Discuss Scratch

thugatwoary
Scratcher
100+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

title
It actually makes no sense why it does this, and it could lead to someone accidentally breaking their project! The whole point of saving as a copy is that it creates a copy and saves the changes there instead of saving the original.
-Valtren-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

couldn't you just save as a copy before you make any changes?
thugatwoary
Scratcher
100+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

-Valtren- wrote:

couldn't you just save as a copy before you make any changes?
It's possible that someone who doesn't know that save as copy acts this way would make changes before saving and accidentally change the original (i have done this)
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

-Valtren- wrote:

couldn't you just save as a copy before you make any changes?
You've probably heard of the infamous grey question mark glitch appearing in big projects. This would count as a change, and saving it would certainly break a project.
thugatwoary
Scratcher
100+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

bump
GIitchInTheMatrix
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

Support, when you want it to be saved, you can easily just save it before Save as a Copy if you want it saved, and the original might work, the copy might be an experiment, so if you don’t realize it, and click save as copy, you’re outta luck.
donotforgetmycode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

This is really important, bump
donotforgetmycode
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

bump
YtArie5
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

It should probably have a
“Save project?” Check box with it
(It saving automatically is actually useful for me sometimes)
SonicFanX123_321
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

YtArie5 wrote:

It should probably have a
“Save project?” Check box with it
(It saving automatically is actually useful for me sometimes)
actually, how about a “Don't save project” checkbox? thatd make it easier for the ST to make it automatically save but making it togglable, bc im pretty sure its kinda hard to automatically tick a checkbox
like this:


also i think this would want to be saveable
rdococ
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

Projects autosave regularly anyway- it's more likely your modifications will overwrite the original project when it autosaves than when you choose to make a copy.
nembence
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

Support - I haven't seen any other program where “Save as (…)” overwrites the original.

Also, with the recent bugs where some of them are fixed by saving and some of them cause data loss when saving, this would be useful

thugatwoary wrote:

-Valtren- wrote:

couldn't you just save as a copy before you make any changes?
It's possible that someone who doesn't know that save as copy acts this way would make changes before saving and accidentally change the original (i have done this)
me too and then I made a similar topic in Bugs and Glitches (a few years ago)

Last edited by nembence (April 24, 2026 19:33:09)

nembence
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Save as Copy should not save the original before making the copy.

If it also saves to the original, it should be called something like "Save and Copy" instead, to give a hint that it overwrites the original

Last edited by nembence (May 29, 2026 14:16:04)

Powered by DjangoBB