Discuss Scratch

ZoomPlay
Scratcher
73 posts

Feature Idea: Allow certain people to edit your original project

Feature Idea
Alright here is my idea that popped into my head recently. What if there was some button that would allow you to select someone to be able to edit and modify your own project. I do not mean this by creating remixes, but changing the original project. This could be useful in collaboration. In my personal opinion, I like this idea. Do you support this idea?
DaSpudLord
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Feature Idea: Allow certain people to edit your original project

No support. Just tell them to remix it. Then take the changes from the remix and add them to the original project, either by using the backpack or downloading the remix and uploading it to your own account.
reallysoftuser
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Feature Idea: Allow certain people to edit your original project

Support, this would be an amazing way to develop a game with your friends without random people remixing your projects.
--starlight
Scratcher
500+ posts

Feature Idea: Allow certain people to edit your original project

This sounds like a good way to develop collabs and other things, but I feel like this could be a way to get around unmoderated chat? Not sure, but the ST probably has some reason this doesn't exist yet

Edit: On second thought, although I support this, this could be a way when someone trusts another Scratcher, they could give them abilities, and let's say their friendship didn't end on good terms. Then that person can go grief their project and ruin it. That could be a possible problem.

Last edited by --starlight (Feb. 23, 2021 22:48:17)

reallysoftuser
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Feature Idea: Allow certain people to edit your original project

--starlight wrote:

This sounds like a good way to develop collabs and other things, but I feel like this could be a way to get around unmoderated chat? Not sure, but the ST probably has some reason this doesn't exist yet

Edit: On second thought, although I support this, this could be a way when someone trusts another Scratcher, they could give them abilities, and let's say their friendship didn't end on good terms. Then that person can go grief their project and ruin it. That could be a possible problem.
That's the creator of the project's problem, not the Scratch Team's
mitdk_test
Scratcher
24 posts

Feature Idea: Allow certain people to edit your original project

Sorry, this is rejected:

TOLORS wrote:

2.1 Adding users to work on projects
Having multiple Scratchers work on the same project would be difficult to moderate not only due to technological limitations, but also because it could lead to private messaging; for more information, see #7.1 on this list. This suggestion includes live editing (similar to Google Docs) and other forms of private collaboration. If you would like to work on a project with another Scratcher, you can remix each others' projects.
In the future, please check the The Official List of Rejected Suggestions before making a topic
cs4715962
Scratcher
100+ posts

Feature Idea: Allow certain people to edit your original project

1: It has been rejected
2: you can easily remix
Also, I don't support
the2000
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Feature Idea: Allow certain people to edit your original project

I think that this would mostly be used for vandalism, because you seem to imply that this would be open to literally everyone. If not, then this is a duplicate of the suggestion for turn-based collaboration. If you want to improve a project or someone wants to improve your project, you or they can just make a remix.
Paddle2See
Scratch Team
1000+ posts

Feature Idea: Allow certain people to edit your original project

This has the problem of not knowing who is responsible for the content of the project, if it turns out to be something that is inappropriate. Or even something that somebody else wants to reuse and credit. There are also concerns with unmoderated communication taking place using the elements of the project (notes, costumes, scratchblocks, etc.). For these reasons, I think it is likely that this won't be implemented.

Powered by DjangoBB