Do NOT add AI to Scratch — #NoAIOnScratch

The21stNumber

ilIusionator wrote:
scampton_the_great wrote:
5_hours_later wrote:
100 pages of people either agreeing or disagreeing about the Ai on Scratch. Wow.
welcome to suggestions
where none of the ideas stated there have been implemented since “change new to scratch to new scratcher on forums”

so true unfortunately

cambegonefr

StarFutureFox wrote:
kip22s wrote:
GNARPY34561 wrote:
kip22s wrote:
the ‘'Unfollow Discussion’' button looks off on here…
Bro get out, you keep saying off topic things, your obviously just here to troll get out mate-
No, I don't keep saying off-topic things, that's an overestimation, get out
Actually you do, please leave. Some random thing about the unfollow discussion button is not at all related to AI on Scratch, please actually reread your own comments before wrongly declaring that nothing you said was unrelated (sorry if that sounded mean TwT)

Can we not tell other users to leave? They're not saying anything wrong and it's always okay to have more users participate in our discussions.

Gaehivian_Karen

100% agree, we should not have AI on Scratch. It'll remove the ability for people to think for themselves and put actual effort into things.

A_gamer_not_A_CODeR7

cambegonefr wrote:
StarFutureFox wrote:
-snipping occurred here-

Actually you do, please leave. Some random thing about the unfollow discussion button is not at all related to AI on Scratch, please actually reread your own comments before wrongly declaring that nothing you said was unrelated (sorry if that sounded mean TwT)
Can we not tell other users to leave? They're not saying anything wrong and it's always okay to have more users participate in our discussions.

I get what you’re saying, and I don’t think they have to leave, but they are saying off topic things a lot, then trying to defend it when being called out. I don’t want to make anyone leave, but it’s seriously starting to get annoying.

Last edited by A_gamer_not_A_CODeR7 (Jan. 29, 2026 13:59:07)

BitcoinFarmer

The21stNumber wrote:
GreenFox701 wrote:
WHY! (I HATE AI) WHY!!!!
Because, why would the big corporations care about their user base and what they think? It makes them money!

Scratch is a nonprofit not a corporation.

Ever noticed any ads here?

No because scratch is not a corporation.

cambegonefr

A_gamer_not_A_CODeR7 wrote:
cambegonefr wrote:
Can we not tell other users to leave? They're not saying anything wrong and it's always okay to have more users participate in our discussions.
I get what you’re saying, and I don’t think they have to leave, but they are saying off topic things a lot, then trying to defend it when being called out. I don’t want to make anyone leave, but it’s seriously starting to get annoying.

I agree, off-topic discussion is why the topic got closed originally.

GreenFox701

The21stNumber wrote:
GreenFox701 wrote:
WHY! (I HATE AI) WHY!!!!
Because, why would the big corporations care about their user base and what they think? It makes them money!

Ig but Scratch Loves Their Followers and Users so idus

Gaehivian_Karen

A_gamer_not_A_CODeR7 wrote:
cambegonefr wrote:
StarFutureFox wrote:
-snipping occurred here-

Actually you do, please leave. Some random thing about the unfollow discussion button is not at all related to AI on Scratch, please actually reread your own comments before wrongly declaring that nothing you said was unrelated (sorry if that sounded mean TwT)
Can we not tell other users to leave? They're not saying anything wrong and it's always okay to have more users participate in our discussions.

I get what you’re saying, and I don’t think they have to leave, but they are saying off topic things a lot, then trying to defend it when being called out. I don’t want to make anyone leave, but it’s seriously starting to get annoying.

Yeah it's really starting to get annoying how off-topic they are

The21stNumber

BitcoinFarmer wrote:
The21stNumber wrote:
GreenFox701 wrote:
WHY! (I HATE AI) WHY!!!!
Because, why would the big corporations care about their user base and what they think? It makes them money!
Scratch is a nonprofit not a corporation.

Ever noticed any ads here?

No because scratch is not a corporation.

they added a membership. I meant to compare the similarities.

Last edited by The21stNumber (Jan. 29, 2026 14:35:18)

The21stNumber

GreenFox701 wrote:
The21stNumber wrote:
GreenFox701 wrote:
WHY! (I HATE AI) WHY!!!!
Because, why would the big corporations care about their user base and what they think? It makes them money!
Ig but Scratch Loves Their Followers and Users so idus

Yeah, they usually do. But they usually have paid attention to the people who are saying things about stuff. This time they really haven't

Gaehivian_Karen

The21stNumber wrote:
GreenFox701 wrote:
The21stNumber wrote:
GreenFox701 wrote:
WHY! (I HATE AI) WHY!!!!
Because, why would the big corporations care about their user base and what they think? It makes them money!
Ig but Scratch Loves Their Followers and Users so idus
Yeah, they usually do. But they usually have paid attention to the people who are saying things about stuff. This time they really haven't

Yeah it feels like they're starting to abandon their userbase in favor of money.

kip22s

A_gamer_not_A_CODeR7 wrote:
cambegonefr wrote:
StarFutureFox wrote:
-snipping occurred here-

Actually you do, please leave. Some random thing about the unfollow discussion button is not at all related to AI on Scratch, please actually reread your own comments before wrongly declaring that nothing you said was unrelated (sorry if that sounded mean TwT)

I get what you’re saying, and I don’t think they have to leave, but they are saying off topic things a lot, then trying to defend it when being called out. I don’t want to make anyone leave, but it’s seriously starting to get annoying.

Once again, it's one post, being so selective about it like as if you're a moderator, this observation of mine is more unrelated than dozens of other people. These replies show how much someone is biased and blind to blockspam, but have some beef and picture themselves as a savior, wasting their own life to ragebait and contradict themselves, this is what I expect from Scratchers that have two-month old accounts, doing nothing to actual spam, spam themselves, and break the CGs themselves, like the ‘'Lion VS Lion’' meme, where both sides are thinking they're the ragebaiter when they're just screaming, you make more spam about this than any other thing, I was actually being on-topic, but yet again, you have to get your attention.

kip22s

GreenFox701 wrote:
WHY! (I HATE AI) WHY!!!!

abab231478 wrote:
Dont add AI to scratch, not now, nor the future.
say [Dont add AI]

This isn't considered spam, the duality of man.
————————————————————-
Anyways, what are some good points supporting this?

ilIusionator

kip22s wrote:
GreenFox701 wrote:
WHY! (I HATE AI) WHY!!!!
abab231478 wrote:
Dont add AI to scratch, not now, nor the future.
say [Dont add AI]
This isn't considered spam, the duality of man.
————————————————————-
Anyways, what are some good points supporting this?

none.
this topic has run out dry, there are no more constructive posts and it's all spam.

Socool438 wrote:
I DO NOT LIKEE AI :mad::mad::mad::mad::mad:

see what i mean

Last edited by ilIusionator (Jan. 29, 2026 16:26:38)

Socool438

I DO NOT LIKEE AI

Exascerbescence

ilIusionator wrote:
kip22s wrote:
GreenFox701 wrote:
WHY! (I HATE AI) WHY!!!!
abab231478 wrote:
Dont add AI to scratch, not now, nor the future.
say [Dont add AI]
This isn't considered spam, the duality of man.
————————————————————-
Anyways, what are some good points supporting this?
none.
this topic has run out dry, there are no more constructive posts and it's all spam.

Exascerbescence wrote:
I’m still yet to see anyone else talk about BitcoinFarmer’s essay

One other person has addressed their counterarguments so far.

ilIusionator

Exascerbescence wrote:
ilIusionator wrote:
kip22s wrote:
GreenFox701 wrote:
WHY! (I HATE AI) WHY!!!!
abab231478 wrote:
Dont add AI to scratch, not now, nor the future.
say [Dont add AI]
This isn't considered spam, the duality of man.
————————————————————-
Anyways, what are some good points supporting this?
none.
this topic has run out dry, there are no more constructive posts and it's all spam.
Exascerbescence wrote:
I’m still yet to see anyone else talk about BitcoinFarmer’s essay
One other person has addressed their counterarguments so far.

and it all gets forgotten because of these spam posts
Everybody on this topic hates AI because everybody else does.

and since scratch is a platform for kids, they hop on the bandwagon for no real reason

WormChow

ilIusionator wrote:
Everybody on this topic hates AI because everybody else does.

and since scratch is a platform for kids, they hop on the bandwagon for no real reason

Heyyy that's not fair to the hundreds of us who have good reasons for disliking the CLA

kip22s

ilIusionator wrote:
Exascerbescence wrote:
ilIusionator wrote:
kip22s wrote:
GreenFox701 wrote:
WHY! (I HATE AI) WHY!!!!
abab231478 wrote:
Dont add AI to scratch, not now, nor the future.
say [Dont add AI]
Everybody on this topic hates AI because everybody else does.

and since scratch is a platform for kids, they hop on the bandwagon for no real reason
That's not true, that's an overgeneralization, a lot of users aren't really kids. Hopping on the bandwagon like the Scratch Foundation

kip22s

kip22s wrote:
I wonder how much of RAM a browser will use when the CLA is added

And if opt-out (if that gets added) will make it still run in the background.

Discuss Scratch