Discuss Scratch

Djf18
Scratcher
37 posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

example is when searching up “ninja the” it will not show the ninja
mysinginmonsters
Scratcher
100+ posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

It searches for exactly what you type. It doesn't look for keywords.

Still a far better search engine than Roblox.
Djf18
Scratcher
37 posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

mysinginmonsters wrote:

It searches for exactly what you type. It doesn't look for keywords.

Still a far better search engine than Roblox.
true but there is a roblox game called “better explorer” which is a better search engine so is there any thing like that on scratch?

scratch should make a option to toggle keywords or exactly
Djf18
Scratcher
37 posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

Djf18 wrote:

mysinginmonsters wrote:

It searches for exactly what you type. It doesn't look for keywords.

Still a far better search engine than Roblox.
true but there is a roblox game called “better explorer” which is a better search engine so is there any thing like that on scratch?

scratch should make a option to toggle keywords or exactly
thanks by the way for telling why it is bad though
8to16
Scratcher
1000+ posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

Djf18 wrote:

(#3)
true but there is a roblox game called “better explorer” which is a better search engine so is there any thing like that on scratch?
Itching Discovery
60 SECOND DEMON BWAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
mysinginmonsters
Scratcher
100+ posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

Djf18 wrote:

thanks by the way for telling why it is bad though
I don't think it's bad. In fact, I think it's better for finding more relevant results.
Djf18
Scratcher
37 posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

mysinginmonsters wrote:

Djf18 wrote:

thanks by the way for telling why it is bad though
I don't think it's bad. In fact, I think it's better for finding more relevant results.
newrounds search engine is a example of what i want the search engine to be
Djf18
Scratcher
37 posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

8to16 wrote:

Djf18 wrote:

(#3)
true but there is a roblox game called “better explorer” which is a better search engine so is there any thing like that on scratch?
Itching Discovery
60 SECOND DEMON BWAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
it does not hace a search engine
8to16
Scratcher
1000+ posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

Djf18 wrote:

it does not hace a search engine
you can request that to be added on the topic

btw i got a bunch of results for “ninja the”
i_eat_coffee
Scratcher
1000+ posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

Djf18 wrote:

8to16 wrote:

Djf18 wrote:

(#3)
true but there is a roblox game called “better explorer” which is a better search engine so is there any thing like that on scratch?
Itching Discovery
60 SECOND DEMON BWAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
it does not hace a search engine
hey, I am the creator of that website
the search engine is currently being worked on, we are trying to make it as perfect and as inclusive as possible
themirrazz
Scratcher
89 posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

Apparently, the indexer stopped indexing new projects a while ago (iirc). You can search for projects by using the “<search query> site:scratch.mit.edu” on Google, which sometimes has better results. Note that Google searches the entire sites, including studios, user profiles, and forums, and it also might match unrelated projects based on the descriptions or comments sections. It also will list NFE projects as well, so if you don't want to see any NFE content, I don't recommend using Google.
Djf18
Scratcher
37 posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

i_eat_coffee wrote:

Djf18 wrote:

8to16 wrote:

Djf18 wrote:

(#3)
true but there is a roblox game called “better explorer” which is a better search engine so is there any thing like that on scratch?
Itching Discovery
60 SECOND DEMON BWAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
it does not hace a search engine
hey, I am the creator of that website
the search engine is currently being worked on, we are trying to make it as perfect and as inclusive as possible
thanks
BigNate469
Scratcher
1000+ posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

themirrazz wrote:

Apparently, the indexer stopped indexing new projects a while ago (iirc). You can search for projects by using the “<search query> site:scratch.mit.edu” on Google, which sometimes has better results. Note that Google searches the entire sites, including studios, user profiles, and forums, and it also might match unrelated projects based on the descriptions or comments sections. It also will list NFE projects as well, so if you don't want to see any NFE content, I don't recommend using Google.
I'm pretty sure that was fixed a few months ago. Still, Google might be a better search engine that Scratch's

mysinginmonsters wrote:

It searches for exactly what you type. It doesn't look for keywords.
And the results that appear are based on a complicated algorithm involving where words show up, and how frequently, that is also the reason tagspam (spamming tags in a project's description to make it appear higher in the Trending category) works, and that searching for anything and clicking on “Trending” is the equivalent of having a button for a tag that is your search query on the Explore page.

mysinginmonsters wrote:

Still a far better search engine than Roblox.
I second that.

There have been cases where I've searched for one thing on Roblox, and the first result is that thing, and the second is completely unrelated

Last edited by BigNate469 (Oct. 22, 2024 20:27:28)

ihavenocluewhythisis
Scratcher
500+ posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

themirrazz wrote:

Apparently, the indexer stopped indexing new projects a while ago (iirc). You can search for projects by using the “<search query> site:scratch.mit.edu” on Google, which sometimes has better results. Note that Google searches the entire sites, including studios, user profiles, and forums, and it also might match unrelated projects based on the descriptions or comments sections. It also will list NFE projects as well, so if you don't want to see any NFE content, I don't recommend using Google.
what does iirc mean
mysinginmonsters
Scratcher
100+ posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

BigNate469 wrote:

mysinginmonsters wrote:

It searches for exactly what you type. It doesn't look for keywords.
And the results that appear are based on a complicated algorithm involving where words show up, and how frequently, that is also the reason tagspam (spamming tags in a project's description to make it appear higher in the Trending category) works, and that searching for anything and clicking on “Trending” is the equivalent of having a button for a tag that is your search query on the Explore page.
I didn't know that tag spamming actually did something. May I ask where you found this information?
Scratch137
Scratcher
1000+ posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

mysinginmonsters wrote:

BigNate469 wrote:

mysinginmonsters wrote:

It searches for exactly what you type. It doesn't look for keywords.
And the results that appear are based on a complicated algorithm involving where words show up, and how frequently, that is also the reason tagspam (spamming tags in a project's description to make it appear higher in the Trending category) works, and that searching for anything and clicking on “Trending” is the equivalent of having a button for a tag that is your search query on the Explore page.
I didn't know that tag spamming actually did something. May I ask where you found this information?
The Explore page itself sort of proves this on its own. The Trending tab is flooded with projects that repeat the same few tags over and over again to appear higher in the list.

Last edited by Scratch137 (Oct. 23, 2024 18:50:06)

LittleTimmy123i
Scratcher
62 posts

why is the scratch search engine so bad?

It honestly probably worked well back in 2010 since there was way less projects than now.

Powered by DjangoBB