Discuss Scratch

hydrofungus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

Oh yeah, I don’t think this is a suggestion list, as they are almost the same thing - linking stuff in the forums.

Yeah, some of you may know the wiki tag, and it links to wiki articles
But then, how about a forum tag that links to the forums like Help with Scripts, Questions about Scratch etc.
This way, we could link forums more easily and we don’t have to grab the link every time a guy posted in the wrong forums or like that
Like this (han614698’s. Thanks for making the visualizations ):

[forum]Suggestions[/forum]

The next isn’t by me, it’s by han614698.

The forum ID
[forum=1]This would link to suggestions.[/forum]

Making hyperlinks with these
[forum=suggestions]This would link to suggestions.[/forum]

Along with post/topics too, if you somehow remember the numbers there.
[topic=712746]This would link to this topic.[/topic]
[post=7531899]This would link to han614693’s post.[/post]

And this is by __Falcon-Games__
A deleted tag for dustbinned posts/topics that would replace the normal “forum” and “post” tags, instead of returning a 403 page, the link could just become a text like this:

This post/topic has been dustbinned.

Last edited by hydrofungus (Sept. 27, 2023 11:31:28)

__Falcon-Games__
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

Why is the title, "An [img] thing or like that but for the forums", what does the [img] tag have to do with this suggestion?
hydrofungus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

Why is the title, "An [img] thing or like that but for the forums", what does the [img] tag have to do with this suggestion?
Basically an “[“ thing, but instead of the word “img”, it’s “forum’.
Yes my English is bad right now
han614698
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

So basically you mean a BBCode tag for other forums? That's not a bad idea.

All of the forums have IDs (a full comprehensive list is here). I suggest that you can link to those, like below.

[forum=1]This would link to suggestions.[/forum]

In addition, I think that we should be able to type the name in the tag AND between the tags, much like the [wiki] tag.

[forum=suggestions]This would link to suggestions.[/forum]
[forum]Suggestions[/forum]

I'd also propose a topic and post one, like this -
[topic=712746]This would link to this topic.[/topic]
[post=7531899]This would link to this post.[/post]

Last edited by han614698 (Sept. 24, 2023 23:12:23)

-Valtren-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

Support, this is a good idea. Linking forums will be easier at notice.

In the meantime, one can use text replacements(or just copy paste from some sort of list, but this is technically faster):

hydrofungus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

-Valtren- wrote:

Support, this is a good idea. Linking forums will be easier at notice.

In the meantime, one can use text replacements(or just copy paste from some sort of list, but this is technically faster):
What replacement? Is it on mobile?
scratchcode1_2_3
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

hydrofungus wrote:

-Valtren- wrote:

Support, this is a good idea. Linking forums will be easier at notice.

In the meantime, one can use text replacements(or just copy paste from some sort of list, but this is technically faster):
What replacement? Is it on mobile?
It's when you set autocorrect to something you use often. I don't know how to get it on computers, though.
ReinoScreech
Scratcher
500+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

This can actually be really helpful since it does make the process to link a topic / forum more quicker than what it currently is right now, someone is probably going to use this (if it does get accepted, likely not though)
hydrofungus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

I summon the bump to this topic
__Falcon-Games__
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

When I first saw this, I was confused. Now it's clearer.
Would this just be a text link or be a widget link?
hydrofungus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

When I first saw this, I was confused. Now it's clearer.
Would this just be a text link or be a widget link?
Can you explain more?
__Falcon-Games__
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

hydrofungus wrote:

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

When I first saw this, I was confused. Now it's clearer.
Would this just be a text link or be a widget link?
Can you explain more?
A text link is like this.
A widget link is that but with an image showing information about the forum.
Sorry I couldn't provide mockups, I have to used my tablet right now.

Last edited by __Falcon-Games__ (Sept. 26, 2023 11:59:32)

hydrofungus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

hydrofungus wrote:

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

When I first saw this, I was confused. Now it's clearer.
Would this just be a text link or be a widget link?
Can you explain more?
A text link is like this.
A widget link is that but with an image showing information about the forum.
Sorry I couldn't provide mockups, I have to used my tablet right now.
That would be a text link then
ajskateboarder
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

hydrofungus wrote:

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

When I first saw this, I was confused. Now it's clearer.
Would this just be a text link or be a widget link?
Can you explain more?
A text link is like this.
A widget link is that but with an image showing information about the forum.
Sorry I couldn't provide mockups, I have to used my tablet right now.
Well, widget links would be nice, but it may not be worth working on over plain text links, especially considering that s2forums are deprecated
__Falcon-Games__
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

ajskateboarder wrote:

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

hydrofungus wrote:

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

When I first saw this, I was confused. Now it's clearer.
Would this just be a text link or be a widget link?
Can you explain more?
A text link is like this.
A widget link is that but with an image showing information about the forum.
Sorry I couldn't provide mockups, I have to used my tablet right now.
Well, widget links would be nice, but it may not be worth working on over plain text links, especially considering that s2forums are deprecated
It would be easy as making an image for each forum and using that image as the content of the link.
hydrofungus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

__Falcon-Games__
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

In the case that the post or topic listed becomes deleted instead of the link becoming a confusing 403 page it could replaced it with a new BBcode tag [deleted] which would say that the corresponding post or topic is deleted in a widget, you could also use this directly to reference a post or topic which is deleted. No more needing to edit posts or topics when a referenced post or topic becomes dustbinned!
hydrofungus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

In the case that the post or topic listed becomes deleted instead of the link becoming a confusing 403 page it could replaced it with a new BBcode tag [deleted] which would say that the corresponding post or topic is deleted in a widget, you could also use this directly to reference a post or topic which is deleted. No more needing to edit posts or topics when a referenced post or topic becomes dustbinned!
Yeah, this could be great.
Though let’s wait until the suggestion gets a bit more attention, then I’ll see if adding that too would be nice.
__Falcon-Games__
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

hydrofungus wrote:

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

In the case that the post or topic listed becomes deleted instead of the link becoming a confusing 403 page it could replaced it with a new BBcode tag [deleted] which would say that the corresponding post or topic is deleted in a widget, you could also use this directly to reference a post or topic which is deleted. No more needing to edit posts or topics when a referenced post or topic becomes dustbinned!
Yeah, this could be great.
Though let’s wait until the suggestion gets a bit more attention, then I’ll see if adding that too would be nice.
Waiting until this gets more attention isn't a good reason to stop improving the suggestion?
hydrofungus
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A “forum”, “post” and “topic” BBcode tags

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

hydrofungus wrote:

__Falcon-Games__ wrote:

In the case that the post or topic listed becomes deleted instead of the link becoming a confusing 403 page it could replaced it with a new BBcode tag [deleted] which would say that the corresponding post or topic is deleted in a widget, you could also use this directly to reference a post or topic which is deleted. No more needing to edit posts or topics when a referenced post or topic becomes dustbinned!
Yeah, this could be great.
Though let’s wait until the suggestion gets a bit more attention, then I’ll see if adding that too would be nice.
Waiting until this gets more attention isn't a good reason to stop improving the suggestion?
Oh…
Okay-

Can the BBcodes replace each other? I intended for the links to be a text link, I didn’t think about widgets in the first place. If the deleted thing could replace other ones, how would it be shown using text?

Powered by DjangoBB