It's naming and shaming which is not allowed. Why does ST not follow the rules? Instead just remove it and add nothing. (And still alert).

Please note that Scratch Team should remove the entire sentence, or paragraph if it won't make sense.

Could help remove some hate, but I feel like it'd barely change anything since some people post alerts to complain.
Support nonetheless.
EDIT: This was worded too porly for me to not reword it

So, something like this?

Scratcher wrote:

Please unban they did nothing wrong!

Looks weird to me. “Removed by ST” is supposed to indicate that something was there and it was removed.

BobRocks20 wrote:

(#3)
So, something like this?

Scratcher wrote:

Please unban they did nothing wrong!

Looks weird to me. “Removed by ST” is supposed to indicate that something was there and it was removed.

That message would probably fully be removed, not just the name.

BobRocks20 wrote:

So, something like this?

Scratcher wrote:

Please unban they did nothing wrong!

Looks weird to me. “Removed by ST” is supposed to indicate that something was there and it was removed.

Remove the whole sentence, well in that case you can remove the post, and in that case you can dustbin the topic.

I think we all should consider this: why does ST close some topics that should be dustbinned instead of, well, dustbinning them?

glitcX wrote:

BobRocks20 wrote:

So, something like this?

Scratcher wrote:

Please unban they did nothing wrong!

Looks weird to me. “Removed by ST” is supposed to indicate that something was there and it was removed.

Remove the whole sentence, well in that case you can remove the post, and in that case you can dustbin the topic.

Sometimes, removing naming and shaming makes a question more general and less targeted toward someone. Removing topics that do this entirely would just leave the OP confused

bump

bump

bump

glitcX wrote:

bump

Don't spam bumps please. You must wait 24 hours and make sure your topic is off the front page before bumping.

Elijah999999 wrote:

glitcX wrote:

bump

Don't spam bumps please. You must wait 24 hours and make sure your topic is off the front page before bumping.

It was 20 hours and it was off the page

Yeah, no. It would make it very confusing and it isn't really naming and shaming, it's just saying that it was removed.

It seems like it would confuse the user why something isn't showing up, and they might think it's bug and try to add it back. Saying "[Removed by ST]" makes it clear what happened.

k7e wrote:

It seems like it would confuse the user why something isn't showing up, and they might think it's bug and try to add it back. Saying "[Removed by ST]" makes it clear what happened.

Note: this person got the about me changed by the st and never got the "[Removed by ST]" message
I still got it and it is completely normal-
don't need to remove the message, just got alerted by ST.
that's basically it, it doesn't confuse me

Removed by scratch/scratch team is easier to show something was removed other than just completely removing it, it could confuse scratchers if it wasn’t there

I don’t see why this is naming and shaming

gdfsgdfsgdfg wrote:

I don’t see why this is naming and shaming

I think it's because it implies that the person did something wrong.

No support. Mods should tell that it was removed themselves and not a hacker.

This is a good idea, but I just wanted to remind everyone that sometimes it could be a person pulling a prank bu putting "" on their profile.

Not saying ST doesn't do that, but it might also be something that was automated years ago.
Nonetheless, this is a good idea.