Discuss Scratch

AU-Ratcatcher
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

It’s ridiculous that Hazbin Hotel is banned on Scratch when there are PLENTY of other extremely inappropriate/violent shows/movies that are allowed on Scratch. Examples: Invincible, Deadpool, South Park.

The best example would be The Boys. INCREDIBLY graphic in terms of violent and inappropriate content.
Look, banning Hazbin Hotel makes sense, but only if you ban the other inappropriate stuff. Instead it just comes off as weird and dumb.
Follow your own rules that you set, Scratch.

And actually deal with this problem instead of closing this topic or brushing aside my argument.
AU-Ratcatcher
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

It’s ridiculous that Hazbin Hotel is banned on Scratch when there are PLENTY of other extremely inappropriate/violent shows/movies that are allowed on Scratch. Examples: Invincible, Deadpool, South Park.

The best example would be The Boys. INCREDIBLY graphic in terms of violent and inappropriate content.
Look, banning Hazbin Hotel makes sense, but only if you ban the other inappropriate stuff. Instead it just comes off as weird and dumb.
Follow your own rules that you set, Scratch.

And actually deal with this problem instead of closing this topic or brushing aside my argument.
And no, I won’t stop until this issue is actually addressed.
Scratch--TheCat
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

According to 3.3 of the Official List of Rejected Suggestions, the Scratch Team bans certain franchises only if a lot of inappropriate projects of it were made and shared on Scratch.

Za-Chary wrote:

3.3 Ban certain franchises
Generally, the Scratch Team does not censor projects based on a certain franchise unless a large number of inappropriate projects were made with the franchise. An example is Five Nights at Freddy's; see this announcement for more information. In general, it is usually possible to make appropriate projects based on a certain franchise. Of course, you should always report inappropriate projects of any kind.

HH is banned due to this reason, and the other inappropriate franchises mentioned in your post weren't because not a lot of inappropriate projects were made and shared on this website.

Last edited by Scratch--TheCat (Sept. 14, 2024 20:52:08)

AU-Ratcatcher
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

Scratch--TheCat wrote:

According to 3.3 of the Official List of Rejected Suggestions, the Scratch Team bans certain franchises only if a lot of inappropriate projects of it were made and shared on Scratch.
HH is banned due to this reason, and the other inappropriate franchises mentioned in your post weren't because not a lot of inappropriate projects were made and shared on this website.
You can make inappropriate projects for literally anything.
Having a normal, appropriate Hazbin pfp and it get taken down is just weird
Scratch_Cat_Coder8
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

Ignore this comment. After reading one of the replies I’m confused now

Last edited by Scratch_Cat_Coder8 (Sept. 14, 2024 20:49:59)

Scratch--TheCat
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

You can make inappropriate projects for literally anything.
Like I said, the Scratch Team will ban those franchises only if a lot of inappropriate projects were made of it [this also applies to any other franchise].
AU-Ratcatcher
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

Scratch--TheCat wrote:

AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

You can make inappropriate projects for literally anything.
Like I said, the Scratch Team will ban those franchises only if a lot of inappropriate projects were made of it [this also applies to any other franchise].
That’s insane. There’s been plenty of violent projects made about Deadpool. Deadpool’s still allowed.
Scratch_Cat_Coder8
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

Scratch--TheCat wrote:

According to 3.3 of the Official List of Rejected Suggestions, the Scratch Team bans certain franchises only if a lot of inappropriate projects of it were made and shared on Scratch.
HH is banned due to this reason, and the other inappropriate franchises mentioned in your post weren't because not a lot of inappropriate projects were made and shared on this website.
You can make inappropriate projects for literally anything.
Having a normal, appropriate Hazbin pfp and it get taken down is just weird
okay so first your attitude towards this topic is a getting a little rotten and rude second of all it is a BANNED topic. Just because it’s innocent doesn’t mean it will stay up. Scratch team is REALLY strict about their rules and want the website to be all ages so when something is banned. It’s banned. It’s not coming back. Also I think scratch only bans topics if it has questionable topics that don’t involve murder (which isn’t okay and is kinda shady)

Last edited by Scratch_Cat_Coder8 (Sept. 15, 2024 00:34:07)

AU-Ratcatcher
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

Okay, but why is the song Rabbit Hole not banned? Really popular and really inappropriate.
AU-Ratcatcher
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

Also… there are still plenty of Hazbin projects on Scratch, and I haven’t seen a single inappropriate one
Jeffalo
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

the scratch team removes any inappropriate content. similarly, they sometimes remove references to inappropriate content (even if the reference itself is fine)

im not a scratch team member, but my understanding is that if the content is niche enough (like the show you mentioned), references to the inappropriate content are inherently problematic. if the content is extremely well known, it’s likely okay to reference (such as Deadpool) as it’s hard to imagine people are unfamiliar with it. and if the content is so niche that the scratch team is unaware of it, references may slip through the cracks.

the scratch team reviews stuff on a case by case basis.

Last edited by Jeffalo (Sept. 14, 2024 20:56:24)

Scratch_Cat_Coder8
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

Okay, but why is the song Rabbit Hole not banned? Really popular and really inappropriate.
Scratch team probably doesn’t know the lyrics (and I don’t think the song users do either )
AU-Ratcatcher
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

Also… there are still plenty of Hazbin projects on Scratch, and I haven’t seen a single inappropriate one
I apologize if my attitude is coming across as rude, but I’m confused and slightly annoyed
Scratch_Cat_Coder8
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

Also… there are still plenty of Hazbin projects on Scratch, and I haven’t seen a single inappropriate one
they were banned… what else do you think ST will do? keep them up and expose the little kiddies? NO!
Lionwarriorspets
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

Scratch_Cat_Coder8 wrote:

AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

Scratch--TheCat wrote:

According to 3.3 of the Official List of Rejected Suggestions, the Scratch Team bans certain franchises only if a lot of inappropriate projects of it were made and shared on Scratch.
HH is banned due to this reason, and the other inappropriate franchises mentioned in your post weren't because not a lot of inappropriate projects were made and shared on this website.
You can make inappropriate projects for literally anything.
Having a normal, appropriate Hazbin pfp and it get taken down is just weird
okay so first your attitude towards this topic is a getting a little rotten and rude second of all it is a BANNED topic. Just because it’s innocent doesn’t mean it will stay up. Scratch team is REALLY strict about their rules and want the website to be all ages so when something is banned. It’s banned. It’s not coming back. But also there are some games like changed (f**tish game) and multiple… questionable studios and games have been made on scratch yet it hasn’t been banned. Also I think scratch only bans topics if it has questionable topics that don’t involve murder (which isn’t okay and is kinda shady)
CHANGED HAS BEEN BANNED. Because they said it to me in contact us ages ago. And took my latexbeast account down.

Last edited by Lionwarriorspets (Sept. 15, 2024 00:32:54)

Scratch_Cat_Coder8
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

Lionwarriorspets wrote:

Scratch_Cat_Coder8 wrote:

AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

Scratch--TheCat wrote:

According to 3.3 of the Official List of Rejected Suggestions, the Scratch Team bans certain franchises only if a lot of inappropriate projects of it were made and shared on Scratch.
HH is banned due to this reason, and the other inappropriate franchises mentioned in your post weren't because not a lot of inappropriate projects were made and shared on this website.
You can make inappropriate projects for literally anything.
Having a normal, appropriate Hazbin pfp and it get taken down is just weird
okay so first your attitude towards this topic is a getting a little rotten and rude second of all it is a BANNED topic. Just because it’s innocent doesn’t mean it will stay up. Scratch team is REALLY strict about their rules and want the website to be all ages so when something is banned. It’s banned. It’s not coming back. But also there are some games like changed (f**tish game) and multiple… questionable studios and games have been made on scratch yet it hasn’t been banned. Also I think scratch only bans topics if it has questionable topics that don’t involve murder (which isn’t okay and is kinda shady)
CHANGED HAS BEEN BANNED. Because they said it to me in contact us ages ago. And took my latexbeast account down.
Oh.
Lionwarriorspets
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

Scratch_Cat_Coder8 wrote:

Lionwarriorspets wrote:

Scratch_Cat_Coder8 wrote:

AU-Ratcatcher wrote:

Scratch--TheCat wrote:

According to 3.3 of the Official List of Rejected Suggestions, the Scratch Team bans certain franchises only if a lot of inappropriate projects of it were made and shared on Scratch.
HH is banned due to this reason, and the other inappropriate franchises mentioned in your post weren't because not a lot of inappropriate projects were made and shared on this website.
You can make inappropriate projects for literally anything.
Having a normal, appropriate Hazbin pfp and it get taken down is just weird
okay so first your attitude towards this topic is a getting a little rotten and rude second of all it is a BANNED topic. Just because it’s innocent doesn’t mean it will stay up. Scratch team is REALLY strict about their rules and want the website to be all ages so when something is banned. It’s banned. It’s not coming back. But also there are some games like changed (f**tish game) and multiple… questionable studios and games have been made on scratch yet it hasn’t been banned. Also I think scratch only bans topics if it has questionable topics that don’t involve murder (which isn’t okay and is kinda shady)
CHANGED HAS BEEN BANNED. Because they said it to me in contact us ages ago. And took my latexbeast account down.
Oh.
Its just not as high priority as Hazbin ig.
cosmosaura
Scratch Team
1000+ posts

Incredibly questionable NFE choices…

I'm afraid this isn't a good fit for the forum. Before making a topic, please check the “sticky” topics (indicated by a pin icon) for information about what goes in each forum. Thanks!

Powered by DjangoBB