Discuss Scratch

M1mikyu
Scratcher
1000+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

With the High Contrast Blocks update, it was implied that more block color pallets would be added. I came up with an idea for one: a “classic” pallet!
This would switch the block colors to how they looked in 2.0.
Some block colors, most notably to me are the Custom Blocks, are very different in 3.0 than they were in 2.0. When following tutorials intended for Scratch 2.0, it can be confusing seeing the blocks be very different colors, making it harder to identify what blocks are what since the colors are so different.
This would also be nice for people who are nostalgic for the 2.0 era block colors! But the main reason it'd be useful is so that the block colors match up with 2.0torials rather than being incredibly different.

In 2.0, custom blocks were purple, but in 3.0 they're a pinkish red. Due to the drastic difference in color between 2.0 and 3.0 custom blocks, it can be confusing telling what blocks are what. Other block colors are just different shades of basically the same color, but custom blocks are a completely different color!
Will update OP with some mockups later

Last edited by M1mikyu (April 14, 2024 18:45:35)

ilovestories
Scratcher
1000+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions wrote:

2.3 Set the editor to look like older versions of Scratch
Some users prefer the look and feel of the older Scratch editors, and have suggested an option to make the editor look like an older version of Scratch (such as Scratch 1.4 or 2.0), but still run off of HTML5 like Scratch 3.0 does. However, this would be more complicated for educational and documentation purposes. It could be confusing if someone is trying to learn Scratch from someone who is using a completely different layout of the editor than them. In addition, the Scratch Team changed the design for a reason: to make it easier, more intuitive, and friendlier for newcomers to use.
I know that this suggestion is only for the blocks, but in my opinion, it's the same deal.
Then again, my opinion could easily be wrong.

Last edited by ilovestories (April 14, 2024 18:52:27)

MythosLore
Scratcher
1000+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

ilovestories wrote:

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions wrote:

2.3 Set the editor to look like older versions of Scratch
Some users prefer the look and feel of the older Scratch editors, and have suggested an option to make the editor look like an older version of Scratch (such as Scratch 1.4 or 2.0), but still run off of HTML5 like Scratch 3.0 does. However, this would be more complicated for educational and documentation purposes. It could be confusing if someone is trying to learn Scratch from someone who is using a completely different layout of the editor than them. In addition, the Scratch Team changed the design for a reason: to make it easier, more intuitive, and friendlier for newcomers to use.
I know that this suggestion is only for the blocks, but in my opinion, it's the same deal.
Then again, my opinion could easily be wrong.
This would only be for the colors of the blocks. Having 2.0-colored blocks wouldn't be any more confusing than high contrast blocks.
Za-Chary
Scratcher
1000+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

ilovestories wrote:

I know that this suggestion is only for the blocks, but in my opinion, it's the same deal.
Then again, my opinion could easily be wrong.
If the OP's suggestion is only asking to change the colors of the blocks, and not the overall shape/structure along with it, then I don't think this rejection applies. After all, we do currently have at least one alternate color palette for the Scratch blocks.
M1mikyu
Scratcher
1000+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

Za-Chary wrote:

ilovestories wrote:

I know that this suggestion is only for the blocks, but in my opinion, it's the same deal.
Then again, my opinion could easily be wrong.
If the OP's suggestion is only asking to change the colors of the blocks, and not the overall shape/structure along with it, then I don't think this rejection applies. After all, we do currently have at least one alternate color palette for the Scratch blocks.
In the High Contrast blocks announcement it was implied that more color pallets might be coming in the future

Ceebee wrote:

You can always change the color mode back or decide not to try High Contrast blocks at all! You may even see some new color mode options in the future.
Source: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/689659/
So I don't think adding a 2.0 block color pallet is out of the question

Last edited by M1mikyu (April 14, 2024 20:11:08)

M1mikyu
Scratcher
1000+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

ilovestories wrote:

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions wrote:

2.3 Set the editor to look like older versions of Scratch
Some users prefer the look and feel of the older Scratch editors, and have suggested an option to make the editor look like an older version of Scratch (such as Scratch 1.4 or 2.0), but still run off of HTML5 like Scratch 3.0 does. However, this would be more complicated for educational and documentation purposes. It could be confusing if someone is trying to learn Scratch from someone who is using a completely different layout of the editor than them. In addition, the Scratch Team changed the design for a reason: to make it easier, more intuitive, and friendlier for newcomers to use.
I know that this suggestion is only for the blocks, but in my opinion, it's the same deal.
Then again, my opinion could easily be wrong.
However, as I stated in the OP, due to the different color pallet it makes 2.0 based tutorials more confusing as many blocks have very different colors than they did originally. This would reduce confusion for people following 2.0 era tutorials
M1mikyu
Scratcher
1000+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

Bump
M1mikyu
Scratcher
1000+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

B
U
M
P
medians
Scratcher
1000+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

I feel like you should just be able to use a color picker, kind of like what happened with Edit Block Colors (a feature that was present in Scratch 2.0 when shift clicking the edit button [this was only in the online editor]):
M1mikyu
Scratcher
1000+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

medians wrote:

I feel like you should just be able to use a color picker, kind of like what happened with Edit Block Colors (a feature that was present in Scratch 2.0 when shift clicking the edit button [this was only in the online editor]):
Bringing back the ability to customize each block's color individually would be awesome, no idea why they removed it to begin with. It's a great accessibility feature, and it's also fun to make everything neon or grayscale.
M1mikyu
Scratcher
1000+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

bump
ChameleonGamerYT
Scratcher
500+ posts

"Classic" block color pallet

Support, would be pretty good for the 2.0 fans.

Powered by DjangoBB