Discuss Scratch

dtnc21
Scratcher
100+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

My browser / operating system: Windows NT 10.0, Chrome 73.0.3683.86, No Flash version detected

So the great thing about Scratch 3's vector editor is that we can now have control over how the vector path curves as it crosses a point using the two handles. Really neat! …Except sometimes, a point splits into two, each having only a single handle of the original. And that's… not a good thing, I imagine.
This happens both in the online editor and the new Scratch Desktop at random. At one point, this even happened with one of the corners of a newly created square!
dtnc21
Scratcher
100+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

bump

To clarify, this isn't me attempting to select a point only to be just slightly off, causing a new point to be created. This is when I do something with a vector shape, select a different costume/sprite, and come back to it only to find that one of the points had split into two separate points.
dtnc21
Scratcher
100+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

Bump because this seems to be happening to me more frequently as of late. Please tell me I'm not the only one who's suffering from this…
TM2125
Scratcher
500+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

I've been experiencing this too, it's pretty annoying.
My browser / operating system: Android Linux 8.1.0, Chrome 74.0.3729.112, No Flash version detected
banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

CNR. However, can you send over a screencap for me? Thanks! My browser / operating system: Windows NT 10.0, Chrome 74.0.3729.131, No Flash version detected

Banana
dtnc21
Scratcher
100+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

Ok, I haven't really gotten around to posting an update and a screencap up until now.
Why now? Because this bug is still happening, and it's occurring way more frequently than it should be.
https://i.imgur.com/KEqJRV6.png

Online Editor after resizing one of the included sprites in the Scratch Library, taken and posted today.
(this happened with the inner star as well, on the same point)
My browser / operating system: Windows NT 10.0, Chrome 75.0.3770.142, No Flash version detected

Last edited by dtnc21 (Aug. 11, 2019 02:15:18)

dtnc21
Scratcher
100+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

Bump because… well, maybe it's just me, but I can't stand having this bug happen all the time.
banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

dtnc21 wrote:

Ok, I haven't really gotten around to posting an update and a screencap up until now.
Why now? Because this bug is still happening, and it's occurring way more frequently than it should be.
https://i.imgur.com/KEqJRV6.png

Online Editor after resizing one of the included sprites in the Scratch Library, taken and posted today.
(this happened with the inner star as well, on the same point)
My browser / operating system: Windows NT 10.0, Chrome 75.0.3770.142, No Flash version detected
That just seems to be a screenshot…

Banana
dtnc21
Scratcher
100+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

…They're both the same. Why, you want the entire screen? Because I don't think that would help out much, to be honest.
banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

dtnc21 wrote:

…They're both the same. Why, you want the entire screen? Because I don't think that would help out much, to be honest.
A screencap's a recording of a portion of the screen…

Banana
dtnc21
Scratcher
100+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

Sorry. Most people I talk with use screencap as a picture, a capture of the screen.


https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/youtube/-eL5jPLvlMM
Kcommand
Scratcher
12 posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

I found the same thing happening in my laptop too. Also happened in my desktop. No matter how I delete the newly created point, it just comes back.
Wackimations
Scratcher
5 posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

Bump. This happens countless times to my vector objects and causes vector thorns.
JachiiStudios
Scratcher
23 posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

Oh my gosh, this happens to me CONSTANTLY. It's legitimately making it SOO frustrating to work with vectors. It seems it just happens to costumes that are not currently selected, which is really weird.

My browser / operating system: Windows NT 10.0, Opera 99.0.0.0, No Flash version detected

Huh, windows 11 and opera gx seem to be so similar technically to windows 10 and regular opera that it detects them as windows 10 and just opera.
I actually use windows 11 and opera gx

Last edited by JachiiStudios (July 15, 2023 20:40:23)

JachiiStudios
Scratcher
23 posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

Also, sometimes bezier vertexes don't split into two, but you can still drag the individual control points without affecting the other, making it just a sharp vertex with 2 curved sides
Mr_Mikl
Scratcher
8 posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

I noticed this to, but I actually want to deliberately cause it manually to a specific point. what I'm talking about is causing the point to become a single point with two “vectors”, kind of like a curved point, but disconnected from each other so I can control them individually, while still having it be one point. one way I do this is by having a point on “curved”, placing two points on “pointed” around it, and select the curved point. I thought it was just that, but thanks to this discussion, now know that there's another step involving switching costumes. I actually find this glitch somewhat helpful in its own ways.
BaldiVsPacmanEtc
Scratcher
19 posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

Bump. This STILL happens, creating the same issue where animations can result in having annoying vector thorns that can be difficult to work with.
Snowwywolfboi
Scratcher
1 post

Vector points sometimes split into two

Yeah, this is still happening to me too. I use scratch (Rather stupidly) to make vector sprites for high quality conversion to sprites in other programs and its frequently happening since i have to make around 30+ costumes each animation. This looks unlikely to be solved. :<

I dont know my os but i use Edge

Last edited by Snowwywolfboi (Feb. 8, 2025 20:16:52)

brybry888
Scratcher
100+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

bumpert. I am experiencing the same issue on ALL DEVICES, ALL OPERATING SYSTEMS, and ALL BROWSERS. It is extremely annoying when you are handling with a curved vector point
minniesworld
Scratcher
500+ posts

Vector points sometimes split into two

I think it's supposed to be a feature… it isn't that helpful tho

Powered by DjangoBB