Discuss Scratch
- Discussion Forums
- » Suggestions
- » The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
- BigNate469
-
1000+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
Please stop inserting an apostrophe at nearly very vowelhttps://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/795797/ (buttons for “support”, “semi-support” and “no support” for suggestions) was rejected, might be worth mentioning under 9.6 that this is also rejected.Actually… I have something important to tell y’about’th. It focus’stoo’m’ch on popularity.
I know why it was rejected. Go read 9.6 and you'll see why I think it's a good idea to add it onto section 9.6.
Still, @Za-Chary already replied to it a few pages ago saying that it counts as a poll anyways and probably didn't deserve a separate mention.
Last edited by BigNate469 (Dec. 31, 2024 19:02:56)
- crazyfrogcat
-
500+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
new rejected suggestion for 8.12
i wat this rejected to help people to know it can be useful
[b]8.12 [url=https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8304551]stop asking for gender on signup[/url][/b]
asking for gender allows the scratch team to see how may people using scratch have a Surten gender, if you fell uncomfortable sharing it on sign up then you can choose no to share you gender, for more information [url=https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8295649]click here[/url], changing the list or requiring people to share their gender is also rejected for similar reseasons
- Za-Chary
-
1000+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
its topic has been closed since all that needs to be said has already been said"Makes sense. I'll update the entry to make it say something like this. How about "However, the ability to connect gaming controllers to a computer or tablet to use for Scratch is NOT rejected, but
over here because i can't find oneDo you speak Spanish fluently, or are you using a translator to make the list? I only link to non-English lists made by those who speak the language fluently. hello I'm making a Spanish version of this list
this?I'm not aware of it being rejected, but I'm not confident that it's not. I suspect there would be problems with this that I'm not thinking of at the moment. What about
How much has this been suggested in the past? new rejected suggestion for 8.12i wat this rejected to help people to know it can be useful[b]8.12 [url=https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8304551]stop asking for gender on signup[/url][/b]
asking for gender allows the scratch team to see how may people using scratch have a Surten gender, if you fell uncomfortable sharing it on sign up then you can choose no to share you gender, for more information [url=https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8295649]click here[/url], changing the list or requiring people to share their gender is also rejected for similar reseasons
The following claim also requires a source: “changing the list or requiring people to share their gender is also rejected for similar reseasons.” That is not indicated in the rejection post.
- crazyfrogcat
-
500+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
(#9423)over here because i can't find oneDo you speak Spanish fluently, or are you using a translator to make the list? I only link to non-English lists made by those who speak the language fluently. hello I'm making a Spanish version of this list
sorry but i used google translate and i don't speak the language fluently
(#9423)How much has this been suggested in the past? new rejected suggestion for 8.12i wat this rejected to help people to know it can be useful[b]8.12 [url=https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8304551]stop asking for gender on signup[/url][/b]
asking for gender allows the scratch team to see how may people using scratch have a Surten gender, if you fell uncomfortable sharing it on sign up then you can choose no to share you gender, for more information [url=https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/8295649]click here[/url], changing the list or requiring people to share their gender is also rejected for similar reseasons
me: that has only been suggested once
za: The following claim also requires a source: “changing the list or requiring people to share their gender is also rejected for similar reseasons.” That is not indicated in the rejection post.
me: but i think it's true
- The-Sushi-Cat
-
500+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
(#9423)over here because i can't find oneDo you speak Spanish fluently, or are you using a translator to make the list? I only link to non-English lists made by those who speak the language fluently. hello I'm making a Spanish version of this list
sorry but i used google translate and i don't speak the language fluently
Perhaps you shouldn't make it then? Not trying to be mean, but Google translate isn't the best, and you may confuse more people than you'll help
- ScratchUser139
-
63 posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
add this to 6.1.
"However, deleting your comments while no one saw it is NOT rejected, you can discuss it on this topic.
"However, deleting your comments while no one saw it is NOT rejected, you can discuss it on this topic.
- endyourenite
-
100+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
Nah Google translate is quite bad. Its uncommon to see that it's gives gibberish.(#9423)over here because i can't find oneDo you speak Spanish fluently, or are you using a translator to make the list? I only link to non-English lists made by those who speak the language fluently. hello I'm making a Spanish version of this list
sorry but i used google translate and i don't speak the language fluently
Perhaps you shouldn't make it then? Not trying to be mean, but Google translate isn't the best, and you may confuse more people than you'll help
- Catscratcher07
-
1000+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
add this to 6.1.
"However, deleting your comments while no one saw it is NOT rejected, you can discuss it on this topic.
Unless a moderator post on that topic confirming it is not rejected, we cannot be confident that it would not be rejected when an ST member sees it.this?I'm not aware of it being rejected, but I'm not confident that it's not. I suspect there would be problems with this that I'm not thinking of at the moment. What about
- teamsonic2011
-
1000+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
Just because you think it's true doesn't mean it is. me: but i think it's true
Last edited by teamsonic2011 (Jan. 4, 2025 17:12:48)
- 0_009
-
100+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
There have been 1.7 3D Scratchtutorials on how to make a 3D Scratch project, so there would be no use putting #1.7 on TOLORS.
A 3D Scratch interface, involving a z-axis in the project stage, could make it easier to create 3D projects. However, Scratch is a language that is designed to be as easy as possible for beginners to learn. The purpose of Scratch is to teach beginners basic programming concepts, which is best accomplished with a 2D interface. Adding a 3D interface could make Scratch more difficult to learn and teach. This includes having a separate website for 3D Scratch. This suggestion also includes the possibility for virtual-reality “Scratch VR” features, where a lot of the same difficulties come up; for more information, see this post.
- nikky10000000
-
500+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
however, people suggest it a lot, because they want it to be easier. so I think its nessesary.There have been 1.7 3D Scratchtutorials on how to make a 3D Scratch project, so there would be no use putting #1.7 on TOLORS.
A 3D Scratch interface, involving a z-axis in the project stage, could make it easier to create 3D projects. However, Scratch is a language that is designed to be as easy as possible for beginners to learn. The purpose of Scratch is to teach beginners basic programming concepts, which is best accomplished with a 2D interface. Adding a 3D interface could make Scratch more difficult to learn and teach. This includes having a separate website for 3D Scratch. This suggestion also includes the possibility for virtual-reality “Scratch VR” features, where a lot of the same difficulties come up; for more information, see this post.
- Kodwx
-
100+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
@TOLORS is great. It helps prevent spam and other things.
My browser / operating system: ChromeOS 14541.0.0, Chrome 130.0.0.0, No Flash version detected
My browser / operating system: ChromeOS 14541.0.0, Chrome 130.0.0.0, No Flash version detected
- nikky10000000
-
500+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
please do not quote the entire OPoh… I tried to make an idea for an extension for 3d mesh.. its not allowed. -snip-
Last edited by nikky10000000 (Jan. 5, 2025 00:41:10)
- starlightsparker
-
1000+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
tutorials on how to make a 3D Scratch project, so there would be no use putting #1.7 on TOLORS.Not quite. 1.7 is there because adding a 3D feature in Scratch is rejected. Not because it isn’t possible/allowed to make 3D projects in the current Scratch. There have been
Attempting to make 3D projects in vanilla Scratch is allowed, 1.7 just means that adding a feature for making 3D projects is a rejected suggestion. oh… I tried to make an idea for an extension for 3d mesh.. its not allowed.
- ametrine_
-
1000+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
specifically an official feature by the st, you are free to make your own using scratch mods for example 1.7 just means that adding a feature for making 3D projects is a rejected suggestion.
Last edited by ametrine_ (Jan. 5, 2025 15:37:42)
- AlejandrixKing245
-
100+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
@TOLORS is great. It helps prevent spam and other things.by @Kodwx
My browser / operating system: ChromeOS 14541.0.0, Chrome 130.0.0.0, No Flash version detected
wow, you are right
- nikky10000000
-
500+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
Yeah but Za-Chary doesnt know if its rejected or not. add this to 6.1.
"However, deleting your comments while no one saw it is NOT rejected, you can discuss it on this topic.
- va04042013
-
100+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
What about verified scratchers for celebrities and brands?
- teamsonic2011
-
1000+ posts
The Official List of Rejected Suggestions
I don't think it is, but there aren't really any brands on Scratch (besides Cartoon Network, but they've been inactive since 2019) What about verified scratchers for celebrities and brands?