The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

starlightsparker

Xzillox wrote:
8.2 says “generally, Scratch Team members do not brag about the Scratch Team rank.” The “generally” implies that this happens, but rarely. Interesting.

I think that’s just there for formal-ness

✮˚. ᵎᵎ ?彡⋆｡˚ starlight !! * ੈ✩‧₊˚ ✧˖° female !! ⋆｡°✩ they.them !!‧˚₊ muslim !!✶ .ᐟ
︶꒦꒷order at star's cafe! served w/ love꒷꒦︶
star's cafe is a store to order banners, pfps, and more!
(rounded) 1000th post | (actual) 1000th post | first post

~ pakistani muslim ~

~ born in arabia

~ palestine supporter! ~
stop the Islam hate! — useful custom blocks — latest project — comment here — Python Learning History
Scratch inspired me to want to become a programmer when i grow up. I plan on learning python :>

0_009

Turning project reporting on/off has been rejected.

Wonders of the Scratch world:
Griffpatch, the most followed Scratcher
Paper Minecraft, the most liked project
scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/9/, the oldest forum thread
deck26, the Scratcher with the most forum posts
Weekend, the oldest project
Sandwhich, the new oldest project
scratch.mit.edu/projects/1000000000/, the first project with an ID of 10 digits
ScratchCat, the most followed ST member

Blue_Moon2607

Za-Chary wrote:
StrangeMagic32 wrote:
Increase Clone Limit
possibly rejected?
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/375856/
Harakou wrote:
Please don't bump up old threads unless it's really necessary. The clone limit we've added is a practical one to prevent projects from becoming unplayable. Otherwise, you could accidentally get sprites making infinite copies of themselves and such.
I'll be adding this later.
XayCraft360 wrote:
There is a new rejected suggestion:
I almost feel like this one is a little too “obvious” in the same way that “Remove the Community Guidelines” is also obvious. It should go without saying that the Scratch Team won't be removing the Terms of Use and the Community Guidelines, so it doesn't exactly seem necessary to add it to the list.

What do you think, is there a good place it could be put?

If the clone limit is increased, there is a slight chance that the projects will lag (or rarely crash) due to too many sprites cloned. It is probably a good idea to keep a 300-clone limit.

I am just a Scratcher who is a Roblox bacon, feel free to go to my profile!
I have a studio called Blue Moon's Bacon Studio and it has a creative curated project including mine, please follow my studio! I also have a Roblox group called “Blue Moon Bacon Hangout”, join today!

Za-Chary

italvera wrote:
I believe adding projects to the App Store is rejected?

I'm not sure that one could be considered a rejection.

Xzillox wrote:
8.2 says “generally, Scratch Team members do not brag about the Scratch Team rank.” The “generally” implies that this happens, but rarely. Interesting.

I basically just didn't want to claim that it has never happened, although I do think it probably has never happened, so I reworded it slightly.

0_009 wrote:
Turning project reporting on/off has been rejected.

Thanks. This seems too obvious to add to the list.

This is my forum signature! On a forum post, it is okay for Scratchers to advertise in their forum signature. The signature is the stuff that shows up below the horizontal line on the post. It will show up on every post I make.

I was a Scratch Team member from May 10th 2019 to October 29th 2021.

my notebook | scratch team essay | accessibility essay

Blue_Moon2607

0_009 wrote:
Turning project reporting on/off has been rejected.

Because inappropriate projects are able to dodge moderation systems, since the report is disabled on the projects.

I am just a Scratcher who is a Roblox bacon, feel free to go to my profile!
I have a studio called Blue Moon's Bacon Studio and it has a creative curated project including mine, please follow my studio! I also have a Roblox group called “Blue Moon Bacon Hangout”, join today!

RSITYTScratch

Blue_Moon2607 wrote:
Because inappropriate projects are able to dodge moderation systems, since the report is disabled on the projects.

Inappropriate projects will then spread around Scratch, and because there's no way to report the projects, the spread gets worse and worse.

3,461: When you see this, copy and paste at the top of your sig if you want to spread the number. If not, then that's fine.

A BIG WAVE OF NOTIFICATIONS AHHHHHH-

Hello, I'm RSITYT! I am a autistic Puerto Rican 11 year old who is known for making Find the Squares.

Here's a game that I been working on: Find the Squares: The Fruit Named Husa, and yes, you can advertise your game in your sig.

Forget about the YT part, I don't have my channel anymore.

when @greenFlag misclicked::events :: hat
check everywhere::sensing
wait (0.01) seconds::control
self-destruct::control :: cap

Please set a status at Ocular by clicking the below image, to make @Jeffalo happy! #OcularStatusesTo2k

Oh, you won't see this without pressing Ctrl+Shift+Down!

robot_amelia

I love the ideas!

Found This Helpful?
Take a look at my profile!

Aaliyah_Newlands

@Za-Chary

How about suggesting to change or redesign the Scratch logo?

A small person that make their posts seem rude.

RethinkingVoxels

Reverting to old forum filter got rejected

GlitchedThrough

RethinkingVoxels wrote:
Reverting to old forum filter got rejected

It sounds like they want it removed.

There's no place like 127.0.0.1
YouTuber, Culinary Enthusiast, CS Enthusiast, programmer, Engineering Enthusiast/Hobbyist, enjoyer of the electric system, and I enjoy writing in my free time. Although I won’t share and of my works on Scratch, feel free to ask why on my profile.
I use a Logi G Pro X Superlight as my mouse

italvera

Closing I-Topics got rejected

han614698

italvera wrote:
Closing I-Topics got rejected

RethinkingVoxels wrote:
Reverting to old forum filter got rejected

Something has the be frequently suggested in order to be rejected, so don't ask to add every rejected topic.

I also think the I-Topic one is too obvious since it's against the very definition of an I-Topic.

Last edited by han614698 (April 1, 2024 17:46:34)

Credit to -gge for the icons in my signature | I condensed all this code into five lines using [p] tags, idk why

italvera

han614698 wrote:
Something has the be frequently suggested in order to be rejected, so don't ask to add every rejected topic.

TOLORS wrote:
Please also update me on any recently-rejected suggestions so we can discuss whether or not to add them to this list. Even if a suggestion is infrequently suggested or it is “obviously rejected,” it's still helpful for me to see that the suggestion exists.

-InsanityGames-

italvera wrote:
Even if a suggestion is infrequently suggested or it is “obviously rejected,” it's still helpful for me to see that the suggestion exists.

That hasn't been being followed lol

By the way dark theme in Scratch was rejected. april fools

PROFILEㅤ・ㅤGITHUBㅤ・ㅤGIVE AN INTERNETㅤ・ㅤULTIMATE TOLORS QUOTER

yo check back another time

-Rodri

-InsanityGames- wrote:
italvera wrote:
Even if a suggestion is infrequently suggested or it is “obviously rejected,” it's still helpful for me to see that the suggestion exists.
That hasn't been being followed lol

By the way dark theme in Scratch was rejected. april fools

omg i can't believe it got rejected!

Last edited by -Rodri (April 2, 2024 00:37:48)

Sent from Samsung Fridge Model RRSGR-34563

they say im gifted but i can't even spell proboably or simoustaniously correctly

omg when you search up “Samsung Fridge Model RRSGR-34563” one of my forums posts are the top result!!111

Have you ever wanted to rule the world?
Get Homework Help here!

✨Yassify the world with kindness✨

I'm Mexican/American

I speak Spanish and English (et un peu de francais)

I'm a roman catholic

I'm smart but have no street smarts

Straight Male
Goals:

Be a better forumer

EngineerRunner

RethinkingVoxels wrote:
Reverting to old forum filter got rejected

that isn't what was suggested..?

social experiment: comment here to not get curator

simpsons and futurama fan

RickRoIler (the first l is a capital i) on PSN, NotXboxGamer765 on xbox (and by that i mean xbox 360), EngineerRunner on Minecraft (find me on hypixel)
also im on the orange cat social media as EngineerRunner

join the worst guild on hypixel with this command!!1/!/!?1/!/

/guild join los gamers

if any of my suggestions ever get accepted, i will have my profile picture set to Just Stamp The Ticket Man for 3 months

give internets pls

an australian cumquat ate my snag and onions

“maintainer” of Pyratch, a very simple text-focused frontend for Scratch
oh god am I becoming an ATer

when I am deleted ::hat control
ask (join (join [what the hell does ] (when I am deleted ::hat control)) [ do?]) and wait
create clone of [Stage v]
delete this project ::control
stop [eh, a few] sounds ::sound

casually taking over the forums:

this is what happens when school goes back in the US, scratch has like no activity

when I am deleted ::hat control

create clone of [Stage v]
delete this project ::control
stop [eh, a few] sounds ::sound

gdfsgdfsgdfg

-InsanityGames- wrote:
By the way dark theme in Scratch was rejected. april fools

where does it say its rejected
hold up I fought ST was not doing april fools in fourms

1000th post also use -forbidden- or highlight and ctrl (optional on some browsers) + shift + down arrow for more of my siggy

I gotta go touch sum grass

If it causes issues make it optional - gdfsgdfsgdfg

Do some research before replying to my posts - gdfsgdfsgdfg

curse you 60 sec rule

glory to Gdfsg Land

gdfsgdfsgdfg returns

Ocular(don’t look at my old posts plz)
PostPercent

kumquats? nah
my siggy is built with titani- *gets eaten*

Gdfsg Radio Station:
https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/1000736602

Are you sleeping you tall cat (project):
https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/1002042247/

The only suggestions I fully support are:
https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/924995948/

Don’t force me to get proof
get it yourself

my favorite topic is this (due to comedic purposes):
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/709979/

my favorite post is this (it’s deleted but I got it from ocular):
https://ocular.jeffalo.net/post/7517300

Grand borrowing cars IV intro and loading (template):
https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/972295666/

Guess the game by its mission name:
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/750145/

GBC (GTA) topic:
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/751981/

BF (Battlefield) topic:
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/753243/

still don’t have the popularity lol (atleast I reached 100 followers)

Skill issue

reject

Embrace :)

SDLT010

Za-Chary wrote:
2.6 Increase the 300 clone limit
The clone limit is set in place to prevent projects from becoming unplayable. Otherwise, users could create a large number of clones very quickly and crash someone's browser page. Plus, the Scratch Team wants to make sure that all projects run smoothly for as many people as possible. Increasing the limit to even 500 clones might make the project run slowly on some users' devices.

but you can still create a large number of clones very quickly and make someones browser lag

I make games and animations

Look at them

TheEpikGamer211

uhh, as of my guessing, I believe turn based ones still count as private messaging.
I know ways to make it so.

Epik gamer 211. Proud inventor of GTTSTES.
im workng on
sc (then SBOX)
GTTSTES 1.3

when (::ff0000) horribly misclicked and pressed @greenFlag instead.:: hat :: events 
Summon Evil Kumquats using (((((((((((((:D):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion):: motion :: motion)

Elijah999999

TheEpikGamer211 wrote:
uhh, as of my guessing, I believe turn based ones still count as private messaging.
I know ways to make it so.

No, because the suggestion states that the project will always be public.

No longer using the forums unless necessary.

Really, stop with the “support/no support” thing. I don't care if you give a reason. If you have a reason you don't need to add this to your post in the first place. Stop acting like your opinion makes a difference. It doesn't. Opinions were never the point. The point is whether or not it's a good suggestion. If you can give a good reason at why this is a good idea or point out a flaw, do it, but don't take sides.
This is not sarcasm.

Discuss Scratch