Sigton wrote:

What was wrong with the old one? It was still being updated often enough and included all the stuff you needed to know…

Sigton

@jvvg Here's what we would like to try - a dual topic approach. Your topic stays as the sticky topic with a summary of the most common rejected suggestions. You have a link in the first post of your topic to @customhacker's topic as providing a more comprehensive list of rejected suggestions, for those that are interested.We make that topic an ITopic showing that it is referenced from a sticky topic.

stickfiregames wrote:

Sigton wrote:

What was wrong with the old one? It was still being updated often enough and included all the stuff you needed to know…

Sigton

It was deliberately incomplete (apparently some suggestions aren't common enough, and it's just been cut down even more) and jvvg wasn't often responding to posts on it. It also used to list some suggestions that weren't actually rejected, but they are gone now.

MathlyCat wrote:

stickfiregames wrote:

Sigton wrote:

What was wrong with the old one? It was still being updated often enough and included all the stuff you needed to know…

Sigton

It was deliberately incomplete (apparently some suggestions aren't common enough, and it's just been cut down even more) and jvvg wasn't often responding to posts on it. It also used to list some suggestions that weren't actually rejected, but they are gone now.

But this one is so much harder to read; the small text is small. It also adds the pain of being able to read why.

customhacker wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

stickfiregames wrote:

Sigton wrote:

What was wrong with the old one? It was still being updated often enough and included all the stuff you needed to know…

Sigton

It was deliberately incomplete (apparently some suggestions aren't common enough, and it's just been cut down even more) and jvvg wasn't often responding to posts on it. It also used to list some suggestions that weren't actually rejected, but they are gone now.

But this one is so much harder to read; the small text is small. It also adds the pain of being able to read why.

The text is small due to the side of the quotes.

jvvg wrote:

14. Banning minor remixes
Remixes are allowed as long as at least something is changed, even if it's minor.

26. Adding a Rank Above Scratcher

DaSpudLord wrote:

Scratch is not a place for people to worry about ranks. The New Scratcher rank only exists to filter spam, and since it only takes 2 weeks to get a promotion, bullying and separation is minimal. Additionally, this would divide the community between those who have a high rank and those who have a low rank, and there would be lots of bragging and bullying coming from users of higher ranks.

15. Live editing

Paddle2See wrote:

I agree that it isn't something we can support right now, because of the moderation and technical issues, however I don't agree with the statement that it teaches bad collaboration techniques. Just because it isn't the way something is done now, or by most people, isn't always a good reason to reject it.

WolfCat67 wrote:

I agree with MathlyCat; please make the quotes in normal-size text. It wouldn't take up too much room.

Paddle2See wrote:

I'm not sure it's been officially rejected for all time. But so far I have not seen a good argument for putting one in that doesn't have issues of elitism. You might also note that we eliminated the Community Moderator rank, which was a rank “above” Scratcher.

stickfiregames wrote:

DaSpudLord's quote and topic used to justify listing it in the other sticky is a good and valid point, and I agree with it, but he doesn't have the authority to reject it.

The4thPixel wrote:

Thank you for making this, we needed it.

Digital_Gaming wrote:

Please don't make duplicates.

Digital_Gaming wrote:

Please don't make duplicates.

customhacker wrote:

I am aware that @jvvg has created one of these topics. I have asked him if I was allowed to take it over, and he gave me permission. I will be using his post to start off this list. He told me here.

Current:

Rejected Suggestions
1.WhateverTheSuggestionIsIForgot
2.DontLetYourMemesBeDreams

What I'm proposing

Rejected Suggestions
1. WhateverTheSuggestionIsIForgot