Discuss Scratch

the_gamearena
Scratcher
4 posts

Stealing projects. THIS MUST CHANGE!

Introduction
It's only a few minutes ago, that was when I realised how easy
it is to steal projects.

It's been around for
years at this point, yet, the scratch team didn't fully fix it yet.

In here, I'll talk about the problem and how they could potentially
stop it.

How does it work?
Well look if you take any project and click on “see inside” you
can download the project, once you downloaded it you can
create a new project, load the file and now the credits are gone.

What's the effect?
People can get away with stealing projects.

They can make a project, wait for a new game, steal it
and then publish as if it is their project.

This causes the actual creator(s) to be accused by
stealing other peoples projects.

How do you fix it?
Well I know that this is already against the rules, and people
can get banned.

The only problem with this is that there's a
chance that they can still get away with it.

Also mentioned in "How does it work?" this is done by downloading
the project. The way we can fix this is by putting
some more information in the file of the project. Maybe some
sort of variable? Some variable that defines who's
project it is?

Last words
I really hope this helps and spread the awareness of
how messed up this truly is.

Last edited by the_gamearena (July 10, 2021 10:06:21)

Reev0102
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Stealing projects. THIS MUST CHANGE!

This is not a bug or glitch, so this topic does not belong in Bugs and Glitches.
the_gamearena
Scratcher
4 posts

Stealing projects. THIS MUST CHANGE!

Well where can I post it?
Infinity-Studios5674
Scratcher
100+ posts

Stealing projects. THIS MUST CHANGE!

If someone steals a project without remixing the original project or giving credit to the original creator then you can just report it.


..╭━━━━━━╮
╭┃ ╭━━━━╮
┃┃ ╰━━━━╯
┃┃

amongus
Vadik1
Scratcher
500+ posts

Stealing projects. THIS MUST CHANGE!

the_gamearena wrote:

Well where can I post it?
Generally topics like this belong to Suggestions.

However, this shouldn't be reposted there post since it's already been suggested and suggestions forum has “no duplicate” rule.

I mostly make 3D projects. Here are some of them:

kccuber
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Stealing projects. THIS MUST CHANGE!

the_gamearena wrote:

Also mentioned in "How does it work?" this is done by downloading
the project. The way we can fix this is by putting
some more information in the file of the project. Maybe some
sort of variable? Some variable that defines who's
project it is?
a randomized hash like in passwords would be better but this is Not A Bug. Reporting to be closed. (dont worry you wont get banned for this)


Made using Nord Theme & Inkscape
Harakou
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Stealing projects. THIS MUST CHANGE!

If someone is circumventing the project credit system, please report the project for not giving credit. If you want to discuss possible improvements to this system, then please use the existing suggestion - thanks.

Powered by DjangoBB