Bring back "My Comments"

greenie_hedgehog

Remember when Scratch had “my comments” tab On “my stuff” page years Ago?

So, could bring It back? Every website has a “comments history” to see all of my own old or recent comments, since the “my comments” tab was removed, everyone had to find by themselves their own comments, that isn't easy at all

(13/10/2024) Note: i Noticed that “my Comments” wasn't a removed feature on Scratch(it was a feature on 1.4?!) but was a concept problably made in 2013 in forums(if im not wrong) so Yeah, back in the day when i wrote this i wasn't knowing about that! But anyway…i would like If Scratch team add this feature on Scratch to people have the option to see your own old comments(its Very cool and funny at the same time).

Last edited by greenie_hedgehog (Oct. 14, 2024 18:07:08)

dertermenter

greenie_hedgehog wrote:
Remember when Scratch had “my comments” tab On “my stuff” page years Ago?

No, and I first used Scratch in 2015.

edit: It turns out this was all the way back in Scratch 1.4. I feel like that could have been problematic as it is very easy to spam innapropriate comments if you find an exploit in the filter - it is a lot easier than making innapropriate projects. I also feel like the comments showing up on your profile page may look odd since they are out of context with other peoples comments, making this feature not the most helpful. Finally, a comment thread may be a private conversation, and having all the users comments on the users profile page could cause people to butt in, which can be annoying and disrespectful.

Key edit: My bad, this comments tab didn't come up for other users, only when yourself went on your own profile page.

Last edited by dertermenter (Jan. 5, 2024 19:01:10)

greenie_hedgehog

dertermenter wrote:
greenie_hedgehog wrote:
Remember when Scratch had “my comments” tab On “my stuff” page years Ago?
No, and I first used Scratch in 2015.

Okay

roofogato

Support, as long as only you can see the page

randomguy3513

dertermenter wrote:
It turns out this was all the way back in Scratch 1.4. I feel like that could have been problematic as it is very easy to spam innapropriate comments if you find an exploit in the filter - it is a lot easier than making innapropriate projects. I also feel like the comments showing up on your profile page may look odd since they are out of context with other peoples comments, making this feature not the most helpful. Finally, a comment thread may be a private conversation, and having all the users comments on the users profile page could cause people to butt in, which can be annoying and disrespectful.

I'm pretty sure they mean it can only be seen by you as the everyone's my stuff page is a private page where no other scratch can get into other then you so if it was public so would the my stuff page.

unmissable

before asking to add it back, why was it removed?

dertermenter

randomguy3513 wrote:
dertermenter wrote:
It turns out this was all the way back in Scratch 1.4. I feel like that could have been problematic as it is very easy to spam innapropriate comments if you find an exploit in the filter - it is a lot easier than making innapropriate projects. I also feel like the comments showing up on your profile page may look odd since they are out of context with other peoples comments, making this feature not the most helpful. Finally, a comment thread may be a private conversation, and having all the users comments on the users profile page could cause people to butt in, which can be annoying and disrespectful.
I'm pretty sure they mean it can only be seen by you as the everyone's my stuff page is a private page where no other scratch can get into other then you so if it was public so would the my stuff page.

Well here they are talking about an old feature which was on Scratch “years ago” and after research this was on the Scratch 1.4 profile page - I assume this is what they are talking about, despite the mistake of them saying it was on the “My Stuff” page when it was public on the profile page.

greenie_hedgehog

unmissable wrote:
before asking to add it back, why was it removed?

I don't know why It was removed in the past,
But It world be cool If Scratch team bring It back.

greenie_hedgehog

dertermenter wrote:
greenie_hedgehog wrote:
Remember when Scratch had “my comments” tab On “my stuff” page years Ago?
No, and I first used Scratch in 2015.

edit: It turns out this was all the way back in Scratch 1.4. I feel like that could have been problematic as it is very easy to spam innapropriate comments if you find an exploit in the filter - it is a lot easier than making innapropriate projects. I also feel like the comments showing up on your profile page may look odd since they are out of context with other peoples comments, making this feature not the most helpful. Finally, a comment thread may be a private conversation, and having all the users comments on the users profile page could cause people to butt in, which can be annoying and disrespectful.

Key edit: My bad, this comments tab didn't come up for other users, only when yourself went on your own profile page.

The detail is that: “my comments” can only be seen individually on its own “my stuff” page, understand?

Last edited by greenie_hedgehog (Jan. 5, 2024 19:06:32)

z10r

unmissable wrote:
before asking to add it back, why was it removed?

Most likely just because it's a pointless feature, iirc there's more features from 1.4 that were removed because they were pointless

EDawg2011

Huge support. I want to find all my old comments that break the CG.

-Rodri

support because it'd be cool to have a place to see all of my comments

Last edited by -Rodri (Jan. 5, 2024 22:04:53)

unmissable

EDawg2011 wrote:
Huge support. I want to find all my old comments that break the CG.

That's an… interesting…reason for supporting…

z10r wrote:
unmissable wrote:
before asking to add it back, why was it removed?
Most likely just because it's a pointless feature, iirc there's more features from 1.4 that were removed because they were pointless

Well, I can agree with that.

To OP: Would this show all your comments, publicly?

greenie_hedgehog

EDawg2011 wrote:
Huge support. I want to find all my old comments that break the CG.

Cool

greenie_hedgehog

-Rodri wrote:
support because it'd be cool to have a place to see all of my comments

Same. It would be awesome!

Last edited by greenie_hedgehog (Jan. 9, 2024 01:17:53)

BabyBoyReader11

I'd love to see all of my cringe comments from 2023-past.

mastergamerx-details

EDawg2011 wrote:
Huge support. I want to find all my old comments that break the CG.

Very interesting…. very interesting indeed…..

mastergamerx-details

z10r wrote:
unmissable wrote:
before asking to add it back, why was it removed?
Most likely just because it's a pointless feature, iirc there's more features from 1.4 that were removed because they were pointless

The ST removes good features and instead sits on their couch making studios and stuff
maybe that was too harsh lol

greenie_hedgehog

mastergamerx-details wrote:
z10r wrote:
unmissable wrote:
before asking to add it back, why was it removed?
Most likely just because it's a pointless feature, iirc there's more features from 1.4 that were removed because they were pointless
The ST removes good features and instead sits on their couch making studios and stuff
maybe that was too harsh lol

Exactly, perhaps Scratch 4.0 Will have New features anyday when get the update!

Last edited by greenie_hedgehog (Oct. 14, 2024 00:15:39)

BigNate469

greenie_hedgehog wrote:
mastergamerx-details wrote:
z10r wrote:
unmissable wrote:
before asking to add it back, why was it removed?
Most likely just because it's a pointless feature, iirc there's more features from 1.4 that were removed because they were pointless
The ST removes good features and instead sits on their couch making studios and stuff
maybe that was too harsh lol
Exactly, perhaps Scratch 4.0 Will have New features anyday when get the update!

Don't get your hopes up

Discuss Scratch