Scratch World’s “Register, Review, Reply”

Description: This is a program designed to help Scratchers get honest, constructive feedback, as well as getting their projects known by the community. In order to put your project up for review, simply comment in the thread with a link to your project. Shortly afterwards, a review for it will be posted in the topic thread, and you will get a message saying your project has been reviewed. Each week, I will select the most innovative and high-quality “proposed-to-be-reviewed” project to be put on the front post as “Scratch World’s Project of the Week.” At least 3 projects must be submitted for a project-of-the-week to be selected.

Application for Being a Reviewer: (NO LIMIT) —– submit responses in this thread. You will get 3 points for being accepted as a reviewer.
Reviewers should be somewhat active and be reviewing a project every one to two weeks. Based on quality, each reviewer will receive 1 to 10 points for each review they complete, and leaderboard will be made.
1. Username and number of projects shared:
2. How active are you?
3. How often will you be able to do a review?
4. What is your best project you have made?
5. Why do you want to be a reviewer?

Project Review Rubric:
1. Quality: ____/20
Here, describe how the gameplay/project went for you: was it smooth? Were there glitches? For example, a smooth game that had just a few minor glitches would score around a 17/20.

2. Creative Ideas/Originality: ____/15
Here, describe whether you thought the project was original and had new, interesting, and creative ideas. Originality means that this game is not a copy of other games: it must have unique features. However, originality would still count if it was inspired by another project, just not the exact copy. For example, a classic Pong game with only a couple of new features would score about a 5/15.

3. Addictiveness: _____/10
Here, describe whether the project wanted you to keep playing and whether you would play it again in the future. Also include how fun you thought the project was. Note: this score may vary due to individual tastes.

4. Scripting: _____/10
Here, describe the complexity of the project; for example, did it have multiple facets or just one straight plot? In addition, consider including comments on the innovative use of different kinds of scripting blocks – did it make good use of the “create your own block”, did it make good use of variables/lists, etc.

5. Bonus Effects: ______/10
Here, describe the sound and graphics of the project: was the graphics realistic and neat? Was the sound high quality; did it fit in with the “theme” of the project?

6. Usage: _____/5
Here, describe the easiness of learning the project. Were there tutorials in the project (or in the description) to help you? Were the control keys fine?

7. The Project Overall: _____/30
Here, share your overall experience with this project and include comments that did not fit in the previous 6 categories. Tell how you felt after playing the project and consider comments on how to improve.

TOTAL SCORE: ______/100

What does this score mean?
0-30: Needs quite a bit of work
31-59: Fair project, but much edits are needed
60-74: Decent quality project; great job overall
75-82: Very good project; only a little bit of work
83-94: One of the best project on Scratch!
95-100: Should be featured!!!

Thanks to everyone for reading; I appreciate your considering joining.

LEADERBOARDS:

REVIEWERS:
1) mathbrain

PROJECTS/STUDIOS TO BE REVIEWED
1) Wasteland
2) A Cube's Life

“SCRATCH WORLD'S PROJECT OF THE WEEK”

I would like my game “Wasteland” to be reviewed. I worked extremely hard on it for 4 months. Wasteland Link Please give it an honest review!

Updated!

Updated! More Reviews Needed…
Thank you!

It's been nearly a month and nothing has happened, are you sure you're ready to run this? If no one will sign up you should start by doing the jobs yourself, then people will trust you, and then people will start signing up and joining. Also, I'd rewrite your front page and make it at least 3 times shorter, it puts a lot of people off.

If you're still reviewing things, please review my game here:
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/11589335/
It's not finished yet, but I've worked really hard on it.