Discuss Scratch
- Discussion Forums
- » Things I'm Making and Creating
- » ✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
- booklover883322
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
✎Welcome to the SWC Leader App Critique Center's Critique Thread!✎
This is not affiliated with the hosts, we're just two people who wanted to set up a little critique center for y'all!
Some basic rules for critiques:
✎Please be polite and respectful. When giving criticism, respect is of utmost importance!
✎There is no format you have to follow. Critique however you see fit!
✎Please do not discuss critiques/apps in this thread. Leave this thread for the critiques/apps themselves. You can discuss things in the studio!
✎Anyone can critique an application and share their application here! We're all here to encourage and help each other.
Anyways, thank you all! I'm so excited to see how this all works out! Skylar and I wish y'all luck!
Last edited by booklover883322 (April 18, 2025 15:53:17)
- ziqing11
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Copy and pasting my google docs into this lol-
Anyway…
About Me
Hi there, nice to meet you! I’m Sunny, and I go by she/her pronouns! I’m a teen girl living in the south-east of France, in other words in the CET (UTC+2) timezone! I speak three languages - Chinese, my native language, English and French. I come from a Chinese family but moved to France when I was three years old. I have since then attended the local international school opened along with the international organisation my parents work for
At school, I’m often looked upon as the straight-A student - and I admit that I do have a certain ease for academic assignments. Though I sometimes can be seen as the stereotypical know-it-all everybody hates (oops-) due to how serious and professional I can act, I’m also a fun person to hang out with in general, especially around close friends. I’m compassionate and helpful, and will not hesitate to crack a few jokes when I’m able to think of some
Online, I’m more extroverted than irl and can be quite chaotic (like most of us here, I presume
). That’s also why I love SWC so much! Everyone is so nice and welcoming (and chaotic!!!) that you don’t have to worry about making a false step or not fitting in.
Personality apart, I have loads of hobbies and extracurricular activities! Just this year, my volleyball coach signed my team up for the regional championships, and so far we’re in second place! We’ve got competitions approximately every two weeks, and each time the team’s bonds grow deeper and more meaningful with the excitement, stress and anticipation ^^ If you can’t tell that already, I love both this sport and my teammates <3
I’ve also played the piano since I was four years old, and though I’m not considering becoming a professional musician, I’ve grown fond of piano music over the years. I’m currently working on Intermezzo op.117 n.2 by Brahms, and I’m not even lying when I say I’ve fallen in love with the piece
During my free time, I also enjoy making handicrafts - I have a drawer full of old cardboard, bits of strings, paint and various other items I’ve collected over the years, and they do come in useful at times, though what they mostly do is lay around untouched hehe…
And, before I forget- I /love/ reading, to the point where my mom gets mad at me from repeating ‘dinner’s ready!’ five times without me hearing her - because I’m absorbed in the fictional universe of a book
I’ve had a passion for reading as far as I can remember, and I think the first time I cried over a book was in second grade :’) Some of my all time favourites are, to state a few, the Count of Monte Cristo, the Harry Potter saga, the Giver and Little Women.
Previous Participation
This upcoming SWC session will be my fifth! It’s fascinating how time flies, it feels like I’ve just stumbled upon the march ‘24 camper signups yesterday…
Here are the cabins I’ve been in (all as campers):
Script Theatron (march ‘24)
Script Podcast (july ‘24)
Apocalyptic - The Infestation (november ‘24)
Illu-Fi Spider Verse (march ‘24)
Aside from SWC, I’ve taken part in smaller camps, including WUC, SAC and SDC. I’ve led once in SAC, which allowed me to better understand with hands-on experience the responsibilities of a leader (cabin planning, storyline, adding words, etc…)
Irl, I’ve held many leadership positions, as I’m pretty much a born leader. It seems that my teachers agree on this point since they’ve mentioned I’m a ‘class leader’ in my latest school report lol. I’ve been class president numerous times during primary school, and I am currently eco-delegate in our class, meaning I, along with eco-delegates from other classes, organise environmental awareness events around the school and propose solutions to make our community more eco-friendly.
As for writing, I really started doing so as a hobby in March ‘24, during my first SWC session. Before that, though I enjoyed writing assignments in school, I never considered it as a leisure activity. With all the dailies and weeklies, I started delving further into the world of writing and since then it has grown into a passion. I’m currently working on a short story that I’m planning to enter for an irl writing competition.
Cabin Preferences
Though I most often write in fan-fi, real-fi, fantasy or dystopian, I love exploring possibilities with new and unfamiliar genres as well, so I’m fine with co-leading any cabin!
I would prefer not to co-lead TCTWNW because I very much enjoy the competitive of SWC ;D
Excerpt
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/808229/?page=6#post-8429269
Time Dedication
In July, it’ll be the summer vacation for me, and for once, we aren’t going back to China, so I’ll be able to dedicate loads of time to SWC! I’ll pretty much be online all day, and will be able to dedicate at least 3 hours per day for SWC (not including personal things like doing the dailies and weeklies)!
For the cabin-planning months, the only things that will keep me away from SWC are school work and extracurricular activities. I do have a couple music exams scattered around in May and June, but hopefully these won’t affect my activity too much.
On the whole, I expect to be able to delicate at least 9 hours a week for cabin-planning.
Time Management
I admit, time management is not my strong suit. Between school work, extracurricular activities, house chores, hobbies and everything online, I often get lost and struggle to prioritise tasks effectively.
Though I ultimately get things done before the deadline, the result is often of poorer quality than if I had planned my tasks beforehand. This is particularly problematic when I have very limited time to get things done (e.g. when I come home at 8pm and have homework for the next day). I learnt the importance of effective time management the hard way: stressful situations and late-night working - I’ve seen all those.
I have been actively working on my time management skills for quite some time now - I’ve tried various methods for effective time management and so far the two that work best for me are:
- Separating my day into a precise schedule for each task
- Sorting out the level of importance of each task, therefore prioritising the completion of one over another.
- Rewarding myself once I finish an important task effectively
These allow me to complete one task first before going to another, and I found that they help improve my work quality and reduce stress for deadlines.
Collaboration & Assets
I am generally good at collaborating effectively with others. From the numerous projects I’ve been part of, I’ve learnt to be attentive to others’ thoughts and questions, and am good at incorporating these with my own ideas. I am also able to attribute tasks fairly to each person depending on their strengths and skills, and am quick to find solutions to any problems that may arise, both online and irl. An example of this is when a person from my group fell sick the day of our presentation. I was able to come up with last minute solutions and attribute their part to those of us who were present. We ended up getting full marks ^^
My main weakness in collaboration used to be the lack of communication, but I am confident when I say that I have improved a lot in this field. In the past, I used to be shy and reluctant to share my opinions and ideas with others. Similarly, when something went off track, I did my best to hide it from others and fix the problem myself. This often led to extremely stressful and awkward situations.
However, I do believe I am much better concerning this. Over the years I’ve grown more extroverted and more open to sharing my thoughts and feelings with others. I’ve learnt that it's okay to step out of my comfort zone and communicate my opinions - even if I’m unsure whether they’re good or not.
One Quality
If I were to choose one quality I would be able to embody as a leader, it would be communication. As I mentioned before, I used to have trouble concerning this, and that reinforced my understanding of its importance.
The lack of communication often leads to misunderstandings, eventually arguments. For a team to work smoothly, we have to prevent these from happening as much as possible. The solution is quality communication. By this, I mean that members of the leadership teams should not hesitate to tell others if something has gone off track - or even just to inform the others that they will be unavailable for a day or two, that they would need a little more time to finish a project, or simply that they have a good idea to share!
Communication is vital for the well-functioning of a leadership team, whether online or irl. If a problem is encountered, nobody should bear the burden alone, as more brains can think of a solution quicker than a single one!
Cabin Atmosphere
A highly competitive cabin with an immersive storyline, all while maintaining a friendly, welcoming and inclusive atmosphere.
Checkboxes
A.
☑ I will be available to help add points in the main cabin consistently throughout camp
☑ I am willing to share a promotional project for SWC
B.
I can complete all leadership responsibilities listed in the FAQ
C.
If I have to go inactive, I will inform all my (co)leaders as soon as I know of it and, if my inactivity will delay projects, I will work out a possible solution with my (co)leaders. If the situation does not allow me to be active enough to take on the role of co-leader anymore, I will propose to step down from my role.
If a fellow (co)leader goes inactive and informs us beforehand, I will work with them to propose a suitable solution to distribute their tasks to the rest of the leadership team. If they have not warned us of their inactivity, the rest of the leadership team shall again distribute the inactive member’s tasks to others to ensure that the cabin will work smoothly. If the inactive member does not show any signs of activity after two or three weeks, we will consider replacing them with a new (co)leader if needed.
Anyway…
About Me
Hi there, nice to meet you! I’m Sunny, and I go by she/her pronouns! I’m a teen girl living in the south-east of France, in other words in the CET (UTC+2) timezone! I speak three languages - Chinese, my native language, English and French. I come from a Chinese family but moved to France when I was three years old. I have since then attended the local international school opened along with the international organisation my parents work for

At school, I’m often looked upon as the straight-A student - and I admit that I do have a certain ease for academic assignments. Though I sometimes can be seen as the stereotypical know-it-all everybody hates (oops-) due to how serious and professional I can act, I’m also a fun person to hang out with in general, especially around close friends. I’m compassionate and helpful, and will not hesitate to crack a few jokes when I’m able to think of some

Online, I’m more extroverted than irl and can be quite chaotic (like most of us here, I presume
). That’s also why I love SWC so much! Everyone is so nice and welcoming (and chaotic!!!) that you don’t have to worry about making a false step or not fitting in.Personality apart, I have loads of hobbies and extracurricular activities! Just this year, my volleyball coach signed my team up for the regional championships, and so far we’re in second place! We’ve got competitions approximately every two weeks, and each time the team’s bonds grow deeper and more meaningful with the excitement, stress and anticipation ^^ If you can’t tell that already, I love both this sport and my teammates <3
I’ve also played the piano since I was four years old, and though I’m not considering becoming a professional musician, I’ve grown fond of piano music over the years. I’m currently working on Intermezzo op.117 n.2 by Brahms, and I’m not even lying when I say I’ve fallen in love with the piece

During my free time, I also enjoy making handicrafts - I have a drawer full of old cardboard, bits of strings, paint and various other items I’ve collected over the years, and they do come in useful at times, though what they mostly do is lay around untouched hehe…
And, before I forget- I /love/ reading, to the point where my mom gets mad at me from repeating ‘dinner’s ready!’ five times without me hearing her - because I’m absorbed in the fictional universe of a book
I’ve had a passion for reading as far as I can remember, and I think the first time I cried over a book was in second grade :’) Some of my all time favourites are, to state a few, the Count of Monte Cristo, the Harry Potter saga, the Giver and Little Women.Previous Participation
This upcoming SWC session will be my fifth! It’s fascinating how time flies, it feels like I’ve just stumbled upon the march ‘24 camper signups yesterday…
Here are the cabins I’ve been in (all as campers):
Script Theatron (march ‘24)
Script Podcast (july ‘24)
Apocalyptic - The Infestation (november ‘24)
Illu-Fi Spider Verse (march ‘24)
Aside from SWC, I’ve taken part in smaller camps, including WUC, SAC and SDC. I’ve led once in SAC, which allowed me to better understand with hands-on experience the responsibilities of a leader (cabin planning, storyline, adding words, etc…)
Irl, I’ve held many leadership positions, as I’m pretty much a born leader. It seems that my teachers agree on this point since they’ve mentioned I’m a ‘class leader’ in my latest school report lol. I’ve been class president numerous times during primary school, and I am currently eco-delegate in our class, meaning I, along with eco-delegates from other classes, organise environmental awareness events around the school and propose solutions to make our community more eco-friendly.
As for writing, I really started doing so as a hobby in March ‘24, during my first SWC session. Before that, though I enjoyed writing assignments in school, I never considered it as a leisure activity. With all the dailies and weeklies, I started delving further into the world of writing and since then it has grown into a passion. I’m currently working on a short story that I’m planning to enter for an irl writing competition.
Cabin Preferences
Though I most often write in fan-fi, real-fi, fantasy or dystopian, I love exploring possibilities with new and unfamiliar genres as well, so I’m fine with co-leading any cabin!
I would prefer not to co-lead TCTWNW because I very much enjoy the competitive of SWC ;D
Excerpt
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/808229/?page=6#post-8429269
Time Dedication
In July, it’ll be the summer vacation for me, and for once, we aren’t going back to China, so I’ll be able to dedicate loads of time to SWC! I’ll pretty much be online all day, and will be able to dedicate at least 3 hours per day for SWC (not including personal things like doing the dailies and weeklies)!
For the cabin-planning months, the only things that will keep me away from SWC are school work and extracurricular activities. I do have a couple music exams scattered around in May and June, but hopefully these won’t affect my activity too much.
On the whole, I expect to be able to delicate at least 9 hours a week for cabin-planning.
Time Management
I admit, time management is not my strong suit. Between school work, extracurricular activities, house chores, hobbies and everything online, I often get lost and struggle to prioritise tasks effectively.
Though I ultimately get things done before the deadline, the result is often of poorer quality than if I had planned my tasks beforehand. This is particularly problematic when I have very limited time to get things done (e.g. when I come home at 8pm and have homework for the next day). I learnt the importance of effective time management the hard way: stressful situations and late-night working - I’ve seen all those.
I have been actively working on my time management skills for quite some time now - I’ve tried various methods for effective time management and so far the two that work best for me are:
- Separating my day into a precise schedule for each task
- Sorting out the level of importance of each task, therefore prioritising the completion of one over another.
- Rewarding myself once I finish an important task effectively
These allow me to complete one task first before going to another, and I found that they help improve my work quality and reduce stress for deadlines.
Collaboration & Assets
I am generally good at collaborating effectively with others. From the numerous projects I’ve been part of, I’ve learnt to be attentive to others’ thoughts and questions, and am good at incorporating these with my own ideas. I am also able to attribute tasks fairly to each person depending on their strengths and skills, and am quick to find solutions to any problems that may arise, both online and irl. An example of this is when a person from my group fell sick the day of our presentation. I was able to come up with last minute solutions and attribute their part to those of us who were present. We ended up getting full marks ^^
My main weakness in collaboration used to be the lack of communication, but I am confident when I say that I have improved a lot in this field. In the past, I used to be shy and reluctant to share my opinions and ideas with others. Similarly, when something went off track, I did my best to hide it from others and fix the problem myself. This often led to extremely stressful and awkward situations.
However, I do believe I am much better concerning this. Over the years I’ve grown more extroverted and more open to sharing my thoughts and feelings with others. I’ve learnt that it's okay to step out of my comfort zone and communicate my opinions - even if I’m unsure whether they’re good or not.
One Quality
If I were to choose one quality I would be able to embody as a leader, it would be communication. As I mentioned before, I used to have trouble concerning this, and that reinforced my understanding of its importance.
The lack of communication often leads to misunderstandings, eventually arguments. For a team to work smoothly, we have to prevent these from happening as much as possible. The solution is quality communication. By this, I mean that members of the leadership teams should not hesitate to tell others if something has gone off track - or even just to inform the others that they will be unavailable for a day or two, that they would need a little more time to finish a project, or simply that they have a good idea to share!
Communication is vital for the well-functioning of a leadership team, whether online or irl. If a problem is encountered, nobody should bear the burden alone, as more brains can think of a solution quicker than a single one!
Cabin Atmosphere
A highly competitive cabin with an immersive storyline, all while maintaining a friendly, welcoming and inclusive atmosphere.
Checkboxes
A.
☑ I will be available to help add points in the main cabin consistently throughout camp
☑ I am willing to share a promotional project for SWC
B.
I can complete all leadership responsibilities listed in the FAQ
C.
If I have to go inactive, I will inform all my (co)leaders as soon as I know of it and, if my inactivity will delay projects, I will work out a possible solution with my (co)leaders. If the situation does not allow me to be active enough to take on the role of co-leader anymore, I will propose to step down from my role.
If a fellow (co)leader goes inactive and informs us beforehand, I will work with them to propose a suitable solution to distribute their tasks to the rest of the leadership team. If they have not warned us of their inactivity, the rest of the leadership team shall again distribute the inactive member’s tasks to others to ensure that the cabin will work smoothly. If the inactive member does not show any signs of activity after two or three weeks, we will consider replacing them with a new (co)leader if needed.
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Sunny!!
- https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/817515/?page=1#post-8514774
513 words <3
Hello, I know you didn’t actually respond about me doing this, but I was bored so here you go
Please remember that these are all suggestions, and it's my opinion on how you can improve, so take it all with a cup or tea and a biscuit <33
Moving on I loved your app, and I can’t wait to see your theme and finalized text. Good luck, and I can’t wait to see how you do this season of Co-hunting. <3
About me -
I really feel like I’ve learnt about you, which is the point of this section, so amazing job!! However, you could try to talk a little more about your hobbies and such, explaining how they affect your personality, or what makes them enjoyable for you.
With participation, it's amazing, although briefly mentioning a bit about what you enjoyed/learnt from your past SWC sessions could be beneficial. And elaborating on what you learnt/enjoyed for your SAC leadership experience as well as a bit more on your writing experience outside of SWC <3
Although you’ve said your cabin preferences, it might be good to mention cabins you would definitely not like to lead, or not want to as much, just to help the Co-hunters out.
Time Dedication is looking great!! But you could mention about letting people know if something comes up? Just a suggestion, and it doesn’t have to even be a lot, a quick sentence would do. <3
Time Management -
You’ve done an amazing job of telling your shortcomings and how you’re improving them, but I would recommend adding an extra paragraph or two to talk about your strengths in time management, as it's a really big thing for Co-hunters and it can remind people of the positives of working with you.
Collaboration, you’ve repeated the word ‘attribute’ quite a lot, so you may want to change it up, this is simply a personal preference though ^^”
You may also want to elaborate on the first skill you mentioned; "I've learnt to be attentive to others’ thoughts and questions, and am good at incorporating these with my own ideas.” and give an example on this or just generally tell us more about this.
And with the things you struggle with, giving good examples on how you’re improving upon your weaknesses can encourage Co-hunters to choose you, and it shows that you’re working on what you struggle with.
Aside from this, just remember to tell the assets you can bring to a team, as it's a crucial part of that section!! <3
One Quality -
Mention how you’d work to embody your leadership value, and show how you’d make sure you use communication in your leadership style and in your cabin. You’ve told us why you think it's important, and why you value it, so now show/tell us how you want to embody it. Aside from that, this section is great!! <3
Checkboxes looks great!! But maybe mention about contacting the inactive (co)leader before taking any steps <3
Your app is amazing!! I definitely wasn't this good with my first time ^^" It's so agshdjlskahd, I have no words, you seem like such a fun, responsible person to lead with and I cannot wait to see where you go from here, and how your app turns out!!
- Liv
- https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/817515/?page=1#post-8514774
513 words <3
Hello, I know you didn’t actually respond about me doing this, but I was bored so here you go
Please remember that these are all suggestions, and it's my opinion on how you can improve, so take it all with a cup or tea and a biscuit <33
Moving on I loved your app, and I can’t wait to see your theme and finalized text. Good luck, and I can’t wait to see how you do this season of Co-hunting. <3
About me -
I really feel like I’ve learnt about you, which is the point of this section, so amazing job!! However, you could try to talk a little more about your hobbies and such, explaining how they affect your personality, or what makes them enjoyable for you.
With participation, it's amazing, although briefly mentioning a bit about what you enjoyed/learnt from your past SWC sessions could be beneficial. And elaborating on what you learnt/enjoyed for your SAC leadership experience as well as a bit more on your writing experience outside of SWC <3
Although you’ve said your cabin preferences, it might be good to mention cabins you would definitely not like to lead, or not want to as much, just to help the Co-hunters out.
Time Dedication is looking great!! But you could mention about letting people know if something comes up? Just a suggestion, and it doesn’t have to even be a lot, a quick sentence would do. <3
Time Management -
You’ve done an amazing job of telling your shortcomings and how you’re improving them, but I would recommend adding an extra paragraph or two to talk about your strengths in time management, as it's a really big thing for Co-hunters and it can remind people of the positives of working with you.
Collaboration, you’ve repeated the word ‘attribute’ quite a lot, so you may want to change it up, this is simply a personal preference though ^^”
You may also want to elaborate on the first skill you mentioned; "I've learnt to be attentive to others’ thoughts and questions, and am good at incorporating these with my own ideas.” and give an example on this or just generally tell us more about this.
And with the things you struggle with, giving good examples on how you’re improving upon your weaknesses can encourage Co-hunters to choose you, and it shows that you’re working on what you struggle with.
Aside from this, just remember to tell the assets you can bring to a team, as it's a crucial part of that section!! <3
One Quality -
Mention how you’d work to embody your leadership value, and show how you’d make sure you use communication in your leadership style and in your cabin. You’ve told us why you think it's important, and why you value it, so now show/tell us how you want to embody it. Aside from that, this section is great!! <3
Checkboxes looks great!! But maybe mention about contacting the inactive (co)leader before taking any steps <3
Your app is amazing!! I definitely wasn't this good with my first time ^^" It's so agshdjlskahd, I have no words, you seem like such a fun, responsible person to lead with and I cannot wait to see where you go from here, and how your app turns out!!
- Liv
Last edited by FireBlood23 (April 26, 2025 03:36:28)
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Maddie!! <3
- Link B)
1854 words :sobs:
Intro -
Omg this whole app just screams ‘Maddie.’ You’ve put so much enthusiasm and personality into it people would be crazy not to choose you ahkjsddkalb. This is amazing and I can’t wait to see where this gets you
(what's up with the first-timers' apps being so good?? :sob: I swear mine wasn’t this good-)
As previously stated, I'd like to apologize in advance if any of my wording is a bit harsh </3 I want you to do the absolute best, but also not sure how to get some of my message across without those words. I think your app is amazing and spectacular, all of any critique is only suggestions, and I love you <33
Extra Notes -
After reading through this alot, it feels a bit like you're rushing through it. Although that might be your enthusiasm, it could benefit from some rewriting to make it seem less chaotic.
And I’d just like to say that you should keep an eye on your general grammar/sentences/spelling as it’s a recurring theme here <3
About me -
‘Yes, I did just make a geometry joke. No I will not be taking your criticism.’ Pop a comma in between ‘No’ and ‘I will.’ <3
‘Haha, classic privacy always keeping things private.’ Another comma here ^^” (between ‘privacy’ and ‘always.’
‘becoming an author will nave to remain’ Little typo here <3
‘because of their definitley not fair’ Just that the spelling of definitely is incorrect ^^”
‘I just have seven words to say to you now.’ From what I’ve read, you’re actually saying six words to us
‘Forgot English existed haha-My user is igloooo1 as you can tell,’ Put a space or new line here <3
‘creative writing, because my dreams’ Substitute ‘because’ for ‘but’ to help it make more sense.
And a little note that you may want to split up the paragraph to make it easier to read rather than a big block of text. <33 (and keep an eye on your fullstops and sentences, just to help it read better)
WEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE okay, now that spelling and grammar is out of the way this section is screaming Maddie from all angles, and I love all the personality you’ve poured into it. A few things, however, including that, in my personal opinion, you could cut out the parts of your age. It’s just a me thing though, and it may give you some words to use for other parts.
It also feels like you’re rambling alot, which is inherently Maddie, but it can also help to read through and cut out/rewrite some parts. At the moment it feels like you’re talking about yourself, to yourself, so cutting it down and organizing a little bit could make it easier to read for others loll.
You’ve also listed quite a few hobbies/things you like to do, and I’m not asking you to cut them down, but elaborating on a couple of them instead of having them as a list could help to connect your crazy (in a good way) introduction together.
Experience -
‘So this would be my third session at SWC!’ You can say ‘will be’ as it says that you’ll definitely participate, and to help it make a little more sense.
‘I wasted my time there-But during my last session’ I’m guessing there was most likely a line here (from the pattern), but just another suggestion to add a line or a space!!
‘campers, it was sad monestly that I’ Not sure what ‘monestly’ is meant to mean, so you may want to clear that up a bit <33
‘sorry just had to say that really quickly,’ No need to apologize B)
Another note about splitting paragraphs ^^” (especially when moving from SWC experience to writing experience and form that to leadership experience)
Okay!! So I like to mention or list all of my sessions and what cabins I was in, just to give material proof. Aside from that, this section looks great!! Awesome job Maddie! <3
Cabin preferences -
‘So if the Opportunity ever arises,’ No need for a capital ‘O’ in opportunity, but you could also scrap this whole bit as this is the opportunity that has arisen <3
‘And as a right-brained kookoo child, I could definitley help come up with a fun storyline for the campers, like a You've Got Mail scenario or even a Pride & Prejudice theme!’ Not quite sure what you mean by this, and you’ve spelt definitely wrong again xD
‘I've got so many ideas, but they will all stay in my tiny mind because I haven't been accepted yet lol!’ Don’t say this!! Elaborate on how many ideas you have, how excited you are!! You could find another way to say this though, like ‘I’m not spilling it all here, as there’s so much I’d like to discuss with my Co’s first.’ Small suggestion ^^”
‘I'm crossing my toes that this session will be my chance to lead! I've applied twice, but haven't gotten in, but became a camper, and still had a good time!’ You could cut this, as it shows a little pessimism, which is understandable, but we’re not talking about your failed attempts, they’re in the past!! We’re talking about the ideas you’d love to make a reality <3
Okay, so three things here.
One, talk about some solid parts for a storyline, proper things or ideas you have that will show the hosts that you really can pull this off, and make it a reality besides vague plot clues.
Two, you don’t have to lead a Thriller cabin to encourage campers to have fun! But I’m honoured you think of us that way <3
Three!! Don’t forget to talk about if you’re a Co, what cabins you’d like to lead, and what cabins you’d rather not lead. And your stance on TCTWNW!! <3
Time Dedication -
‘I believe I will be able to dedicate’ You could cut out the first ‘I believe’ to make yourself sound more confident in your dedication. <33
So with this, try to elaborate on exact dates, and go more into what amount of hours over the months of planning and actual session you’ll be able to dedicate, and it might be good to mention that you’d let your leadership team know if anything comes up.
Time Management -
(I'm so sorry if any of this comes across as rude, it's a very important thing, and can make or break your app. So this will likely be strongly worded ^^”)
I have a lot to say here, so let's begin. This is a crucial part of anyone's app, as it's what most (if not all) Co-hunters/Hosts look at when they’re choosing leadership teams. Which means that you need to properly display your skills here, if you’re struggling to write it, I find that looking at other’s leader apps helps to give you a good idea of what to write.
That being said, here’s what the last leader app asked ‘what are your skills and shortcomings in Time Management.’ So you should be able to say some proper, set examples of skills you succeed in with time management, and elaborate on why it marks you a good leader or how you have used those skills.
As well as set examples of things you struggle with, as well as why or how you struggle with them, and how you are improving them/plan to improve on them.
I would recommend rewriting this particular part of your app, while looking at past apps (typically ones from recent sessions that got picked) to help you understand what to write. I’m happy to critique this if you end up rewriting this part, but this is just a thing to keep in mind!! <3
Collaboration and Assets
‘I can safely say people go to me to do all the work because they know (they know… >:D) I'll get it done the best.’ So I’ve started reading this, and I find that this would not be something I would look for in a app, this is about collaboration, and with your wording it feels like you’re talking about being in control/running the show, which isn’t really teamwork </3 Which carries into this sentence ‘And I honestly don't mind all that much because I love when things are in my control,’ So just a note to remind you to watch your wording and see if you could spin it into a more positive light.
And whilst reading through this, I feel like you’ve mentioned how you like to take it all up, and control/run it, but you may want to watch this/rephrase this or list it as a weakness so it doesn’t feel like its controlling or smothering the other things you’re trying to talk about in this section.
This general section feels very disorganized, and like it's jumping from part to part. So like with Time Management, try to show your strengths with working with others, and your weaknesses with how you're working on them. As well as your assets separately.
Again, happy to critique this again if you do rewrite/edit it <3 (and I'd recommend looking at past apps for reference if you need any help!!)
One Quality -
This is amazing!! But I’d like to remind you how to spell definitely xDD
There's a few spelling mistakes or typos that need fixing, like ‘vould’ and ‘deterined’ and ‘definitly’
And ‘at camp their most enjoyable session, they've ever’ This should be ‘at camp the most enjoyable session they’ve ever’ <3
‘show others How hard I'm trying,’ No capital ‘H’ in ‘how’ here!
Atmosphere -
With this, this is an example of what would be put in the camper sign ups, so you wouldn’t ‘want’ your cabin atmosphere to be like this so much as ‘have’ your cabin atmosphere be like this!!
For example ‘A cabin focused on being everything our leaders have had in the past; fun, chaotic, awesome, comforting, supportive, loving and competitive! To make camper's experience as enjoyable as in the past!’
If you’d like me to elaborate, just let me know, otherwise I love this and how personal the atmosphere felt! It shows dedication to being who you’re aiming to be. <3
Checkboxes -
Weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee, okayyyyyyy.
So you may want to elaborate on who you’d ask for keeping things running smoothly, as if you’re a Co, you’d likely ask your leader or other Co, and if you’re a Leader you may want to ask the Hosts <3
You also could benefit from talking about the exact steps you’d take if you were to be inactive, or another to be inactive, like discussing courses of action, and stepping down or promoting someone new, etc.
And mention if you were to go inactive without knowing you were going to, or how you’d organise tasks/moderate discussions in any case <33
Final Note -
This is amazing Maddie!! I can’t imagine you not getting chosen, and I cannot wait to see where you go from here!! I’m so proud of you my child, (they grow up so fast *wipes tear*) and best of luck!!
- Mum, aka, Liv <3
- Link B)
1854 words :sobs:
Intro -
Omg this whole app just screams ‘Maddie.’ You’ve put so much enthusiasm and personality into it people would be crazy not to choose you ahkjsddkalb. This is amazing and I can’t wait to see where this gets you
(what's up with the first-timers' apps being so good?? :sob: I swear mine wasn’t this good-)As previously stated, I'd like to apologize in advance if any of my wording is a bit harsh </3 I want you to do the absolute best, but also not sure how to get some of my message across without those words. I think your app is amazing and spectacular, all of any critique is only suggestions, and I love you <33
Extra Notes -
After reading through this alot, it feels a bit like you're rushing through it. Although that might be your enthusiasm, it could benefit from some rewriting to make it seem less chaotic.
And I’d just like to say that you should keep an eye on your general grammar/sentences/spelling as it’s a recurring theme here <3
About me -
‘Yes, I did just make a geometry joke. No I will not be taking your criticism.’ Pop a comma in between ‘No’ and ‘I will.’ <3
‘Haha, classic privacy always keeping things private.’ Another comma here ^^” (between ‘privacy’ and ‘always.’
‘becoming an author will nave to remain’ Little typo here <3
‘because of their definitley not fair’ Just that the spelling of definitely is incorrect ^^”
‘I just have seven words to say to you now.’ From what I’ve read, you’re actually saying six words to us
‘Forgot English existed haha-My user is igloooo1 as you can tell,’ Put a space or new line here <3
‘creative writing, because my dreams’ Substitute ‘because’ for ‘but’ to help it make more sense.
And a little note that you may want to split up the paragraph to make it easier to read rather than a big block of text. <33 (and keep an eye on your fullstops and sentences, just to help it read better)
WEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE okay, now that spelling and grammar is out of the way this section is screaming Maddie from all angles, and I love all the personality you’ve poured into it. A few things, however, including that, in my personal opinion, you could cut out the parts of your age. It’s just a me thing though, and it may give you some words to use for other parts.
It also feels like you’re rambling alot, which is inherently Maddie, but it can also help to read through and cut out/rewrite some parts. At the moment it feels like you’re talking about yourself, to yourself, so cutting it down and organizing a little bit could make it easier to read for others loll.
You’ve also listed quite a few hobbies/things you like to do, and I’m not asking you to cut them down, but elaborating on a couple of them instead of having them as a list could help to connect your crazy (in a good way) introduction together.
Experience -
‘So this would be my third session at SWC!’ You can say ‘will be’ as it says that you’ll definitely participate, and to help it make a little more sense.
‘I wasted my time there-But during my last session’ I’m guessing there was most likely a line here (from the pattern), but just another suggestion to add a line or a space!!
‘campers, it was sad monestly that I’ Not sure what ‘monestly’ is meant to mean, so you may want to clear that up a bit <33
‘sorry just had to say that really quickly,’ No need to apologize B)
Another note about splitting paragraphs ^^” (especially when moving from SWC experience to writing experience and form that to leadership experience)
Okay!! So I like to mention or list all of my sessions and what cabins I was in, just to give material proof. Aside from that, this section looks great!! Awesome job Maddie! <3
Cabin preferences -
‘So if the Opportunity ever arises,’ No need for a capital ‘O’ in opportunity, but you could also scrap this whole bit as this is the opportunity that has arisen <3
‘And as a right-brained kookoo child, I could definitley help come up with a fun storyline for the campers, like a You've Got Mail scenario or even a Pride & Prejudice theme!’ Not quite sure what you mean by this, and you’ve spelt definitely wrong again xD
‘I've got so many ideas, but they will all stay in my tiny mind because I haven't been accepted yet lol!’ Don’t say this!! Elaborate on how many ideas you have, how excited you are!! You could find another way to say this though, like ‘I’m not spilling it all here, as there’s so much I’d like to discuss with my Co’s first.’ Small suggestion ^^”
‘I'm crossing my toes that this session will be my chance to lead! I've applied twice, but haven't gotten in, but became a camper, and still had a good time!’ You could cut this, as it shows a little pessimism, which is understandable, but we’re not talking about your failed attempts, they’re in the past!! We’re talking about the ideas you’d love to make a reality <3
Okay, so three things here.
One, talk about some solid parts for a storyline, proper things or ideas you have that will show the hosts that you really can pull this off, and make it a reality besides vague plot clues.
Two, you don’t have to lead a Thriller cabin to encourage campers to have fun! But I’m honoured you think of us that way <3
Three!! Don’t forget to talk about if you’re a Co, what cabins you’d like to lead, and what cabins you’d rather not lead. And your stance on TCTWNW!! <3
Time Dedication -
‘I believe I will be able to dedicate’ You could cut out the first ‘I believe’ to make yourself sound more confident in your dedication. <33
So with this, try to elaborate on exact dates, and go more into what amount of hours over the months of planning and actual session you’ll be able to dedicate, and it might be good to mention that you’d let your leadership team know if anything comes up.
Time Management -
(I'm so sorry if any of this comes across as rude, it's a very important thing, and can make or break your app. So this will likely be strongly worded ^^”)
I have a lot to say here, so let's begin. This is a crucial part of anyone's app, as it's what most (if not all) Co-hunters/Hosts look at when they’re choosing leadership teams. Which means that you need to properly display your skills here, if you’re struggling to write it, I find that looking at other’s leader apps helps to give you a good idea of what to write.
That being said, here’s what the last leader app asked ‘what are your skills and shortcomings in Time Management.’ So you should be able to say some proper, set examples of skills you succeed in with time management, and elaborate on why it marks you a good leader or how you have used those skills.
As well as set examples of things you struggle with, as well as why or how you struggle with them, and how you are improving them/plan to improve on them.
I would recommend rewriting this particular part of your app, while looking at past apps (typically ones from recent sessions that got picked) to help you understand what to write. I’m happy to critique this if you end up rewriting this part, but this is just a thing to keep in mind!! <3
Collaboration and Assets
‘I can safely say people go to me to do all the work because they know (they know… >:D) I'll get it done the best.’ So I’ve started reading this, and I find that this would not be something I would look for in a app, this is about collaboration, and with your wording it feels like you’re talking about being in control/running the show, which isn’t really teamwork </3 Which carries into this sentence ‘And I honestly don't mind all that much because I love when things are in my control,’ So just a note to remind you to watch your wording and see if you could spin it into a more positive light.
And whilst reading through this, I feel like you’ve mentioned how you like to take it all up, and control/run it, but you may want to watch this/rephrase this or list it as a weakness so it doesn’t feel like its controlling or smothering the other things you’re trying to talk about in this section.
This general section feels very disorganized, and like it's jumping from part to part. So like with Time Management, try to show your strengths with working with others, and your weaknesses with how you're working on them. As well as your assets separately.
Again, happy to critique this again if you do rewrite/edit it <3 (and I'd recommend looking at past apps for reference if you need any help!!)
One Quality -
This is amazing!! But I’d like to remind you how to spell definitely xDD
There's a few spelling mistakes or typos that need fixing, like ‘vould’ and ‘deterined’ and ‘definitly’
And ‘at camp their most enjoyable session, they've ever’ This should be ‘at camp the most enjoyable session they’ve ever’ <3
‘show others How hard I'm trying,’ No capital ‘H’ in ‘how’ here!
Atmosphere -
With this, this is an example of what would be put in the camper sign ups, so you wouldn’t ‘want’ your cabin atmosphere to be like this so much as ‘have’ your cabin atmosphere be like this!!
For example ‘A cabin focused on being everything our leaders have had in the past; fun, chaotic, awesome, comforting, supportive, loving and competitive! To make camper's experience as enjoyable as in the past!’
If you’d like me to elaborate, just let me know, otherwise I love this and how personal the atmosphere felt! It shows dedication to being who you’re aiming to be. <3
Checkboxes -
Weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee, okayyyyyyy.
So you may want to elaborate on who you’d ask for keeping things running smoothly, as if you’re a Co, you’d likely ask your leader or other Co, and if you’re a Leader you may want to ask the Hosts <3
You also could benefit from talking about the exact steps you’d take if you were to be inactive, or another to be inactive, like discussing courses of action, and stepping down or promoting someone new, etc.
And mention if you were to go inactive without knowing you were going to, or how you’d organise tasks/moderate discussions in any case <33
Final Note -
This is amazing Maddie!! I can’t imagine you not getting chosen, and I cannot wait to see where you go from here!! I’m so proud of you my child, (they grow up so fast *wipes tear*) and best of luck!!
- Mum, aka, Liv <3
- Milkysplash
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Question 1 - About Me - 391 Words
Hi there! I’m Skylar (she/her), a 16-year-old Year 12 A Level student from the UK, living in the B(e)ST timezone. I currently take Biology, Chemistry, Maths, and Physics at school and am suffering through the fact I decided to take four subjects. I’m also hopelessly obsessed with public transport, city planning, and commercial aviation, and I want to work as a civil engineer in the future.
In addition to my interest in the sciences, I also am interested in politics and current affairs. I am overly involved in Model United Nations at school, spending much of my time on a Tuesday and Wednesday afternoon dedicated to this activity. I’ve been doing it for three years now, and needless to say this is one of the best things I’ve ever done in my life.
Aside from my academic pursuits, I love being creative! If I’m not studying, working on something for Model UN, or chasing my train/plane obsession down various rabbit holes, you can probably find me making music. I play piano, violin, and also sing in a choir. I love to make music of any kind, and I especially love making covers of songs!
Art is also something I like to do in my free time! I used to spend a lot more time doing art than I currently do, but due to the pressures of life I’ve found myself writing a lot more than drawing. I still draw, and often find myself doing this just before I go to bed.
I, of course, also love writing! I’ve found myself enjoying writing more and more recently. I love to write short stories and scenes, set in worlds I’ve created and established - but that doesn’t mean I don’t write the occasional fanfiction. Regardless of what I’m writing, worldbuilding will always be my favourite part of the writing process. I love combining my interests in sciences and humanities to create a world where my characters can freely live their lives.
I’m not just big into academics and creative stuff though! A fun fact about me is that I figure skate! I’m currently learning salchow and spins, and due to my academics I haven’t had the chance to go to any competitions or perform in anything yet. I do, however, miss the ice rink a lot when I’m not there.
Question 2 - Experience - 398 Words
This coming session will mark my tenth session of SWC - crazy, am I right? I first discovered SWC back in March 2021, and have been coming back ever since. The majority of sessions I’ve attended - eight of those nine - have been as a camper, and last session was my first time co-leading an SWC Cabin!
I have co-led one session of SWC, that being the absolutely fantabulously amazing Fanfi Battle of the Bands last session with Alana, Pepper, and Snowy! It was such a fun experience, getting to plan activities and engage with the SWC community from the leadership side. During this session, I also learnt so much about what it means to be an SWC leader, aside from just adding points and making a fun storyline! It also involved taking on other responsibilities and improvising on the fly should a storyline or plan fall through. This experience also made me appreciate how much work goes into preparing a cabin, and also taught me how to handle complex storylines.
I have also hosted and led various other scratch camps in the past, such as being a current host of Science Exploration Camp (SXC) and Scratch Study Camp (SSC), leader in SMC, and a co-leader in SRC. As a host and leader in these camps, I’ve had to improvise last minute to get an activity out, create daily and weekly activities, and also pick leaders to help create amazing and memorable sessions.
In real life, I’ve been on my school’s Model United Nations Secretariat for the past few months, helping to plan and organise our conference. During this time, my role has primarily been mentoring students both new and old to Model UN within the school, training them to be better delegates. In addition, I’ve also collaborated with the rest of the team to get various other things organised, such as logistic plans.
I have also run a few clubs in the past, as well as organised a few charity sales at my school before. These have involved organising people into completing different tasks, advertising, and talking with the teachers about what we’re planning to do and when.
In terms of my writing experience, I have been writing for as long as I can remember, making stories and being creative in my free time. I mainly write for fun, but I’ve entered the occasional essay competition in the past.
Question 3 - Cabin Pref - 496 Words
The cabins I’d most like to lead this session would be Apocalyptic, Adventure, and Science Fiction! I would prefer not to lead Fanfiction as I co-led that cabin last session, and would not like to lead Romance or Horror mainly because I’m uncomfortable writing in those genres. Aside from that, I would be happy to lead any cabin.
Apocalyptic (or Science Fiction) - Inspired by my endless love of Model United Nations, this would be a cabin partially inspired by this amazing activity that I do. Campers would be called from their various imaginary countries/worlds/planets to an emergency committee, where they discuss their solutions to a dramatic event that, if handled incorrectly, could involve the destruction of the universe. It would function as a bit of a hybrid between a crisis committee and a regular committee except with none of the formalities.
This cabin will be a rather chaotic mess, which is focused on the storyline. Campers will be able to complete little writing prompts focused on worldbuilding that will further expand on the consequences of the apocalypse they’re living through, as well as lots of roleplay in the committee room to find a solution. I would absolutely love the opportunity to lead this cabin this session - out of my three ideas, this is my favourite.
Adventure (or Realistic Fiction) - World Tour! Campers would be part of a tour group, travelling around the world in a month! They’ll visit all sorts of places, from New Zealand, Australia, Singapore, and China, to Germany, France, and the United Kingdom! In each location, campers will be able to complete different challenges that will earn them the postcard from that location, which they can then add to their collection. I’m also hoping to create a cabin memory book as well titled the Travel Journal, which campers can use to remember their journey together with pieces of writing from each of the locations they’ll visit!
This cabin would be extremely adaptable to differing levels of cabin activity as well. If campers are super engaged with the storyline, then they can visit more countries and earn more postcards but if they’re not super engaged with the storyline then less countries will be visited. Either way, it will still result in a “completed” storyline. This is definitely my most fleshed out idea and I would love to have the opportunity to lead this cabin.
Science Fiction (or Adventure) - This cabin is inspired by Star Trek, where campers are on a mission to discover new planets and species and conduct scientific research. They’d receive missions from Starfleet, which would be one-week mini-storylines (for a total of four) in and of themselves which campers can complete. However, this is the least fleshed out idea I have, and my least favourite out of the three I’ve mentioned here. Regardless, I would still love to lead this cabin.
I would prefer not to lead TCTWNW, as I find I really enjoy the competitive side of SWC.
Question 4 - Excerpt - 448 Words
The night was warm - thankfully, it was the height of summer. The skies were fairly dark, and the stars were fairly noticeable, even above the bright city lights. Renée, Robert, and Ally all went out with their day clothes to stay warm. Renée smiled as she and Robert walked with Ally down to their local park.
Renée could already tell there was real joy on Ally’s face, and that Ally was already feeling better.
“Star!” Ally shouted, letting go of Renée’s hand to point up at the sky. “Mama, Dad, there’s a star!”
“You’re right, there is a star,” Renée said, smiling. “Do you know what constellation that’s from?”
Ally blinked. “I… hmmm!”
Renée saw Robert smile as well. “We’re almost at the park, Ally. How about we get there first and then maybe you can tell us what constellation that star is from.”
Ally laughed. “Yes! I know all the stars!”
Renée laughed. “You do know all the stars,” she said, as they turned the corner.
In front of them stood the park, all grassy and quiet. There weren’t any swings, or slides, or climbing frames, but that was okay. This park had some nice benches that Renée loved to take Ally out to when the night got dark during winter.
“Star!” Ally said. “And another, and another! So many stars!”
Renée and Robert both laughed.
“Can you find the star you saw earlier?” Robert asked, as they sat down on their usual bench.
Renée saw Ally’s face bunch up in concentration. “Hmmm… there? No… there!” Ally exclaimed. “That star!”
“Do you know what constellation that star is from?” Renée asked.
Ally once again bunched her face up in concentration. “The cross! The- the south cross!”
“Close enough,” Robert corrected. “That one’s from the Southern Cross, a constellation we can only see where we are. In ancient times, it used to help sailors navigate the seas south of the equator.”
“Equa- equator?” Ally asked.
“It’s a big imaginary line that splits the Earth into north and south,” Renée explained. “We live south of it so we can see certain stars that people in the north can’t. And when sailors from England started exploring the world, they couldn’t see the North Star anymore. So they found the Southern Cross.”
“Sailor! Stars!” Ally exclaimed in delight. “I love this one!”
“It’s very pretty,” Renée replied. “I like it too.”
“Me as well,” Robert added. “Maybe one day you’ll know all the stars.”
“STARS!” Ally exclaimed. “I want to see the stars. And space. Lots of space.”
Renée felt Robert lean closer to her. “I think we have a future astrophysicist on our hands, don’t you?”
Renée smiled. “Oh, absolutely.”
Question 5 - Time Dedication - 245 Words
As a sixth form student, and as someone who is taking four A Levels, there is a lot of work involved in my academic life. However, I can dedicate at least an hour a day to SWC, and more on weekends. I’ve also found that I’ve been managing my schoolwork and life quite well recently too, especially with my recent and somewhat successful foray into bullet journaling.
During June, the first two weeks will consist of my end-of-year exams, however I have been managing my work-life balance fairly well. I would say that while they are important, I should still be able to spend an hour a day on SWC. It would also come as a welcome break to me as well. I may be a bit more inactive than usual in late May but aside from that, they won’t really impact my ability to be online for SWC.
As of now, I have no concrete plans in July, however we do have family coming over to visit during July. I don’t know how much I’ll actually be travelling with them since I’ll still be in school when they arrive. In addition, I’m also planning on doing internships and work experience jobs as well, however these have not yet been confirmed. Overall, my activity and ability to lead a cabin should not be significantly affected by this, and if it is, I will inform the hosts and my (co)leaders as soon as I can.
Question 6 - Time Management - 230 Words
I wouldn’t say my time management is the greatest skill I have. In fact, I’m extremely bad at it. I often procrastinate, but I do my best to break a task down into smaller steps that try to get me over any mountain of work that is freaking me out. I also have started bullet journaling as well in a better effort to manage my time, by creating a to-do list each day of what needs to get done. A lot of the things I plan on there normally get done by the end of the day.
In the past, my terrible time management skills have led to me doing homework the night before, procrastinating until the last minute, forgetting to do things, and waking up stupidly early in the morning to study.
My main strength with time management is my ability to chunk tasks out and take them step by step. This allows me to complete them over a longer period of time, and also allows me to also take a break and deal with my rather short attention span.
This has really helped me complete tasks I normally wouldn’t like to complete recently, especially with my never ending task of revision. Chunking out my time like this has really helped me get things done step by step, especially with a few large research projects I’ve done for school.
Question 7 - Collaboration & Teamwork - 267 Words
I am a bit of a control freak, I’ll admit that. However, my experience with being on my school’s MUN Secretariat has meant that I’ve become a better collaborator. On a team, I do my best to listen to other people and let them carry out their ideas, even if I don’t necessarily agree with it. I’m also willing to compromise on my end, and will usually concede points on my end if it means everyone will be able to come to an agreement.
One of my main strengths in collaboration would be my ability to communicate. Whenever I’m working with other people, I do my best to be as transparent and as open about things as possible. I try to do this by explaining the plan, sending out reminders every so often, and ensuring everything is organised.
I also find myself working best when with other people, and bouncing ideas off one another is where I think my biggest strength is in collaboration. Being able to work with others really helps in truly fleshing out my ideas, as when I talk with others I’m able to try and find some sort of compromise that satisfies all of us. In addition to this, I also am not afraid to throw more absurd and out-there ideas, usually as an offhand comment. These ideas usually end up sparking some discussion, resulting in a better group overall.
In addition, I am a self-taught artist and graphic designer. I’d be willing to make cabin aesthetics and matching profile pictures in addition to the usual cabin work - storylines, word-adding, and so on.
Question 8 - One Quality - 284 Words
The one quality I think I embody the most as a leader is mentorship. Being a leader doesn’t just mean organising fun activities, it’s also about teaching the people you’re leading, encouraging them, and helping them get better.
I think mentorship is a quality I’ve grown into over time as I find myself taking on more of these leadership roles in real life. Much of my job in the secretariat involves training younger delegates and that involves mentoring them and teaching them. In addition to this, I’ve also mentored a younger year group at school. I truly enjoy mentoring: it makes me feel so fulfilled and it’s rewarding watching people grow over time with my guidance.
A huge part of SWC is all about growth, as a writer and also personally to an extent as well. I’ve experienced so much growth over my time in SWC, not just as a writer but also as a person, and that couldn’t have been possible without the amazing people I’ve met along the way: Alana, Pepper, Snowy, Ris, Livy, Sage, Amethyst, Bookie, Em, Ivory, Gee, Pi, Waterfall, Fini, Gigi, Hope, and Mouse - just to name some - who have helped me become the person I am today and supported me through my time here at SWC in different ways.
Mentorship is present in SWC in all forms, from doing critiques to helping new members find their way around. In SWC, I would focus my time on really helping the newer SWCers, whether that be through critiquing their writing, or answering questions, and encouraging them to reach their own writing goals. Another thing I’d do is encourage the formation of relationships, especially between more experienced SWCers and newer campers.
Question 9 - Cabin Atmosphere - 75 Words
The cabin atmosphere that I hope to create this session would be a cabin with an engaging storyline, focused on cabin bonding and chaos, allowing SWCers of all ages and experiences to grow. I’d also aim to create a somewhat competitive cabin, but keep the atmosphere generally relaxed.
“A cabin with a fun and welcoming atmosphere with an engaging storyline. A place for personal growth, while also being lightly competitive on the leaderboard.” (157 characters)
Question 10 - Checkboxes - 253 Words
Yes
Yes
I will be able to complete the responsibilities listed.
If a leader in my cabin goes inactive without prior notice, I’d first try contacting them and wait four days. If the four days have passed and they still haven’t responded, I’d contact them again and begin drawing up plans with the other leaders as to how we can proceed. I would also give the hosts a heads-up that this is happening as well. If they still don’t respond, I will implement the plans I made with the other leaders, such as splitting up campers to different word count groups and figuring out how we can best end the storyline nicely.
If a leader in my cabin did give notice that they were going inactive for an extended period of time, I would discuss with them and my other leaders about practicalities before they go inactive. These practicalities include handing over hostship of a word count groups or redistributing campers in word count groups, wrapping up the storyline in a way that makes sense, and redistributing projects that would be released by that person.
If I was to go inactive, I’d let the leaders and the hosts know all the details I have about the inactivity (keeping reasons as general as possible). I’d then discuss with my leaders in the time I have left about transferring hostship of studios or redistributing campers in word count groups, suggestions as to how the other leaders can proceed with/end the storyline without me present.
Question 11 - Bonus - 80 Words
Oooh, good question! I never really got into Barbie so I don’t know what my dream house would look like. But I know my dream house would have a garage workshop for me to make all sorts of amazing things, as well as an upstairs observatory room so I can look at the stars/night sky. And I’d also have tons of space on the walls for a model plane collection and posters of railway maps and a world map!
Hi there! I’m Skylar (she/her), a 16-year-old Year 12 A Level student from the UK, living in the B(e)ST timezone. I currently take Biology, Chemistry, Maths, and Physics at school and am suffering through the fact I decided to take four subjects. I’m also hopelessly obsessed with public transport, city planning, and commercial aviation, and I want to work as a civil engineer in the future.
In addition to my interest in the sciences, I also am interested in politics and current affairs. I am overly involved in Model United Nations at school, spending much of my time on a Tuesday and Wednesday afternoon dedicated to this activity. I’ve been doing it for three years now, and needless to say this is one of the best things I’ve ever done in my life.
Aside from my academic pursuits, I love being creative! If I’m not studying, working on something for Model UN, or chasing my train/plane obsession down various rabbit holes, you can probably find me making music. I play piano, violin, and also sing in a choir. I love to make music of any kind, and I especially love making covers of songs!
Art is also something I like to do in my free time! I used to spend a lot more time doing art than I currently do, but due to the pressures of life I’ve found myself writing a lot more than drawing. I still draw, and often find myself doing this just before I go to bed.
I, of course, also love writing! I’ve found myself enjoying writing more and more recently. I love to write short stories and scenes, set in worlds I’ve created and established - but that doesn’t mean I don’t write the occasional fanfiction. Regardless of what I’m writing, worldbuilding will always be my favourite part of the writing process. I love combining my interests in sciences and humanities to create a world where my characters can freely live their lives.
I’m not just big into academics and creative stuff though! A fun fact about me is that I figure skate! I’m currently learning salchow and spins, and due to my academics I haven’t had the chance to go to any competitions or perform in anything yet. I do, however, miss the ice rink a lot when I’m not there.
Question 2 - Experience - 398 Words
This coming session will mark my tenth session of SWC - crazy, am I right? I first discovered SWC back in March 2021, and have been coming back ever since. The majority of sessions I’ve attended - eight of those nine - have been as a camper, and last session was my first time co-leading an SWC Cabin!
I have co-led one session of SWC, that being the absolutely fantabulously amazing Fanfi Battle of the Bands last session with Alana, Pepper, and Snowy! It was such a fun experience, getting to plan activities and engage with the SWC community from the leadership side. During this session, I also learnt so much about what it means to be an SWC leader, aside from just adding points and making a fun storyline! It also involved taking on other responsibilities and improvising on the fly should a storyline or plan fall through. This experience also made me appreciate how much work goes into preparing a cabin, and also taught me how to handle complex storylines.
I have also hosted and led various other scratch camps in the past, such as being a current host of Science Exploration Camp (SXC) and Scratch Study Camp (SSC), leader in SMC, and a co-leader in SRC. As a host and leader in these camps, I’ve had to improvise last minute to get an activity out, create daily and weekly activities, and also pick leaders to help create amazing and memorable sessions.
In real life, I’ve been on my school’s Model United Nations Secretariat for the past few months, helping to plan and organise our conference. During this time, my role has primarily been mentoring students both new and old to Model UN within the school, training them to be better delegates. In addition, I’ve also collaborated with the rest of the team to get various other things organised, such as logistic plans.
I have also run a few clubs in the past, as well as organised a few charity sales at my school before. These have involved organising people into completing different tasks, advertising, and talking with the teachers about what we’re planning to do and when.
In terms of my writing experience, I have been writing for as long as I can remember, making stories and being creative in my free time. I mainly write for fun, but I’ve entered the occasional essay competition in the past.
Question 3 - Cabin Pref - 496 Words
The cabins I’d most like to lead this session would be Apocalyptic, Adventure, and Science Fiction! I would prefer not to lead Fanfiction as I co-led that cabin last session, and would not like to lead Romance or Horror mainly because I’m uncomfortable writing in those genres. Aside from that, I would be happy to lead any cabin.
Apocalyptic (or Science Fiction) - Inspired by my endless love of Model United Nations, this would be a cabin partially inspired by this amazing activity that I do. Campers would be called from their various imaginary countries/worlds/planets to an emergency committee, where they discuss their solutions to a dramatic event that, if handled incorrectly, could involve the destruction of the universe. It would function as a bit of a hybrid between a crisis committee and a regular committee except with none of the formalities.
This cabin will be a rather chaotic mess, which is focused on the storyline. Campers will be able to complete little writing prompts focused on worldbuilding that will further expand on the consequences of the apocalypse they’re living through, as well as lots of roleplay in the committee room to find a solution. I would absolutely love the opportunity to lead this cabin this session - out of my three ideas, this is my favourite.
Adventure (or Realistic Fiction) - World Tour! Campers would be part of a tour group, travelling around the world in a month! They’ll visit all sorts of places, from New Zealand, Australia, Singapore, and China, to Germany, France, and the United Kingdom! In each location, campers will be able to complete different challenges that will earn them the postcard from that location, which they can then add to their collection. I’m also hoping to create a cabin memory book as well titled the Travel Journal, which campers can use to remember their journey together with pieces of writing from each of the locations they’ll visit!
This cabin would be extremely adaptable to differing levels of cabin activity as well. If campers are super engaged with the storyline, then they can visit more countries and earn more postcards but if they’re not super engaged with the storyline then less countries will be visited. Either way, it will still result in a “completed” storyline. This is definitely my most fleshed out idea and I would love to have the opportunity to lead this cabin.
Science Fiction (or Adventure) - This cabin is inspired by Star Trek, where campers are on a mission to discover new planets and species and conduct scientific research. They’d receive missions from Starfleet, which would be one-week mini-storylines (for a total of four) in and of themselves which campers can complete. However, this is the least fleshed out idea I have, and my least favourite out of the three I’ve mentioned here. Regardless, I would still love to lead this cabin.
I would prefer not to lead TCTWNW, as I find I really enjoy the competitive side of SWC.
Question 4 - Excerpt - 448 Words
The night was warm - thankfully, it was the height of summer. The skies were fairly dark, and the stars were fairly noticeable, even above the bright city lights. Renée, Robert, and Ally all went out with their day clothes to stay warm. Renée smiled as she and Robert walked with Ally down to their local park.
Renée could already tell there was real joy on Ally’s face, and that Ally was already feeling better.
“Star!” Ally shouted, letting go of Renée’s hand to point up at the sky. “Mama, Dad, there’s a star!”
“You’re right, there is a star,” Renée said, smiling. “Do you know what constellation that’s from?”
Ally blinked. “I… hmmm!”
Renée saw Robert smile as well. “We’re almost at the park, Ally. How about we get there first and then maybe you can tell us what constellation that star is from.”
Ally laughed. “Yes! I know all the stars!”
Renée laughed. “You do know all the stars,” she said, as they turned the corner.
In front of them stood the park, all grassy and quiet. There weren’t any swings, or slides, or climbing frames, but that was okay. This park had some nice benches that Renée loved to take Ally out to when the night got dark during winter.
“Star!” Ally said. “And another, and another! So many stars!”
Renée and Robert both laughed.
“Can you find the star you saw earlier?” Robert asked, as they sat down on their usual bench.
Renée saw Ally’s face bunch up in concentration. “Hmmm… there? No… there!” Ally exclaimed. “That star!”
“Do you know what constellation that star is from?” Renée asked.
Ally once again bunched her face up in concentration. “The cross! The- the south cross!”
“Close enough,” Robert corrected. “That one’s from the Southern Cross, a constellation we can only see where we are. In ancient times, it used to help sailors navigate the seas south of the equator.”
“Equa- equator?” Ally asked.
“It’s a big imaginary line that splits the Earth into north and south,” Renée explained. “We live south of it so we can see certain stars that people in the north can’t. And when sailors from England started exploring the world, they couldn’t see the North Star anymore. So they found the Southern Cross.”
“Sailor! Stars!” Ally exclaimed in delight. “I love this one!”
“It’s very pretty,” Renée replied. “I like it too.”
“Me as well,” Robert added. “Maybe one day you’ll know all the stars.”
“STARS!” Ally exclaimed. “I want to see the stars. And space. Lots of space.”
Renée felt Robert lean closer to her. “I think we have a future astrophysicist on our hands, don’t you?”
Renée smiled. “Oh, absolutely.”
Question 5 - Time Dedication - 245 Words
As a sixth form student, and as someone who is taking four A Levels, there is a lot of work involved in my academic life. However, I can dedicate at least an hour a day to SWC, and more on weekends. I’ve also found that I’ve been managing my schoolwork and life quite well recently too, especially with my recent and somewhat successful foray into bullet journaling.
During June, the first two weeks will consist of my end-of-year exams, however I have been managing my work-life balance fairly well. I would say that while they are important, I should still be able to spend an hour a day on SWC. It would also come as a welcome break to me as well. I may be a bit more inactive than usual in late May but aside from that, they won’t really impact my ability to be online for SWC.
As of now, I have no concrete plans in July, however we do have family coming over to visit during July. I don’t know how much I’ll actually be travelling with them since I’ll still be in school when they arrive. In addition, I’m also planning on doing internships and work experience jobs as well, however these have not yet been confirmed. Overall, my activity and ability to lead a cabin should not be significantly affected by this, and if it is, I will inform the hosts and my (co)leaders as soon as I can.
Question 6 - Time Management - 230 Words
I wouldn’t say my time management is the greatest skill I have. In fact, I’m extremely bad at it. I often procrastinate, but I do my best to break a task down into smaller steps that try to get me over any mountain of work that is freaking me out. I also have started bullet journaling as well in a better effort to manage my time, by creating a to-do list each day of what needs to get done. A lot of the things I plan on there normally get done by the end of the day.
In the past, my terrible time management skills have led to me doing homework the night before, procrastinating until the last minute, forgetting to do things, and waking up stupidly early in the morning to study.
My main strength with time management is my ability to chunk tasks out and take them step by step. This allows me to complete them over a longer period of time, and also allows me to also take a break and deal with my rather short attention span.
This has really helped me complete tasks I normally wouldn’t like to complete recently, especially with my never ending task of revision. Chunking out my time like this has really helped me get things done step by step, especially with a few large research projects I’ve done for school.
Question 7 - Collaboration & Teamwork - 267 Words
I am a bit of a control freak, I’ll admit that. However, my experience with being on my school’s MUN Secretariat has meant that I’ve become a better collaborator. On a team, I do my best to listen to other people and let them carry out their ideas, even if I don’t necessarily agree with it. I’m also willing to compromise on my end, and will usually concede points on my end if it means everyone will be able to come to an agreement.
One of my main strengths in collaboration would be my ability to communicate. Whenever I’m working with other people, I do my best to be as transparent and as open about things as possible. I try to do this by explaining the plan, sending out reminders every so often, and ensuring everything is organised.
I also find myself working best when with other people, and bouncing ideas off one another is where I think my biggest strength is in collaboration. Being able to work with others really helps in truly fleshing out my ideas, as when I talk with others I’m able to try and find some sort of compromise that satisfies all of us. In addition to this, I also am not afraid to throw more absurd and out-there ideas, usually as an offhand comment. These ideas usually end up sparking some discussion, resulting in a better group overall.
In addition, I am a self-taught artist and graphic designer. I’d be willing to make cabin aesthetics and matching profile pictures in addition to the usual cabin work - storylines, word-adding, and so on.
Question 8 - One Quality - 284 Words
The one quality I think I embody the most as a leader is mentorship. Being a leader doesn’t just mean organising fun activities, it’s also about teaching the people you’re leading, encouraging them, and helping them get better.
I think mentorship is a quality I’ve grown into over time as I find myself taking on more of these leadership roles in real life. Much of my job in the secretariat involves training younger delegates and that involves mentoring them and teaching them. In addition to this, I’ve also mentored a younger year group at school. I truly enjoy mentoring: it makes me feel so fulfilled and it’s rewarding watching people grow over time with my guidance.
A huge part of SWC is all about growth, as a writer and also personally to an extent as well. I’ve experienced so much growth over my time in SWC, not just as a writer but also as a person, and that couldn’t have been possible without the amazing people I’ve met along the way: Alana, Pepper, Snowy, Ris, Livy, Sage, Amethyst, Bookie, Em, Ivory, Gee, Pi, Waterfall, Fini, Gigi, Hope, and Mouse - just to name some - who have helped me become the person I am today and supported me through my time here at SWC in different ways.
Mentorship is present in SWC in all forms, from doing critiques to helping new members find their way around. In SWC, I would focus my time on really helping the newer SWCers, whether that be through critiquing their writing, or answering questions, and encouraging them to reach their own writing goals. Another thing I’d do is encourage the formation of relationships, especially between more experienced SWCers and newer campers.
Question 9 - Cabin Atmosphere - 75 Words
The cabin atmosphere that I hope to create this session would be a cabin with an engaging storyline, focused on cabin bonding and chaos, allowing SWCers of all ages and experiences to grow. I’d also aim to create a somewhat competitive cabin, but keep the atmosphere generally relaxed.
“A cabin with a fun and welcoming atmosphere with an engaging storyline. A place for personal growth, while also being lightly competitive on the leaderboard.” (157 characters)
Question 10 - Checkboxes - 253 Words
Yes
Yes
I will be able to complete the responsibilities listed.
If a leader in my cabin goes inactive without prior notice, I’d first try contacting them and wait four days. If the four days have passed and they still haven’t responded, I’d contact them again and begin drawing up plans with the other leaders as to how we can proceed. I would also give the hosts a heads-up that this is happening as well. If they still don’t respond, I will implement the plans I made with the other leaders, such as splitting up campers to different word count groups and figuring out how we can best end the storyline nicely.
If a leader in my cabin did give notice that they were going inactive for an extended period of time, I would discuss with them and my other leaders about practicalities before they go inactive. These practicalities include handing over hostship of a word count groups or redistributing campers in word count groups, wrapping up the storyline in a way that makes sense, and redistributing projects that would be released by that person.
If I was to go inactive, I’d let the leaders and the hosts know all the details I have about the inactivity (keeping reasons as general as possible). I’d then discuss with my leaders in the time I have left about transferring hostship of studios or redistributing campers in word count groups, suggestions as to how the other leaders can proceed with/end the storyline without me present.
Question 11 - Bonus - 80 Words
Oooh, good question! I never really got into Barbie so I don’t know what my dream house would look like. But I know my dream house would have a garage workshop for me to make all sorts of amazing things, as well as an upstairs observatory room so I can look at the stars/night sky. And I’d also have tons of space on the walls for a model plane collection and posters of railway maps and a world map!
Last edited by Milkysplash (May 5, 2025 13:44:20)
- taylorsversion--
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
critique for sunny!!
WIP
WIP
About Me
Hi there, nice to meet you! I’m Sunny, and I go by she/her pronouns! I’m a teen girl living in the south-east of France, in other words in the CET (UTC+2) timezone! I speak three languages - Chinese, my native language, English and French. I come from a Chinese family but moved to France when I was three years old. I have since then attended the local international school opened along with the international organisation my parents work for
At school, I’m often looked upon as the straight-A student - and I admit that I do have a certain ease for academic assignments. Though I sometimes can be seen as the stereotypical know-it-all everybody hates (oops-) due to how serious and professional I can act, I’m also a fun person to hang out with in general, especially around close friends. I’m compassionate and helpful, and will not hesitate to crack a few jokes when I’m able to think of some
Online, I’m more extroverted than irl and can be quite chaotic (like most of us here, I presume ). That’s also why I love SWC so much! Everyone is so nice and welcoming (and chaotic!!!) that you don’t have to worry about making a false step or not fitting in.
Personality apart, I have loads of hobbies and extracurricular activities! Just this year, my volleyball coach signed my team up for the regional championships, and so far we’re in second place! We’ve got competitions approximately every two weeks, and each time the team’s bonds grow deeper and more meaningful with the excitement, stress and anticipation ^^ If you can’t tell that already, I love both this sport and my teammates <3
I’ve also played the piano since I was four years old, and though I’m not considering becoming a professional musician, I’ve grown fond of piano music over the years. I’m currently working on Intermezzo op.117 n.2 by Brahms, and I’m not even lying when I say I’ve fallen in love with the piece
During my free time, I also enjoy making handicrafts - I have a drawer full of old cardboard, bits of strings, paint and various other items I’ve collected over the years, and they do come in useful at times, though what they mostly do is lay around untouched hehe…
And, before I forget- I /love/ reading, to the point where my mom gets mad at me from repeating ‘dinner’s ready!’ five times without me hearing her - because I’m absorbed in the fictional universe of a book I’ve had a passion for reading as far as I can remember, and I think the first time I cried over a book was in second grade :’) Some of my all time favourites are, to state a few, the Count of Monte Cristo, the Harry Potter saga, the Giver and Little Women.
Previous Participation
This upcoming SWC session will be my fifth! It’s fascinating how time flies, it feels like I’ve just stumbled upon the march ‘24 camper signups yesterday…
Here are the cabins I’ve been in (all as campers):
Script Theatron (march ‘24)
Script Podcast (july ‘24)
Apocalyptic - The Infestation (november ‘24)
Illu-Fi Spider Verse (march ‘24)
Aside from SWC, I’ve taken part in smaller camps, including WUC, SAC and SDC. I’ve led once in SAC, which allowed me to better understand with hands-on experience the responsibilities of a leader (cabin planning, storyline, adding words, etc…)
Irl, I’ve held many leadership positions, as I’m pretty much a born leader. It seems that my teachers agree on this point since they’ve mentioned I’m a ‘class leader’ in my latest school report lol. I’ve been class president numerous times during primary school, and I am currently eco-delegate in our class, meaning I, along with eco-delegates from other classes, organise environmental awareness events around the school and propose solutions to make our community more eco-friendly.
As for writing, I really started doing so as a hobby in March ‘24, during my first SWC session. Before that, though I enjoyed writing assignments in school, I never considered it as a leisure activity. With all the dailies and weeklies, I started delving further into the world of writing and since then it has grown into a passion. I’m currently working on a short story that I’m planning to enter for an irl writing competition.
Cabin Preferences
Though I most often write in fan-fi, real-fi, fantasy or dystopian, I love exploring possibilities with new and unfamiliar genres as well, so I’m fine with co-leading any cabin!
I would prefer not to co-lead TCTWNW because I very much enjoy the competitive of SWC ;D
Excerpt
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/808229/?page=6#post-8429269
Time Dedication
In July, it’ll be the summer vacation for me, and for once, we aren’t going back to China, so I’ll be able to dedicate loads of time to SWC! I’ll pretty much be online all day, and will be able to dedicate at least 3 hours per day for SWC (not including personal things like doing the dailies and weeklies)!
For the cabin-planning months, the only things that will keep me away from SWC are school work and extracurricular activities. I do have a couple music exams scattered around in May and June, but hopefully these won’t affect my activity too much.
On the whole, I expect to be able to delicate at least 9 hours a week for cabin-planning.
Time Management
I admit, time management is not my strong suit. Between school work, extracurricular activities, house chores, hobbies and everything online, I often get lost and struggle to prioritise tasks effectively.
Though I ultimately get things done before the deadline, the result is often of poorer quality than if I had planned my tasks beforehand. This is particularly problematic when I have very limited time to get things done (e.g. when I come home at 8pm and have homework for the next day). I learnt the importance of effective time management the hard way: stressful situations and late-night working - I’ve seen all those.
I have been actively working on my time management skills for quite some time now - I’ve tried various methods for effective time management and so far the two that work best for me are:
- Separating my day into a precise schedule for each task
- Sorting out the level of importance of each task, therefore prioritising the completion of one over another.
- Rewarding myself once I finish an important task effectively
These allow me to complete one task first before going to another, and I found that they help improve my work quality and reduce stress for deadlines.
Collaboration & Assets
I am generally good at collaborating effectively with others. From the numerous projects I’ve been part of, I’ve learnt to be attentive to others’ thoughts and questions, and am good at incorporating these with my own ideas. I am also able to attribute tasks fairly to each person depending on their strengths and skills, and am quick to find solutions to any problems that may arise, both online and irl. An example of this is when a person from my group fell sick the day of our presentation. I was able to come up with last minute solutions and attribute their part to those of us who were present. We ended up getting full marks ^^
My main weakness in collaboration used to be the lack of communication, but I am confident when I say that I have improved a lot in this field. In the past, I used to be shy and reluctant to share my opinions and ideas with others. Similarly, when something went off track, I did my best to hide it from others and fix the problem myself. This often led to extremely stressful and awkward situations.
However, I do believe I am much better concerning this. Over the years I’ve grown more extroverted and more open to sharing my thoughts and feelings with others. I’ve learnt that it's okay to step out of my comfort zone and communicate my opinions - even if I’m unsure whether they’re good or not.
One Quality
If I were to choose one quality I would be able to embody as a leader, it would be communication. As I mentioned before, I used to have trouble concerning this, and that reinforced my understanding of its importance.
The lack of communication often leads to misunderstandings, eventually arguments. For a team to work smoothly, we have to prevent these from happening as much as possible. The solution is quality communication. By this, I mean that members of the leadership teams should not hesitate to tell others if something has gone off track - or even just to inform the others that they will be unavailable for a day or two, that they would need a little more time to finish a project, or simply that they have a good idea to share!
Communication is vital for the well-functioning of a leadership team, whether online or irl. If a problem is encountered, nobody should bear the burden alone, as more brains can think of a solution quicker than a single one!
Cabin Atmosphere
A highly competitive cabin with an immersive storyline, all while maintaining a friendly, welcoming and inclusive atmosphere.
Checkboxes
A.
☑ I will be available to help add points in the main cabin consistently throughout camp
☑ I am willing to share a promotional project for SWC
B.
I can complete all leadership responsibilities listed in the FAQ
C.
If I have to go inactive, I will inform all my (co)leaders as soon as I know of it and, if my inactivity will delay projects, I will work out a possible solution with my (co)leaders. If the situation does not allow me to be active enough to take on the role of co-leader anymore, I will propose to step down from my role.
If a fellow (co)leader goes inactive and informs us beforehand, I will work with them to propose a suitable solution to distribute their tasks to the rest of the leadership team. If they have not warned us of their inactivity, the rest of the leadership team shall again distribute the inactive member’s tasks to others to ensure that the cabin will work smoothly. If the inactive member does not show any signs of activity after two or three weeks, we will consider replacing them with a new (co)leader if needed.
Last edited by taylorsversion-- (April 30, 2025 21:38:31)
- starunicorn_5
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
kat's rough draft app--
about me
Hi! I’m Kat. I use she/her pronouns and I live in the ex(IST)ing timezone! I’m your everyday eccentric STEM-and-cat-obsessed girl, who loves to read and (WAIT WHAT REALLY??) write. Some of my other hobbies are playing chess, badminton, and sketching (both digital and traditional). I can usually be find sticking my nose in a book or chatting with my friends! I do have lots of interests- science and theater being some I’m most passionate about- they’ve changed my life for the better in more ways than I can count!
Some of my favourite books are the Wings of Fire series by Tui T. Sutherland, Harry Potter by J.K Rowling, and of course: The Girl Who Drank the Moon by Kelly Barnhill <3 Another lovely aspect of my life is ✨music✨ Music is always really calming. My current obsessions are Taylor Swift and EPIC: the musical (hint: it’s epic!)! I also listen to Olivia Rodrigo, Katy Perry, Alan Walker, and a mix of other bands and artists. A huge part of my life is science. Pure, beautiful, nerdy science. It’s passions in life; a scientist is what I’ve wanted to be since I was six. It’s always helped me grow in knowledge and understanding of the world, and given me a steady ground of safety.
And then: theatre. This is one of my more recent ventures, but I already love it. Acting, watching, being a part of the crew- it’s all amazing. There’s just something about stepping into the one of my bigger life of another person that can open your eyes to the life of the people standing around you!
Finding SWC is one of the best things that have happened to me! I cannot imagine my social or writing journey without it- my confidence grew tenfold after joining and I hope that everyone gets a chance to experience just as much magic! ❤️
-
experience
July ‘25 will be my sixth session of SWC (woah I’m getting old). I’ve also participated in camps like JWC, WUC, SRC, etc…
Here’s an overview all my sessions in SWC:
>Nov ‘23 - backup camper
>March ‘24 (:nostalgia
- camper >July ‘24 - camper
>Nov ‘24 (a year?!) - camper
>March ‘25 - co-leader
Among all these sessions, I’ve definitely learned a lot and hope to give a lot back!
For leadership experience, I have experience both online and IRL. Recently, I co-led myth (sage and willow ❤️) and found out a lot more about being on the SWC leadership team, and about the responsibility and expectations. I’ve also been the admin of a roleplay or two on Scratch. In real life, a lot of my experience is from either school or home. At school, I’ve been the leader of several group projects or assignments. At home, I take care of the household in my parents’ absence.
I still have a lot to learn, but I’m trying my best to improve on how I handle situations with people online as well using this experience! As for writing experience, I’ve been writing for a very long time- from short stories written at five (minus punctuation and logic) to novel attempts at ten. I’ve also participated in several writing competitions IRL.
While I don’t have any titles to state my writing experience, I have time and passion- because writing is an art!
-
preferences
If I was going to be a leader, my top preferences for cabins to lead are spy-fi, adventure, fantasy, mythology, mystery, or dystopian. I have ideas for a few of these-
Spy-fi/Mystery: This is my most fledged-out idea, and the one I’m most in love with! The storyline revolves around an academy that is training the next generation of secret spies, but when a piece of high-tech gadgetry that could unbalance technology is stolen and something strange happens to the teachers, the cadets will have to prove their skills earlier than expected.
Mythology: This storyline is EPIC-based- the basic plot is that in modern times, a ship is wrecked on Circe’s island. Circe knows a way to help the crew get back home, but before she can do that, the crew has to help her with a problem on her island that is interfering with her magic. While I like both of these ideas, I would be able to contribute more to spy-fi as a leader in a storyline, because I really think that the new genre has lots of new opportunities! Next, cabins I wouldn’t do very well in leading because of lack of experience in these genres are poetry, romance, and journalism. As a co-leader, I would be honoured to co-lead any genre!
TCTWNW: Even though I think that this is a good idea, I prefer the competitive levels of SWC, and it motivates me, so I’d prefer not to (co)lead TCTWNW this session.
-
excerpt
my march '25 writing contest entry - https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/813497/?page=1#post-8468732
-
dedication
I will try my best to check in everyday and complete all my responsibilities as early as possible. In July, I will be able to dedicate an hour a day on SWC.
I don’t have any specific plans that I know of currently, except for school and chess extracurriculars, which would take up more or less nine hours of my time in a day. As for June I have little-to-no plans, but since school will just be starting up after summer vacation, that will be my priority. The first half of the month will be holidays, so I can spend as much time as possible on cabin planning! I should be able to complete all my responsibilities, along with write, but if anything comes up, I will notify my leadership team.
-
time management
Time management has always been an important thing for me to work on. It’s a necessary skill to have in a lot of aspects in daily life- whether it’s short-term, for a test or exam, or long-term, for how well you can divide your homework up and submit it in time.
Starting off with my skills in time management, the two most prominent are efficiency and completing deadlines. First- I always do my work as efficiently as possible while maintaining speed and quality. I try to think of new ways to make my work simpler. Saving time is important for me, so this skill comes in handy. Second- no matter if I have to finish it at the last minute, I always strive to complete all my work on time, and I do most of the time. Though I do procrastinate at times, I always find a way to complete it.
Onto weakness- my two major weak points are procrastination (I do love potatoes :wink
and distraction. Procrastinating is a little demon that urges you to push back hard work, and it’s a bit difficult for me to gather the enough will to refuse. I have a habit of leaving things to the last minute, and overworking myself. I’m trying to work on this, by increasing my willpower and choosing more effective times of the day for work! Moving on, I get easily distracted. If I’m studying a topic for a test, it’s likely that I’ll forget about it and start doodling. When I get distracted, it’s hard to get back into the flow of work. This has been a weakness for as long as I can remember, but I’m trying to reduce the effects! Some things I’m trying are making my workspace less cluttered, and focusing only on the task until it’s complete. These weaknesses do impact my ability, but I’ll always endeavor to tone them down and improve my time management skills, and also my skill in completing my responsibilities as a whole!
-
collaboration
Collaboration is something awesome, because to me it’s several minds working together to make something great.
Starting with my strengths in this field: the main ones are open-mindedness and reliability. First, I always listen to every idea, and go through it carefully, considering everyone’s opinion. In my mindset, there are no bad ideas- there’s always space to build upon! Listening is one of the things I’m proud of- I strive to give everyone a chance to pitch in.
Next, I always do the tasks that others are depending on me to complete. Being reliable is a big thing to me- I hate to let anyone down. When your colleague or friend is counting on you, it increases the motivation to get it done a thousand times, because letting that person down makes me feel awful- so, tasks that will affect others are always high on the priority list.
Now, to weaknesses. The ones that stand out the most are overthinking and saying ‘no‘. First, I overthink a LOT. In real life, I’m a socially awkward person sometimes, so I’m constantly second guessing whether I’ve said anything wrong, or done anything displeasing. I’m trying to combat this by being more open, and sharing my thoughts, rather than bottling them up and letting them turn into an overthinking storm.
As for saying ‘no’, this weakness goes hand in hand with overthinking. I get really guilty when I feel like I’ve let someone down, so I do my best to do everything I can. I avoid refusing a request whenever possible, but sometimes I extend my limits. I’m glad to say this has reduced in the past few months, but I’m still trying to improve by setting solid boundaries for myself.
The assets that I can bring to the team are creativity, the ability to hold deadlines, and graphic design.
-
one quality
There are many qualities I value and can embody in a leadership role, but I think the one that I would choose is integrity. Integrity is one of my qualities, and I think it’s important in a leader because (especially in a community like SWC, where things run on an honor system) while a leader’s job is to make sure that everyone’s honest, it’s just as important that they are honest themselves. A leader should be trustworthy to both the leadership team and the campers- anyone participating in SWC, and even beyond that. Actions I will take to embody this are following the honor system, following the ideals and morals that make SWC a better place, and always choosing the honest option: I will do my best to be a good leader.
-
atmosphere
Make memories and long-lasting friendships here, in a storyline-oriented cabin that is slightly competitive, with a welcoming and inclusive atmosphere.
(151 characters)
❤️
-
checkboxes
A.yup
yup
B. No, I can complete all my responsibilities!
C. In the case of a fellow leader’s inactivity, I will first wait for 48 hours, and if they are not active, then I’ll ping them, and wait again for 48 hours. If they do not respond, I’ll discuss it with the rest of my team, inform the hosts, and come up with a solution to ensure that for the inactivity period, camp runs smoothly by shifting all necessary responsibilities between us.
In the case of my own inactivity, I’ll do my best to inform the hosts, the rest of the leadership team, and the campers about the inactivity period, and shift responsibilities and controls accordingly.
————————-
edited after
-kiara
-livy
's
critique(s)
Last edited by starunicorn_5 (May 8, 2025 12:10:18)
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Kat
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/817515/?page=1#post-8528140
621 words
About Me -
This section is looking great, however I would cut out the part about your age, it's just personal preference, but I like to keep that more private. <3
I love trying
new things so come over and talk anytime, meeting new people
You don’t need a new line here either <3
Pure,
beautiful, nerdy science.
You don’t need a new line here ^^”
With this general section, it feels a little list-like, and quite short on each paragraph so I would recommend elaborating more on each of your topics and hobbies, perhaps talking about how they’ve changed your life? What skills you get from them? Or what makes them so special to you?
Experience -
situations!As for writing
Put a space between ‘situations’ and ‘as’
And you’ve said ‘as for’ twice, so you may want to change that, although it's just personal preference <3
Otherwise this section is looking great!! I would recommend just going through and making sure your sentences connect together well, otherwise they look awesome!
Preference -
This is good, but I would recommend elaborating on your ideas a little more, and mentioning what cabin you’d be okay with co-leading, as you’ve mentioned which ones you’d rather not lead, so the ones you would want to lead might be a good thing to say.
I’d also recommend choosing one of your ideas that you're most passionate about and trying to sell it to the host more than the others.
Dedication -
This, like all the others, is looking amazing. I would recommend mentioning something about contacting people if any activities come up, however it could just be a short sentence as you go more in-depth about this for Checkboxes <3
Time Management -
Time management I would say to elaborate a bit more of your strengths, although you’ve done a great job as is.
I would also suggest saying a bit more on how you’re improving, but like with strengths, you’re doing an awesome job with just how it is.
Collaboration -
This is looking (curse that I’m saying it again) AMAZING!! My recommendations would be to say whether you can bring things like graphic design or art as assets, and to talk a little more on how you're improving on your weaknesses, it feels a bit vague at the moment, so being a little more straightforward would be great!!
One quality -
Actions I will take to embody this are following the honor system by partaking in point/word/etcetera truthfully; being honest in submission of activities and extensions; conveying the truth in all circumstances; among others: I will do my best to be a good leader.
I would suggest changing this to be commas instead of semicolons, to make it more grammatically correct, else I would just say to rewrite this sentence or split it up so it's easier to understand.
I would also say to talk about how you embody it personality wise, but that doesn’t particularly affect this section and is just an idea. <3
Atmosphere -
Looks great!!
Checkboxes -
For A) you could say - both boxes are checked - or something along those lines, instead of having written ‘yup’ on two lines <3
I’ll discuss itwith
Space here between ‘it’ and ‘with’
Aside from that, this section looks great!!
I would recommend removing the ‘etc…’ and continuing to give more examples of what you would do, or summing it up instead.
Final note -
Your app is looking amazing Kat!!! Your answers are clearly well thought through, and everythings handled so maturely and honestly, I’m *scream for words* this is looking spectacular!
I can’t wait to see how the rest of your app goes, and I hope this helps! <3
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/817515/?page=1#post-8528140
621 words
About Me -
This section is looking great, however I would cut out the part about your age, it's just personal preference, but I like to keep that more private. <3
I love trying
new things so come over and talk anytime, meeting new people
You don’t need a new line here either <3
Pure,
beautiful, nerdy science.
You don’t need a new line here ^^”
With this general section, it feels a little list-like, and quite short on each paragraph so I would recommend elaborating more on each of your topics and hobbies, perhaps talking about how they’ve changed your life? What skills you get from them? Or what makes them so special to you?
Experience -
situations!As for writing
Put a space between ‘situations’ and ‘as’
And you’ve said ‘as for’ twice, so you may want to change that, although it's just personal preference <3
Otherwise this section is looking great!! I would recommend just going through and making sure your sentences connect together well, otherwise they look awesome!
Preference -
This is good, but I would recommend elaborating on your ideas a little more, and mentioning what cabin you’d be okay with co-leading, as you’ve mentioned which ones you’d rather not lead, so the ones you would want to lead might be a good thing to say.
I’d also recommend choosing one of your ideas that you're most passionate about and trying to sell it to the host more than the others.
Dedication -
This, like all the others, is looking amazing. I would recommend mentioning something about contacting people if any activities come up, however it could just be a short sentence as you go more in-depth about this for Checkboxes <3
Time Management -
Time management I would say to elaborate a bit more of your strengths, although you’ve done a great job as is.
I would also suggest saying a bit more on how you’re improving, but like with strengths, you’re doing an awesome job with just how it is.
Collaboration -
This is looking (curse that I’m saying it again) AMAZING!! My recommendations would be to say whether you can bring things like graphic design or art as assets, and to talk a little more on how you're improving on your weaknesses, it feels a bit vague at the moment, so being a little more straightforward would be great!!
One quality -
Actions I will take to embody this are following the honor system by partaking in point/word/etcetera truthfully; being honest in submission of activities and extensions; conveying the truth in all circumstances; among others: I will do my best to be a good leader.
I would suggest changing this to be commas instead of semicolons, to make it more grammatically correct, else I would just say to rewrite this sentence or split it up so it's easier to understand.
I would also say to talk about how you embody it personality wise, but that doesn’t particularly affect this section and is just an idea. <3
Atmosphere -
Looks great!!
Checkboxes -
For A) you could say - both boxes are checked - or something along those lines, instead of having written ‘yup’ on two lines <3
I’ll discuss itwith
Space here between ‘it’ and ‘with’
Aside from that, this section looks great!!
I would recommend removing the ‘etc…’ and continuing to give more examples of what you would do, or summing it up instead.
Final note -
Your app is looking amazing Kat!!! Your answers are clearly well thought through, and everythings handled so maturely and honestly, I’m *scream for words* this is looking spectacular!
I can’t wait to see how the rest of your app goes, and I hope this helps! <3
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Kiara
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8518919/
630 words
Hi Kiara!! I’m so sorry if this seems a bit nitpicky, your writing is amazing and it's so hard to pick out flaws when it's this good. I’ve tried my best, so let me know if you want me to elaborate on anything I’ve said. <3
About Me -
This section looks amazing!! You’ve introduced yourself to us wonderfully, however your paragraph about books feels a bit list-like, so I would recommend cutting out a few, or talking about a couple of other books that you’ve mentioned as well as the Amie Kaufman books <3
Experience -
I’ve campered four times,
Personally, I like to say that I’ve ‘camped’ rather than ‘campered’ but both work here!
I would also suggest making sure that you paint your crash in July in a slightly more positive light, elaborating on what you learnt from it so that it feels a bit more balanced.
The Paranormal paragraph is looking great! But I might suggest mentioning how the storyline not going right helped you learn or affected what you learnt from that session.
Also, don’t forget to mention what writing experience you’ve had in real life! And maybe talk a little more about your in real life leadership experience as well <3
(I’m asking you to add more words to your word count. I'm sorry :sob
Cabin Preferences -
I personally like to try to sell the idea I’d like to do the most more than the other option, just so you have a higher chance of being picked for it, but if you want to do your two ideas the same, it's nice as is!
(but oakdhajldhaj your cabin ideas are amazing omg :star_struck
And mentioning a couple of cabin you would NOT like to co-lead might be beneficial to show you have clear boundaries on what you do and don’t want. <3
Expert -
I read this a month or so back and it's so good omg, excellent show of writing! <3
Dedication -
This is looking great!! I don’t really have anything to say here <3
Time Management -
I personally prefer to place your weaknesses up top as it shows how you're working to improve yourself before bringing into the parts that you’re a lot better at so they end with a positive outlook.
This section is exceptionally hard to pick any flaws into, but a small recommendation I would have is to add just another sentence or two onto the paragraphs with your strengths, so they seem powerful (not the word I’m looking for but you know what I mean :sob
next to your weaknesses.
Collaboration -
Here I would suggest adding another short paragraph about your strengths, again just to emphasize that your weakness is only a small part of how awesome you are.
Again, I prefer to lead with my weakness, although that's just personal preference.
Aside from this, it looks great!! (also your voice is so pretty!! /gen)
One Quality -
I would say to talk a bit more about how respect bleeds into your leadership style, and how you’ll apply to SWC, otherwise this section is amazing. I love your leadership trait. <3
Atmosphere -
Looks good!
Checkboxes -
Also looks amazing <3
Final Note -
Omg your app is so amazing I cannot imagine a single timeline where you wont get chosen for leader agsdjkhal. All your answers are so well thought out and handled so well. *screams*
I can’t wait to see what your app theme is!
When you were asking for a critique, you asked if anything seemed rambly or anything, and I don’t think so. All your answers are detailed, which is likely where the word count stems from, however I don’t see it as a problem or that you need to cut anything.
Good luck!!!
- Liv
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8518919/
630 words
Hi Kiara!! I’m so sorry if this seems a bit nitpicky, your writing is amazing and it's so hard to pick out flaws when it's this good. I’ve tried my best, so let me know if you want me to elaborate on anything I’ve said. <3
About Me -
This section looks amazing!! You’ve introduced yourself to us wonderfully, however your paragraph about books feels a bit list-like, so I would recommend cutting out a few, or talking about a couple of other books that you’ve mentioned as well as the Amie Kaufman books <3
Experience -
I’ve campered four times,
Personally, I like to say that I’ve ‘camped’ rather than ‘campered’ but both work here!
I would also suggest making sure that you paint your crash in July in a slightly more positive light, elaborating on what you learnt from it so that it feels a bit more balanced.
The Paranormal paragraph is looking great! But I might suggest mentioning how the storyline not going right helped you learn or affected what you learnt from that session.
Also, don’t forget to mention what writing experience you’ve had in real life! And maybe talk a little more about your in real life leadership experience as well <3
(I’m asking you to add more words to your word count. I'm sorry :sob

Cabin Preferences -
I personally like to try to sell the idea I’d like to do the most more than the other option, just so you have a higher chance of being picked for it, but if you want to do your two ideas the same, it's nice as is!
(but oakdhajldhaj your cabin ideas are amazing omg :star_struck

And mentioning a couple of cabin you would NOT like to co-lead might be beneficial to show you have clear boundaries on what you do and don’t want. <3
Expert -
I read this a month or so back and it's so good omg, excellent show of writing! <3
Dedication -
This is looking great!! I don’t really have anything to say here <3
Time Management -
I personally prefer to place your weaknesses up top as it shows how you're working to improve yourself before bringing into the parts that you’re a lot better at so they end with a positive outlook.
This section is exceptionally hard to pick any flaws into, but a small recommendation I would have is to add just another sentence or two onto the paragraphs with your strengths, so they seem powerful (not the word I’m looking for but you know what I mean :sob
next to your weaknesses.Collaboration -
Here I would suggest adding another short paragraph about your strengths, again just to emphasize that your weakness is only a small part of how awesome you are.
Again, I prefer to lead with my weakness, although that's just personal preference.
Aside from this, it looks great!! (also your voice is so pretty!! /gen)
One Quality -
I would say to talk a bit more about how respect bleeds into your leadership style, and how you’ll apply to SWC, otherwise this section is amazing. I love your leadership trait. <3
Atmosphere -
Looks good!
Checkboxes -
Also looks amazing <3
Final Note -
Omg your app is so amazing I cannot imagine a single timeline where you wont get chosen for leader agsdjkhal. All your answers are so well thought out and handled so well. *screams*
I can’t wait to see what your app theme is!
When you were asking for a critique, you asked if anything seemed rambly or anything, and I don’t think so. All your answers are detailed, which is likely where the word count stems from, however I don’t see it as a problem or that you need to cut anything.
Good luck!!!
- Liv
- booklover883322
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Here's my app! This is SUCH a first draft, so please rip into it like crazy guys I know it's bad *sob*
About Me
HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Ahem-
Please ignore the random bouts of maniacal laughter. It’s a medical condition.
Anyways! You can call me B̟̈́̆̐̄̚͜i̵͓͙̱͚̎͟ḻ̸͈ͧ͑̓̓̀͡ḻ̸͈ͧ͑̓̓̀͡', I mean, Bookie! I live in the glorious MST time zone, and I use she/her pronouns. I’m a Christian, first and foremost, and everything else falls in line after that. I’m also an avid author, reader, content creator, artist, and academic. I’m currently taking dual credit courses with two colleges, and until recently, my life has been CONSUMED by school. However, with my creative streak, I’ve learned how to work with the time that I have. I’m a high school junior (I’m going to be a senior next year?? :eyes: I’m not sure that I’m ready-), and I’m in love with all things words, whether that be writing, reading, speech and debate, and really truly anything with communication. I also am in MANY a fandom, such as Gravity Falls (hence the theme), Carmen Sandiego, Alien Stage, Percy Jackson, I/ASTV, and so much more! Ask me about a fandom you’re in, and it’s pretty dang likely that I’m in it as well! Outside of the online fandom space, I’m the oldest of three kids, and I’ve learned that being the oldest sister comes with quite the heavy load. However, I’m so grateful for my siblings! I also absolutely love music, and some of my favorite artists are Jann, Maneskin, Belle Sisoki, and Derivakat. (Would highly recommend you listen to Gladiator by Jann, which is a MASTERPIECE of a song!)
Wait! Don’t go yet! Before it’s too late, why don’t I tell you about his nefarious pl-
W-WAIT, THAT’S IT, THAT’S ALL YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT THIS- *cough* I MEAN ME! I’VE ALREADY SAID TOO MUCH! AHHH
Previous participation
I’ve been in SWC since March 2020! I haven't been in EVERY session since then, but I’ve been in quite a lot! I’ve been a co-leader three times, co-leading Fan-fi twice and Bangsian once. The experiences I’ve had while co-leading have shaped me into a better leader. I’ve learned so much from the SWCommunity. The diversity, the uniqueness, all of it, is SO inspiring! Thanks to SWC, I’ve emerged as a better leader, a better person, and a better writer.
As for my leadership experience outside of SWC, I am a part of the traveling staff team for a Christian non-profit that travels all over the USA to teach teens about civics. I’ve gotten in-depth training on leadership, the mindset behind it, and how to practically apply my leadership skills in the classroom. (The training was a straight week where I was essentially drinking from a firehose the entire time-) I’ve traveled to state capitols all over the USA, and have served on a team that served a student body with a range of 40-100 students (the student body size depends on the class and state). Within this same organization, I also have worked on campaign teams for mock elections, where I have maintained and monitored a large group chat, making sure that it was appropriate and active and that it maintained the campaign’s image. I worked on my friend’s campaigns as well as my own. That admin work can very easily transfer over to a SWC cabin ;D
I also work in my church with the children’s ministry. I have also been given leadership opportunities in my homeschool co-op, my church youth group, my dual credit college courses, as well as in my family. I seek out leadership wherever I go, which has been an interesting experience overall.
Cabin Prefs
It’s summer vacation, and you and your friends live in Gravity Falls, Oregon, with absolutely nothing to do. After the events of Weirdmageddon, everything lacks that ‘weird flair’. All the random happenings feel utterly uninspired and offensively ordinary. You and your friends need something fresh for this summer.
*snicker* Oh imagine just how boring their lives will be for the entire summer. I doubt that anything will change about THAT. *cough*
I would absolutely love to lead a Gravity Falls-inspired cabin underneath the label of Bi-Fi, or maybe Thriller, Mystery, or Adventure. All of those genres would fit with the story I would cook up! Knowledge of Gravity Falls would not be necessary, since I would like to develop a new story that takes inspiration from the series. I- um, no, sorry, BILL, will make appearances as an antagonist, but prior knowledge of who I am- sorry, who HE IS won’t be necessary.
Obviously, I love Gravity Falls, and a cabin underneath those genres would be most preferred. However, I would be down to leading almost any cabin, since each cabin genre offers unique ideas, experiences, and challenges. The only genre I would not be comfortable leading would be anything romance-adjacent.
Excerpt
Time dedication
I have quite a lot of plans, but nothing insane except for two major things: summer camps taking place on June 16-21 (during the planning phase) and July 19-26 (during camp). The July camp will have long road trips that span two days each towards the end, so I will be able to participate in Cabin Wars during that part of the trip. Throughout the duration of the actual camping experiences, I will have zero access to the internet, as I will either be serving or participating as a camper during those times, respectively. I have respect for the rules put in place by these camps, and thus, I will not be online at all during those times.
Each day that I am available, I will be able to dedicate at least an hour to SWC. I am in the process of swimming (read: drowning) in the job market, and I intend to (read: desperately hope to) have a part-time job during the summer. This will not affect activity, just WHEN I am active.
Time management
Over the past couple of months or so, I have grown a LOT in time management. I have learned how to use to-do lists and Pomodoro timers to my advantage, and gosh, it feels so great to be able to use more of my time to do the things I love instead of the things that I’m required to do. I’m able to multitask, and I’m able to get responsibilities done in a timely manner.
However, some areas I still have to improve in are procrastination as well as getting distracted. Thankfully, these things have been hampered by things like the Pomodoro technique that I’ve been using recently. My mind can wander easily, and, gosh, it’s been a journey.
Collaboration and assets
As I’ve stated already, I’ve worked in teams quite a lot, both inside and outside of SWC. I’ve taken leadership roles in various parts of my life, so I know how to work with a team well. I can bring a variety of skills to the table, such as delegation, creativity, deference, decisiveness, and flexibility. I will value every single person on my team, and I will make sure that each of them gets to add their own flair and creativity to the cabin-making process. Sometimes, I can be too flexible and I won’t speak up about ideas that I have, but I’ve been learning to recognize the level to which I can offer ideas depending on the job that I have in a team.
One quality: Flexibility
I’ve learned that flexibility is such an important quality for a leader. Rolling with the punches is a huge part of being a good leader. If you can’t anticipate and adapt to challenges, then your leadership is too rigid and needs to loosen up a little. I have learned that if I’m not flexible, I can easily lose control. At first, I thought it was the opposite, but now I understand how important flexibility actually is.
Cabin atmosphere
Dive into an adventure where you can trust nothing. The only realism you can count on is the amazing memories, supportive leadership, and a vibrant, competitive cabin in which community is paramount.
Checkboxes
(yes) I will be available to consistently add points in the main cabin
(yes) I am willing to share a promotional project for SWC
B. No, I should be able to complete all of them with ease!
C. In the case of unexpected inactivity from another leader, I would wait 48 hours before taking any action. After that, I would delegate their tasks to my other co-leader and me. If I were to go inactive, I would give a notice far in advance if possible. I don’t anticipate needing to go inactive more than what I’ve already talked about, so it shouldn’t be an issue!
Bonus: What would your dream house look like?
I was MADE for this question. As a little girl, one of the many toys that I played with constantly was my very own Barbie Dreamhouse. I remember decorating it from head to toe with stickers, self-made furniture, and items that seriously added to the lore of my dolls. I don’t doubt that my decorating philosophy would be much different if I were given a real house. I would decorate it in my favorite color, green (I know, in a Barbie world… X( ), and I would personalize it like no other. Glorious sage chandeliers would hang from the ceiling, my art would be hung on every wall (at least, the art I’m proud of), and I’d DIY all my furniture. Truly, the house of my childhood dreams right there!
About Me
HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Ahem-
Please ignore the random bouts of maniacal laughter. It’s a medical condition.
Anyways! You can call me B̟̈́̆̐̄̚͜i̵͓͙̱͚̎͟ḻ̸͈ͧ͑̓̓̀͡ḻ̸͈ͧ͑̓̓̀͡', I mean, Bookie! I live in the glorious MST time zone, and I use she/her pronouns. I’m a Christian, first and foremost, and everything else falls in line after that. I’m also an avid author, reader, content creator, artist, and academic. I’m currently taking dual credit courses with two colleges, and until recently, my life has been CONSUMED by school. However, with my creative streak, I’ve learned how to work with the time that I have. I’m a high school junior (I’m going to be a senior next year?? :eyes: I’m not sure that I’m ready-), and I’m in love with all things words, whether that be writing, reading, speech and debate, and really truly anything with communication. I also am in MANY a fandom, such as Gravity Falls (hence the theme), Carmen Sandiego, Alien Stage, Percy Jackson, I/ASTV, and so much more! Ask me about a fandom you’re in, and it’s pretty dang likely that I’m in it as well! Outside of the online fandom space, I’m the oldest of three kids, and I’ve learned that being the oldest sister comes with quite the heavy load. However, I’m so grateful for my siblings! I also absolutely love music, and some of my favorite artists are Jann, Maneskin, Belle Sisoki, and Derivakat. (Would highly recommend you listen to Gladiator by Jann, which is a MASTERPIECE of a song!)
Wait! Don’t go yet! Before it’s too late, why don’t I tell you about his nefarious pl-
W-WAIT, THAT’S IT, THAT’S ALL YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT THIS- *cough* I MEAN ME! I’VE ALREADY SAID TOO MUCH! AHHH
Previous participation
I’ve been in SWC since March 2020! I haven't been in EVERY session since then, but I’ve been in quite a lot! I’ve been a co-leader three times, co-leading Fan-fi twice and Bangsian once. The experiences I’ve had while co-leading have shaped me into a better leader. I’ve learned so much from the SWCommunity. The diversity, the uniqueness, all of it, is SO inspiring! Thanks to SWC, I’ve emerged as a better leader, a better person, and a better writer.
As for my leadership experience outside of SWC, I am a part of the traveling staff team for a Christian non-profit that travels all over the USA to teach teens about civics. I’ve gotten in-depth training on leadership, the mindset behind it, and how to practically apply my leadership skills in the classroom. (The training was a straight week where I was essentially drinking from a firehose the entire time-) I’ve traveled to state capitols all over the USA, and have served on a team that served a student body with a range of 40-100 students (the student body size depends on the class and state). Within this same organization, I also have worked on campaign teams for mock elections, where I have maintained and monitored a large group chat, making sure that it was appropriate and active and that it maintained the campaign’s image. I worked on my friend’s campaigns as well as my own. That admin work can very easily transfer over to a SWC cabin ;D
I also work in my church with the children’s ministry. I have also been given leadership opportunities in my homeschool co-op, my church youth group, my dual credit college courses, as well as in my family. I seek out leadership wherever I go, which has been an interesting experience overall.
Cabin Prefs
It’s summer vacation, and you and your friends live in Gravity Falls, Oregon, with absolutely nothing to do. After the events of Weirdmageddon, everything lacks that ‘weird flair’. All the random happenings feel utterly uninspired and offensively ordinary. You and your friends need something fresh for this summer.
*snicker* Oh imagine just how boring their lives will be for the entire summer. I doubt that anything will change about THAT. *cough*
I would absolutely love to lead a Gravity Falls-inspired cabin underneath the label of Bi-Fi, or maybe Thriller, Mystery, or Adventure. All of those genres would fit with the story I would cook up! Knowledge of Gravity Falls would not be necessary, since I would like to develop a new story that takes inspiration from the series. I- um, no, sorry, BILL, will make appearances as an antagonist, but prior knowledge of who I am- sorry, who HE IS won’t be necessary.
Obviously, I love Gravity Falls, and a cabin underneath those genres would be most preferred. However, I would be down to leading almost any cabin, since each cabin genre offers unique ideas, experiences, and challenges. The only genre I would not be comfortable leading would be anything romance-adjacent.
Excerpt
Time dedication
I have quite a lot of plans, but nothing insane except for two major things: summer camps taking place on June 16-21 (during the planning phase) and July 19-26 (during camp). The July camp will have long road trips that span two days each towards the end, so I will be able to participate in Cabin Wars during that part of the trip. Throughout the duration of the actual camping experiences, I will have zero access to the internet, as I will either be serving or participating as a camper during those times, respectively. I have respect for the rules put in place by these camps, and thus, I will not be online at all during those times.
Each day that I am available, I will be able to dedicate at least an hour to SWC. I am in the process of swimming (read: drowning) in the job market, and I intend to (read: desperately hope to) have a part-time job during the summer. This will not affect activity, just WHEN I am active.
Time management
Over the past couple of months or so, I have grown a LOT in time management. I have learned how to use to-do lists and Pomodoro timers to my advantage, and gosh, it feels so great to be able to use more of my time to do the things I love instead of the things that I’m required to do. I’m able to multitask, and I’m able to get responsibilities done in a timely manner.
However, some areas I still have to improve in are procrastination as well as getting distracted. Thankfully, these things have been hampered by things like the Pomodoro technique that I’ve been using recently. My mind can wander easily, and, gosh, it’s been a journey.
Collaboration and assets
As I’ve stated already, I’ve worked in teams quite a lot, both inside and outside of SWC. I’ve taken leadership roles in various parts of my life, so I know how to work with a team well. I can bring a variety of skills to the table, such as delegation, creativity, deference, decisiveness, and flexibility. I will value every single person on my team, and I will make sure that each of them gets to add their own flair and creativity to the cabin-making process. Sometimes, I can be too flexible and I won’t speak up about ideas that I have, but I’ve been learning to recognize the level to which I can offer ideas depending on the job that I have in a team.
One quality: Flexibility
I’ve learned that flexibility is such an important quality for a leader. Rolling with the punches is a huge part of being a good leader. If you can’t anticipate and adapt to challenges, then your leadership is too rigid and needs to loosen up a little. I have learned that if I’m not flexible, I can easily lose control. At first, I thought it was the opposite, but now I understand how important flexibility actually is.
Cabin atmosphere
Dive into an adventure where you can trust nothing. The only realism you can count on is the amazing memories, supportive leadership, and a vibrant, competitive cabin in which community is paramount.
Checkboxes
(yes) I will be available to consistently add points in the main cabin
(yes) I am willing to share a promotional project for SWC
B. No, I should be able to complete all of them with ease!
C. In the case of unexpected inactivity from another leader, I would wait 48 hours before taking any action. After that, I would delegate their tasks to my other co-leader and me. If I were to go inactive, I would give a notice far in advance if possible. I don’t anticipate needing to go inactive more than what I’ve already talked about, so it shouldn’t be an issue!
Bonus: What would your dream house look like?
I was MADE for this question. As a little girl, one of the many toys that I played with constantly was my very own Barbie Dreamhouse. I remember decorating it from head to toe with stickers, self-made furniture, and items that seriously added to the lore of my dolls. I don’t doubt that my decorating philosophy would be much different if I were given a real house. I would decorate it in my favorite color, green (I know, in a Barbie world… X( ), and I would personalize it like no other. Glorious sage chandeliers would hang from the ceiling, my art would be hung on every wall (at least, the art I’m proud of), and I’d DIY all my furniture. Truly, the house of my childhood dreams right there!
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Kit
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/808229/?page=41#post-8529324
353 words
About me -
This is great!! However it does feel a bit list-like, so I would recommend either cutting down on the listing, or elaborating on some of the things you mention a bit more.
I’d also recommend talking about how each thing affects you as a person, so they seem more in-depth rather than rambly. <3
Experience -
Looking good!!
Cabin Preferences -
I like to choose my favourite of the ideas I’m offering, and try to sell it more than the other two, so I have more of a chance to be a part of it! But this is only personal preference though!!
Aside from that I’d recommend saying a couple of cabins you’d not like to lead in the upcoming session, in case you don't get chosen for leader.
Time Dedication -
When you say that you won't have access on the 11-13 and 20, It might be good to specify what month you are talking about, as if we think its May, it might contradict your past statement, or not make as much sense. Otherwise this is looking good!!
Time Management -
With this section, I would recommend talking about how you work on and counter your weaknesses, to show that they won't stop you from being a great leader. Aside from that, it looks good.
Collaboration -
Again with showing how you're improving, and maybe splitting your paragraphs more so that it's not just big blocks of text! Otherwise it looks awesome!!
One Quality -
I would recommend talking a bit more about how you embody this, as you’ve done an awesome job of talking about how you’ll apply it to SWC, but not as much of how you embody it. Otherwise it looks awesome!! <3
Checkboxes -
Don’t forget to mention about the checkboxes and the leadership responsibilities!! Also it might be worth mentioning if you go inactive without prior notice, as you’ve said if you knew you were, but not otherwise. <3
Final Note -
This is an amazing app Kit!!! Good luck, and I cannot wait to see what you do this session!!!! <3
- Liv
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/808229/?page=41#post-8529324
353 words
About me -
This is great!! However it does feel a bit list-like, so I would recommend either cutting down on the listing, or elaborating on some of the things you mention a bit more.
I’d also recommend talking about how each thing affects you as a person, so they seem more in-depth rather than rambly. <3
Experience -
Looking good!!
Cabin Preferences -
I like to choose my favourite of the ideas I’m offering, and try to sell it more than the other two, so I have more of a chance to be a part of it! But this is only personal preference though!!
Aside from that I’d recommend saying a couple of cabins you’d not like to lead in the upcoming session, in case you don't get chosen for leader.
Time Dedication -
When you say that you won't have access on the 11-13 and 20, It might be good to specify what month you are talking about, as if we think its May, it might contradict your past statement, or not make as much sense. Otherwise this is looking good!!
Time Management -
With this section, I would recommend talking about how you work on and counter your weaknesses, to show that they won't stop you from being a great leader. Aside from that, it looks good.
Collaboration -
Again with showing how you're improving, and maybe splitting your paragraphs more so that it's not just big blocks of text! Otherwise it looks awesome!!
One Quality -
I would recommend talking a bit more about how you embody this, as you’ve done an awesome job of talking about how you’ll apply it to SWC, but not as much of how you embody it. Otherwise it looks awesome!! <3
Checkboxes -
Don’t forget to mention about the checkboxes and the leadership responsibilities!! Also it might be worth mentioning if you go inactive without prior notice, as you’ve said if you knew you were, but not otherwise. <3
Final Note -
This is an amazing app Kit!!! Good luck, and I cannot wait to see what you do this session!!!! <3
- Liv
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Cat
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/808229/?page=41#post-8527885
342 words
About Me -
Your paragraphs here feel rather short, so it might be good to elaborate or talk more about a couple of things you’ve noticed. I like how you’ve mentioned your personality, so it might be a good section to elaborate on especially as it tells us a lot about you.
Experience -
You’ve said that you go more in-depth about each of your sessions in your project app, but I would recommend putting stuff about it in here, even just a few paragraphs, or what you put in your app.
I’d also recommend going more in-depth about what your 18 camp session have taught you, especially where you’ve leaded/hosted <3
Cabin Preferences -
Here you could say a couple of cabins you wouldn’t want to lead, and perhaps elaborate on why you wouldn’t be a good fit for them, or why you’d like to lead the cabins you’ve put in here as well.
Time Dedication -
Looking Good!! I’d recommend talking a bit more about how you’ll make sure you’re at least semi-active throughout your sleepaway camp, like how you would ensure you’d have enough time to complete your leadership responsibilities.
Time Management -
There's a couple of little things you’ve mentioned when you’re talking about perfectionism that might contradict your strength of being focused, so you might want to check your wording or changing/adding a couple of sentences to there. <3
Collaboration and Assets -
You may want to talk a little bit more about how you’re improving upon your weakness, or generally add a little more about each section, making your strengths seem stronger than your weaknesses. This is looking awesome!!
Checkboxes -
I would suggest mentioning a bit about if you were going to go active but you didn;t know about it in advance, otherwise it looks great!!
Final Note -
I love your app Cat!! Your answers are clear and cosine while still getting the message across, best of luck and I can't wait to see how you do this session!!
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/808229/?page=41#post-8527885
342 words
About Me -
Your paragraphs here feel rather short, so it might be good to elaborate or talk more about a couple of things you’ve noticed. I like how you’ve mentioned your personality, so it might be a good section to elaborate on especially as it tells us a lot about you.
Experience -
You’ve said that you go more in-depth about each of your sessions in your project app, but I would recommend putting stuff about it in here, even just a few paragraphs, or what you put in your app.
I’d also recommend going more in-depth about what your 18 camp session have taught you, especially where you’ve leaded/hosted <3
Cabin Preferences -
Here you could say a couple of cabins you wouldn’t want to lead, and perhaps elaborate on why you wouldn’t be a good fit for them, or why you’d like to lead the cabins you’ve put in here as well.
Time Dedication -
Looking Good!! I’d recommend talking a bit more about how you’ll make sure you’re at least semi-active throughout your sleepaway camp, like how you would ensure you’d have enough time to complete your leadership responsibilities.
Time Management -
There's a couple of little things you’ve mentioned when you’re talking about perfectionism that might contradict your strength of being focused, so you might want to check your wording or changing/adding a couple of sentences to there. <3
Collaboration and Assets -
You may want to talk a little bit more about how you’re improving upon your weakness, or generally add a little more about each section, making your strengths seem stronger than your weaknesses. This is looking awesome!!
Checkboxes -
I would suggest mentioning a bit about if you were going to go active but you didn;t know about it in advance, otherwise it looks great!!
Final Note -
I love your app Cat!! Your answers are clear and cosine while still getting the message across, best of luck and I can't wait to see how you do this session!!
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Surf!
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8531166/
285 words <3
About Me -
This is looking great!! I would recommend maybe talking a bit about your personality, or how your hobbies affect your personality, although seeing as an app is all about your personality, it's understandable if you want to leave it out.
Experience -
I like to talk a bit about what I’ve learnt from each of my SWC co-leading/camping experiences, whichever were most impactful for you, because it shows how you improve and learn from each session.
Cabin Preferences -
You’ve listed a few ideas here, which is great!! However you might want to keep a couple of less fleshed out ones in your pocket to use in future sessions. <3
Time Dedication -
I would suggest saying a sentence about letting people know if anything comes up, although that's covered in checkboxes, so it's just a little add on.
I would also recommend saying about your activity in late May, if it's like June, or you have more time like July <3
Time Management -
You could add another strength (or weakness), although this section is looking awesome in general!! Especially where you talk about your improvements in your shortcomings.
Collaboration and Assets -
I’d suggest adding an introduction paragraph, similar to what you did in time management, as it provides a little step before we dive straight into your answers. Otherwise it looks great!!
One Quality -
Looks awesome!!
Checkboxes -
I would suggest adding a little bit about if you have an unplanned absence within your time leading. <3
Final Note -
This is awesome Surf, your answers are so detailed and thought out!!! Wishing you the best of luck, and I can’t wait to see what you do this July!!
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8531166/
285 words <3
About Me -
This is looking great!! I would recommend maybe talking a bit about your personality, or how your hobbies affect your personality, although seeing as an app is all about your personality, it's understandable if you want to leave it out.
Experience -
I like to talk a bit about what I’ve learnt from each of my SWC co-leading/camping experiences, whichever were most impactful for you, because it shows how you improve and learn from each session.
Cabin Preferences -
You’ve listed a few ideas here, which is great!! However you might want to keep a couple of less fleshed out ones in your pocket to use in future sessions. <3
Time Dedication -
I would suggest saying a sentence about letting people know if anything comes up, although that's covered in checkboxes, so it's just a little add on.
I would also recommend saying about your activity in late May, if it's like June, or you have more time like July <3
Time Management -
You could add another strength (or weakness), although this section is looking awesome in general!! Especially where you talk about your improvements in your shortcomings.
Collaboration and Assets -
I’d suggest adding an introduction paragraph, similar to what you did in time management, as it provides a little step before we dive straight into your answers. Otherwise it looks great!!
One Quality -
Looks awesome!!
Checkboxes -
I would suggest adding a little bit about if you have an unplanned absence within your time leading. <3
Final Note -
This is awesome Surf, your answers are so detailed and thought out!!! Wishing you the best of luck, and I can’t wait to see what you do this July!!
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Thea
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/820240/?page=1#post-8531253
412 words
About Me -
With this, your first paragraph feels a bit jumpy, so stitching the sentences together might help it feel more cohesive. I’d also recommend talking a bit about what you’ve mentioned in your first paragraph, like your hobbies, as well as having the stuff about Splatfest to help us get to know you more <3
Experience -
You might like to talk about what you’ve learnt in your leading experience with S-POP to go more in-depth and share how you’ve grown in your leadership or learnt from things that have happened there.
Cabin Preferences -
You’ve said a lot about quite a few different ideas, but I would suggest taking the ones you’re most excited about and elaborating on them in particular, keeping the other ones for future sessions or when you’re more excited about them/have fleshed them out better.
Time Dedication -
Looks good, but you don’t need to mention August as camp doesn’t roll over onto there, I’d also suggest giving dates for your trip in June.
Time Management -
I would suggest making each of your weaknesses a separate paragraph and talking a bit more on how you improve from them.
I’d also like to remind you to talk about your strengths!! It's a vital part of this section, so make sure you add a paragraph or two <3
Collaboration and Assets -
This section I would recommend splitting each thing or idea you’re mentioning into separate paragraphs so you can see what needs elaborating on more, like your strengths and weaknesses. This section typically references Time Management in terms of layout, by listing strengths and then weaknesses as well as how you improve on them, followed by a short paragraph on assets you bring to a team!
One Quality -
With this, it's more focused, not on what others think, although I love this idea, but it's more focused on what quality you think you best embody and how you embody this as well as how you apply it to your leadership within SWC.
It feels currently like you’ve changed a bit about what this section is supposed to be about, so re-reading the question or looking at others answers might help you <33
Checkboxes -
A suggestions to say about if you do go inactive even with the encouragement <33
Final Note -
This is a great app!! Good luck, and I can’t wait to see how this session goes for you!! <3
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/820240/?page=1#post-8531253
412 words
About Me -
With this, your first paragraph feels a bit jumpy, so stitching the sentences together might help it feel more cohesive. I’d also recommend talking a bit about what you’ve mentioned in your first paragraph, like your hobbies, as well as having the stuff about Splatfest to help us get to know you more <3
Experience -
You might like to talk about what you’ve learnt in your leading experience with S-POP to go more in-depth and share how you’ve grown in your leadership or learnt from things that have happened there.
Cabin Preferences -
You’ve said a lot about quite a few different ideas, but I would suggest taking the ones you’re most excited about and elaborating on them in particular, keeping the other ones for future sessions or when you’re more excited about them/have fleshed them out better.
Time Dedication -
Looks good, but you don’t need to mention August as camp doesn’t roll over onto there, I’d also suggest giving dates for your trip in June.
Time Management -
I would suggest making each of your weaknesses a separate paragraph and talking a bit more on how you improve from them.
I’d also like to remind you to talk about your strengths!! It's a vital part of this section, so make sure you add a paragraph or two <3
Collaboration and Assets -
This section I would recommend splitting each thing or idea you’re mentioning into separate paragraphs so you can see what needs elaborating on more, like your strengths and weaknesses. This section typically references Time Management in terms of layout, by listing strengths and then weaknesses as well as how you improve on them, followed by a short paragraph on assets you bring to a team!
One Quality -
With this, it's more focused, not on what others think, although I love this idea, but it's more focused on what quality you think you best embody and how you embody this as well as how you apply it to your leadership within SWC.
It feels currently like you’ve changed a bit about what this section is supposed to be about, so re-reading the question or looking at others answers might help you <33
Checkboxes -
A suggestions to say about if you do go inactive even with the encouragement <33
Final Note -
This is a great app!! Good luck, and I can’t wait to see how this session goes for you!! <3
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Mabel
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/715198/?page=3#post-8531547
403 words <3
About Me -
I would suggest breaking apart the paragraphs so that they’re not just big blocks of text <3
And it might be a you thing, but capital letters…
a write and storyteller
“A writer and storyteller” <3
This is looking great, although you’ve mentioned so many things and just jump from hobby to hobby with no paragraph breaks. I would recommend just reading through and making sure that it all fits together well and perhaps make each paragraph or note about the hobby a little longer so it's more cohesive.
Experience -
and tooken on small
“And taken on small”
You’ve mentioned learning different things from different people, so maybe go a bit more into that? And you were such an amazing person to work with last session Mabel, I can’t wait to see where you go this session. <3
Aside from that, don't forget to talk about your writing experience!!
Cabin Preferences -
and i can get rid of that if i
An unfinished sentence here ^^”
Personally I like to try to sell the idea I’m most excited for than the others, and keep some of my other ones in my back pocket for the future, but this looks great whether or not you choose to do that!!
I’d also recommend saying a couple of cabins you’d prefer not to lead, in case you get chosen or for Leaders if you’re only a Co <3
Time Dedication -
This looks great!!
Time Management -
Also looks great!! I would suggest making a couple of changes to your wording in weaknesses to make it sound less negative, else it looks awesome!!
Collaboration and Assets -
Because your weakness paragraphs look so much larger than your strengths, I would suggest adding another paragraph on strengths or elaborating a bit more on them to balance out the visuals.
Aside from that, it looks awesome!! You could mention if you have any material assets, like graphic design or art that you’d be willing to do <3
One Quality -
for why your doing it.
“for why you’re doing it”
This looks great!! <3
Checkboxes -
Also looks pretty good, you could mention about planned and unplanned absences, otherwise I have nothing to say here <3
Final Note -
This application is awesome Mabel!!! I can’t wait to see how you do this session and be perfectly competitive with you hehe. Good luck!!
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/715198/?page=3#post-8531547
403 words <3
About Me -
I would suggest breaking apart the paragraphs so that they’re not just big blocks of text <3
And it might be a you thing, but capital letters…
a write and storyteller
“A writer and storyteller” <3
This is looking great, although you’ve mentioned so many things and just jump from hobby to hobby with no paragraph breaks. I would recommend just reading through and making sure that it all fits together well and perhaps make each paragraph or note about the hobby a little longer so it's more cohesive.
Experience -
and tooken on small
“And taken on small”
You’ve mentioned learning different things from different people, so maybe go a bit more into that? And you were such an amazing person to work with last session Mabel, I can’t wait to see where you go this session. <3
Aside from that, don't forget to talk about your writing experience!!
Cabin Preferences -
and i can get rid of that if i
An unfinished sentence here ^^”
Personally I like to try to sell the idea I’m most excited for than the others, and keep some of my other ones in my back pocket for the future, but this looks great whether or not you choose to do that!!
I’d also recommend saying a couple of cabins you’d prefer not to lead, in case you get chosen or for Leaders if you’re only a Co <3
Time Dedication -
This looks great!!
Time Management -
Also looks great!! I would suggest making a couple of changes to your wording in weaknesses to make it sound less negative, else it looks awesome!!
Collaboration and Assets -
Because your weakness paragraphs look so much larger than your strengths, I would suggest adding another paragraph on strengths or elaborating a bit more on them to balance out the visuals.
Aside from that, it looks awesome!! You could mention if you have any material assets, like graphic design or art that you’d be willing to do <3
One Quality -
for why your doing it.
“for why you’re doing it”
This looks great!! <3
Checkboxes -
Also looks pretty good, you could mention about planned and unplanned absences, otherwise I have nothing to say here <3
Final Note -
This application is awesome Mabel!!! I can’t wait to see how you do this session and be perfectly competitive with you hehe. Good luck!!
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Snowy!!
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/721861/?page=7#post-8533380
418 words
About Me -
You could add a bit in the first paragraph that sort of sums up what you’re going to talk about in this section, like a list?
And the parts you’ve mentioned about your hobbies are shorter and not very detailed, so you could elaborate more on what makes each of the things, like soccer and piano, so important to you.
And you could add a bit about your personality, but as I said to Cat, your whole app is about your personality, so it's completely understandable if you’d prefer to leave it out!
Experience -
I like to mention a bit about a few sessions that really stood out for me, and talk about what I learnt from them, as it shows that you learn and grow from your experiences and can give a little insight into maybe a couple of traits that you don’t mention widely across your app but still have.
Aside from this, don’t forget to mention any leadership experience you have in real life!! Or specify if there already is some in the paragraph. <3
Cabin Preferences -
This looks awesome!!! I love the way you’ve organised this! <3
Time Dedication -
Looks good! But maybe mention how many hours you’ll be able to dedicate during May and early June?
Time Management -
For starters, between soccer, a vigorous history competition I participated in, piano, and my regular schoolwork, last year, I had to spend a lot of time prioritizing and figuring out how to get everything that needed to be done actually finished.
I’m not quite sure if ‘last year’ belongs to the first part of the sentence or last part of the sentence, so you may want to clear it up.
You could add another strength (or weakness), however your answers seem to be more on the ‘clear, to the point’ side of the spectrum, so it's understandable if you’d rather not <3
Collaboration -
This looks great!! Like I said above, you could add another strength or weakness, and don’t forget to mention what assets you can bring to a team!! <3
One Quality -
I don’t have anything to say to this, it's looking great!!
Checkboxes -
My only recommendation here would be to mention talking with the hosts or such if it's an exceptionally long inactivity period without notice.
Final Note -
Your application is amazing Snowy!! I can’t wait to see what you do this session, and wishing you the best of luck!! <3
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/721861/?page=7#post-8533380
418 words
About Me -
You could add a bit in the first paragraph that sort of sums up what you’re going to talk about in this section, like a list?
And the parts you’ve mentioned about your hobbies are shorter and not very detailed, so you could elaborate more on what makes each of the things, like soccer and piano, so important to you.
And you could add a bit about your personality, but as I said to Cat, your whole app is about your personality, so it's completely understandable if you’d prefer to leave it out!
Experience -
I like to mention a bit about a few sessions that really stood out for me, and talk about what I learnt from them, as it shows that you learn and grow from your experiences and can give a little insight into maybe a couple of traits that you don’t mention widely across your app but still have.
Aside from this, don’t forget to mention any leadership experience you have in real life!! Or specify if there already is some in the paragraph. <3
Cabin Preferences -
This looks awesome!!! I love the way you’ve organised this! <3
Time Dedication -
Looks good! But maybe mention how many hours you’ll be able to dedicate during May and early June?
Time Management -
For starters, between soccer, a vigorous history competition I participated in, piano, and my regular schoolwork, last year, I had to spend a lot of time prioritizing and figuring out how to get everything that needed to be done actually finished.
I’m not quite sure if ‘last year’ belongs to the first part of the sentence or last part of the sentence, so you may want to clear it up.
You could add another strength (or weakness), however your answers seem to be more on the ‘clear, to the point’ side of the spectrum, so it's understandable if you’d rather not <3
Collaboration -
This looks great!! Like I said above, you could add another strength or weakness, and don’t forget to mention what assets you can bring to a team!! <3
One Quality -
I don’t have anything to say to this, it's looking great!!
Checkboxes -
My only recommendation here would be to mention talking with the hosts or such if it's an exceptionally long inactivity period without notice.
Final Note -
Your application is amazing Snowy!! I can’t wait to see what you do this session, and wishing you the best of luck!! <3
- starunicorn_5
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
critique for hope!
beginning notes-
HIHIHI HOPE!! i'm really excited to critique your app
D just a note that all of this is just my personal preference, so feel free to take it however you like! YAY LET'S START <33 i. about me
now i love talking about myself, so get ready.A comma after the ‘now’ would be great <3
however, i also love to listen to music.These two parts are more or less linked, so there's no need for a contrasting connective- an adding connective would make more sense imo, like ‘moreover’ or something like that.
so, i did, and i fell in love immediately.This sentence can work without a comma after the ‘so’ and without the ‘I’ before ‘fell’, though this is just personal preference.
still, i have some books i am still in love with — the secret history, the six of crows duology, and the song of achilles, jus to name a few.Very small detail, but ‘jus’ should be corrected to ‘just’.
You have enthusiasm in this about me, so maybe vary your punctuation around by placing some exclamation marks around! (or this is just me XD i'm a very excitable person-)
ii. previous participation
this upcoming session will be my tenth session, and will mark the fourth year since i discovered swc. despite being inactive for many of my earlier sessions, in the past year i’ve participated much more in both the main cabin’s activities as well as cabin storylines. and i’ve loved it all.These two sentences can be connected by a comma, because the second one seems a bit fragmented alone <3
i didn’t talk about writing in my about me, because it never came easily for me. i tried without success to write so many times, that i eventually regarded writing as something i disliked. and then i discovered swc.Again, these two sentences can be connected!
iii. cabin preferences
I love your cabin ideas :awed:
You've mentioned the cabins that you'd like to lead, but also mention those you would not want to lead, those you would be okay co-leading, and those you wouldn't want to co-lead <3
v. time dedication
generally, i would be able to dedicate at least one hour to swc on weekdays, and multiple hours on the weekends.You could state how many hours ‘multiple hours’ would be!
in the first two weeks of june, i will have exams, so i will be focusing on recvising for them.Small typo here <3 on ‘revising’.
vi. time management
time management has never been my strong suit, and i doubt it ever will.This has a bit of a negative tone, so maybe add a ‘but’ in there, to reduce the effect of this first sentence?
vii. collaboration and assets
i’m also pretty adaptable and flexible, and i’m able to react to sudden setbacks or changes. i would be happy taking on other leaders’ responsibilities if they weren’t able to complete them.It would be great if you could elaborate on this a bit more!
viii. one quality
The question asks about a quality you ‘embody’ and ‘actions you will take to embody this’ so maybe change the wording slightly around the first part and add a bit talking about what you would do to embody patience!
ix. cabin atmosphere
looking good!
x. checkboxes
also looking good <3
finishing notes-
HOPE AHH <33 your answers are really well-written and mature, and i can't wait to see where this app takes you! I really love this app- good luck! <33
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Bookie
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8537841/
316 words
About Me -
BWHAHAHA, Bookie I love the maniacal laughter omg-
I love this intro, it's so unique!! I would recommend splitting up the big paragraph about yourself and elaborating on a couple of things to make it feel less list-like and rushed, else this is awesome!!
Previous Participation -
Personally, I like to go more into depth about a couple of sessions that were the most important to me, because it gives a chance to show that you have learnt from the past and you can show off a few skills that maybe you don’t mention across your app.
And then a paragraph space when you switch from SWC leadership to IRL leadership could make it easier to read.
And don’t forget to mention any writing experience out of SWC!!!
Cabin Preference -
Don’t forget to mention about TCTWNW!! Otherwise this is looking good! <3
Time Dedication -
Looks good, I would suggest adding something about telling your team if anything comes up, even just a small sentence as it comes up for in Checkboxes
Time Management -
I would suggest lengthening this in general, talking about what your strengths are more in depth, and going into what helps you improve on your weaknesses and the improvements you’ve made <3
Collaboration -
Again, like I suggested with time management, generally lengthening this section could be good. And don’t forget to mention any assets you can bring to a team!!
One Quality -
Don’t forget to talk about how exactly you embody it, give examples. And how you apply it to your SWC leadership or leadership in general!!
Checkboxes -
You might want to try contacting the inactive leadership member before taking any action <3
And add if you went inactive without prior warning and what you would do then!!
Final Note -
This is looking awesome Bookie!! I can’t wait to see the final product. Good luck!!
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8537841/
316 words
About Me -
BWHAHAHA, Bookie I love the maniacal laughter omg-
I love this intro, it's so unique!! I would recommend splitting up the big paragraph about yourself and elaborating on a couple of things to make it feel less list-like and rushed, else this is awesome!!
Previous Participation -
Personally, I like to go more into depth about a couple of sessions that were the most important to me, because it gives a chance to show that you have learnt from the past and you can show off a few skills that maybe you don’t mention across your app.
And then a paragraph space when you switch from SWC leadership to IRL leadership could make it easier to read.
And don’t forget to mention any writing experience out of SWC!!!
Cabin Preference -
Don’t forget to mention about TCTWNW!! Otherwise this is looking good! <3
Time Dedication -
Looks good, I would suggest adding something about telling your team if anything comes up, even just a small sentence as it comes up for in Checkboxes
Time Management -
I would suggest lengthening this in general, talking about what your strengths are more in depth, and going into what helps you improve on your weaknesses and the improvements you’ve made <3
Collaboration -
Again, like I suggested with time management, generally lengthening this section could be good. And don’t forget to mention any assets you can bring to a team!!
One Quality -
Don’t forget to talk about how exactly you embody it, give examples. And how you apply it to your SWC leadership or leadership in general!!
Checkboxes -
You might want to try contacting the inactive leadership member before taking any action <3
And add if you went inactive without prior warning and what you would do then!!
Final Note -
This is looking awesome Bookie!! I can’t wait to see the final product. Good luck!!
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Hope <3
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/808229/?page=41#post-8538142
379 words <3
About Me -
Don’t forget about capital letters!! Although if its an aesthetic thing, it's perfectly understandable.
and i’m your average rock music enjoyer, artist, and science enthusiast, just to name a few of the many interests i have.
I would personally remove the ‘just to name a few of the many interests I have’ as I don’t think it's needed in this sentence and it doesn't quite make sense.
I would suggest going a little more in depth for each of your paragraphs, especially the last one. Even a sentence or two added would make it feel more personal, otherwise this looks good!
Experience -
This looks great, however I like to mention a couple of standout sessions and talk a little bit about them and what you learnt from them, as it gives you a chance to talk about any skills you might have that you don’t mention widely across your app.
I’d also like to remind you not to forget to talk about your irl leading experience and out-of-swc writing experience!! <3
Cabin Preferences -
I like to choose the idea I’m most excited about and try to sell it more than my other ones, so you have a higher chance of getting it.
And a small note that when you’re a co-leader, you don't have to create your own ideas necessarily, but rather build upon your leader’s idea and cabin.
Time Dedication -
I have nothing to say here, it looks great.
Time Management -
Like I say below, elaborate a bit on how you’re improving your strength and working on your weakness, and you could add another shortcoming or skill here as well. <3
Collaboration -
I would suggest adding another strength here (or weakness) and elaborate on your current strength as well as going a little more in depth on how you’re improving on your weakness.
One Quality -
This is looking great!! If you’re having trouble writing this part, you could put it down for a second, or find another quality that you feel you can write easier about, as that typically means you can embody it better. <3
Checkboxes -
Looks awesome!!
Final Note -
Your app is looking awesome, I can’t wait to see the final product!! Good luck!!
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/808229/?page=41#post-8538142
379 words <3
About Me -
Don’t forget about capital letters!! Although if its an aesthetic thing, it's perfectly understandable.
and i’m your average rock music enjoyer, artist, and science enthusiast, just to name a few of the many interests i have.
I would personally remove the ‘just to name a few of the many interests I have’ as I don’t think it's needed in this sentence and it doesn't quite make sense.
I would suggest going a little more in depth for each of your paragraphs, especially the last one. Even a sentence or two added would make it feel more personal, otherwise this looks good!
Experience -
This looks great, however I like to mention a couple of standout sessions and talk a little bit about them and what you learnt from them, as it gives you a chance to talk about any skills you might have that you don’t mention widely across your app.
I’d also like to remind you not to forget to talk about your irl leading experience and out-of-swc writing experience!! <3
Cabin Preferences -
I like to choose the idea I’m most excited about and try to sell it more than my other ones, so you have a higher chance of getting it.
And a small note that when you’re a co-leader, you don't have to create your own ideas necessarily, but rather build upon your leader’s idea and cabin.
Time Dedication -
I have nothing to say here, it looks great.
Time Management -
Like I say below, elaborate a bit on how you’re improving your strength and working on your weakness, and you could add another shortcoming or skill here as well. <3
Collaboration -
I would suggest adding another strength here (or weakness) and elaborate on your current strength as well as going a little more in depth on how you’re improving on your weakness.
One Quality -
This is looking great!! If you’re having trouble writing this part, you could put it down for a second, or find another quality that you feel you can write easier about, as that typically means you can embody it better. <3
Checkboxes -
Looks awesome!!
Final Note -
Your app is looking awesome, I can’t wait to see the final product!! Good luck!!
- FireBlood23
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎
Critique for Chuey!!!! :P
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/808229/?page=40#post-8527685
329 words
About Me -
You’ve said the word ‘staring’ twice in one sentence, so you could change that, although I’m just very picky about word repetition haha.
You asked for tips on expansion, so I would suggest adding a bit about one of the hobbies you mentioned around your daydreaming (which is so real by the way omg) but I think this section is pretty good so whatever you decide!
Experience -
I like to go a little in depth and talk about a few particularly stand out sessions for me and say how they impacted my SWC journey, and maybe a few skills you learnt from those sessions that you don’t talk about a lot throughout your app. Its gives you a chance to show off said skills, show that you improve and learn over time, and it adds a good chunk to your words
Cabin Preferences -
Looks good!!
Time Dedication -
You could add a bit about plans for late May, and a short sentence about notifying people if things do come up (only short, because you go more in-depth in the Checkboxes section <3)
Time Management -
I really have no suggestions here except to maybe add an introductory sentence?
Collaboration -
Nothing much to say expect like above, you might benefit form an introductory paragraph <3
One Quality -
Extension here would be to generally expand on how you’d work this into SWC, although it's looking awesome as it is!!
Checkboxes -
Again, looking really good. My only suggestion would be to split a paragraph into two about your inactivity, and go on about a planned inactivity period versus an unplanned one.
Final Notes -
Your app is awesome Chuey sdfghjksafalk!!! Your answers are so in depth and well thought out and I have no words, it is so organized and easy to read and understand! Good luck, and I’m so excited to see whatever crazy app you come up with hehe <33
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/808229/?page=40#post-8527685
329 words
About Me -
You’ve said the word ‘staring’ twice in one sentence, so you could change that, although I’m just very picky about word repetition haha.
You asked for tips on expansion, so I would suggest adding a bit about one of the hobbies you mentioned around your daydreaming (which is so real by the way omg) but I think this section is pretty good so whatever you decide!
Experience -
I like to go a little in depth and talk about a few particularly stand out sessions for me and say how they impacted my SWC journey, and maybe a few skills you learnt from those sessions that you don’t talk about a lot throughout your app. Its gives you a chance to show off said skills, show that you improve and learn over time, and it adds a good chunk to your words
Cabin Preferences -
Looks good!!
Time Dedication -
You could add a bit about plans for late May, and a short sentence about notifying people if things do come up (only short, because you go more in-depth in the Checkboxes section <3)
Time Management -
I really have no suggestions here except to maybe add an introductory sentence?
Collaboration -
Nothing much to say expect like above, you might benefit form an introductory paragraph <3
One Quality -
Extension here would be to generally expand on how you’d work this into SWC, although it's looking awesome as it is!!
Checkboxes -
Again, looking really good. My only suggestion would be to split a paragraph into two about your inactivity, and go on about a planned inactivity period versus an unplanned one.
Final Notes -
Your app is awesome Chuey sdfghjksafalk!!! Your answers are so in depth and well thought out and I have no words, it is so organized and easy to read and understand! Good luck, and I’m so excited to see whatever crazy app you come up with hehe <33
- Discussion Forums
- » Things I'm Making and Creating
-
» ✎SWC Leader App Critique Center ~ Critique Thread✎