Discuss Scratch

revenget_
Scratcher
5 posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

So I think scratch should add a copyright button, so if it is enabled on a project, then you can remix the project, but not share it until the code, look, behavior or the backdrop has been changed.
scratchy_boy106
Scratcher
500+ posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

An option to toggle off remixing is rejected (I think it is)
Even if not, no support.
People might wanna add cool ideas to your projects!

Last edited by scratchy_boy106 (April 26, 2026 14:52:16)

mingo-gag
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

Projects on here are Copyleft, just use the report button if someone copies your project

Last edited by mingo-gag (April 26, 2026 14:53:55)

revenget_
Scratcher
5 posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

No I clearly stated “you can remix the project, but not share it until the code, look, behavior or the backdrop has been changed.” So it’s a similar, but different idea.
Martiniquetwins
Scratcher
100+ posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

Sorry, a copyright button can be easily rejected because it will disable remix.
So yeah, please don't add that or else how could I join the RALR community?
revenget_
Scratcher
5 posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

@MARTINIQUETWINS look at the 4th reply
scratchy_boy106
Scratcher
500+ posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

Martiniquetwins wrote:

Sorry, a copyright button can be easily rejected because it will disable remix.
So yeah, please don't add that or else how could I join the RALR community?
Look:

revenget_ wrote:

No I clearly stated “you can remix the project, but not share it until the code, look, behavior or the backdrop has been changed.” So it’s a similar, but different idea.
ZippyZebraZoom85749
Scratcher
100+ posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

According to post #4, this appears to be what you're looking for.

Last edited by ZippyZebraZoom85749 (April 26, 2026 15:06:04)

Martiniquetwins
Scratcher
100+ posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

scratchy_boy106 wrote:

Martiniquetwins wrote:

Sorry, a copyright button can be easily rejected because it will disable remix.
So yeah, please don't add that or else how could I join the RALR community?
Look:

revenget_ wrote:

No I clearly stated “you can remix the project, but not share it until the code, look, behavior or the backdrop has been changed.” So it’s a similar, but different idea.
Seen. My browser / operating system: MacOS Macintosh X 10.15.7, Safari 26.4, No Flash version detected
Scratch team simply license projects with copyleft or CCBYSA.
gdfsgdfsgdfg
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

whos gonna tell this scratcher?

scratch is foss
projects are also foss
d016
Scratcher
500+ posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

revenget_ wrote:

No I clearly stated “you can remix the project, but not share it until the code, look, behavior or the backdrop has been changed.” So it’s a similar, but different idea.
So you can only publish the remix if the something's different? That's already supposed to be the rule for remixes on Scratch. just Report any exact copies you see on the site!
HotDogYummy5
Scratcher
37 posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

I like this. It's technically not breaking the embrace remix culture guideline, if you can still remix but just you have to change things. I don't think Scratch Team would like this though. They are obsessed with the steal <—“remix” button.
HotDogYummy5
Scratcher
37 posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

d016 wrote:

revenget_ wrote:

No I clearly stated “you can remix the project, but not share it until the code, look, behavior or the backdrop has been changed.” So it’s a similar, but different idea.
So you can only publish the remix if the something's different? That's already supposed to be the rule for remixes on Scratch. just Report any exact copies you see on the site!

There is so many of them…
HotDogYummy5
Scratcher
37 posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

HotDogYummy5 wrote:

I like this. It's technically not breaking the embrace remix culture guideline, if you can still remix but just you have to change things. I don't think Scratch Team would like this though. They are obsessed with the steal <—“remix” button.

I FEEL LIKE UNDER THE "EMBRACE REMIX CULTURE THEY WOULD HAVE INTENDED FOR US TO DO IT OURSELVES

As d016 said:

d016 wrote:

revenget_ wrote:

No I clearly stated “you can remix the project, but not share it until the code, look, behavior or the backdrop has been changed.” So it’s a similar, but different idea.
So you can only publish the remix if the something's different? That's already supposed to be the rule for remixes on Scratch. just Report any exact copies you see on the site!
I_wantasheep
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

similar but not exactly-the-same topic: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/39464/
plum_the_fox
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

by agreeing to the ToS you agree to let people use your stuff

Last edited by plum_the_fox (April 26, 2026 21:07:44)

LittleGreyCells
Scratch Team
1000+ posts

A COPYRIGHT BUTTON!!!

Closing as this is rejected since we won't disable remixing, even for an exact copy. Sharing exact copies is already against our guidelines, so please use the report button if you see them.

Powered by DjangoBB