 (maybe more) are an option in that certain browser extension.

@mythoslore was so much more obvious than @spookily

kinosaurs515

medians wrote:
kinosaurs515 wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
-snip-
I have an update suggestion, the 1.11 does not count anymore, as it is now an option in (). Please update it to state that!
Do not name browser extensions, and that isn't affiliated with the Scratch Team, so no.
It's still rejected.

oh ok! I thought that it was allowed, since it is censored in normal Scratch chat, but not in here. Thanks for telling me!

Hi! I'm kinosaurs515!

These are my trusty guardians who protect my signature from evil kumquats! If you want to create a guardian for me, tell me on my profile! I can creat one for you too!

(=I)()(K) // This is Kino. No one knows why, but he has a hole in his body. He is very protective and energetic, but just isn't brave.

-_- // This is Lance. Lance is tired all the time, but is still somewhat "helpful".

define AWAKE 
broadcast [ sleep] // This is Sleep. Just as the code says, as if he's awake, he will sleep.
(-_-)

when green flag clicked
forever
if <not <[bumped] = [true]>> then // This is Bump. He helps bump my posts. Because he is Bump, he has a bump on his head.
broadcast [ bump]
stop [ all]
end
say [Yay! It was bumped!] for (2) secs
C0-K
end

when I receive [ NOISE] // This is Nosy. He noses a lot with a long nose.
BE NOSY

define BE NOSY
Nose with nose until they say nose
o-----
|

Discuss Scratch