Bump

Himdoy2-2 wrote:

You don't need to bump the topic again.

I was going to say something else but I forgot literally two seconds I came up with it

Shajiui_Da_Black_Fox wrote:

I don't think this would benefit Scratch as an educational site.

Also it would be quite laggy… imagine having that on the most “popular” scratch project.

It'd be a nightmare…

Does it need to be enabled for every project? If it is implemented as a block then there can be a check mark to turn the live updating on

PARTIAL support, sort of useless, sort of not ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Shajiui_Da_Black_Fox wrote:

I don't think this would benefit Scratch as an educational site.

Also it would be quite laggy… imagine having that on the most “popular” scratch project.

It'd be a nightmare…

big numbers = nightmare?

Yeah I don't support.

I don't think this would benefit Scratch.

Fazah_Champ wrote:

I don't think this would benefit Scratch.

And why is that? Be constructive please!

dertermenter wrote:

Fazah_Champ wrote:

I don't think this would benefit Scratch.

And why is that? Be constructive please!

The mascot we have now is almost perfect and we dont need to destroy that

Fazah_Champ wrote:

dertermenter wrote:

Fazah_Champ wrote:

I don't think this would benefit Scratch.

And why is that? Be constructive please!

The mascot we have now is almost perfect and we dont need to destroy that

THis suggestion isn't about the mascot.

This seems like a useless feature, no support.
(I know what your thinking dertermenter, please be constructive I know, but my reason is the same reason as many others, could be laggy, or hard to implement, or just unneeded in general.)

dertermenter wrote:

Fazah_Champ wrote:

I don't think this would benefit Scratch.

And why is that? Be constructive please!

That's not constructive itself.
Support if there's a way to implement this without lag since it would be helpful to see if there are people on your project.

coder2045 wrote:

dertermenter wrote:

Fazah_Champ wrote:

I don't think this would benefit Scratch.

And why is that? Be constructive please!

That's not constructive itself.
Support if there's a way to implement this without lag since it would be helpful to see if there are people on your project.

It is. Constructive, I’m asking why they support and a suggestion to stop people from saying that got rejected as paddle said he has no problem in people teaching others how to be constructive

how do u do it

Hmm, it seems like i should update the OP post. didnt expect this very old suggestion to gain traction, although it is being necroposted repeatedly haha

full support for that one

You could just make one without the stuff.

just make a list and when someone click the green flag the project add there username in the list, and when Username click it again it won't change the variable, but first you need a cloud variable called “View”, and then… uhhh… yea am gonna make a project about it, so am gonna send a link.




(Edited) done: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/627155456/

I made a project like this. Here; i’ll give you the link.

I don't believe it would be that beneficial, and im pretty sure you could have cloud variables add 1 when green flag clicked, and -1 when project ever gets stopped (i guess there would be bugs but with a bit of coding, it should work fine)