The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

The-Sushi-Cat

Maybe you should add, “Showing/censor bad words” or whatever (I can't think of a better way to word it, I'm very tired- it's 4:30 am lol-) to the list at section 6

Actual rejection message: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/798092/?page=2#post-8330655
Paddle confirming that rejection: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/822526/?page=1#post-8554785
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/809490/?page=1#post-8428658
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/352321/
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/810998/?page=1#post-8443278

Only two of these are closed as rejected, but this seems like a popular suggestion (there's even one more that I made! However, it has my old username in it lol- it just weirds me out a bit to know tons of people would be looking at it)

Last edited by The-Sushi-Cat (May 18, 2025 10:34:00)

acohen_bhusd

add this as a solution for changing usernames

Catscratcher07

acohen_bhusd wrote:
add this as a solution for changing usernames

Without any ST input, it is impossible to tell if this is considered a valid solution or if it has just not been seen yet.

supermonsterkids

Scratch Team,
Is it possible to add some extensions from TurboWarp? Scratch and TurboWarp are both coded with JavaScript, so is this possible? P.S. If you can and if it's not too much work, could you add some like Lily's Toolbox, List Tools, and Key Simulation? (If you are the scratch team and you read this could you please reply to this message so I can know)

lfg30700

supermonsterkids wrote:
Scratch Team,
Is it possible to add some extensions from TurboWarp? Scratch and TurboWarp are both coded with JavaScript, so is this possible? P.S. If you can and if it's not too much work, could you add some like Lily's Toolbox, List Tools, and Key Simulation? (If you are the scratch team and you read this could you please reply to this message so I can know)

The best idea would be to make your own topic, as nobody is going to care here because it's irrelevant to what we're talking about.

supermonsterkids

lfg30700 wrote:
supermonsterkids wrote:
Scratch Team,
Is it possible to add some extensions from TurboWarp? Scratch and TurboWarp are both coded with JavaScript, so is this possible? P.S. If you can and if it's not too much work, could you add some like Lily's Toolbox, List Tools, and Key Simulation? (If you are the scratch team and you read this could you please reply to this message so I can know)
The best idea would be to make your own topic, as nobody is going to care here because it's irrelevant to what we're talking about.

Oh ok thanks, i kind of got confused because it was talking about scratch suggestions

jmb1293634

supermonsterkids wrote:
lfg30700 wrote:
supermonsterkids wrote:
Scratch Team,
Is it possible to add some extensions from TurboWarp? Scratch and TurboWarp are both coded with JavaScript, so is this possible? P.S. If you can and if it's not too much work, could you add some like Lily's Toolbox, List Tools, and Key Simulation? (If you are the scratch team and you read this could you please reply to this message so I can know)
The best idea would be to make your own topic, as nobody is going to care here because it's irrelevant to what we're talking about.
Oh ok thanks, i kind of got confused because it was talking about scratch suggestions

it says:

Za-Chary wrote:
PLEASE DO NOT SUGGEST THINGS HERE!
I am not a member of the Scratch Team; your suggestion will get more attention if you make your own topic about it. Also, please do not spam or create off-topic posts, or else they may be deleted.

Last edited by jmb1293634 (May 19, 2025 16:52:57)

securitytower

You could fix 6.3 by doing one notification per minute maybe?

Last edited by securitytower (May 23, 2025 11:42:38)

Catscratcher07

securitytower wrote:
You could fix 6.3 by doing one notification per minute maybe?

One notification per minute is still a lot, maybe at one per day we could consider said solution.

acohen_bhusd

King of the Page

one solution for 6.3 in the list is that if there are multiple mentions that have your username then only one notification is sent explaining that the user was mentioned

Last edited by acohen_bhusd (May 23, 2025 17:13:04)

Za-Chary

ametrine_ wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
What does “remix message” refer to?
i'm assuming they're talking about the change made to the remix notification

What change was made?

The-Sushi-Cat wrote:
Maybe you should add, “Showing/censor bad words” or whatever (I can't think of a better way to word it, I'm very tired- it's 4:30 am lol-) to the list at section 6

Actual rejection message: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/798092/?page=2#post-8330655
Paddle confirming that rejection: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/822526/?page=1#post-8554785
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/809490/?page=1#post-8428658
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/352321/
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/810998/?page=1#post-8443278

Only two of these are closed as rejected, but this seems like a popular suggestion (there's even one more that I made! However, it has my old username in it lol- it just weirds me out a bit to know tons of people would be looking at it)

Thanks! I know this one's a popular suggestion, so I added it to the list. See 6.5; I'm open to changing the name. Let me know if the description looks okay; while the Scratch Team member quotes above don't explain much about why this is rejected, I believe I gave reasoning based on what the Scratch Team would likely agree with.

Catscratcher07 wrote:
acohen_bhusd wrote:
add this as a solution for changing usernames
Without any ST input, it is impossible to tell if this is considered a valid solution or if it has just not been seen yet.

Yeah, I think I'll agree with you on that. I'm still not sure how this suggestion does not involve “changing display names.”

KingDrover

Za-Chary wrote:
ametrine_ wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
What does “remix message” refer to?
i'm assuming they're talking about the change made to the remix notification
What change was made?

Basically, when someone remixes your project, the notification will have a link to it saying “Check out the remix!” instead of actually showing the title like it used to. I think it was implemented because of trolls remixing projects and giving them inappropriate titles

acohen_bhusd

Za-Chary wrote:
ametrine_ wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
What does “remix message” refer to?
i'm assuming they're talking about the change made to the remix notification
What change was made?

now it says “check out the remix” instead

Blue_Retro_Dragon

Za-Chary wrote:
(#9742)
ametrine_ wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
What does “remix message” refer to?
i'm assuming they're talking about the change made to the remix notification
What change was made?

The wording of the remix notification got changed to: (Username) remixed your project (Project-Name). Check out the remix!"

I believe this was because of trolls and remix spammers changing the title inappropriately, so now the remixed project titles don't appear.

ninja'd

Last edited by Blue_Retro_Dragon (May 23, 2025 18:36:39)

ExcitedDuckVienna

For the 3D scratch thing, why not use this block as an example like all the other ones:

set z to () ::motion

(use “set z to () ::motion” to recreate.)

Last edited by ExcitedDuckVienna (May 24, 2025 15:21:19)

Poptart-Princess

za-chary wrote:
they may confuse users by having them wonder where the mouse pointer went.

this was way funnier to me than it was probably supposed to be

MattCatt8188

“turn cw (15) degrees”

acohen_bhusd

MattCatt8188 wrote:
“turn cw (15) degrees”

also turn ccw

tagrim123

This was recently rejected. First time i've seen it happen

.

Create-Scratch101

tagrim123 wrote:
This was recently rejected. First time i've seen it happen .

Not closed, not rejected.

Discuss Scratch