Discuss Scratch

gosoccerboy5
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

A lot of suggestions go to more advanced concepts such as custom reporters and the like. I even have my own advanced suggestion. I think a lot of these ideas are great, but a common complaint is that they'd clutter up the UI and/or would be confusing to new Scratchers. So, I have a solution to these problems! If we create a new Scratch Extension for advanced blocks like custom reporters and other cool stuff also in Snap!, advanced Scratchers could use it, New Scratchers don't need to use it, and intermediate Scratchers can ignore it. Win-win-win!

I'm not sure how it works, maybe the new blocks appear in their normal category (eg advanced sensing blocks now go in Sensing) or all the advanced blocks go under the “Advanced Blocks” Extension.

I know it's a long shot but please consider it??

ATTENTION it looks like this is a dupe so yeah go here: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/379628/

Last edited by gosoccerboy5 (Nov. 4, 2020 02:31:54)

latin_gamerX
Scratcher
500+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

eh, I'm kinda in between on this one.
ScratchReinert
Scratcher
100+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

I would like to build on that saying what if there is an option in account settings marked “I'm an advanced scratcher” to enable these sorts of features it could also provide a couple of useful resources when clicked, there wouldn't be a minimum amount of time your account has to exist.
-InsanityPlays-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

Support because Scratch is a beginner's programming language, but many people want to use advanced blocks.
gosoccerboy5
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

ScratchReinert wrote:

I would like to build on that saying what if there is an option in account settings marked “I'm an advanced scratcher” to enable these sorts of features it could also provide a couple of useful resources when clicked, there wouldn't be a minimum amount of time your account has to exist.

That might feel inaccessible to some but I see where you're coming from. Maybe if we implemented that then there should be some sort of easily accessible link to it.
gosoccerboy5
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

-InsanityPlays- wrote:

Support because Scratch is a beginner's programming language, but many people want to use advanced blocks.

Ya, I mean Scratch is like the only thing I know, like even Tosh is too hard for me. But there are some features I'd like. Scratch has that awesome experience of being great for beginners but also has an amazing community. I'd like to bring the outside world in, so to speak.
MartianSoil
Scratcher
100+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

latin_gamerX wrote:

eh, I'm kinda in between on this one.

Yeah, same here. I really want it in real Scratch, but I feel like this would also be a good way to implement it.
mitdk
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

I actually support as i have seen a lot of posts get the reply of “That might be too complicated for scratch”. This would be a great way of implementing advanced features into scratch!
mitdk
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

gosoccerboy5 wrote:

ScratchReinert wrote:

I would like to build on that saying what if there is an option in account settings marked “I'm an advanced scratcher” to enable these sorts of features it could also provide a couple of useful resources when clicked, there wouldn't be a minimum amount of time your account has to exist.

That might feel inaccessible to some but I see where you're coming from. Maybe if we implemented that then there should be some sort of easily accessible link to it.
Maybe it could be a feature for scratchers only, a bit like cloud variables?
gosoccerboy5
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

mitdk wrote:

gosoccerboy5 wrote:

ScratchReinert wrote:

I would like to build on that saying what if there is an option in account settings marked “I'm an advanced scratcher” to enable these sorts of features it could also provide a couple of useful resources when clicked, there wouldn't be a minimum amount of time your account has to exist.

That might feel inaccessible to some but I see where you're coming from. Maybe if we implemented that then there should be some sort of easily accessible link to it.
Maybe it could be a feature for scratchers only, a bit like cloud variables?
That'd be a good idea.
mitdk
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

There are only 2 things(neither of them are huge problems),

1)Is getting a scratcher status a milestone that makes you advanced enough for this?

2)This is probably(if accepted) something that is a long shot like gosoccerboy5 said.

Last edited by mitdk (Oct. 1, 2020 21:23:05)

Joaovtor
Scratcher
49 posts

New Scratch Extension?

What kind of advanced blocks where you thinking of?
gosoccerboy5
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

Joaovtor wrote:

What kind of advanced blocks where you thinking of?
There's a list by @ProdigyZeta7 somewhere.. I'll try to dig it up..

Here it is. ProdigyZeta7's Block Wish List

Also, here's another one. Better Custom Blocks

(And here's mine, just to keep all the links in one place.)

Last edited by gosoccerboy5 (Oct. 1, 2020 22:10:33)

gosoccerboy5
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

Bummmmmmmmp??????????
gosoccerboy5
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

As it turns out there is a suggestion like this so I think this is a duplicate, sorry (click the sad guy for the link)
gosoccerboy5
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

Bupppity

Sorry, you have to wait 60 seconds between posts.
MartianSoil
Scratcher
100+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

MartianSoil wrote:

latin_gamerX wrote:

eh, I'm kinda in between on this one.

Yeah, same here. I really want it in real Scratch, but I feel like this would also be a good way to implement it.

Okay, I have changed my mind. This would allow for so many features that are “to complicated” for Scratch.
gosoccerboy5
Scratcher
1000+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

MartianSoil wrote:

MartianSoil wrote:

latin_gamerX wrote:

eh, I'm kinda in between on this one.

Yeah, same here. I really want it in real Scratch, but I feel like this would also be a good way to implement it.

Okay, I have changed my mind. This would allow for so many features that are “to complicated” for Scratch.
Thanks!!!! Idk if I should redirect you to here..
MartianSoil
Scratcher
100+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

gosoccerboy5 wrote:

MartianSoil wrote:

MartianSoil wrote:

latin_gamerX wrote:

eh, I'm kinda in between on this one.

Yeah, same here. I really want it in real Scratch, but I feel like this would also be a good way to implement it.

Okay, I have changed my mind. This would allow for so many features that are “to complicated” for Scratch.
Thanks!!!! Idk if I should redirect you to here..
I saw that thread earlier today, but thanks anyway.
MartianSoil
Scratcher
100+ posts

New Scratch Extension?

gosoccerboy5 wrote:

I'm not sure how it works, maybe the new blocks appear in their normal category (eg advanced sensing blocks now go in Sensing) or all the advanced blocks go under the “Advanced Blocks” Extension.

I think that this could also work: Make separate categories (i.e“Advanced Operators”) for blocks like
pi :: operators reporter

Edit: Fixed block thing

Last edited by MartianSoil (Oct. 5, 2020 20:47:18)

Powered by DjangoBB