Discuss Scratch

100+ posts

What is wrong with "A curator should add this soon"?

I have noticed many featured studios and the SDSs do not count that as helping. It does not bother me that much, and I count that as helping.

Remember to enter my 100 follower contest! You can also be a prize giver!

1000+ posts

What is wrong with "A curator should add this soon"?

How does it benefit anyone at all? They already know a curator will add it soon. It's not feedback, it's not useful information, it's just something that people who want to be invited say.

Step 1: Find a question you don't know the answer to.
Step 2: Post a reply saying “I don't know!”
Hello there! I'm TheAnimalKingdom42, a female digital artist and a lover of zoology. No matter how bad your day is, you can make it better by making others' days better!
1000+ posts

What is wrong with "A curator should add this soon"?

I agree that it's not really too helpful. Since curators have to check anyway whether or not a project can be added to the studio, saying this sort of thing doesn't really say them any time in the long run. It also makes things awkward if someone says “This will be added soon” but a curator never gets around to adding it (due to curator inactivity, lots of requests, etc.).

What I do think is helpful is if you happen to check the project and find some reason why it cannot be featured — for example, the project was made by the user proposing it. Then it should be perfectly acceptable/helpful to tell them “Sorry, you cannot propose your own project to be featured.” Then a curator could look at that reply comment and not waste their time checking to see if the project could be added.

Be moist

If you're interested in getting constructive feedback on your recent forum posts, let me know on my profile!

This is my forum signature! On a forum post, it is okay for Scratchers to advertise in their forum signature. The signature is the stuff that shows up below the horizontal line on the post. It will show up on every post I make.

I was a Scratch Team member from May 10th 2019 to October 29th 2021.

my notebook
500+ posts

What is wrong with "A curator should add this soon"?

Well, They look at the oldest comments first, and it goes up to the newest comments.
Also, they have to check the games / projects / animations or whatever to make sure it fits the studio and that it's not inappropriate.

Think this is my 500th post…

For Paddle2See 20/06/22 PADDLE2SEE NOTICED ME :O

if you want to see the rest of my signature then highlight some text then press ctrl, shift, down at the same time and hold down until you wanna stop going down or until the bottom of my signature.

btw i will recreate your profile picture in scratch (inspired by @scoldercreations)
Click here

or… with pencils and sharpies or whatever here.

If I was providing an answer, I hope it helped!

– Popjam12

100+ posts

What is wrong with "A curator should add this soon"?

I would say that it is helpful in a way. Many people use that as a way to get invited to the studio. However, simply posting a comment like this is not really considered feedback. A more constructive comment would be like this for example, “I loved how you added the music to some of the intense parts of the project. Consider adding some effects! It should be added soon.”

Roles: Forumer, SDS Helper, Scratch Wikian, Community Helper
Achievements: 3x trending, 13x Scratch Studio Curator, 3x SDS Helper, 6x Curated, etc

SDS Helpersl
Check out the SDS Helpers website:https://materarc.github.io/sdshelpers.github.io/

Powered by DjangoBB

Standard | Mobile