Discuss Scratch

ametrine_
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

va04042013 wrote:

Where?

va04042013 wrote:

Hey there @Za-Chary

I got a rejected suggestion | Combining Scratch and Scratch Jr | you need to add!
Link: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/798507/
@Paddle2See confirmed rejected.
Za-Chary
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

crazyfrogcat wrote:

me: that has only been suggested once
In that case I don't think I need to add it at this time.

crazyfrogcat wrote:

za: The following claim also requires a source: “changing the list or requiring people to share their gender is also rejected for similar reseasons.” That is not indicated in the rejection post.

me: but i think it's true
Personal opinions are not the same thing as Scratch Team rejections.

ScratchUser139 wrote:

add this to 6.1.
"However, deleting your comments while no one saw it is NOT rejected, you can discuss it on this topic.
As I indicated above, I'm not confident that it's not rejected. Perhaps someone should get moderator input.

0_009 wrote:

There have been tutorials on how to make a 3D Scratch project, so there would be no use putting #1.7 on TOLORS.
The suggestion is to make it easier to make 3D projects by adding blocks dedicated for making 3D projects. That is the suggestion which is rejected. It's allowed to make 3D projects for those who can handle it, but the Scratch Team will not be adding any features to make them easier to make, hence why it is on TOLORS.

Kodwx wrote:

@TOLORS is great. It helps prevent spam and other things.
Thank you for the nice comment

va04042013 wrote:

What about verified scratchers for celebrities and brands?
Seems that this is rejected: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8319140/

NotK3ndricAltAgain wrote:

Here’s one for 6.5:
6.5 Removing comments entirely
Thanks, but this seems “obviously rejected” and so I don't think I need to add it to the list.

Za-Chary wrote:

2) Add a blurb in 8.2 linking to this post which gives more information on why a “verified Scratcher” system is rejected in the case where it may be used to confirm Scratch accounts based on famous people outside of Scratch: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8319140/
Done.

1THEKINGBOB3 wrote:

Ill remind you… next week?
No need, I already check this thread every week myself.

va04042013 wrote:

Hey there @Za-Chary

I got a rejected suggestion | Combining Scratch and Scratch Jr | you need to add!
Link: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/798507/
@Paddle2See confirmed rejected.
Thanks. I don't think it's suggested often, so I think I'll leave it off the list for now.
conta-1
Scratcher
8 posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

I made a Spanish version
The Link is here
SegaSurvivor1991
Scratcher
12 posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

I feel like you're going to reject this but I'll ask can you delete the studio notifications it's pretty annoying if a new scratcher joins making his first game and has a lot of Studios to follow and it always just says something new to another Studio happened so I think that the studio notifications should not be happening.

Last edited by SegaSurvivor1991 (Jan. 17, 2025 15:35:57)

ametrine_
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

SegaSurvivor1991 wrote:

I feel like you're going to reject this but I'll ask can you delete the studio notifications it's pretty annoying if a new scratcher joins making his first game and has a lot of Studios to follow and it always just says something new to another Studio happened so I think that the studio notifications should not be happening.
if you want less notifications, join less studios.
also, this is not the place to suggest features. please do so by creating a new topic instead.

Last edited by ametrine_ (Jan. 17, 2025 15:39:18)

Draked12
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

SegaSurvivor1991 wrote:

I feel like you're going to reject this but I'll ask can you delete the studio notifications it's pretty annoying if a new scratcher joins making his first game and has a lot of Studios to follow and it always just says something new to another Studio happened so I think that the studio notifications should not be happening.
Please make a new topic suggestion rather then inputting it here.
2016s4m29
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

conta-1 wrote:

(#9463)
I made a Spanish version
The Link is here
This looks very google translated to me
Draked12
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

conta-1 wrote:

I made a Spanish version
The Link is here
Did you use Google Translate (or a alternative translate app)?

Last edited by Draked12 (Jan. 17, 2025 16:37:06)

AlejandrixKing245
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Draked12 wrote:

conta-1 wrote:

I made a Spanish version
The Link is here
Did you use Google Translate (or a translate app)
i think
Mozboz
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Draked12 wrote:

conta-1 wrote:

I made a Spanish version
The Link is here
Did you use Google Translate (or a alternative translate app)?
Translating it back gives me an identical (near) version to the actual English one. So extremely likely.
teamsonic2011
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

a spanish version of TOLORS exists here.
The-Sushi-Cat
Scratcher
500+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

This won't be added (Unless more topics start getting made about it? Even then it'd probably be temporary) But disabling search is rejected: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/800137/?page=1#post-8341217
Catscratcher07
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

teamsonic2011 wrote:

a spanish version of TOLORS exists here.
that TOLoRS español has already been rejected from being linked here because it is outdated and likely machine-translated, creating a new, better spanish TOLoRS would be a good thing.
AlejandrixKing245
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Catscratcher07 wrote:

teamsonic2011 wrote:

a spanish version of TOLORS exists here.
that TOLoRS español has already been rejected from being linked here because it is outdated and likely machine-translated, creating a new, better spanish TOLoRS would be a good thing.
yeah. but scratch mutes you by just naming a app or site, it is unfair okay i know this is unrelated
Draked12
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Za-Chary
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

conta-1 wrote:

I made a Spanish version
The Link is here
Looks like @Paddle2See linked to another version of the list. Can anyone vouch for whether or not @Gipthepig424's list (and @conta-1's list, for that matter) was made using an online translator? Or does it sound like this one was made by someone fluent in the language?

Okay, people already did. I'm tempted to link to @conta-1's because they appear to be from Brazil. Are we certain this is online-translated? Does other text in this user's projects/profile appear to be online-translated? Unless someone can definitively vouch against it, I think I'd like to link to this new list.

The-Sushi-Cat wrote:

This won't be added (Unless more topics start getting made about it? Even then it'd probably be temporary) But disabling search is rejected: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/800137/?page=1#post-8341217
Thanks; this seems temporary so I probably don't need to add it to the list.

Draked12 wrote:

I think the portugese version is google translated
Perhaps… but some of the user's comments suggest that they know Portuguese. It's fine if parts of the list were assisted via online translator, as long as the user is fluent in the language and can catch any major issues. (Keep this in mind regarding @conta-1's Spanish list above… or is that one Portuguese, too? I'll tune in next week to find out!)

Last edited by Za-Chary (Jan. 18, 2025 00:52:53)

Mozboz
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Za-Chary wrote:

conta-1 wrote:

I made a Spanish version
The Link is here
Looks like @Paddle2See linked to another version of the list. Can anyone vouch for whether or not @Gipthepig424's list (and @conta-1's list, for that matter) was made using an online translator? Or does it sound like this one was made by someone fluent in the language?

Okay, people already did. I'm tempted to link to @conta-1's because they appear to be from Brazil. Are we certain this is online-translated? Does other text in this user's projects/profile appear to be online-translated? Unless someone can definitively vouch against it, I think I'd like to link to this new list.

The-Sushi-Cat wrote:

This won't be added (Unless more topics start getting made about it? Even then it'd probably be temporary) But disabling search is rejected: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/800137/?page=1#post-8341217
Thanks; this seems temporary so I probably don't need to add it to the list.

Draked12 wrote:

I think the portugese version is google translated
Perhaps… but some of the user's comments suggest that they know Portuguese. It's fine if parts of the list were assisted via online translator, as long as the user is fluent in the language and can catch any major issues. (Keep this in mind regarding @conta-1's Spanish list above… or is that one Portuguese, too? I'll tune in next week to find out!)
When I translated @conta-1's list, it was identical to this English list. That was with Google Translate, which is usually wildly inaccurate on long lists unless translating back text that was translated using Google Translate. That being said, could be just a very literal translation.
ChameleonGamerYT
Scratcher
500+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

PrincessIsza wrote:

han614698 wrote:

PrincessIsza wrote:

(#9277)

8to16 wrote:

1.9 doesn't have a loop arrow icon, it should be this:

forever if <> {

} @loopArrow :: control cap

Fixed scratchblocks:
forever if <> {

} @loopArrow :: control cap
What is Scratch 1.9?
I don't believe 8to16 is referring to Scratch 1.9, but rather item 1.9 on TOLORS.
Where is tolors?
Right here
lnecel
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

for using forever if when enabling pen extension, use this script:
when pen extension enabled :: pen :: hat
forever if <> :: control :: loop arrow

end

Last edited by lnecel (Jan. 18, 2025 16:08:07)

crazyfrogcat
Scratcher
500+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

why would the scratch team reject the under bellow suggestion when it's useful

9.7 Guide section on the forums
This proposed forum section would be a place for guides and tutorials that Scratchers could freely make with the purpose of helping others. However, the forums are generally a place for discussion; it is not a good place for topics with content that is not meant to be changed. A Scratch project or the Scratch Wiki are two good places to make tutorials.

Powered by DjangoBB