Obv not about real deaths, but rather inactive scratch accounts, and itll be more of like a memorial type of thing idek
I dont remember anything that would specifically ban it (except maybe the “no naming and shaming” rule?), but it just sounds like something that might not be allowed

Its ok if you don't include why they went inactive

I think that would be allowed

What if certain users im mentioning were banned/deleted their account? (Obv the reasoning for they're ban/deletion wouldn't be included, but if the user was widely known, they it might be easy to recognize what had happened anyways)

For context, one of my friends had multiple top loved projects and was later involved in some pretty large controversy and stuff

HurricaneMitch1998M wrote:

if you don't include why they went inactive

Please elaborate.

EDawg2011 wrote:

HurricaneMitch1998M wrote:

if you don't include why they went inactive

Please elaborate.

I thought it was kind of clear as-is, but basically, you should not include the reasons for why a Scratcher went inactive in a project

yadayadayadagoodbye wrote:

What if certain users im mentioning were banned/deleted their account? (Obv the reasoning for they're ban/deletion wouldn't be included, but if the user was widely known, they it might be easy to recognize what had happened anyways)

For context, one of my friends had multiple top loved projects and was later involved in some pretty large controversy and stuff

You aren't spreading any gossip about what happened to the accounts, so that should also be fine

ajskateboarder wrote:

You aren't spreading any gossip about what happened to the accounts, so that should also be fine

True, however, im afraid it might cause argueing and stuff (then again its been like 2 years, it should be fine)

Did this myself before, wasn't a good idea but was meant for memorial purposes, so I'd say it's totally fine. As long as you aren't naming or listing the people who got banned or that deleted their accounts.

PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:

Did this myself before, wasn't a good idea but was meant for memorial purposes, so I'd say it's totally fine. As long as you aren't naming or listing the people who got banned or that deleted their accounts.

The important thing here is “naming”
Without naming the people (obv usernames), it kinda defeats the entire point of the project. I understand you cant list the reasons of their ban (or inactivity), but I don't believe theres any specific rules forbidding naming people (obv theres “no naming and shaming”, but that specifically refers to when it is related to gossip, I don't believe sharing the fact that they're inactive would be gossip.)

would be nice if you could provide what is forbidding providing usernames

yadayadayadagoodbye wrote:

if you could provide what is forbidding providing usernames, that would be nice

I don't know much about why or if they are forbidden, but I think it only applies if a certain user is either banned or deleted.

PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:

yadayadayadagoodbye wrote:

if you could provide what is forbidding providing usernames, that would be nice

I don't know much about why or if they are forbidden, but I think it only applies if a certain user is either banned or deleted.

wdym you don't know if its forbidden, but you know it applies to certain situations????

how do you not know if a rule even exists or not but know who it applies to