You should mute people who comment the word "hate"

Artkids5000

I have noticed that a lot of people have been commenting the word “hate” On projects they don't like. I think the scratch team should mute people who say the word hate in the comments. Some people don't know there bounderys and need to learn them. Don't believe me? Well just ask around! I really want people to be given POSITIVE feed back, not negative feed back that makes them feel like losers. Please scratch team mute people who comment the word hate in a negitive way

Za-Chary

There are quite a number of uses for “hate” that aren't geared towards someone's creation. “I hate homework” is one example.

Futurebot5

What if someone said: “Report hate comments”?

Sikecon

Even though “hate” is not a good word, the posters above ^^^ have a point. “Hate” is sometimes just another word to express their feelings and their thoughts. Besides, not all comments are leaning towards someone's creation, and you can't just mute people for that.

scratchieguy12345678

Sikecon wrote:
Even though “hate” is not a good word, the posters above ^^^ have a point. “Hate” is sometimes just another word to express their feelings and their thoughts. Besides, not all comments are leaning towards someone's creation, and you can't just mute people for that.

Yeah, it all depends on context. No support.

bobosigianan

Even if you do type the term ‘Hate’, it does not always mean you are hating on someone or their Projects. So, I oppose on this one.

Swear words, however? People who use those should be muted.

Jonathan50

The OP did say to mute those who use the word in a negative way. It might be a good idea to make the filter prevent one from posting a comment which isn't a reply and has no words but “hate.”

fdreerf

Jonathan50 wrote:
The OP did say to mute those who use the word in a negative way. It might be a good idea to make the filter prevent one from posting a comment which isn't a reply and has no words but “hate.”

“hate hate hate hate” isn't a very coherent statement that can offend someone. It's pretty much nonsense.

Last edited by fdreerf (April 29, 2021 03:57:11)

NormalMaker

Jonathan50 wrote:
The OP did say to mute those who use the word in a negative way. It might be a good idea to make the filter prevent one from posting a comment which isn't a reply and has no words but “hate.”

Why would someone just type ‘hate’? If they were talking about a project then they would probably say something along the lines of ‘I hate this project’.

PkmnQ

Artkids5000 wrote:
I have noticed that a lot of people have been commenting the word “hate” On projects they don't like.

NormalMaker

PkmnQ wrote:
Artkids5000 wrote:
I have noticed that a lot of people have been commenting the word “hate” On projects they don't like.

There's no way to tell whether they meant that people were just commenting ‘hate’, they could have just phrased that sentence poorly.

mybearworld

Sure, “I hat this project”, but maybe someone misspells “hat”, or

Za-Chary wrote:
There are quite a number of uses for “hate” that aren't geared towards someone's creation. “I hate homework” is one example.

Jonathan50

fdreerf wrote:
“hate hate hate hate” isn't a very coherent statement that can offend someone. It's pretty much nonsense.

NormalMaker wrote:
Why would someone just type ‘hate’? If they were talking about a project then they would probably say something along the lines of ‘I hate this project’.

I agree, though that's sort of what I had the impression the OP's first sentence was talking about. (People may make comments like “bad,” though.)

-EmeraldThunder-

Za-Chary wrote:
There are quite a number of uses for “hate” that aren't geared towards someone's creation. “I hate homework” is one example.

It's not a positive thing to say and can encourage frequent negativity and reluctance to preform the action.

dertermenter

-EmeraldThunder- wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
There are quite a number of uses for “hate” that aren't geared towards someone's creation. “I hate homework” is one example.
It's not a positive thing to say and can encourage frequent negativity and reluctance to preform the action.

What? Saying “I hate homework” encourages bad behaviour? Za-Chary is just pointing out a flaw in the sugggestion. It’s not even that bad of a word

Cupcake19880

No support. “hate” like @Za-Chary said, can be used for many reasons. Like it could be even used for doing good things like saying “Stop commenting hate on random projects” or something like that. Or they could just be giving feedback like "What i like about the project is that you can move the cat but what i hate about the project is that you cannot move gobo." So i don't think you should do that.

Last edited by Cupcake19880 (April 29, 2021 15:10:24)

p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-

Za-Chary wrote:
There are quite a number of uses for “hate” that aren't geared towards someone's creation. “I hate homework” is one example.

what about muting people who comment ONLY “hate” and “I hate this”?

Artkids5000

p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p- wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
There are quite a number of uses for “hate” that aren't geared towards someone's creation. “I hate homework” is one example.
what about muting people who comment ONLY “hate” and “I hate this”?

yes,

p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p- wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
There are quite a number of uses for “hate” that aren't geared towards someone's creation. “I hate homework” is one example.
what about muting people who comment ONLY “hate” and “I hate this”?

Yes!

TheTrillion

People could say

Scratcher wrote:
I hate having to run!

and they would be muted. There are no bots that exist that can detect context, and they would be difficult to program.

Last edited by TheTrillion (Feb. 23, 2022 05:04:46)

p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-

TheTrillion wrote:
No support. People could say
Somebody wrote:
I hate having to run!
and they would be muted. And before you say it'll detect context, no bots that can do that exist.

Artkids5000 wrote:
p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p-p- wrote:
Za-Chary wrote:
There are quite a number of uses for “hate” that aren't geared towards someone's creation. “I hate homework” is one example.
what about muting people who comment ONLY “hate” and “I hate this”?
Yes!

Discuss Scratch