¶ Commenting addition! ¶

Scratchifier

PrincessFlowerTV wrote:
If the owner were to create the comment messages, they could be really mean.
If this were to be added, it would be a good idea to be able to report the message somehow.

That's already part of my suggestion. Thanks for not only reading the title but for giving your opinion on my title as well. I'll make sure to put the entire idea and explanation of it into the title as well next time.

PrincessFlowerTV

Scratchifier wrote:
PrincessFlowerTV wrote:
If the owner were to create the comment messages, they could be really mean.
If this were to be added, it would be a good idea to be able to report the message somehow.

That's already part of my suggestion. Thanks for not only reading the title but for giving your opinion on my title as well. I'll make sure to put the entire idea and explanation of it into the title as well next time.

I'm sorry.

Lion1278

I like the idea! Support!

-CrystalWaters-

theonlygusti wrote:
Hmm, I like the concept a lot, but not the messages you suggested.

I think too many people post their scores in the comments, and it is a useful way of presenting challenges to others, who might accept and develop new relationships. I think that the current message is actually perfect (I think it says to be nice because the person might not have much programming experience).

I do like the idea for profiles though, maybe the profile owner can choose a message for it to display to someone.

And the “go away” one just seems to defy all community guidelines, it's just outright mean and disrespectful. I don't think that Scratch would be able to tell when someone was being mean, but I'm sure that if they could they would just stop the user from commenting altogether.

Instead of go away, you could just put Report.

-CrystalWaters-

Scratchifier wrote:
OmnipotentPotato wrote:
KingOfAwesome58219 wrote:
I don't think it should pop EVERY time, just maybe once a day nor something. Support anyways.
You mean have like 1/3 chance of showing on any project? That's not very effective.

What about it shows for your first comment on the project? Then it goes away. (Unless it gets updated).

It would be the same for studios and profiles.

Yeah! That's a good one! so, you see it once!

fdreerf

How did I not bump this?

mybearworld

This would be very useful to explain some stuff to people (for example the controls if many people ask for it).
3.0 mockups:

I would suggest another addition:

(Not a necropost.)

Last edited by mybearworld (May 23, 2021 09:32:24)

DarthVader4Life

This can be helpful… make sure everyone sees your personal policy. It's also good that's able to be reported if need be. I see no reason to not do this.

Pianostar4

mybearworld wrote:
This would be very useful to explain some stuff to people (for example the controls if many people ask for it).
3.0 mockups:

I would suggest another addition:

(Not a necropost.)

I support this mockup if the report button looks more like the report comments button.

PkmnQ

Sorry if this is unconstructive, but I'm just putting this here to highlight it:

LionHeart70 wrote:
duckboycool wrote:
LionHeart70 wrote:
-snip-
Yes, I know. That's why I said I wanted restrictions so they're reportable.
I'm sorry. What exactly would these restrictions do?
It'd be like restrictions for all other things. A bad word detector, moderation, whitelist of things you can say and blacklist of things you can't say, etc.

dave-alt-4

support (bump)

OhOkSir12345

dave-alt-4 wrote:
support (bump)

please elaborate

Last edited by OhOkSir12345 (May 16, 2022 14:11:07)

dave-alt-4

OhOkSir12345 wrote:
dave-alt-4 wrote:
support (bump)
please elaborate and don't bump a topic if it is unrelevant

well that way there MIGHT just be less advertising…..

TheAnimalKingdom42

Bump

Scratchifier

OhOkSir12345 wrote:
dave-alt-4 wrote:
support (bump)
please elaborate and don't bump a topic if it is unrelevant

All of my suggestions are relevant.

Which is unfortunate, considering the last time the scratch team actually implemented a highly upvoted suggestion was like never.

It's not like I made this suggestion many years before twitch.tv implemented this exact feature…oh wait :bongocat:

musicROCKS013

Scratchifier wrote:
Which is unfortunate, considering the last time the scratch team actually implemented a highly upvoted suggestion was like never.

(Sorry for offtopic) The ST is really good at implementing what the site needs, but hardly ever what the site wants.

This would be such a cool feature and would allow for the user to interact with the project in a whole new way. Comments allow people to give feedback, but the best comments are often drowned out by spam and ads, so this would help to tell people to stop putting ads in the comments, because people NEVER read the description.

7salad3salad

This would be pretty cool for establishing a set of rules in the comments.
I can see this being used by many people.
Also, bee to the you to the em to the pee

musicROCKS013

Bump

-Valtren-

I think you should be able to make a separate one for each project, as it's impossible to have one message that says everything you need to say for all your projects
same thing with the profile and studios

pizzafox20109

Support.
This seems pretty useful and is also pretty foolproof since you can report it.
If this does get added it would be useful if it was a different color from the standard yellow, maybe blue or green.

Discuss Scratch