GENERAL INFORMATION

WELCOME TO THE UNOFFICIAL LIST OF REJECTED SUGGESTIONS!
This topic contains suggestions that were unofficially rejected. I believe that the current Official List of Rejected Suggestions is too old and biased based on the information provided in this topic. Thus I declare that we need a new and better list of rejected suggestions that will better benefit the community.

PLEASE SUGGEST THINGS HERE!
Your suggestion will get more attention if you suggest it here. Otherwise, it may be on this list.

Also, you may ask, “Why did you put ‘Sticky’ in the title?”, it's so the word ‘Sticky’ appears in the title twice when this topic becomes a Sticky. It looks cooler that way.

Anyway, here are your rejected suggestions.

Click on the hyperlink to see why they were rejected.

THE REJECTED SUGGESTIONS

0. ⠀
0.0 ⠀
⠀

1. Removing Stuff

1.4 Remove Scratch
Although the Scratch Team is looking forward to removing Scratch some time, they cannot do that before removing the suggestion that suggests removing Scratch, so— wait a minute…

1.7 Remove @griffpatch's account
Until someone helps @wheelsonfire beat the highscore on Bouncy Heroes (which is not a griffpatch project), @griffpatch's account will not be removed.

1.10 Remove the Scratch Editor
We never learn why, but unfortunately, the ST says that they wouldn't implement this. Oh well!

1.11 Remove the “When green flag clicked” block
While many people agree that it makes more sense to ‘wave’ a green flag than to ‘click’ a green flag, I believe that we should not remove this block because it presents us the chance to experiment all the fun things you can do by ‘clicking’ a green flag!

1.17 Remove projects and comments and the forums
Actually, I kinda agree with this one. But I can't help but be told that my boss wants it here for no reason.

1.50 Remove half of all Scratchers
The Scratch Team wants to try some less drastic measures to meet their resource needs before they can consider implementing this suggestion.

1.51 Delete this
[This explanation has been deleted]

1.100 (removed by moderator)
(removed by (removed by moderator — please keep names a secret) — (removed by myself — I don't know why I removed this))

2. Scratch Community

2.2 Lasers destroying people who try to destroy the donations mechanism
They're out of stock. I sold and copyrighted them all.

2.3 Give @Scratchmaster295 popcorn
scratch does not want to give away popcorn i meant they just waited a minute and 45 seconds for their popcorn to pop and now they gotta do that again

2.5 Give all users moderator status
I'm not sure what's going on here, but it appears that the person in charge of promoting people to moderator status prefers dancing to an ‘80s hit rather than allowing all users on the site to become mods. I think it’s safe to say that this suggestion is rejected for this reason.

2.8 Do not post here
Because the mods have not found a way to shut down this topic, it is very much possible to post here. Therefore, this suggestion is rejected.

2.17 Add Animal Soccer World to Scratch
It's an interesting idea, but we don't have enough chocolate chip cookies to implement this suggestion. We're gonna have to reject this.

2.24 Make this topic a Sticky
We're out of superglue from high demand, so we can't sticky this topic.

2.30 Unban WAHSP
Because the person in inquiry refused to supply chocolate chip cookies and espresso coffee, this suggestion simply cannot be added.

2.35 Implement confusing code into Scratch
Self-explanatory.

2.90 Ban people who post rejected suggestions
Rejected.

2.100 Close all topics
Let's start by closing this one first. Then we can close everything else.

2.101 Uno reverse cards
Because of how frequently they are used on Scratch, our servers are running out of Uno reverse cards. Therefore we need to reject this suggestion.

2.120 Add raining tacos
There's only one thing better than raining tacos and that's raining burgers. So we're going to reject this one.

2.121 Make Rick Astley the mascot of Scratch

Rick Astley @rickastley • 2h wrote:

no sorry I can't be the mascot of scratch

2.150 Add new things to the donation system
Unfortunately, our donation system got hacked and as a result, all donations are being sent to the black hats instead of the Scratch Team. We are required to suspend all donations until this issue is fixed.

2.200 9-step verification
Nine steps is too short, let's make it 200 steps instead. Much better security-wise.

2.343 Add Super Mario to Scratch
Instead of Super Mario, we're going to hire Sonic instead because his super speed is great for the mod team.

2.9999 Numbers higher than one trillion or floating-point (decimal) numbers
Decimal numbers and numbers greater than one trillion are too confusing to read. We can't allow them on the site.

3. Blocks

3.911 A “call 911” block
Some people want a “call 911” block. Unfortunately, we cannot add it. Here's why:

NxNmultiply wrote:

Ok, so I suggest to add

call [911 v]

because Scratch is designed for young people so when kids become homeless they decide to live in Scratch, and they need occasional emergencies as well.

5. Teams

5.1 Team Lowercase
They were asked to ‘try harder next time’… whatever that means.

5.2 Team Uppercase or Team Capital
Our team of Scratch Cats kept thinking that Capitals and Uppercase letters are yarn strings and so they kept scratching and destroying them. So to accommodate them, we are going to ban all uppercase letters.

6. Selling and Rating Stuff

6.2 Selling and copyrighting stuff
Selling and copyrighting stuff is an exciting concept but because we're deprived of chocolate chip cookies this suggestion will have to be postponed for another 2051.3939 years.

6.6 Rating suggestions
Unfortunately, a sudden demand in server operations meant that we are short of supply of espresso coffee, which we've been using to power our servers. So we cannot accept this suggestion because our servers are out of service.

9. Rejected Suggestions

9.1 The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
The Rejected Suggestions are rejected because of the excellent reasoning by Za-Chary Paddle2See. The current list of rejected suggestions rejects too many good features that could be useful. Therefore, I need to reject it for the better of the community.

9.2 Remove the Rejected Suggestions Sticky
In addition to everything said by @Paddle2See,

Za-Chary wrote:

The Rejected Suggestions sticky isn’t even made by a Scratch Team member. I know this because I tried looking up “is za-chary a scratch team member” on Google and no sources I looked at said “yes.” This user is clearly not a Scratch Team member, not even in disguise, so I don’t see what makes them so special. For all we know, the sticky could just be a list of things that that user doesn’t want to see in Scratch.

However, we can clearly see the “Scratch Team” tag inscribed below his name, so therefore the person who created that topic obviously wanted those rejected suggestions rejected for no reason! Thus this suggestion must be rejected.

9.9 Reject all suggestions
ok so I'll add this to the list of rejected suggestions then

9.40 Reject rejecting suggestions
If we reject the ability to reject suggestions then our only other option is to ban people for posting rejected suggestions.

9.41 Reject reject rejecting suggestions
Error 1042.49: Explanation not found. Please check with your local post office.

9.999 Reject
We recently discovered that our servers become sentient and plan to destroy the website every time the word ‘reject’ and all of its synonyms, tenses, and related forms appear on the website. Thus we have decided to reject all uses of the word ‘reject’ and all of its synonyms, tenses, and related forms for good.

45. Single Character Suggestions
45.0 .
Many people would like ., however, . is too . to be . to Scratch; therefore, we have to reject this one.

45.1 i
Unfortunately, we do not have enough chocolate chip cookies to consider this suggestion. View this project to see why.

45.2 f
While having single-letter posts is an interesting and certainly revolutionary concept, there simply is not enough space on the servers to allow this at the moment.

73. Miscellaneous

73.1 Duplicate
Thanks for the link! It does look like this is a duplicate topic so I'll close it to keep the conversation all in one place.

Please use the existing topic in the link above.

73.2 Reject this Suggestion
Rejected. Read the Stickies before posting.

73.3 Thanks for the link! It does look like this is a duplicate topic so I'll close it to keep the conversation all in one place.

Please use the existing topic in the link above.
Hey, you're right! Thanks!

To keep the conversation focused in one place, I'll be closing this topic now. Feel free to continue the discussion in the link provided above.

73.8 Duplicate
Hey, you're right! Thanks!

To keep the conversation focused in one place, I'll be closing this topic now. Feel free to continue the discussion in the link provided above.

73.20 Bump
I don't like bumps. Every time I do it I bonk my head and it hurts. This needs to be rejected.

73.80 Rickrolling
For budgeting purposes, the Scratch Team unfortunately does not have the ability to rickroll Scratchers effectively. See the topic linked above for the details.

ǐ̫͒͊͂͐ͥ ̘̝͈͔͔͉͚̀ͮ̂ͧͬ̐m̙̝̗͖͇̥̭̳ͧ̆̏̾ḛ̰̤̿ͪ͐ͪ̿a̠͚͍̠̼͌̿̓̂̅n͖̥̙̝̻̙͇̦͋̽̃̈,̖͛̔ͨͪ̓̈́ ͎̘̺͍̻̞̤̠̓̍ͩ̄ͬ͂̂w͈̜ͭ͑ͪḥ̳̫́y̘͙̯̦͛́̀ ͇̭̞̥̍̃ͯ͑ͥ̔͗͂n̟͍̆̎̚o͉͎ͪ́͌̍̀̀ͭ̂̌t̟̯̳̅ͫ̆͆ͪͩ

THIS IS A GOOD TOPIC;

PREPARE TO BE STICKIED;

is throwing scratch into my basement rejected

y͙̻ͦͪö͉̜́̌͌̊̿u͇͍̭ͨͪ͐́ͣ͒̓̌͌ ̝̫̲̤̩̫̄͆̐̎ͨ̈͊ͧû̼̜̣̞͚͍̣ͪ̾ͥ͛ͧ̃̌̊ṡ̥͋ͣ̋͌̊e̲̽̈͋ͮ̔ͬ͋̑͛d̻̫̅͊́͐̄ ̰͇̟̩͚̙͍͋ͭ̀ͤ͑̽̑̚t̳̥͖͍̪͈͎̝ͯ̀̔͑ͧ̐ͣͭh͙͈̬̗͍̟̹̹̃ͥ́̿ͮ͑̑e͍̰̗͋̽̋ͣͮ̉ ̞̇̄ͪp̱͎͚ͨͯ͐ͅo̦̥̖̰̩̠͉̠͗̀̀ͬ̃͛ͪͮ̀w̘͎̫ͪ̈́̆ͧͅe̖͚͓̓̇̏ͮ̇͑̽̃ͧṙ̪̱͖̜̖̠̈̓̒͒̎̎ ̗̿̆̊̊ͣ̏̿ö͓̟͍̦́̏̎f̪̝ͯ̾ͅ ̬͇͉̫͖ͬ̓̄͋ͮ͂ả̪̮̥̺̖͋̑p̮̖̹̗̠͔͖̜̒͛r̠ͭ̓̌ͨͦ͐͑ͩͨȋ̲͉̲̘̟̠̜ͦḽ̬͎̪̭̥̭̮̓̍̀͐̏̒̀ ̫̺͖̥̠̝̖ͨͯ̈͆̒f̭̗̑͂ͭ̚o͍̜̲̥̻̝͒̃ȯ͙͔͎̖ͬ͋͗͐l͍͖͗ͥ͆͐ͨ̓s̺̙̖͖͚̯͍̘ͦͩͥͩ̽̾̂ͅ ̤̳͓̐̐̔͊̉̇̈t͖̹̫͑͛o̖̦͎̥̥̒ͭ͐͋̌ͧ ͎̙͚̗͇̜̣ͥ͗ͩo̦̜̘̩͑͗ͥ̽̇ͣb͖͈̙̭͇̦̗̣̦́̒̃̒̂t͚̫̥͚̤͋̆̄͊̃̇̋̔ā̤̩͈͖̼͍͖͉̓ͦ̀i̺̦͍̟̪͖̻ͬ̾ͯ̅ͫn͇̥͎̺͍͙̪͍̆̏ͧ̄̏ͮ͂ ̲͉̗ͭ͌́a͕̳͓͚̱̜̰͔̐ͤ ͈̜̫̗̪̗̣͇̍ͪ͛ͩ̾̀̍p̲̭̺̞̭̠̈́̍̈͛͆e̲̬͕̱̩̜ͣͦ̀͆r̝̝͆̉̇̓ͤ̀̌͂s̼̞̞̲̼̬̹͋ͧò͚̙̭ͭn̺̱̗͔̹͖̙̰ͭ͐͂͛͛ͤ̓̽͂ȧ̦̤̊̊̌ͪͅl͚͇̫̺̻̘̗̟̱̈͊ͧͧ͋̔ ͔̎ͭ̇͂s͍̺̟̼̅ͪ͋̌ͬ͂̚a̞̹͓̗̙͗ͥ̽̽ͬt͓͈̗͓ͪͦ͆̄̎ͥ̔̈i̟͍̹̜͖̳ͤ́͐̔ͫͣ̚s͙̱̰̞͍̰͙̙ͣ̓̆f̼̰̼̖̭̪͈͎̊ͨ̊̌̄a̤͙̱̲̰͈͎͎̎ͯ̇̈̾c̗̤̖͇̠̝͍̬̥ͤ́̾̍̓̂̓t̳͇͍͂ͨͥ̂̑̐̋̇̚i͍̭͌͆̑ȏ̪̺͎̰̰n̥̙͉̰͓͖̬̭ͬ̅͊

delete this

NxNmultiply wrote:

Ok, so I suggest to add

call [911 v]

because Scratch is designed for young people so when kids become homeless they decide to live in Scratch, and they need occasional emergencies as well.

Thank you! I've added it to the list.

E_Equals_EmCeCube3 wrote:

NxNmultiply wrote:

Ok, so I suggest to add

call [911 v]

because Scratch is designed for young people so when kids become homeless they decide to live in Scratch, and they need occasional emergencies as well.

Thank you! I've added it to the list.

Hi there! Please don't post on old topics as doing so is called necroposting, which is not allowed. Thanks!

Please reject my suggestions. https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/392958/ https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/392934/ . But do NOT close them. That wqiouu8odkl; bhre= 9u9retdfigodfghn avrdsgfmkbg dfhuviodnhuirnnnmuhignvmhatnrhi4hnevvtaunvauvnanmiuomvumuernmiuohtmhovimnuiuetiumnuihviunm- This transmission has been halted by the Scratch Team.

how about rejecting every suggestion?

chrdagos wrote:

how about rejecting every suggestion?

THAT IS REJECTED;

ZA-CHARY IF YOU ADD THIS TO THE LIST OF ACCEPTED SUGGESTIONS I WILL DESTROY YOU;

THERE I CROSSED OUT THE WORD DESTROY SO NO ONE CAN BANISH ME;

chrdagos wrote:

click here to get rickrolled.

Rejected:

Sticky: The Unofficial List of Rejected Suggestions wrote:

73.80 Allow rickrolling
For budgeting purposes, the Scratch Team unfortunately does not have the ability to rickroll Scratchers effectively. See the topic linked above for the details.

(throws into my basement with all the anime characters)

could u reject the server crashing

bump

ban everyone on the scratch team

PLEASE ADD THIS TO THE LIST; https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/393042/

I AM TOO LAZY TO ADD IT MYSELF;

r̲̳̪͙̀̾ͬ͋e̤̹͉̋̋ͤ̈́j̭̪̭̯̎̄e̻̣̥̦̘͚̮̝͌ͯͦ́̆͂ͅc̭̯̘̙̪̗͐̓͗t̪͕̺̳͓̱̄̓ ̳̩̲͙̘ͣ̉t͕̙̪̥͍͑̒̍̈́ḧ̙ͨ̂ͭe̝͈̍͆ ̫̭̰̞͓̣̩̭̻̏ͨ̓͗̌̀ͭ́t͇̫̲̯̰͕͐͊͌͂̋̚e̝̟̟̤̭͖͖ͦͦ̆̓̉̍a̰̮̠̮̪ͥͤͧͭ̑̅m͖̼͛͌͒̾ͅ ̬̦̘̺͚̈̂ͦc̰͓͎̯̬͗́̽̀a̺͍ͤ̏̓̽p͇̬̘̹̒̈̎͆̌i̻͇̎̎ͪ̿ͦ̍̚t̗͆́ͤ̊ͮ̌ȧ̭̫̠̟̣͙̣̠ͮl͇͋̉

please add https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/t0pic/392955/, as creates a maj0r security issue, as 9 step verificati0n is n0t en0ugh