Discuss Scratch
- Discussion Forums
- » Things I'm Reading and Playing
- » Warriors - by Erin Hunter
- blossombreeze
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
They would have to break it up. Trying to cram that much story into one movie would just be an incomprehensible mess.Great news! I just learned that a few days ago, Alibaba Pictures, a Chinese film company, bought the rights to Warrior Cats. This means that there will in fact be at least one Warrior Cats movie, so long as the project doesn't fall flat. The release probably won't be for a few years, but it's definitely awesome news. I can share an article tonight. It's a little hard to do from my phone.
Here's hoping they don't ruin it!
Also, for those of you who don't trust outside links, this information is also available on the Warrior cat's website.
Do you think they'll cram it all into one giant movie or break it up into the story-arcs or even do a separate movie for each book or two?
True but film-making companies have made similar incomprehensible messes out of treasured series Avatar the last Airbender
- VixenMangleTheFox
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
I feel like it'd be best to make it into a series. The first book has an ending that prepares you for more, and then After that, they can make one for Books 2 and 3, then 4 and 5, then have 6 get its own.They would have to break it up. Trying to cram that much story into one movie would just be an incomprehensible mess.Great news! I just learned that a few days ago, Alibaba Pictures, a Chinese film company, bought the rights to Warrior Cats. This means that there will in fact be at least one Warrior Cats movie, so long as the project doesn't fall flat. The release probably won't be for a few years, but it's definitely awesome news. I can share an article tonight. It's a little hard to do from my phone.
Here's hoping they don't ruin it!
Also, for those of you who don't trust outside links, this information is also available on the Warrior cat's website.
Do you think they'll cram it all into one giant movie or break it up into the story-arcs or even do a separate movie for each book or two?
True but film-making companies have made similar incomprehensible messes out of treasured series Avatar the last Airbender
- jji10
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
I feel it would be better to make it into a TV series.I feel like it'd be best to make it into a series. The first book has an ending that prepares you for more, and then After that, they can make one for Books 2 and 3, then 4 and 5, then have 6 get its own.They would have to break it up. Trying to cram that much story into one movie would just be an incomprehensible mess.Great news! I just learned that a few days ago, Alibaba Pictures, a Chinese film company, bought the rights to Warrior Cats. This means that there will in fact be at least one Warrior Cats movie, so long as the project doesn't fall flat. The release probably won't be for a few years, but it's definitely awesome news. I can share an article tonight. It's a little hard to do from my phone.
Here's hoping they don't ruin it!
Also, for those of you who don't trust outside links, this information is also available on the Warrior cat's website.
Do you think they'll cram it all into one giant movie or break it up into the story-arcs or even do a separate movie for each book or two?
True but film-making companies have made similar incomprehensible messes out of treasured series Avatar the last Airbender
- Cindertail2877
-
Scratcher
7 posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
I feel it would be better to make it into a TV series.I feel like it'd be best to make it into a series. The first book has an ending that prepares you for more, and then After that, they can make one for Books 2 and 3, then 4 and 5, then have 6 get its own.They would have to break it up. Trying to cram that much story into one movie would just be an incomprehensible mess.Great news! I just learned that a few days ago, Alibaba Pictures, a Chinese film company, bought the rights to Warrior Cats. This means that there will in fact be at least one Warrior Cats movie, so long as the project doesn't fall flat. The release probably won't be for a few years, but it's definitely awesome news. I can share an article tonight. It's a little hard to do from my phone.
Here's hoping they don't ruin it!
Also, for those of you who don't trust outside links, this information is also available on the Warrior cat's website.
Do you think they'll cram it all into one giant movie or break it up into the story-arcs or even do a separate movie for each book or two?
True but film-making companies have made similar incomprehensible messes out of treasured series Avatar the last Airbender
I agree. But I guess they have worked it out.
- WildfiretheSandwing
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
I don't know if i'm missing something but what happened to Sol? Did they talk about him?? Or something??he kind of just disappeared after the forgotten warrior
I wonder if the Erin Hunters even remember him-he was the real forgotten warrior
hehe
anyway I know it's stupid but his name kind of annoys me ‘Sol’ means ‘sun’ in Spanish. Would you name a brown, black, and orange (I think) cat Sun? So why would you name one Sol? It's the same thing really. If his name is Sol he should be white or orange. I mean yes so he is partly orange but he shouldn't be BLACK AND BROWN mostly and be named AFTER SOMETHING THAT IS ORANGE/YELLOW BUT LOOKS MORE WHITE FROM EARTH
so yes
stupid rant there

- WildfiretheSandwing
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
Poll thing because I can!
Best Leader
Firestar or Bramblestar?
Tallstar or Onestar?
Crookedstar or Leopardstar?
Blackstar or Rowanstar?
Leafstar or Cloudstar?
Of all I mentioned?
Of all leaders?
Biggest mary-sue/gary-sue
Firestar or Dovewing?
Ivypool or Brambleclaw?
Bluestar or Graystripe?
Of all I mentioned?
Of all characters?
Worst Parent?
Rainflower or Millie?
Squirrelflight (fostering The Three) or Leafpool?
Crowfeather or Nightcloud?
Of all I mentioned?
Of all parents?
Best Name? (real characters)
Mapleshade or Lionblaze?
Brightflower or Appledawn?
Brambleberry or Dawnflower?
Ivypool or Deerdapple?
Echsong or Larksplash?
Leafstorm or Morningflower?
Of All I mentioned?
Of all names?
Worst Name? (real characters)
Cypresspaw or Needletail?
Crouchfoot or Slightfoot?
Rooktail or Pearnose?
Echosnout or Rubblepaw?
Barkface or Daisytoe?
Deadfoot or Tornear?
Of all I mentioned?
Of all names?
Best Name?
Breezesong or Swiftstorm?
Lightningstrike or Grasscloud?
Hawkshadow or Tallberry?
Gorsesplash or Willowsong?
Emberwind or Snowleaf?
Of all I mentioned?
Worst Name?
Maggotbreath or Bloodyclaw?
Curlysnout or Sloetoe?
Wormnose or Antface?
Logfur or Shortpelt?
Parsleycoat or Mallowball?
Of all I mentioned?
Best Clan?
WindClan or ShadowClan?
ThunderClan or Riverclan?
SkyClan or ThunderClan?
Of all?
Worst of all?
please don't start any arguments about any of this stuff guys :3
Best Leader
Firestar or Bramblestar?
Tallstar or Onestar?
Crookedstar or Leopardstar?
Blackstar or Rowanstar?
Leafstar or Cloudstar?
Of all I mentioned?
Of all leaders?
Biggest mary-sue/gary-sue
Firestar or Dovewing?
Ivypool or Brambleclaw?
Bluestar or Graystripe?
Of all I mentioned?
Of all characters?
Worst Parent?
Rainflower or Millie?
Squirrelflight (fostering The Three) or Leafpool?
Crowfeather or Nightcloud?
Of all I mentioned?
Of all parents?
Best Name? (real characters)
Mapleshade or Lionblaze?
Brightflower or Appledawn?
Brambleberry or Dawnflower?
Ivypool or Deerdapple?
Echsong or Larksplash?
Leafstorm or Morningflower?
Of All I mentioned?
Of all names?
Worst Name? (real characters)
Cypresspaw or Needletail?
Crouchfoot or Slightfoot?
Rooktail or Pearnose?
Echosnout or Rubblepaw?
Barkface or Daisytoe?
Deadfoot or Tornear?
Of all I mentioned?
Of all names?
Best Name?
Breezesong or Swiftstorm?
Lightningstrike or Grasscloud?
Hawkshadow or Tallberry?
Gorsesplash or Willowsong?
Emberwind or Snowleaf?
Of all I mentioned?
Worst Name?
Maggotbreath or Bloodyclaw?
Curlysnout or Sloetoe?
Wormnose or Antface?
Logfur or Shortpelt?
Parsleycoat or Mallowball?
Of all I mentioned?
Best Clan?
WindClan or ShadowClan?
ThunderClan or Riverclan?
SkyClan or ThunderClan?
Of all?
Worst of all?
please don't start any arguments about any of this stuff guys :3
- WildfiretheSandwing
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
Poll thing because I can!and yes I'm going to be THAT person who fills out their own poll
Best Leader
Firestar or Bramblestar?
Tallstar or Onestar?
Crookedstar or Leopardstar?
Blackstar or Rowanstar?
Leafstar or Cloudstar?
Of all I mentioned?
Tallstar
Of all leaders?
Tallstar
Biggest mary-sue/gary-sue
Firestar or Dovewing?
Ivypool or Brambleclaw?
Bluestar or Graystripe?
Of all I mentioned?
Firestar
Of all characters?
Firestar
Worst Parent?
Rainflower or Millie?
Squirrelflight (fostering The Three) or Leafpool?
Crowfeather or Nightcloud?
Of all I mentioned?
Rainflower
Of all parents?
Rainflower
Best Name? (real characters)
Mapleshade or Lionblaze?
Brightflower or Appledawn?
Brambleberry or Dawnflower?
Ivypool or Deerdapple?
Echosong or Larksplash?
Leafstorm or Morningflower?
Of All I mentioned?
Morningflower
Of all names?
Morningflower
Worst Name? (real characters)
Cypresspaw or Needletail?
Crouchfoot or Slightfoot?
Rooktail or Pearnose?
Echosnout or Rubblepaw?
Barkface or Daisytoe?
Deadfoot or Tornear?
Of all I mentioned?
Deadfoot
Of all names?
Deadfoot
Best Name?
Breezesong or Swiftstorm?
Lightningstrike or Grasscloud?
Hawkshadow or Tallberry?
Gorsesplash or Willowsong?
Emberwind or Snowleaf?
Of all I mentioned?
Breezesong
Worst Name?
Maggotbreath or Bloodyclaw?
Curlysnout or Sloetoe?
Wormnose or Antface?
Logfur or Shortpelt?
Parsleycoat or Mallowball?
Of all I mentioned?
Maggotbreath (the poor cat with that name)
Best Clan?
WindClan or ShadowClan?
ThunderClan or Riverclan?
SkyClan or ThunderClan?
Of all?
WindClan
Worst of all?
RiverClan
please don't start any arguments about any of this stuff guys :3
deal with it
Last edited by WildfiretheSandwing (Nov. 16, 2016 21:50:36)
- blossombreeze
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
I don't know if i'm missing something but what happened to Sol? Did they talk about him?? Or something??he kind of just disappeared after the forgotten warrior
I wonder if the Erin Hunters even remember him-he was the real forgotten warrior
hehe
anyway I know it's stupid but his name kind of annoys me ‘Sol’ means ‘sun’ in Spanish. Would you name a brown, black, and orange (I think) cat Sun? So why would you name one Sol? It's the same thing really. If his name is Sol he should be white or orange. I mean yes so he is partly orange but he shouldn't be BLACK AND BROWN mostly and be named AFTER SOMETHING THAT IS ORANGE/YELLOW BUT LOOKS MORE WHITE FROM EARTH
so yes
stupid rant there
They probably did it to be ironic. After all Sol “makes” the sun disappear. I once made a character who was a fox named Zorro just to be funny…
- blossombreeze
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
Poll thing because I can!
Best Leader
Firestar or Bramblestar?
Tallstar or Onestar?
Crookedstar or Leopardstar?
Blackstar or Rowanstar? Blackstar was better politically but Rowanstar was a better cat in my opinion
Leafstar or Cloudstar?
Of all I mentioned? Leafstar
Of all leaders? Bluestar before she went Crazy
Biggest mary-sue/gary-sue
Firestar or Dovewing?
Ivypool or Brambleclaw?
Bluestar or Graystripe?
Of all I mentioned? Firestar
Of all characters? Tigerheart
Worst Parent?
Rainflower or Millie?
Squirrelflight (fostering The Three) or Leafpool? They both did their best in my opinion
Crowfeather or NIGHTCLOUD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?
Of all I mentioned? NIGHTCLOUD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Of all parents? NIGHTCLOUD!!!!!!!!!
By the way I think Nightcloud was a terrible parent
Best Name? (real characters)
Mapleshade or Lionblaze?
Brightflower or Appledawn?
Brambleberry or Dawnflower?
Ivypool or Deerdapple?
Echosong or Larksplash?
Leafstorm or Morningflower?
Of All I mentioned? Leafstorm
Of all names? Spikefur
Worst Name? (real characters)
Cypresspaw or Needletail?
Crouchfoot or Slightfoot?
Rooktail or Pearnose?
Echosnout or Rubblepaw?
Barkface or Daisytoe?
Deadfoot or Tornear?
Of all I mentioned? Barkface
Of all names? Hollytuft
Best Name?
Breezesong or Swiftstorm?
Lightningstrike or Grasscloud?
Hawkshadow or Tallberry?
Gorsesplash or Willowsong?
Emberwind or Snowleaf?
Of all I mentioned? Lightningstrike
Worst Name?
Maggotbreath or Bloodyclaw?
Curlysnout or Sloetoe?
Wormnose or Antface?
Logfur or Shortpelt?
Parsleycoat or Mallowball?
Of all I mentioned? Bloodyclaw
Best Clan?
WindClan or ShadowClan?
ThunderClan or Riverclan!?
SkyClan or ThunderClan?
Of all? Riverclan!
Worst of all? Shadowclan
please don't start any arguments about any of this stuff guys :3
- -Scotch-
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
I agree completely. It was basically asking for fanfics. Designed that way. Yeah, absolutely. Like I said before, it was asking for OC's.Well, I don't really know what to tell you there. What made you want to pick up the book? My point exactly. You took the words straight from my mouth.Blah, blah, snippity snip.I think another thing is that it's really easy to write Warriors fanfictions, at least for me. The way the whole Warriors universe is set up it's easy to make your own character and place them in it, too. And yeah Warrior cat names are real easy to make. Personally I didn't even like cats until reading warriors- I had a pet dog and thought dogs were the greatest things and cats sucked. Once I started reading Warriors I became obsessed with cats. I definitely liked to imagine the cats I soon got as warriors-i even attempted to write a warrior fanfic where one of them did become one.
I guess something else is Warriors was something new- basically wild cats that were social like dogs so dog and cat lovers would like it. Of course now there are so many Warriors rip-offs (i mean people write “original” fiction with groups of wild cats) that its pretty much the least original thing now. Warriors has fairly good plotlines, but the characters are either mary-sue or don't even have a real personality, so I cant understand how so many people can get so obsessed with the characters. Warriors probably has more reader x character fanfics than any other fandom
Honestly, I thought more people would reply to this rant. Maybe I just made too many liable points (totally not patting myself on the back there. Or, maybe they just didn't want to read the whole thing through.
- blossombreeze
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
ClipBlah, blah, snippity snip.I think another thing is that it's really easy to write Warriors fanfictions, at least for me. The way the whole Warriors universe is set up it's easy to make your own character and place them in it, too. And yeah Warrior cat names are real easy to make. Personally I didn't even like cats until reading warriors- I had a pet dog and thought dogs were the greatest things and cats sucked. Once I started reading Warriors I became obsessed with cats. I definitely liked to imagine the cats I soon got as warriors-i even attempted to write a warrior fanfic where one of them did become one.
I guess something else is Warriors was something new- basically wild cats that were social like dogs so dog and cat lovers would like it. Of course now there are so many Warriors rip-offs (i mean people write “original” fiction with groups of wild cats) that its pretty much the least original thing now. Warriors has fairly good plotlines, but the characters are either mary-sue or don't even have a real personality, so I cant understand how so many people can get so obsessed with the characters. Warriors probably has more reader x character fanfics than any other fandom
Honestly, I thought more people would reply to this rant. Maybe I just made too many liable points (totally not patting myself on the back there. Or, maybe they just didn't want to read the whole thing through.
I don't mean to be rude, but I think most of us just have more important things to discuss
I.E. The movie. But you did make some fairly good points, although in addition Scratch user tend to be within the target age range for the Warriors books.- VixenMangleTheFox
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
Poll thing because I can!
Best Leader
Firestar or Bramblestar?
Tallstar or Onestar?
Crookedstar or Leopardstar?
Blackstar or Rowanstar?
Leafstar or Cloudstar?
Of all I mentioned? Crookedstar
Of all leaders? Crookedstar
Biggest mary-sue/gary-sue
Firestar or Dovewing?
Ivypool or Brambleclaw?
Bluestar or Graystripe?
Of all I mentioned? Firestar
Of all characters? Sparkpaw I guess…
Worst Parent?
Rainflower or Millie?
Squirrelflight (fostering The Three) or Leafpool?
Crowfeather or Nightcloud?
Of all I mentioned? Rainflower
Of all parents? Clear Sky
Best Name? (real characters)
Mapleshade or Lionblaze?
Brightflower or Appledawn?
Brambleberry or Dawnflower?
Ivypool or Deerdapple?
Echsong or Larksplash?
Leafstorm or Morningflower?
Of All I mentioned? Appledawn
Of all names? Wind Runner
Worst Name? (real characters)
Cypresspaw or Needletail?
Crouchfoot or Slightfoot?
Rooktail or Pearnose?
Echosnout or Rubblepaw?
Barkface or Daisytoe?
Deadfoot or Tornear?
Of all I mentioned? Echosnout
Of all names? Halftail
Best Name?
Breezesong or Swiftstorm?
Lightningstrike or Grasscloud?
Hawkshadow or Tallberry?
Gorsesplash or Willowsong?
Emberwind or Snowleaf?
Of all I mentioned? Swiftsong
Worst Name?
Maggotbreath or Bloodyclaw?
Curlysnout or Sloetoe?
Wormnose or Antface?
Logfur or Shortpelt?
Parsleycoat or Mallowball?
Of all I mentioned? Maggotbreath
Best Clan?
WindClan or ShadowClan?
ThunderClan or Riverclan?
SkyClan or ThunderClan?
Of all? WindClan
Worst of all? SkyClan by Default
please don't start any arguments about any of this stuff guys :3
- FoxysAnime
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
Honestly, I'm SUPER excited for a Warriors movie! I can't wait to see all that sweet action and drama before my eyes~ I loved the books and I bet I'll adore the movie. They better not butcher the series though…
- XxHawkwardxX
-
Scratcher
1 post
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
Honestly, I'm SUPER excited for a Warriors movie! I can't wait to see all that sweet action and drama before my eyes~ I loved the books and I bet I'll adore the movie. They better not butcher the series though…Yeah, the movie will probably be really cool… and I don't know about you guys, but I was bullied for liking Warriors irl, and when the movie comes out, and it gains popularity… then those bullies might like it even though they bullied people for liking it before ;m; That would be really pathetic and aggravating, you know? And the other crowd would just like it ignorantly.
- WildfiretheSandwing
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
I read Warriors because I was bored and wandering around the school library and one of the librarians said “read this child” or something along those lines and I did and I liked it so yes.I agree completely. It was basically asking for fanfics. Designed that way. Yeah, absolutely. Like I said before, it was asking for OC's.Well, I don't really know what to tell you there. What made you want to pick up the book? My point exactly. You took the words straight from my mouth.Blah, blah, snippity snip.I think another thing is that it's really easy to write Warriors fanfictions, at least for me. The way the whole Warriors universe is set up it's easy to make your own character and place them in it, too. And yeah Warrior cat names are real easy to make. Personally I didn't even like cats until reading warriors- I had a pet dog and thought dogs were the greatest things and cats sucked. Once I started reading Warriors I became obsessed with cats. I definitely liked to imagine the cats I soon got as warriors-i even attempted to write a warrior fanfic where one of them did become one.
I guess something else is Warriors was something new- basically wild cats that were social like dogs so dog and cat lovers would like it. Of course now there are so many Warriors rip-offs (i mean people write “original” fiction with groups of wild cats) that its pretty much the least original thing now. Warriors has fairly good plotlines, but the characters are either mary-sue or don't even have a real personality, so I cant understand how so many people can get so obsessed with the characters. Warriors probably has more reader x character fanfics than any other fandom
Honestly, I thought more people would reply to this rant. Maybe I just made too many liable points (totally not patting myself on the back there. Or, maybe they just didn't want to read the whole thing through.
- blossombreeze
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
I read Warriors because I was bored and wandering around the school library and one of the librarians said “read this child” or something along those lines and I did and I liked it so yes.
I got tired in a bookstore so I sat in a chair and there was a book in front of me with a picture of a cat on the cover. I love cats so I picked it up and read through the first few pages and I was hooked on Warriors from that moment on…
- VixenMangleTheFox
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
I read it because I had seen one of my friends reading it, then a bit later, I saw some random stranger reading Bluestar's Prophecy. I was also obsessed with cats for a while, and now I'm only behind by one book.I read Warriors because I was bored and wandering around the school library and one of the librarians said “read this child” or something along those lines and I did and I liked it so yes.
I got tired in a bookstore so I sat in a chair and there was a book in front of me with a picture of a cat on the cover. I love cats so I picked it up and read through the first few pages and I was hooked on Warriors from that moment on…
- FoxysAnime
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
True, true.Honestly, I'm SUPER excited for a Warriors movie! I can't wait to see all that sweet action and drama before my eyes~ I loved the books and I bet I'll adore the movie. They better not butcher the series though…Yeah, the movie will probably be really cool… and I don't know about you guys, but I was bullied for liking Warriors irl, and when the movie comes out, and it gains popularity… then those bullies might like it even though they bullied people for liking it before ;m; That would be really pathetic and aggravating, you know? And the other crowd would just like it ignorantly.
- enspcds
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
Warriors - by Erin Hunter
Has anyone noticed that most Thunderclan leaders are mentored by other Thunderclan leaders?
Such as:
Bluestar - mentored by Doestar (I think)
Firestar - mentored by Bluestar
Bramblestar - mentored by Firestar

Such as:
Bluestar - mentored by Doestar (I think)
Firestar - mentored by Bluestar
Bramblestar - mentored by Firestar

Last edited by enspcds (Nov. 4, 2016 22:29:40)









