I feel like Scratch should send you a notification if someone sees your project or adds it to a studio.

Cedarsfajrb

What I feel is that when someone adds your project to a studio (Like they did to mine) then you should get a notification.
First, it is your own project so you have to right to see when someone views it or adds it to a studio.
Second, I'm having to keep going on my project to check for new views or studios so it's getting kinda annoying.
And finally, it'll be interesting to see who viewed your project or added it to a studio.
I hope this will be listened to.

Have a nice day!

MagicCoder330

Cedarsfajrb wrote:
What I feel is that when someone adds your project to a studio (Like they did to mine) then you should get a notification.
First, it is your own project so you have to right to see when someone views it or adds it to a studio.
Second, I'm having to keep going on my project to check for new views or studios so it's getting kinda annoying.
And finally, it'll be interesting to see who viewed your project or added it to a studio.
I hope this will be listened to.

Have a nice day!

1. rejected
2. I think it's a dupe but Ocular is down

Cedarsfajrb

MagicCoder330 wrote:
Cedarsfajrb wrote:
What I feel is that when someone adds your project to a studio (Like they did to mine) then you should get a notification.
First, it is your own project so you have to right to see when someone views it or adds it to a studio.
Second, I'm having to keep going on my project to check for new views or studios so it's getting kinda annoying.
And finally, it'll be interesting to see who viewed your project or added it to a studio.
I hope this will be listened to.

Have a nice day!
1. rejected
2. I think it's a dupe but Ocular is down

It's rejected by the Scratch team??
Idk anything this is my first topic.

gem1001

Cedarsfajrb wrote:
MagicCoder330 wrote:
Cedarsfajrb wrote:
What I feel is that when someone adds your project to a studio (Like they did to mine) then you should get a notification.
First, it is your own project so you have to right to see when someone views it or adds it to a studio.
Second, I'm having to keep going on my project to check for new views or studios so it's getting kinda annoying.
And finally, it'll be interesting to see who viewed your project or added it to a studio.
I hope this will be listened to.

Have a nice day!
1. rejected
2. I think it's a dupe but Ocular is down
It's rejected by the Scratch team??
Idk anything this is my first topic.

Getting a message when someone views it is, so people can't go after people who view a project but don't love/favourite it.

Cedarsfajrb

gem1001 wrote:
Cedarsfajrb wrote:
MagicCoder330 wrote:
Cedarsfajrb wrote:
What I feel is that when someone adds your project to a studio (Like they did to mine) then you should get a notification.
First, it is your own project so you have to right to see when someone views it or adds it to a studio.
Second, I'm having to keep going on my project to check for new views or studios so it's getting kinda annoying.
And finally, it'll be interesting to see who viewed your project or added it to a studio.
I hope this will be listened to.

Have a nice day!
1. rejected
2. I think it's a dupe but Ocular is down
It's rejected by the Scratch team??
Idk anything this is my first topic.
Getting a message when someone views it is, so people can't go after people who view a project but don't love/favourite it.

show variable [Oh yeah they can go after those people. But I'm thinking of it saying like: 'You have a new view!' v]

starlightsparker

Cedarsfajrb wrote:
gem1001 wrote:
Cedarsfajrb wrote:
MagicCoder330 wrote:
Cedarsfajrb wrote:
What I feel is that when someone adds your project to a studio (Like they did to mine) then you should get a notification.
First, it is your own project so you have to right to see when someone views it or adds it to a studio.
Second, I'm having to keep going on my project to check for new views or studios so it's getting kinda annoying.
And finally, it'll be interesting to see who viewed your project or added it to a studio.
I hope this will be listened to.

Have a nice day!
1. rejected
2. I think it's a dupe but Ocular is down
It's rejected by the Scratch team??
Idk anything this is my first topic.
Getting a message when someone views it is, so people can't go after people who view a project but don't love/favourite it.
show variable [Oh yeah they can go after those people. But I'm thinking of it saying like: 'You have a new view!' v]

show variable [ that’s not really a solution to the rejection.v]

qwertyy_the_artist

even if this wasn't rejected, i would not support this suggestion

every few minutes i would receive more annoying messages that are drowning out the ones actually worth reading, like replies or new comments.
if someone's project was featured, the poor chap would log on to scratch one day and find 6,000-450,000+ messages in their inbox.
i do not need to know when someone views my project

MythosLore

starlightsparker wrote:

show variable [ that’s not really a solution to the rejection.v]

Yes it is; if it doesn't tell you who viewed the project, it just tells you that someone viewed it (“You got a new view!”), then it's not rejected.

Nobody bothered to link the list that explains exactly why suggestions are rejected, so you wouldn't have seen this, but it's the ability to see who viewed the topic that's rejected:

Za-Chary wrote:
4.3 Ability to see who viewed a project
Views are different from loves and favorites in that users can view a project to see if they like it, and then love or favorite the project if they do like it. With this suggestion, drama could be started if a user sees that another user viewed a project, but did not love or favorite it. Moreover, projects generally get significantly more views than loves, favorites, or comments, so if users got notifications for this, it would lead to lots of unwanted messages. Despite all this, there is a workaround for this which uses cloud variables, so one could potentially see who viewed a project. This includes the ability to see who viewed a comment, profile, studio, or forum post.

Last edited by MythosLore (June 15, 2024 12:44:22)

julmik6478

starlightsparker wrote:
Cedarsfajrb wrote:
gem1001 wrote:
Cedarsfajrb wrote:
MagicCoder330 wrote:
Cedarsfajrb wrote:
What I feel is that when someone adds your project to a studio (Like they did to mine) then you should get a notification.
First, it is your own project so you have to right to see when someone views it or adds it to a studio.
Second, I'm having to keep going on my project to check for new views or studios so it's getting kinda annoying.
And finally, it'll be interesting to see who viewed your project or added it to a studio.
I hope this will be listened to.

Have a nice day!
1. rejected
2. I think it's a dupe but Ocular is down
It's rejected by the Scratch team??
Idk anything this is my first topic.
Getting a message when someone views it is, so people can't go after people who view a project but don't love/favourite it.
show variable [Oh yeah they can go after those people. But I'm thinking of it saying like: 'You have a new view!' v]
show variable [ that’s not really a solution to the rejection.v]

show variable [bad input type v]

BACK8543

Bump cause dupe

StefanLovesAlphabets

BACK8543 wrote:
Bump cause dupe

No it isn't, but still I do want this to happen

VedanshS933

Please do not make a list of suggestions.
This would make the dupe not dupe but the decision is the ST’s.

IGNITEstudios

Why would I want a notification every time someone views my project? Why would I care? If it's not a social action like a comment I don't have anything to reply with.

That's also too many notifications in my opinion

Kiyan_LiftFan

Cedarsfajrb wrote:
What I feel is that when someone adds your project to a studio (Like they did to mine) then you should get a notification.

I don’t think this is a good idea. If you get thousands of people to view your project and get notified for every single one of them, it’ll get to a point where you can’t view your inbox due to server lag. Plus, more important notifications (like someone commenting on your profile or asking a question on your forum topic) will get buried.

Cedarsfajrb wrote:
First, it is your own project so you have to right to see when someone views it or adds it to a studio.

Again, no support for the aforementioned reasons. I believe you can already get notified when someone adds your project to a studio, correct me if I’m wrong though.

Cedarsfajrb wrote:
And finally, it'll be interesting to see who viewed your project or added it to a studio.

This has been rejected.

4.3 Ability to see who viewed a project
Views are different from loves and favorites in that users can view a project to see if they like it, and then love or favorite the project if they do like it. With this suggestion, drama could be started if a user sees that another user viewed a project, but did not love or favorite it. Moreover, projects generally get significantly more views than loves, favorites, or comments, so if users got notifications for this, it would lead to lots of unwanted messages. Despite all this, there is a workaround for this which uses cloud variables, so one could potentially see who viewed a project. This includes the ability to see who viewed a comment, profile, studio, or forum post.

Paddle2See

Please create a separate topic for each suggestion you have, rather than creating a list of suggestions. That way, the conversation stays focused and each idea can get the attention it needs.

Before making a new topic, please check out the following:

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions. If your suggestion is in this list, please do not make a new topic about it, as it will not be implemented anyway.
The Suggestions Directory. If your suggestion is in this list, please continue the discussion in the existing topic, rather than making a new topic.

Thank you!

Discuss Scratch