Scratch and China (Discussion on Recent Website Block)

Felix-13

我都唔知

Byron_Inc

Felix-13 wrote:

Please don't spam.

-Zyte-

Felix-13 wrote:
Chinese government is good to block because “Free HK” project 涉及國家安全的問題

What they said is that it is good for the Chinese government to block Scratch because the “Free HK” movement on Scratch, because it is interfering with China, as an country, it's safety. (Which is basically stability and not an mess.)

ResExsention

-Zyte- wrote:
Felix-13 wrote:
Chinese government is good to block because “Free HK” project 涉及國家安全的問題
What they said is that it is good for the Chinese government to block Scratch because the “Free HK” movement on Scratch, because it is interfering with China, as an country, it's safety. (Which is basically stability and not an mess.)

Nah, it's nationalism. The last thing China wants is for Hong Kong to go rogue and become independent.

They certainly don't want a democratic bastion right outside their front door.

scratch978654

ResExsention wrote:
-Zyte- wrote:
Felix-13 wrote:
Chinese government is good to block because “Free HK” project 涉及國家安全的問題
What they said is that it is good for the Chinese government to block Scratch because the “Free HK” movement on Scratch, because it is interfering with China, as an country, it's safety. (Which is basically stability and not an mess.)

Nah, it's nationalism. The last thing China wants is for Hong Kong to go rogue and become independent.

They certainly don't want a democratic bastion right outside their front door.

Yeah HK legally belongs to them, but since Scratch seems to support democracy, China banned it

Last edited by scratch978654 (Aug. 16, 2020 09:59:32)

dragon0307

qrcool wrote:
Byron_Inc wrote:
BearSlothCoding wrote:
[insert some quotes of above posts here, I can't quote a single one of them without half of this statement not making sense]
But freedom of speech is legal in the US, where Scratch is based and where most users live. Banning freedom of speech just so China is happy would be silly.
Exactly, that's why China banned Scratch.
Yeah…
Also, wouldn't banning freedom of speech be illegal?
It's literally in the Constitution.

Constitution is an American thing.

gavinye2018

scratch978654 wrote:
ResExsention wrote:
-Zyte- wrote:
Felix-13 wrote:
Chinese government is good to block because “Free HK” project 涉及國家安全的問題
What they said is that it is good for the Chinese government to block Scratch because the “Free HK” movement on Scratch, because it is interfering with China, as an country, it's safety. (Which is basically stability and not an mess.)

Nah, it's nationalism. The last thing China wants is for Hong Kong to go rogue and become independent.

They certainly don't want a democratic bastion right outside their front door.
Yeah HK legally belongs to them, but since Scratch seems to support democracy, China banned it

Guys, have you ever read the Wikipedia? Have you ever learned history (or social studies). It literally says that after ww2, England Admit to returning Hong Kong to China（smthing like that）

Byron_Inc

gavinye2018 wrote:
scratch978654 wrote:
ResExsention wrote:
-Zyte- wrote:
Felix-13 wrote:
Chinese government is good to block because “Free HK” project 涉及國家安全的問題
What they said is that it is good for the Chinese government to block Scratch because the “Free HK” movement on Scratch, because it is interfering with China, as an country, it's safety. (Which is basically stability and not an mess.)

Nah, it's nationalism. The last thing China wants is for Hong Kong to go rogue and become independent.

They certainly don't want a democratic bastion right outside their front door.
Yeah HK legally belongs to them, but since Scratch seems to support democracy, China banned it
Guys, have you ever read the Wikipedia? Have you ever learned history (or social studies). It literally says that after ww2, England Admit to returning Hong Kong to China（smthing like that）

I think not in their textbooks.
But I think is the 100 year agreement is over, so England have to return HK to China.

jiuxiongdi

I get why scratch is banned. China may think it has bad influence on the country, since Hong Kong, Taiwan, and Macau are listed as countries.

pavcato

NOTANO0B wrote:
4096bits wrote:
leogames2016 wrote:
qrcool wrote:
leogames2016 wrote:
A bit sad… I think it should be temporarily because of mean people trying to swear in Chinese or something that they don't understand.
No, it's because the CCP saw some stuff they didn't like, including, but not limited to, Hong Kong and Taiwan being listed as countries. The ban might be permanent if Scratch doesn't clearly show communist views. That is, if you're talking about why China banned Scratch.

Aaah. Scratch Should Ban Communist Views for Some Countries. But not Worldwide.
But Scratch supports freedom of speech under the ToU…
that's illegal in china yk
freedom of speech is totally illegal

Actually, freedom of speech is legal in china.

-Zyte-

pavcato wrote:
NOTANO0B wrote:
4096bits wrote:
leogames2016 wrote:
qrcool wrote:
leogames2016 wrote:
A bit sad… I think it should be temporarily because of mean people trying to swear in Chinese or something that they don't understand.
No, it's because the CCP saw some stuff they didn't like, including, but not limited to, Hong Kong and Taiwan being listed as countries. The ban might be permanent if Scratch doesn't clearly show communist views. That is, if you're talking about why China banned Scratch.

Aaah. Scratch Should Ban Communist Views for Some Countries. But not Worldwide.
But Scratch supports freedom of speech under the ToU…
that's illegal in china yk
freedom of speech is totally illegal
Actually, freedom of speech is legal in china.

as long as your not offending the government or saying anything that interferes with the country's saftey.

leahcimto

(deleted by leachimto)

Last edited by leahcimto (Aug. 16, 2020 14:30:53)

pavcato

-Zyte- wrote:
pavcato wrote:
NOTANO0B wrote:
4096bits wrote:
leogames2016 wrote:
qrcool wrote:
leogames2016 wrote:
A bit sad… I think it should be temporarily because of mean people trying to swear in Chinese or something that they don't understand.
No, it's because the CCP saw some stuff they didn't like, including, but not limited to, Hong Kong and Taiwan being listed as countries. The ban might be permanent if Scratch doesn't clearly show communist views. That is, if you're talking about why China banned Scratch.

Aaah. Scratch Should Ban Communist Views for Some Countries. But not Worldwide.
But Scratch supports freedom of speech under the ToU…
that's illegal in china yk
freedom of speech is totally illegal
Actually, freedom of speech is legal in china.
as long as your not offending the government or saying anything that interferes with the country's saftey.

Well, if you say something like a threat, the US will do the same thing.

-Zyte-

pavcato wrote:
-Zyte- wrote:
pavcato wrote:
NOTANO0B wrote:
4096bits wrote:
leogames2016 wrote:
qrcool wrote:
leogames2016 wrote:
A bit sad… I think it should be temporarily because of mean people trying to swear in Chinese or something that they don't understand.
No, it's because the CCP saw some stuff they didn't like, including, but not limited to, Hong Kong and Taiwan being listed as countries. The ban might be permanent if Scratch doesn't clearly show communist views. That is, if you're talking about why China banned Scratch.

Aaah. Scratch Should Ban Communist Views for Some Countries. But not Worldwide.
But Scratch supports freedom of speech under the ToU…
that's illegal in china yk
freedom of speech is totally illegal
Actually, freedom of speech is legal in china.
as long as your not offending the government or saying anything that interferes with the country's saftey.
Well, if you say something like a threat, the US will do the same thing.

yes, it's normal for every country, but some are more chill™ than others.

BearSlothCoding

dragon0307 wrote:
qrcool wrote:
Also, wouldn't banning freedom of speech be illegal?
It's literally in the Constitution.

Constitution is an American thing.

That's kind of our point. Since Scratch is based in America, everything on Scratch has to abide by US law.

pavcato wrote:
-Zyte- wrote:
pavcato wrote:
]Actually, freedom of speech is legal in china.
as long as your not offending the government or saying anything that interferes with the country's saftey.
Well, if you say something like a threat, the US will do the same thing.

You can't threaten the US government, but you can insult it and nothing will happen. In China, can you call the president incompetent?

DancingNekoGirl

BearSlothCoding wrote:
pavcato wrote:
-Zyte- wrote:
pavcato wrote:
]Actually, freedom of speech is legal in china.
as long as your not offending the government or saying anything that interferes with the country's saftey.
Well, if you say something like a threat, the US will do the same thing.
You can't threaten the US government, but you can insult it and nothing will happen. In China, can you call the president incompetent?

Well, this might have something to do with the new security law passed in Hong Kong. It does give the government of China more control over the media, internet, etc.

64lu

BearSlothCoding wrote:
You can't threaten the US government, but you can insult it and nothing will happen.

not usually anyways

Basic88

Bump (the topic fell off the first page)

jiuxiongdi

Basic88 wrote:
Bump (the topic fell off the first page)

Please don't post comments that aren't related.

pavcato

jiuxiongdi wrote:
Basic88 wrote:
Bump (the topic fell off the first page)
Please don't post comments that aren't related.

A bump is to bring it back to the first page.

Discuss Scratch