WigglyJoey wrote:

mmachiix wrote:

Martiniquetwins wrote:

mtnif wrote:

creeper117743 wrote:

banana

please do not create off-topic posts

Don't worry, i reported this guy's forum post

same

You shouldn't mention reporting someone since it draws attention to that person.

alright

Almost 900,000.
You want to see it coming? TOLORS is hitting 900,000 views, get it?
EDIT: 900,000! IM GONNA CRY

gem1001 wrote:

Jackyraz wrote:

Za-Chary wrote:

10.4 A list of accepted suggestions
As a counterpart to the list of rejected suggestions, some Scratchers have expressed interest in compiling a list of features of Scratch that were suggested by someone, and eventually implemented. But it is not easy to tell whether a suggestion was implemented because it was suggested by Scratchers in the forums, Scratchers elsewhere, a Scratch Team member, a teacher, or someone else. In other words, every feature currently in Scratch was suggested by somebody, so such a list would just be a list of all features of Scratch.

Why cant i do it?

It would get closed instead of stickied

what if I make a scratch project that is the list of accepted suggestions

should 10.4 be removed as anyone can create a list of accepted suggestions and not just the scratch team

Jackyraz wrote:

gem1001 wrote:

Jackyraz wrote:

Za-Chary wrote:

10.4 A list of accepted suggestions
As a counterpart to the list of rejected suggestions, some Scratchers have expressed interest in compiling a list of features of Scratch that were suggested by someone, and eventually implemented. But it is not easy to tell whether a suggestion was implemented because it was suggested by Scratchers in the forums, Scratchers elsewhere, a Scratch Team member, a teacher, or someone else. In other words, every feature currently in Scratch was suggested by somebody, so such a list would just be a list of all features of Scratch.

Why cant i do it?

It would get closed instead of stickied

what if I make a scratch project that is the list of accepted suggestions

Probably allowed. But good luck finding the next to 0 accepted updates!

Jackyraz wrote:

gem1001 wrote:

Jackyraz wrote:

Za-Chary wrote:

10.4 A list of accepted suggestions
As a counterpart to the list of rejected suggestions, some Scratchers have expressed interest in compiling a list of features of Scratch that were suggested by someone, and eventually implemented. But it is not easy to tell whether a suggestion was implemented because it was suggested by Scratchers in the forums, Scratchers elsewhere, a Scratch Team member, a teacher, or someone else. In other words, every feature currently in Scratch was suggested by somebody, so such a list would just be a list of all features of Scratch.

Why cant i do it?

It would get closed instead of stickied

what if I make a scratch project that is the list of accepted suggestions

you could, it just wouldnt be supported by st like tolors is

Mimi-EEEEE wrote:

Probably allowed. But good luck finding the next to 0 accepted updates!

The Scratch Team cannot accept every single suggestion.

DanielaScunk wrote:

Mimi-EEEEE wrote:

Probably allowed. But good luck finding the next to 0 accepted updates!

The Scratch Team cannot accept every single suggestion.

Dude that exponent tread is 13 years old and wouldn't even be hard to add.

unisparks8 wrote:

Dude that exponent tread is 13 years old and wouldn't even be hard to add.

Please don't make me stress over that topic…
I do agree that it's not that hard to implement, but then again, developers have more things to do than just implement suggestions.

Would a 3D art count as rejected b/c 3D scratch? It's not exactly the same though…

GunesKing wrote:

Would a 3D art count as rejected b/c 3D scratch? It's not exactly the same though…

There are 3D projects in Scratch.
However, the Scratch Team has rejected the idea of adding 3D blocks as it would be too hard for beginners.

So I believe that 3D art would count as rejected.

*Also, don't quit! I see you helping out everywhere!*

GunesKing wrote:

Would a 3D art count as rejected b/c 3D scratch? It's not exactly the same though…

Wdym like 3d sprites?

https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/882597/
? Hasn't been closed at the time of this post. Might not be rejected so maybe when you come back from that trip you can add it to 8.8

3.8+i Ban specific genres

Generally, the Scratch Team does not censor projects from a certain genre unless a large number of projects from a banned franchise were made with the genre. In general, it is usually possible to make appropriate projects based on a certain genre. Depending on the franchise, the Scratch Team may choose to ban a specific project from a genre from Scratch by accident, but that is at their discretion. Of course, you should always use the Report button on those genres of projects.

Note that, in general, it is not rejected to relax or remove restrictions on genres that are already banned from Scratch; for more information, see this post and this post.

7.8+i Require age verification to unlock features
Age verification causes many privacy concerns; because they attempt to create an invasion of privacy, and use fallacies to try to strengthen their suggestion. Requiring age verification will give you weaknesses such as being unable to get free-form comments on profiles & projects, being unable to use the forums, or getting your projects unshared.

However, it is also rejected to prevent adults from talking to children. For more information, see this post.

I know this is not commonly suggested but here is another one in case you need to refer back to it in case it does become commonly suggested.

Someone suggested a rejected idea here

Martiniquetwins wrote:

Someone suggested a rejected idea here

You don't need to point that out.

ILuvDogs-5335 wrote:

3.8+i Ban specific genres

Generally, the Scratch Team does not censor projects from a certain genre unless a large number of projects from a banned franchise were made with the genre. In general, it is usually possible to make appropriate projects based on a certain genre. Depending on the franchise, the Scratch Team may choose to ban a genre from Scratch if they need to, but that is at their discretion. Of course, you should always use the Report button on those genres of projects.

Note that, in general, it is not rejected to relax or remove restrictions on genres that are already banned from Scratch; for more information, see this post.

Three things:
1) I will stand with my opinion that “ban certain franchises” does not belong on this list, given the fact that the Scratch Team indeed does ban specific franchises. Either all topics regarding banning a certain franchise should be closed as “up to the Scratch Team's discretion” (similar to un-rejecting a suggestion) or suggestions regarding banning franchises (that are not already rejected) should be allowed on the forums.
2) Do you have a source for anywhere that “ban specific genres” is rejected? I would consider a “genre” of a project to be, for instance, animations, art projects, games, etc.
3) That link is saying not to make suggestions about suggestions, not to relax or remove restrictions on certain genres.