Re-add "Echo" Sound Effect

Mr_PenguinAlex

IAmClausAgain wrote:
I think the reason they removed it is that people would abuse the feature and make loud noises.

They removed it because it would “make the sound editor overwhelming”

pavcato

I have supported this topic since I started foruming, so let me make a better support reason:
Support. I think the echo effect is extremely useful for editing sound.
The reason “too many features” to not support is not a really good reason.
This would just be a better option than “Robot”.
I'm not saying robot should be removed, but robot kinda ruins the audio. Echo can actually be used as an effect.

Last edited by pavcato (Oct. 12, 2020 15:40:05)

MeIzAwezomeDede

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:
IAmClausAgain wrote:
I think the reason they removed it is that people would abuse the feature and make loud noises.
They removed it because it would “make the sound editor overwhelming”

pavcato wrote:
I have supported this topic since I started foruming, so let me make a better support reason:
Support. I think the echo effect is extremely useful for editing sound.
The reason “too many features” to not support is not a really good reason.
This would just be a better option than “Robot”.
I'm not saying robot should be removed, but robot kinda ruins the audio. Echo can actually be used as an effect.

Plus, robot can literally be used to make loud noises. If you spam it it just gets really loud.
edit: not saying I hate robot effect here

Last edited by MeIzAwezomeDede (Nov. 24, 2020 15:16:09)

Nothing to see here

CuteHoomanFrisk

when green flag clicked

say [PLEASE BRING ECHO BACK!!!]

*

rrllaurence1708

ddgdgdgdgdgdgdgdgdgd

pikachucandy2

ask [hey, whats going on here lol:lol::lol::lol:] and wait

Life is like Mentos in Coca-Cola.

DevilGutz
any pronouns (but not she/her plz)

MeIzAwezomeDede

rrllaurence1708 wrote:
ddgdgdgdgdgdgdgdgdgd

pikachucandy2 wrote:

ask [hey, whats going on here lol:lol::lol::lol:] and wait

please don't spam

Nothing to see here

Arose159

LegoManiac04 wrote:
The “Echo” sound effect in the Sound Editor was in 3.0 before the update today (8/1/19), but now it's removed.
I understand that the Sound Editor may seem overwhelming with all of these features, but it was a cool effect.

Please add it back.

yes i totaly agree it could make some games and some animated things awesome and we they could add some other things

SuperCappy

Arose159 wrote:
LegoManiac04 wrote:
The “Echo” sound effect in the Sound Editor was in 3.0 before the update today (8/1/19), but now it's removed.
I understand that the Sound Editor may seem overwhelming with all of these features, but it was a cool effect.

Please add it back.
yes i totaly agree it could make some games and some animated things awesome and we they could add some other things

yes i also support because of the reasons above

I moved my Account to Scratchy697

SuperCappy

lebupm

I moved my Account to Scratchy697

Tupurdidi

Agreed!

when green flag clicked
forever
say [ADD ECHO SOUND EFFECT!!!!] for (5) secs
end

pikachucandy2

We need the echo filter back.

Life is like Mentos in Coca-Cola.

DevilGutz
any pronouns (but not she/her plz)

lovecodeabc

pavcato wrote:
I have supported this topic since I started foruming, so let me make a better support reason:
Support. I think the echo effect is extremely useful for editing sound.
The reason “too many features” to not support is not a really good reason.
This would just be a better option than “Robot”.
I'm not saying robot should be removed, but robot kinda ruins the audio. Echo can actually be used as an effect.

Support ^^^^^

Highlight + Ctrl + Shift + down to see full sig

Check out my thingymagings!
Click on them to go to them

Google
© 2019 - 2023 lovecodeabc. All Rights Reserved under Title 17 of the United States Code, and especialy under Section 101-513. Unauthorized Use Prohibited, except under 17 USC § 107, Fair Use. cease and desist letters go brrrrrrr
Uh oh, did the kumquats come again?

Click here!!!OR ELSE I WILL EAT YOUR COOKIESSSSSSSSSSSSSS AND ALSO MAYBE YOUR MOM, WHO KNOWS??

;

TheNothingBird

Support. The echo sound effect will be epic, however, I joined scratch after the echo sound effect was removed.

anyways heres the chipflake sonic 3 and knuckles 12 month thing

TheNothingBird

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:
Super_Scratch_Bros20 wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
Just gonna throw this out there; not meant to shut down your suggestion.

The developers felt that, with all these new features, the sound editor would be overwhelming with all these different features. It was a tough call to determine what to get rid of, but eventually they decided on the Echo effect. At least they didn't get rid of more than one effect!

Glad they still kept the Robot effect.

I feel like the developers made a tough decision - and I don't want that to be in vain.

No support.
but when have you ever seen the robot effect used?
i'm sure no one would care if the echo sound replaced the robot

Probably you’re right, the robot sound effect is underrated, meaning almost everyone don’t use it.

anyways heres the chipflake sonic 3 and knuckles 12 month thing

MeIzAwezomeDede

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:
-snip-

but when have you ever seen the robot effect used?
i'm sure no one would care if the echo sound replaced the robot

I- I use robot effect

That being said (since I haven't really contributed much) I know they removed echo to make it “less overwhelming” but what if they could add echo back while also keeping robot?

Nothing to see here

-CloudGate-

just play the sound multiple times with different volumes, it would be easier to just have an echo sound effect tho

box of Asian citrus psyllids and please give me an internet here

scratchykit5743

HUGE support. i may or will really need it for some of my in-progress games, and so would numerous others.

psst! Hit ctrl + shift + down to see the rest!

For whatever reason mister Jon Arbuckle got removed ;-; I'll find a replacement GIF later

Anyways hi, I'm SK

I've been on this site since I was 10 years old. I am currently 15

I have a major addiction to sweet tea and draw a crap ton of stuff in my free time (not all of which is scratch appropriate). I post whatever I want to on the main site and mostly manage the collaborations directory and answer questions in QaS on the forums

I have over 2000 posts lol, a huge chunk of them being from when I was 11-12 during the height of COVID

If by any chance the post you''re reading is from early 2021 or before, please forget that post exists since it is cringey

This is Kimikat.

     (OwO)

She protecc my siggy, and has been since 2020

Mr_PenguinAlex

MeIzAwezomeDede wrote:
Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:
-snip-

but when have you ever seen the robot effect used?
i'm sure no one would care if the echo sound replaced the robot
I- I use robot effect

but if echo was added back, would you use echo more often than robot?

MeIzAwezomeDede

Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:
MeIzAwezomeDede wrote:
Mr_PenguinAlex wrote:
-snip-

but when have you ever seen the robot effect used?
i'm sure no one would care if the echo sound replaced the robot
I- I use robot effect
but if echo was added back, would you use echo more often than robot?

No not really ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) but that's just because of the kind of games I make (robot effect proves more useful for voice-changing type things)

Echo would still be great to have tho

Nothing to see here

Discuss Scratch