Reply to comments in messages

unisparks8

IDEA: What if you could reply to comments INSIDE their messages page. I feel like this could be useful, especially with Scratch being laggy and crashing so much. And it saves time from having to go from link to link of comments someone posted.
Thanks for reading!!

marinmilaqi

thats a great idea, support, what if this is not limited to comments, but also curator invites

ChristianScratcher1

Sem-Support cuz context matters since you'll get notifications from someone replying to someone else if its on your profile or project

unisparks8

ChristianScratcher1 wrote:
Sem-Support cuz context matters since you'll get notifications from someone replying to someone else if its on your profile or project

There's just the normal reply button by it and it opens a thing where you reply.

RedBreck

Yes this would be so nice

unisparks8

Bump

BitcoinFarmer

But if somebody replied to you in a comment chain you might need to see previous comments.

unisparks8

BitcoinFarmer wrote:
But if somebody replied to you in a comment chain you might need to see previous comments.

You could click the link. This is mainly for quick replies.

nembence

I think it should show the comment chain when you click on the reply button.

unisparks8

nembence wrote:
I think it should show the comment chain when you click on the reply button.

Maybe. Maybe a separate button for that.

Michael_M_Games

Support, this would give us way less pages to load!

unisparks8

Michael_M_Games wrote:
Support, this would give us way less pages to load!

Yes absolutely

unisparks8

Bump

unisparks8

unisparks8 wrote:
Bump

HunterRedmond

I don't understand what you mean.

unisparks8

HunterRedmond wrote:
I don't understand what you mean.

You could reply to comments on your profile or project in the messages page

HunterRedmond

unisparks8 wrote:
HunterRedmond wrote:
I don't understand what you mean.
You could reply to comments on your profile or project in the messages page

Oh. I think that's a bit too social-media-ish for my liking.

unisparks8

HunterRedmond wrote:
unisparks8 wrote:
HunterRedmond wrote:
I don't understand what you mean.
You could reply to comments on your profile or project in the messages page

Oh. I think that's a bit too social-media-ish for my liking.

Doesn't save time from having to click comment to comment in messages though?

HunterRedmond

unisparks8 wrote:
HunterRedmond wrote:
unisparks8 wrote:
HunterRedmond wrote:
I don't understand what you mean.
You could reply to comments on your profile or project in the messages page

Oh. I think that's a bit too social-media-ish for my liking.
Doesn't save time from having to click comment to comment in messages though?

… I think the inconvenience is a good thing.

SMG4fan7236

No support.
I had a reply here saying semi-support but I removed it because I no longer agree with this. I think there might be spam that can be seen even after the comment is taken down, as well as inappropriate content. While it does show the first few letters, I think this should be reduced to a link that says “View Comment”, similar to remixes in the current system. Your proposed system only increases that risk.

Discuss Scratch