Discuss Scratch

abualrob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

I think we should add “studios” that contain studios. Should we call it a “megastudio”?

Last edited by Paddle2See (July 29, 2019 09:56:51)

-Reshiram-
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

I would suggest calling it a “gallery” (Scratch 1.4's name for studios) but I support!

I am now @SquirreIstar with an i, as in “I used to be -Reshiram-”
abualrob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

-Reshiram- wrote:

I would suggest calling it a “gallery” (Scratch 1.4's name for studios) but I support!
Thanks for the name, because mega studio was the best name i can think of!
SookiDitto
Scratcher
63 posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

Can you think of any useful situations where you would need or want a gallery?

“Television is a vast wasteland.” -Newton N. Minow
-Reshiram-
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

SookiDitto wrote:

Can you think of any useful situations where you would need or want a gallery?
A gallery containing all of the SDSes?

I am now @SquirreIstar with an i, as in “I used to be -Reshiram-”
WindOctahedron
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

Then why won't we create “2nd degree galleries” that contain galleries? And “3rd degree galleries” that contain 2nd degree galleries? And “4th degree galleries” that contain 3rd degree galleries?
Anyway, this can continue forever.

The message above may contain wrong information, rude remarks, or something embarrassing to my current self. In this case, please ignore it and remember that I likely wrote it back when I didn't know what “respect” truly meant. I really hate thinking about it again.
Hi_I_am_Alex
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

Well, this is interesting. First, I was all up for it, but now the following makes me rethink.

WindOctahedron wrote:

Then why won't we create “2nd degree galleries” that contain galleries? And “3rd degree galleries” that contain 2nd degree galleries? And “4th degree galleries” that contain 3rd degree galleries?
Anyway, this can continue forever.
Perhaps we could have just studios and galleries, there cannot be galleries that can hold galleries?

Hi, nice to meet you! I am Alex.
*Disclaimer - my real name is not Alex
abualrob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

Hi_I_am_Alex wrote:

Well, this is interesting. First, I was all up for it, but now the following makes me rethink.

WindOctahedron wrote:

Then why won't we create “2nd degree galleries” that contain galleries? And “3rd degree galleries” that contain 2nd degree galleries? And “4th degree galleries” that contain 3rd degree galleries?
Anyway, this can continue forever.
Perhaps we could have just studios and galleries, there cannot be galleries that can hold galleries?
I really dont want galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries.
EZ-Games
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

I think having galleries would help organize certain studios, for example, Scratch Battles, a thing I am doing, has a lot of studios, so having a gallery for Scratch Battles would really help with organization, so I support.


God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but to save the world through him.
John 3:17

Advice:
Saying “Support” or “No Support” doesn't contribute anything to the conversation.
A question that has already been answered doesn't need to be answered twice with the same answer - bring something new to the table.
EIephant_Lover
Scratcher
500+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

Hmm, partial support.

Although I'm not sure if this would be a major improvement, it could be helpful.

However, as someone noted about having galleries of galleries, that's the issue. You would just keep needing bigger and bigger galleries to hold more galleries. And what if you could put a gallery into a gallery, and then put the second gallery (which has the first one in it) into the first one?

I'm not really sure where I stand on this.
abualrob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

EIephant_Lover wrote:

Hmm, partial support.

Although I'm not sure if this would be a major improvement, it could be helpful.

However, as someone noted about having galleries of galleries, that's the issue. You would just keep needing bigger and bigger galleries to hold more galleries. And what if you could put a gallery into a gallery, and then put the second gallery (which has the first one in it) into the first one?

I'm not really sure where I stand on this.

If you put a gallery in a gallery, then the gallery that contains the gallery is just another form of gallery and needs to be called something else. And I really dont need infinity galleries (like galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries of galleries)
EeveeLegends
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

Hmm, semi-support.
The feature would be helpful but i'm not sure we would really need it.

LegoManiac04
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

Support!

I think this would be really cool! It would allow you to make hub-like things, like where you have multiple similar studios in a gallery. I can see how I could use this, and how the ST could too!

But how would it work with curators? Would there be curator and manager positions? Would you automatically be a curator of the studios in the gallery if you accept the invite for the gallery? And can the studios be put in any gallery, or can they only be put in galleries created by the owner of the studios?

abualrob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

EeveeLegends wrote:

Hmm, semi-support.
The feature would be helpful but i'm not sure we would really need it.

Actually, we do, so we can put all our studios in 1 like 1 humongous SDS gallery of sds studios.
abualrob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

LegoManiac04 wrote:

Support!

I think this would be really cool! It would allow you to make hub-like things, like where you have multiple similar studios in a gallery. I can see how I could use this, and how the ST could too!

But how would it work with curators? Would there be curator and manager positions? Would you automatically be a curator of the studios in the gallery if you accept the invite for the gallery? And can the studios be put in any gallery, or can they only be put in galleries created by the owner of the studios?

LegoManiac04 wrote:

Support!

I think this would be really cool! It would allow you to make hub-like things, like where you have multiple similar studios in a gallery. I can see how I could use this, and how the ST could too!

But how would it work with curators? Would there be curator and manager positions? Would you automatically be a curator of the studios in the gallery if you accept the invite for the gallery? And can the studios be put in any gallery, or can they only be put in galleries created by the owner of the studios?

I think the curator system will be the same with regualar studios
abualrob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

oops i quoted that twice
WindOctahedron
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

abualrob wrote:

oops i quoted that twice
You can just edit your posts.

The message above may contain wrong information, rude remarks, or something embarrassing to my current self. In this case, please ignore it and remember that I likely wrote it back when I didn't know what “respect” truly meant. I really hate thinking about it again.
abualrob
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

WindOctahedron wrote:

abualrob wrote:

oops i quoted that twice
You can just edit your posts.

It said I have to wait 60 seconds and I really coudn't wait that long. I dont care if thats just a minute
Nambaseking01
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

Support, this could be useful. It would be nice if we could expand this system by also allowing discussion threads in studios. If this was added, curators could also advertise their studios instead of only projects.

Hey there! My name is Nammy. I'm a male Forum Helper and Scratch Wiki Editor.
Profile | Test Account | Talk with me here! | Griffpatch is quitting Scratch?!
WindOctahedron
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studios [allow studios to contain other studios]

abualrob wrote:

WindOctahedron wrote:

abualrob wrote:

oops i quoted that twice
You can just edit your posts.

It said I have to wait 60 seconds and I really coudn't wait that long. I dont care if thats just a minute
You don't have to wait 60 seconds to edit posts.

Last edited by WindOctahedron (July 26, 2019 16:43:26)


The message above may contain wrong information, rude remarks, or something embarrassing to my current self. In this case, please ignore it and remember that I likely wrote it back when I didn't know what “respect” truly meant. I really hate thinking about it again.

Powered by DjangoBB