So HH recently got banned for “mature themes” but other shows like South Park aren't banned. South Park includes more mature themes and to make it worse jokes about them. Like innapropriate and illegal stuff some adults do to minors and it jokes about that horrible stuff! No young people should be watching this stuff because they might think it's okay to joke about. At least HH doesn't treat this stuff as a joke! So it should be banned from Scratch.

Rejected

TOLORS wrote:

3.3 Ban certain franchises
Generally, the Scratch Team does not censor projects based on a certain franchise unless a large number of inappropriate projects were made with the franchise. An example is Five Nights at Freddy's; see this announcement for more information. In general, it is usually possible to make appropriate projects based on a certain franchise. Of course, you should always report inappropriate projects of any kind

The-Sushi-Cat wrote:

Rejected

TOLORS wrote:

3.3 Ban certain franchises
Generally, the Scratch Team does not censor projects based on a certain franchise unless a large number of inappropriate projects were made with the franchise. An example is Five Nights at Freddy's; see this announcement for more information. In general, it is usually possible to make appropriate projects based on a certain franchise. Of course, you should always report inappropriate projects of any kind

They banned HH. It's possible to make appropriate HH projects. One of my projects was just making cat versions of the characters.

I definitely agree. Not only is the show itself kinda very problematic, but also, as you said, VERY mature. There's no reason for it to be allowed on Scratch.

Horsekatto wrote:

The-Sushi-Cat wrote:

Rejected

TOLORS wrote:

3.3 Ban certain franchises
Generally, the Scratch Team does not censor projects based on a certain franchise unless a large number of inappropriate projects were made with the franchise. An example is Five Nights at Freddy's; see this announcement for more information. In general, it is usually possible to make appropriate projects based on a certain franchise. Of course, you should always report inappropriate projects of any kind

They banned HH.

Were a large amount of bad projects referring to it created?

roofogato wrote:

I definitely agree. Not only is the show itself kinda very problematic, but also, as you said, VERY mature. There's no reason for it to be allowed on Scratch.

I think an appropriate South Park dress-up game should be fine, but your point is very valid.

EDawg2011 wrote:

roofogato wrote:

I definitely agree. Not only is the show itself kinda very problematic, but also, as you said, VERY mature. There's no reason for it to be allowed on Scratch.

I think an appropriate South Park dress-up game should be fine, but your point is very valid.

It might convince kids to watch the show.

EDawg2011 wrote:

roofogato wrote:

I definitely agree. Not only is the show itself kinda very problematic, but also, as you said, VERY mature. There's no reason for it to be allowed on Scratch.

I think an appropriate South Park dress-up game should be fine, but your point is very valid.

The same could be said about HH.

The-Sushi-Cat wrote:

Rejected

TOLORS wrote:

3.3 Ban certain franchises
Generally, the Scratch Team does not censor projects based on a certain franchise unless a large number of inappropriate projects were made with the franchise. An example is Five Nights at Freddy's; see this announcement for more information. In general, it is usually possible to make appropriate projects based on a certain franchise. Of course, you should always report inappropriate projects of any kind

And yet here we are.
—
Now, I find South Park hilarious, but it is such because it is offensive, and doesn’t hold back any punches. It’s much less tame then HH, I’d say, so it would be beneficial.

Horsekatto wrote:

EDawg2011 wrote:

roofogato wrote:

I definitely agree. Not only is the show itself kinda very problematic, but also, as you said, VERY mature. There's no reason for it to be allowed on Scratch.

I think an appropriate South Park dress-up game should be fine, but your point is very valid.

It might convince kids to watch the show.

Then maybe put something in the description like “South Park isn't appropriate.”

cactus-cacti wrote:

Horsekatto wrote:

The-Sushi-Cat wrote:

Rejected

TOLORS wrote:

3.3 Ban certain franchises
Generally, the Scratch Team does not censor projects based on a certain franchise unless a large number of inappropriate projects were made with the franchise. An example is Five Nights at Freddy's; see this announcement for more information. In general, it is usually possible to make appropriate projects based on a certain franchise. Of course, you should always report inappropriate projects of any kind

They banned HH.

Were a large amount of bad projects referring to it created?

Just like uncensored songs I think.

EDawg2011 wrote:

Horsekatto wrote:

EDawg2011 wrote:

roofogato wrote:

I definitely agree. Not only is the show itself kinda very problematic, but also, as you said, VERY mature. There's no reason for it to be allowed on Scratch.

I think an appropriate South Park dress-up game should be fine, but your point is very valid.

It might convince kids to watch the show.

Then maybe put something in the description like “South Park isn't appropriate.”

Children do not listen to warnings. That's why most warnings aren't allowed.

Horsekatto wrote:

Just like uncensored songs I think.

That is a big deal on Scratch.

Horsekatto wrote:

Children do not listen to warnings. That's why most warnings aren't allowed.

They would just want to watch it more.

Horsekatto wrote:

EDawg2011 wrote:

roofogato wrote:

I definitely agree. Not only is the show itself kinda very problematic, but also, as you said, VERY mature. There's no reason for it to be allowed on Scratch.

I think an appropriate South Park dress-up game should be fine, but your point is very valid.

It might convince kids to watch the show.

exactly
i saw many vids about hh, and it SEEMED appropriate, so i thought i might watch it but a friend warned me its mature
same thing can happen with south park

Horsekatto wrote:

#11
Children do not listen to warnings. That's why most warnings aren't allowed.

Then why are FNAF projects still allowed even though a huge amount of inappropriate FNAF projects were made? (As long as they're appropriate.)

EDawg2011 wrote:

Horsekatto wrote:

#11
Children do not listen to warnings. That's why most warnings aren't allowed.

Then why are FNAF projects still allowed even though a huge amount of inappropriate FNAF projects were made? (As long as they're appropriate.)

they're literally not
they're NFEd lol

yadayadayadagoodbye wrote:

they're literally not
they're NFEd lol

NFE doesn't mean it isn't allowed; it would only be banned if FNAF projects get taken down no matter what.

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions wrote:

3.3 Ban certain franchises

Generally, the Scratch Team does not censor projects based on a certain franchise unless a large number of inappropriate projects were made with the franchise. An example is Five Nights at Freddy's; see this announcement for more information. In general, it is usually possible to make appropriate projects based on a certain franchise. Of course, you should always report inappropriate projects of any kind.

View source

While South Park is an inappropriate and controversial show, most projects made about it aren't as inappropriate and are mostly fine for Scratch. It might be NFE-able but not straight up banned.

not sure about this because the dupe was closed https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/691179

-InsanityGames- wrote:

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions wrote:

3.3 Ban certain franchises

Generally, the Scratch Team does not censor projects based on a certain franchise unless a large number of inappropriate projects were made with the franchise. An example is Five Nights at Freddy's; see this announcement for more information. In general, it is usually possible to make appropriate projects based on a certain franchise. Of course, you should always report inappropriate projects of any kind.

View source

While South Park is an inappropriate and controversial show, most projects made about it aren't as inappropriate and are mostly fine for Scratch. It might be NFE-able but not straight up banned.

Most projects with HH were also not innapropriate. Yet it still got banned.

starlightsparker wrote:

Horsekatto wrote:

EDawg2011 wrote:

roofogato wrote:

I definitely agree. Not only is the show itself kinda very problematic, but also, as you said, VERY mature. There's no reason for it to be allowed on Scratch.

I think an appropriate South Park dress-up game should be fine, but your point is very valid.

It might convince kids to watch the show.

exactly
i saw many vids about hh, and it SEEMED appropriate, so i thought i might watch it but a friend warned me its mature
same thing can happen with south park

Yeah, some episodes are okay with some vulgar language and gore at most. But episodes like ep 4 deal with much darker and mature topics but at least it doesn't make fun and it actually portrays them correctly unlike South park. I am going to say that the songs are mostly okay with some swears at most.