How To Decide If A Suggestion Is Good Or Not

walkcycle

FancyFoxy wrote:
Charles12310 said that this topic wasn't made for supporting or not supporting, but being a “guide” or something along those lines.

Okay, I see the part in parentheses where it says it isn't a suggestion. But it does seem like a suggestion for deciding if a suggestion is good or not.

-penandpaper-

comic snasssss
Nice guide! It'd definitely help lots of people out if it got stickied.

aking_

Charles12310 wrote:
Please tell me this is a joke, have you even read the first parts of the topic?

No support, we aren't good readers.

This is a joke don't worry lol

Last edited by aking_ (Nov. 7, 2017 21:54:06)

aking_

eeymao wrote:
hilarious

I know I'm very hilarious.

I'm glad someone recognizes my comedic talents.

Charles12310

aking_ wrote:
Charles12310 wrote:
Please tell me this is a joke, have you even read the first parts of the topic?
No support, we aren't good readers.

This is a joke don't worry lol

haha

Charles12310

bump

walkcycle

Charles12310 wrote:
bump

It's not a suggestion, though.

Maybe ask to combine it with

A guide to suggestions

Constructive Recommendations On How to Respond to and Make Suggestions!

or one of the other existing threads.

Charles12310

bump

Sheep_maker

Charles12310 wrote:
To find out if there is an older topic, type this at Google: “site:scratch.mit.edu/discuss INSERT SUGGESTION HERE”.

Some people don't seem to trust Google, but since the site: search parameter seems to work for many other search engines, it could be rephrased to something more search engine neutral.

Charles12310

bump

WooHooBoy

hey i felt like your guide was missing something so i made this

Last edited by WooHooBoy (Dec. 28, 2017 01:47:19)

Charles12310

WooHooBoy wrote:
hey i felt like your guide was missing something so i made this

This looks like a joke to me.

wWSunPandaWw

Bump.

20XXFox

step 1
weigh out pros and cons
step 2
use judgement

Bla-Games

Reported to become a sticky!

thedogcoder440

probably necro-posting but great post, reported to be stickied

qwerty_wasd_gone

Looks like a topic that can be stickied.

ajskateboarder

thedogcoder440 wrote:
probably necro-posting but great post, reported to be stickied

qwerty_wasd_gone wrote:
Looks like a topic that can be stickied.

You know we do have this topic right? It provides reasons on why most suggestions fail and how to improve them

qwerty_wasd_gone

ajskateboarder wrote:
thedogcoder440 wrote:
probably necro-posting but great post, reported to be stickied
qwerty_wasd_gone wrote:
Looks like a topic that can be stickied.
You know we do have this topic right? It provides reasons on why most suggestions fail and how to improve them

this topic is older though

yadayadayadagoodbye

qwerty_wasd_gone wrote:
ajskateboarder wrote:
thedogcoder440 wrote:
probably necro-posting but great post, reported to be stickied
qwerty_wasd_gone wrote:
Looks like a topic that can be stickied.
You know we do have this topic right? It provides reasons on why most suggestions fail and how to improve them
this topic is older though

older doesn't always better

Discuss Scratch