The Informal and Unofficial List of Rejected Suggestions

unisparks8

Maybe remove 10.8 because it's not suggested a lot.
Just an idea…

Za-Chary

Catscratcher07 wrote:
This was clearly a popular suggestion, so I will add it to the list. See 8.11. Do you think its current wording avoids implying a precedent that any new variant of a language would be rejected? I don't want to imply that something like Quebec French is rejected without sufficient precedent.

I think it's made clear enough. I'm no expert on Quebec French or France French, but from a cursory glance, I suspect @chrisg's statement would also apply to Quebec French (even if her post was originally on a thread about British English). I don't think there's any need to expand on that right now in the list, however.

bitmap_caketin

WigglyJoey wrote:
*snip*
The funniest thing is 8.11 used to be remove the membership, and the membership would have turned one year old today.

Wait, already?

WigglyJoey

bitmap_caketin wrote:
WigglyJoey wrote:
*snip*
The funniest thing is 8.11 used to be remove the membership, and the membership would have turned one year old today.
Wait, already?

Because the earliest topic about the membership when it actually came out was made that day.
More facts, this topic contained two important messages addressing the membership and I also replied there.

Last edited by WigglyJoey (Oct. 2, 2026 19:43:15)

CK840

I have a suggestion to improve the List of Rejected Suggestions. You could add a Table of Contents to the General Information section if you want. It could help others find whether their suggestion is rejected faster. For example, someone who is thinking about suggesting a “When stop clicked” hat block, could find the rejection faster if they see that section #1 is about Scratch blocks. Or someone who wants to suggest changing usernames can see that account related rejections are at 9. Account Information.

Table of Contents
Scratch Blocks
The Coding Interface
Scratch Projects
Project Pages
Studio Pages
Comments and Text Fields
Scratch Community
Scratch Website Features
Account Information
Discussion Forum Features
Discussion Forum Restrictions

WigglyJoey

Another Rejected Suggestion (It could be rewritten as using a specific name brand for a sprite)

medians

bitmap_caketin wrote:
Yes, I would remove the remix tree: I don't think that that was a rejection, more of an explanation of the removal.

If I remember correctly, they closed the topic asking for the button back, so IDK

DeathReviews

Catscratcher07 wrote:
2.5 Scratch editor for video game consoles
The Scratch Team does not have the resources to put a Scratch editor onto a video game console. This includes making a Scratch editor for any gaming console.

Idk… the grammar on that seems weird. I would do:

“This includes making a Scratch editor Xbox, Switch, PlayStation, Steam Deck, or any other console.”

Last edited by DeathReviews (Oct. 5, 2026 02:54:10)

medians

DeathReviews wrote:
Catscratcher07 wrote:
2.5 Scratch editor for video game consoles
The Scratch Team does not have the resources to put a Scratch editor onto a video game console. This includes making a Scratch editor for any gaming console.
Idk… the grammar on that seems weird. I would do:

“This includes making a Scratch editor Xbox, Switch, PlayStation, Steam Deck, or any other console.”

It seems fine to me, outside of the repetitiveness
Also, do you mean:

This includes making a Scratch editor for Xbox, Switch, Playstation, Steam Deck, or any other console.

Last edited by medians (Oct. 5, 2026 12:58:53)

bitmap_caketin

medians wrote:
bitmap_caketin wrote:
Yes, I would remove the remix tree: I don't think that that was a rejection, more of an explanation of the removal.
If I remember correctly, they closed the topic asking for the button back, so IDK

I was looking at the linked topic on the list when it was there but you could definitely be right.

medians

bitmap_caketin wrote:
medians wrote:
bitmap_caketin wrote:
Yes, I would remove the remix tree: I don't think that that was a rejection, more of an explanation of the removal.
If I remember correctly, they closed the topic asking for the button back, so IDK
I was looking at the linked topic on the list when it was there but you could definitely be right.

Yeah IDK why though bc the “rejection reason” made no sense since that wasn't a problem with the remix tree itself

Last edited by medians (Oct. 5, 2026 14:46:52)

Discuss Scratch