Lightningstep36 wrote:

PonyPokiPanikku wrote:

Does my OC count as a Mary Sue? She has purple hair with orange tips, blue eyes, pony/cat ears, and she is a secret shape-shifter. She can transform into a human, a robot, or a pony, but her true form is her pony form. Is she a dumb idea? I've been using her for a while but I'm building her character up. She is not in any fanfiction whatsoever. She is a different age in each form.

Whether or not she's a Mary Sue depends on what fandom she's being used for. If every character in the fandom is like that, then she's fine. In my opinion, if you only write fanfiction about her for yourself and never post it online, then whether or not she's a Mary Sue is not that much of a problem. I've made a lot of characters who one would consider a Mary Sue (they'd be considered that mostly for the reasons of having a tragic pasts, and/or are considerably powerful fighters in the present), but I've never shared any of them online so no one ever gives me grief for them.

MSPA wrote:

I read a nessXlucas fanfiction (i happen to like yaoi) and it was sort of sad..

lucas had to move away from onett with claus, leaving ness (whom lucas was dating) and ninten (whom claus was dating) in the end. i almost actually cried and all i was thinking was “you ruined my otp with your sad garbage”

lucas and claus had moved to onett in the beginning and stuff happened with a idiotic popular girl who had a severe crush on ness and hated lucas for dating ness and things happened haha

Mistyiscute wrote:

Lightningstep36 wrote:

PonyPokiPanikku wrote:

Does my OC count as a Mary Sue? She has purple hair with orange tips, blue eyes, pony/cat ears, and she is a secret shape-shifter. She can transform into a human, a robot, or a pony, but her true form is her pony form. Is she a dumb idea? I've been using her for a while but I'm building her character up. She is not in any fanfiction whatsoever. She is a different age in each form.

Whether or not she's a Mary Sue depends on what fandom she's being used for. If every character in the fandom is like that, then she's fine. In my opinion, if you only write fanfiction about her for yourself and never post it online, then whether or not she's a Mary Sue is not that much of a problem. I've made a lot of characters who one would consider a Mary Sue (they'd be considered that mostly for the reasons of having a tragic pasts, and/or are considerably powerful fighters in the present), but I've never shared any of them online so no one ever gives me grief for them.

LOL, Mary Sues are so annoying. Usually my characters have tragic pasts, though.

Demosthenes_ wrote:

MSPA wrote:

I read a nessXlucas fanfiction (i happen to like yaoi) and it was sort of sad..

lucas had to move away from onett with claus, leaving ness (whom lucas was dating) and ninten (whom claus was dating) in the end. i almost actually cried and all i was thinking was “you ruined my otp with your sad garbage”

lucas and claus had moved to onett in the beginning and stuff happened with a idiotic popular girl who had a severe crush on ness and hated lucas for dating ness and things happened haha

how is that even possible
lucas is from the future (after eb)
and claus is the masked man
._.

PonyPokiPanikku wrote:

Lightningstep36 wrote:

PonyPokiPanikku wrote:

Does my OC count as a Mary Sue? She has purple hair with orange tips, blue eyes, pony/cat ears, and she is a secret shape-shifter. She can transform into a human, a robot, or a pony, but her true form is her pony form. Is she a dumb idea? I've been using her for a while but I'm building her character up. She is not in any fanfiction whatsoever. She is a different age in each form.

Whether or not she's a Mary Sue depends on what fandom she's being used for. If every character in the fandom is like that, then she's fine. In my opinion, if you only write fanfiction about her for yourself and never post it online, then whether or not she's a Mary Sue is not that much of a problem. I've made a lot of characters who one would consider a Mary Sue (they'd be considered that mostly for the reasons of having a tragic pasts, and/or are considerably powerful fighters in the present), but I've never shared any of them online so no one ever gives me grief for them.

She's used for the MLP fandom and the Mega Man fandom…..She's a multi-fandom OC but she doesn't have a tragic past.

MidnightMystique wrote:

Gryffindor_Hobbit wrote:

Sooo… does anyone read Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings crossover fanfiction like me?

It's a guilty pleasure of mine. Harry Potter has a lot of freedom if you know the plot extremely well, as with Lord of the Rings. However, one of my pet peeves is Mary Sue-ish Harry Potter OCs. Which is a kind of hypocritical when you see my old Fan Characters.

Lightningstep36 wrote:

harleyquin wrote:

Fanfiction that is well-written nowadays is usually labeled as “lemon” or “smut” on AO3 and FFN.

What're those?

Turquoise-Lion wrote:

What're those?

PonyoPenguin wrote:

Um…they're not things kids should be reading. Moving on…

I think I've found my primary fandom. My Gravity Falls fic has gotten 30+ reviews! Plus I have plenty of other ideas for the fandom too.

Turquoise-Lion wrote:

PonyoPenguin wrote:

Um…they're not things kids should be reading. Moving on…

I think I've found my primary fandom. My Gravity Falls fic has gotten 30+ reviews! Plus I have plenty of other ideas for the fandom too.

I'm 13. You can tell me.

PonyoPenguin wrote:

Turquoise-Lion wrote:

PonyoPenguin wrote:

Um…they're not things kids should be reading. Moving on…

I think I've found my primary fandom. My Gravity Falls fic has gotten 30+ reviews! Plus I have plenty of other ideas for the fandom too.

I'm 13. You can tell me.

Well, um…keeping things appropriate for Scratch, they are stories about romance, with explicit material only people 18+ should read. Not going into further detail. Moving on.

Mister Blue Sky
Please tell us why
You had to hide away for so long, so long
Where did we go wrong?

“The more fan fictions the better.” gorge washington

Crispydogs101 wrote:

One of teh longest bumpys' eva!

DifferentDance8 wrote:

Crispydogs101 wrote:

One of teh longest bumpys' eva!

That was one of the biggest bumps ever
=
I heard a lot about fanfics. Some good, most bad

Crispydogs101 wrote:

I do know that the first ever fanfic I read was a wall e fanfic about Wall e being dead and then EVE decides to… I can't mention. It wasn't really that good for a first.

DifferentDance8 wrote:

Crispydogs101 wrote:

I do know that the first ever fanfic I read was a wall e fanfic about Wall e being dead and then EVE decides to… I can't mention. It wasn't really that good for a first.

…what the? XD