Discuss Scratch

Scungilio64
Scratcher
500+ posts

Sticky Comments

PhanVinhHien wrote:

snip
um i think you accidentally posted that in this forum
LightSpeedX68
Scratcher
19 posts

Sticky Comments

How is that considered a suggestion, again?

Last edited by LightSpeedX68 (July 16, 2026 19:57:10)

fun_fic
New Scratcher
8 posts

Sticky Comments

PhanVinhHien wrote:

How it works: Next to the “Delete” or “Report” button on a comment, creators will see a “Pin” icon.

The Result: The pinned comment will move to the very top of the comment section, highlighted with a distinct background color or a small pin icon, remaining there regardless of how many new comments are posted.

Limit: To keep things clean, creators can pin a maximum of 1 or 2 comments at a time.


This is a good idea. It solves many problems.
PaperMarioFan2024
Scratcher
500+ posts

Sticky Comments

medians
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Sticky Comments

Bringng this topic up.
medians
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Sticky Comments

LightSpeedX68 wrote:

How is that considered a suggestion, again?
Wait what do you mean xD
Dharkon777
Scratcher
22 posts

Sticky Comments

Support. Right now the only alternative is to write your own comment and then lock comments, but this comes with the downsides of only being able to sticky your own comment and not someone else's, as well as preventing other users from commenting altogether. I think it would be a good idea to add the ability to sticky comments on your projects so they stay at the top while letting others comment as well.
NutOfCoco
Scratcher
500+ posts

Sticky Comments

I like this idea, but one problem with it might be that the project owner stickies too many comments and you have to scroll a long way down to find non-stickied comments.
CuteRobot22
Scratcher
100+ posts

Sticky Comments

NutOfCoco wrote:

I like this idea, but one problem with it might be that the project owner stickies too many comments and you have to scroll a long way down to find non-stickied comments.
You could only sticky one comment.
Dharkon777
Scratcher
22 posts

Sticky Comments

Dharkon777 wrote:

Support. Right now the only alternative is to write your own comment and then lock comments, but this comes with the downsides of only being able to sticky your own comment and not someone else's, as well as preventing other users from commenting altogether. I think it would be a good idea to add the ability to sticky comments on your projects so they stay at the top while letting others comment as well.

To address possible concerns regarding this ability:

1. You could add a limit to the number of stickied comments at a time (if the limit were up to me, it would be 10)
2. You could add a “Collapse/Expand stickied comments” button at the very top of the comments section that hides/shows all stickied comments (in my opinion this would be the best way to address spamming stickied comments)
3. And any stickied comments attacking other users or anything else violating the Community Guidelines can still of course be reported as normal.

Last edited by Dharkon777 (Yesterday 16:42:20)

CuteRobot22
Scratcher
100+ posts

Sticky Comments

Dharkon777 wrote:

Dharkon777 wrote:

Support. Right now the only alternative is to write your own comment and then lock comments, but this comes with the downsides of only being able to sticky your own comment and not someone else's, as well as preventing other users from commenting altogether. I think it would be a good idea to add the ability to sticky comments on your projects so they stay at the top while letting others comment as well.

To address possible concerns regarding this ability:

1. You could add a limit to the number of stickied comments at a time (if the limit were up to me, it would be 10)
2. You could add a “Collapse/Expand stickied comments” button at the very top of the comments section that hides/shows all stickied comments (in my opinion this would be the best way to address spamming stickied comments)
3. And any stickied comments attacking other users or anything else violating the Community Guidelines can still of course be reported as normal.
I think there should just be one allowed stickied comment
Dharkon777
Scratcher
22 posts

Sticky Comments

CuteRobot22 wrote:

Dharkon777 wrote:

Dharkon777 wrote:

Support. Right now the only alternative is to write your own comment and then lock comments, but this comes with the downsides of only being able to sticky your own comment and not someone else's, as well as preventing other users from commenting altogether. I think it would be a good idea to add the ability to sticky comments on your projects so they stay at the top while letting others comment as well.

To address possible concerns regarding this ability:

1. You could add a limit to the number of stickied comments at a time (if the limit were up to me, it would be 10)
2. You could add a “Collapse/Expand stickied comments” button at the very top of the comments section that hides/shows all stickied comments (in my opinion this would be the best way to address spamming stickied comments)
3. And any stickied comments attacking other users or anything else violating the Community Guidelines can still of course be reported as normal.
I think there should just be one allowed stickied comment
Certainly viable.
ilIusionator
Scratcher
500+ posts

Sticky Comments

CuteRobot22 wrote:

Dharkon777 wrote:

Dharkon777 wrote:

Support. Right now the only alternative is to write your own comment and then lock comments, but this comes with the downsides of only being able to sticky your own comment and not someone else's, as well as preventing other users from commenting altogether. I think it would be a good idea to add the ability to sticky comments on your projects so they stay at the top while letting others comment as well.

To address possible concerns regarding this ability:

1. You could add a limit to the number of stickied comments at a time (if the limit were up to me, it would be 10)
2. You could add a “Collapse/Expand stickied comments” button at the very top of the comments section that hides/shows all stickied comments (in my opinion this would be the best way to address spamming stickied comments)
3. And any stickied comments attacking other users or anything else violating the Community Guidelines can still of course be reported as normal.
I think there should just be one allowed stickied comment
or two, sometimes there's a funny comment you want stickied AND a notice that every commenter needs to see
fun_fic
New Scratcher
8 posts

Sticky Comments

I believe the limit must me 2. That way it won't be taking much space and it will let other comments be seen as well.
There's something else I've been wondering. If the project owner stickies a comment, would the owner of the comment receive a notification? Would it be a good idea? Personnaly I see no harm to it.
CuteRobot22
Scratcher
100+ posts

Sticky Comments

fun_fic wrote:

I believe the limit must me 2. That way it won't be taking much space and it will let other comments be seen as well.
There's something else I've been wondering. If the project owner stickies a comment, would the owner of the comment receive a notification? Would it be a good idea? Personnaly I see no harm to it.
Yeah, that's a good idea, as long as we don't send a message every time a comment gets stickied if the same user's comment gets stickied on the same project multiple times.

Powered by DjangoBB