Discuss Scratch

Scratch137
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

greentreebee wrote:

(#8979)
Also, people are calling this accepted because @Paddle2See was really enthusiastic about it and commented on it without even closing it! (there has got to be something there if he comments and not closes it!!! )
Not necessarily. A suggestion isn't “accepted” until the Scratch Team confirms they are implementing it.

However, the fact that @Paddle2See liked the idea is a very good sign—it could very well be accepted in the future.

greentreebee wrote:

Question for Za-Chary: Could there be a official list of accepted suggestions??? Like sorted from A-Z to decrease topic dupes?
This suggestion is on the rejected list.
9.4 An official list of accepted suggestions
As a counterpart to the list of rejected suggestions, some Scratchers have expressed interest in compiling a list of features of Scratch that were suggested by someone, and eventually implemented. But it is not easy to tell whether a suggestion was implemented because it was suggested by Scratchers in the forums, Scratchers elsewhere, a Scratch Team member, a teacher, or someone else. In other words, every feature currently in Scratch was suggested by somebody, so such a list would just be a list of all features of Scratch.

(it's not halloween anymore, new signature coming eventually)


;
greentreebee
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

TheCreatorOfUnTV wrote:

greentreebee wrote:

Question for Za-Chary: Could there be a official list of accepted suggestions??? Like sorted from A-Z to decrease topic dupes?
I'm 100% sure that's rejected.
where's the link?



Hi! I'm greentreebee! I love coding, gaming, baseball, and bees!

Thanks for 100 200 follows! look at this post lol its like 10000 characters long :lol:
MY MOST POPULAR PROJECT https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/910045655/

follow me for a cookie PRESS SHIFT AND HIGHLIGHT THE WHOLE SIGNATURE AND PRESS DOWN ARROW TO SEE WHOLE SIGNATURE High Contrast Blue

when green flag clicked
forever
go to [my profile v]
if <[done with scratch] = [yes]> then
set [screen v] to [MINECRAFTTTTTTTTTTTTTT]
if <[mom says hop off the computer] = [yes]> then
cry
end
AliMASTER430258
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

greentreebee wrote:

TheCreatorOfUnTV wrote:

greentreebee wrote:

Question for Za-Chary: Could there be a official list of accepted suggestions??? Like sorted from A-Z to decrease topic dupes?
I'm 100% sure that's rejected.
where's the link?
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/371581/?page=1#post-3718725 (deadlinked)

Last edited by AliMASTER430258 (Oct. 5, 2024 01:36:46)

8to16
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

starlightsparker wrote:

(#8981)
This is not The Official List of Closed Suggestions. Please only link a topic if it is rejected.
TOLOCS confirmed

^^^^^ Below this line is a signature. It doesn't have anything to do with the post above, also use extension or highlight this and use shift+down to scroll down. And I AM NOT A BOT! if I use the exact same response I used before, I am using a text expansion system.




























@cheddargirl's signature before it was eaten

Everything is better when you add a little cheddar, because when you have cheese your life is at ease
Za-Chary
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Scratch137 wrote:

Za-Chary wrote:

(#8939)

Catscratcher07 wrote:

Make a true equation with <(5-5) = (0)> format return tru just got rejected.
There have been suggestions before about typing in an equation/expression and having Scratch automatically solve/evaluate it, right? I don't think this is the only time this has been suggested. I am interested in adding this to the list, but I'd like to see when else this has been suggested.
I was able to find this one from 2018.
Thanks! This is the one I was thinking of, but @Paddle2See confirms that this is not rejected — it is a different suggestion. So I probably won't add @Catscratcher07's linked suggestion to the list for now, seeing as this suggestion is not frequently-suggested.

8to16 wrote:

Roman numeral blocks got rejected.
Thanks! I probably don't need to add it at this time.

Also, please don't make multiple posts for the same thing. I check TOLORS once per weekend. If I make a new post in this thread but I don't respond to your particular post, then you can bump it if you need a response from me.

endyourenite wrote:

Guys, Stop suggesting rejected suggestions to TOLORS if there is barely any topics about that rejected suggestion. I think we need 3 or 4+ rejected topics per month for OP to add it, also, it shouldn't be a joke or spam topic.
I encourage everybody to share newly-rejected suggestions in this thread. Even if the suggestion is “obviously rejected” or “infrequently suggested,” it's good for me to be aware that it was suggested and rejected so I can keep this in mind for the future, in case the suggestion ever does become “frequently suggested.”

Coughfe wrote:

Za-Chary wrote:

I've been using the post/ID links whenever I add a new entry to the list. This is something I want to do, but I haven't had the chance to do it. Now that the forums load quickly, I may be able to do it faster. When I finish writing this post, I'll update some of them at least in Section 2, and see if I can continue this later.
I forgot to remind, whoop.
Doesn't seem like anyone else has, so uh…
Reminder
I gotta do grocery shopping and other things soon, so I might not be able to get to this today. Please continue to remind me as you think of it.

Coughfe wrote:

Also, 7.4 uses the /jobs link, rather than scratch.org; could that be updated?
There is an inconsistency between the two links — /jobs claims that there are no positions open, but scratch.org lists several open positions. So it is unclear to me which one is correct. The /jobs link is what is used at the bottom of the scratch.mit.edu website, so this is the link I will continue to use until further notice; I am open to changing it if a Scratch Team member confirms that scratch.org is now the official place to show new job openings.

8to16 wrote:

Allowing younger people (under 18s) to join ST was rejected

I'm almost certain there are a few other topics suggesting this but I'm gonna have to find them on ocular

This could be added as a “This extends to …” in 7.4
I don't think I need to add anything; 7.4 already makes it clear that only adults can moderate the website.

greentreebee wrote:

A studio for studios has been closed, but not rejected. It was a dupe and now they are going to the old one.
Thanks, but in this thread I only need to know about the suggestions that are actually rejected. No need to link a topic here if it was merely determined to be a duplicate of another suggestion.

greentreebee wrote:

Question for Za-Chary: Could there be a official list of accepted suggestions??? Like sorted from A-Z to decrease topic dupes?
If you are looking for a list of already-suggested suggestions, see the Suggestions Directory.

If you are looking for a list of already-implemented suggestions, see 9.4 on this rejected suggestions list for more information on why there won't be one.

AliMASTER430258 wrote:

greentreebee wrote:

where's the link?
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/371581/?page=1#post-3718725 (deadlinked)
It's unclear where you got this link; this particular link is not in TOLORS. Here is the link explaining why there will be no list of accepted suggestions: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/4426090/

This is my forum signature! On a forum post, it is okay for Scratchers to advertise in their forum signature. The signature is the stuff that shows up below the horizontal line on the post. It will show up on every post I make.

I was a Scratch Team member from May 10th 2019 to October 29th 2021. I reached 20,000 forum posts on June 24th 2024.

my notebook | scratch team essay | accessibility essay
endyourenite
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Za-Chary wrote:

endyourenite wrote:

Guys, Stop suggesting rejected suggestions to TOLORS if there is barely any topics about that rejected suggestion. I think we need 3 or 4+ rejected topics per month for OP to add it, also, it shouldn't be a joke or spam topic.
I encourage everybody to share newly-rejected suggestions in this thread. Even if the suggestion is “obviously rejected” or “infrequently suggested,” it's good for me to be aware that it was suggested and rejected so I can keep this in mind for the future, in case the suggestion ever does become “frequently suggested.”
Ah Ok

found something silly
Suggestions I own:
Scrollable What I have been doing
that's all….

Posts I found Funny:

A-MARIO-PLAYER wrote:

WHEN TOPIC FALLS OFF FRONT PAGE
  1. (src)
    Bump it.
  2. Get people to talk about this weird suggestion.
  3. Watch as the number of posts on this topic expands.
  4. Leave any rickrolls or evil kumquats behind.

(ignore this)
my first ever post on scratch forums
Anyways, just stop reading this, I am only a silly forumer.
But what do you want from me?




;
Rosho_Robotics
Scratcher
30 posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

here's a block, this will be really useful for a lot of people, I wouldn't be surprised if somebody had this idea, I will also show its use, also another block that's cool, ill show that one.:
< [mouse-pointer v] touching [sprite1 v] ?>
say [this would be rly useful! plz add it.]

when green flag clicked
forever
if << [mouse-pointer v] touching [Settings icon v] ?>> then
if <(Settings Open) = [True]> then
set [Settings Open v] to [False]
wait (0.05) secs


else
set [Settings Open v] to [True]
wait (0.05) secs
end
end
end

transition backdrop from [backdrop1 v] to [backdrop2 v]

transition costume from [costume1 v] to [costume2 v]

Last edited by Rosho_Robotics (Oct. 7, 2024 03:19:12)


when green flag clicked
go to x: (0) y: (0)
point in direction (90 v)
say [Subscribe to @EveryCoder2024 on youtube for more awesome tutorails!]
forever
move (10) steps
turn cw (15) degrees
set [Ghost v] effect to (100)
pen down
end
Scratch137
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Rosho_Robotics wrote:

(#8989)
here's a block, this will be really useful for a lot of people, I wouldn't be surprised if somebody had this idea, I will also show its use, also another block that's cool, ill show that one.:
< [mouse-pointer v] touching [sprite1 v] ?>
say [this would be rly useful! plz add it.]

when green flag clicked
forever
if << [mouse-pointer v] touching [Settings icon v] ?>> then
if <(Settings Open) = [True]> then
set [Settings Open v] to [False]
wait (0.05) secs


else
set [Settings Open v] to [True]
wait (0.05) secs
end
end
end

transition backdrop from [backdrop1 v] to [backdrop2 v]

transition costume from [costume1 v] to [costume2 v]
It's great that you want to share your ideas! However, this thread is for listing rejected suggestions, and isn't a good place for making new suggestions.

Instead, I encourage you to create a new topic for each of your ideas so they can gather feedback.

(it's not halloween anymore, new signature coming eventually)


;
Bobmr2024
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Add these please

when @greenFlag clicked and <> = [true v] :: events hat

<@greenFlag pressed?::events>

if <[1]=[1]> then repeat{
. . .
} @loopArrow::control

<⌐■_■ :: sensing> // This is Sam! He will protect me if any kumquats try to eat my siggy.

when gf clicked
forever
if <<kumquat?:: #ff8c00> = <near:: sensing>> then
Get rid of all kumquats in the universe :: custom stack
end

Guard housing <っ◕‿◕っ::sensing> <⌐■ᴗ■::sensing> <'__'::sensing> <◕–◕::sensing> :: custom stack
8to16
Scratcher
1000+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Bobmr2024 wrote:

(#8991)
Add these please

when @greenFlag clicked and <> = [true v] :: events hat

<@greenFlag pressed?::events>

if <[1]=[1]> then repeat{
. . .
} @loopArrow::control
Please put your suggestions in separate topics, instead of posting them here!

You can create a new topic here

^^^^^ Below this line is a signature. It doesn't have anything to do with the post above, also use extension or highlight this and use shift+down to scroll down. And I AM NOT A BOT! if I use the exact same response I used before, I am using a text expansion system.




























@cheddargirl's signature before it was eaten

Everything is better when you add a little cheddar, because when you have cheese your life is at ease
100blacktak
Scratcher
78 posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Make sure to add the “remove followers” followers

this is old she/her trombone player
50_scratch_tabs
Scratcher
500+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Could you please link to https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/780031 as not rejected for 7.1?

Highlight this text and Shift+Down for more fun!

I don't mind if you post off-topic replies on my profile, but please don't post links to posts you think I missed. I follow every topic I post in, and I'm often too busy to be on Scratch.

He/Him | ATer? | I like Scratch API projects like this one, which usually knows it's own stats!

Scratch (obviously) | Python | HTML/CSS/JS | PHP | Minecraft | Slightly C/C++ | One of these days I'll learn Java.

I used to have the 9000th post on TOLORS | My first post was an accident | Interesting comment thread

Tic-tac-toe :: events hat
(1::grey) (X:: variables) (3::grey):: stack grey
(4::grey) (O:: sensing) (6::grey):: stack grey
(X:: variables) (O:: control) (X :: variables):: stack grey

Colors :: events hat
50_scratch_tabs \(me) :: variables
8to16 :: sensing
SaberDragon73 :: control
Comment a move on my profile and I will add it.




If you have a signature that requires Shift+down, paste this at the bottom of it. If you actually read this far, you deserve my respect. -50_scratch_tabs
AliMASTER430258
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

8to16 wrote:

(#8992)

Bobmr2024 wrote:

(#8991)
Add these please

when @greenFlag clicked and <> = [true v] :: events hat

<@greenFlag pressed?::events>

if <[1]=[1]> then repeat{
. . .
} @loopArrow::control
Please put your suggestions in separate topics, instead of posting them here!

You can create a new topic here

I think that they were saying they wanted them to be added to the TOLoRS, not actually implemented in Scratch.
AliMASTER430258
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

50_scratch_tabs wrote:

(#8994)
Could you please link to https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/780031 as not rejected for 7.1?
Zach will probably add this on Saturday; I thinks he checks it weekly.
50_scratch_tabs
Scratcher
500+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

AliMASTER430258 wrote:

(#8996)
Zach will probably add this on Saturday; I thinks he checks it weekly.
Yup, I expected that. Hope to see it added soon!

Highlight this text and Shift+Down for more fun!

I don't mind if you post off-topic replies on my profile, but please don't post links to posts you think I missed. I follow every topic I post in, and I'm often too busy to be on Scratch.

He/Him | ATer? | I like Scratch API projects like this one, which usually knows it's own stats!

Scratch (obviously) | Python | HTML/CSS/JS | PHP | Minecraft | Slightly C/C++ | One of these days I'll learn Java.

I used to have the 9000th post on TOLORS | My first post was an accident | Interesting comment thread

Tic-tac-toe :: events hat
(1::grey) (X:: variables) (3::grey):: stack grey
(4::grey) (O:: sensing) (6::grey):: stack grey
(X:: variables) (O:: control) (X :: variables):: stack grey

Colors :: events hat
50_scratch_tabs \(me) :: variables
8to16 :: sensing
SaberDragon73 :: control
Comment a move on my profile and I will add it.




If you have a signature that requires Shift+down, paste this at the bottom of it. If you actually read this far, you deserve my respect. -50_scratch_tabs
UserBlockedYou
Scratcher
37 posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

add file checking please
(file::sensing)
ask file []::sensing

True Identity:
UNKNOWN
User’s Roblox Account 1!
Working on:
Part 3 ~ 7 for URA1
Go to Show&Tell -> User’s Roblox Account
Scratchedbyyou
Scratcher
100+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

UserBlockedYou wrote:

add file checking please
(file::sensing)
ask file []::sensing
This isn't the place to suggest. Make a new topic instead

My profile here!
My alternate account here!
My forums account here!
If you want to comment about one or more posts I made, I recommend posting the comment on my forums account.
If you see me or any of my accounts using the support convention, its an old post.
I make animations and games. I also do a little posting on the forums. Scratch is a great place!
when green flag clicked
set voice to [tenor v]::pen
say [I do F4F]::custom

define say (words)
say (words)
speak (words)::pen
say []
50_scratch_tabs
Scratcher
500+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Wow. I'm already unfollowing this topic. Let me know on my profile if anything related to my post happened.

I used to be the 9000th post on TOLORS.

Last edited by 50_scratch_tabs (Oct. 18, 2024 18:35:43)


Highlight this text and Shift+Down for more fun!

I don't mind if you post off-topic replies on my profile, but please don't post links to posts you think I missed. I follow every topic I post in, and I'm often too busy to be on Scratch.

He/Him | ATer? | I like Scratch API projects like this one, which usually knows it's own stats!

Scratch (obviously) | Python | HTML/CSS/JS | PHP | Minecraft | Slightly C/C++ | One of these days I'll learn Java.

I used to have the 9000th post on TOLORS | My first post was an accident | Interesting comment thread

Tic-tac-toe :: events hat
(1::grey) (X:: variables) (3::grey):: stack grey
(4::grey) (O:: sensing) (6::grey):: stack grey
(X:: variables) (O:: control) (X :: variables):: stack grey

Colors :: events hat
50_scratch_tabs \(me) :: variables
8to16 :: sensing
SaberDragon73 :: control
Comment a move on my profile and I will add it.




If you have a signature that requires Shift+down, paste this at the bottom of it. If you actually read this far, you deserve my respect. -50_scratch_tabs
UserBlockedYou
Scratcher
37 posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

Scratchedbyyou wrote:

UserBlockedYou wrote:

add file checking please
(file::sensing)
ask file []::sensing
This isn't the place to suggest. Make a new topic instead
i meant add file checking into the rejected suggestions list

True Identity:
UNKNOWN
User’s Roblox Account 1!
Working on:
Part 3 ~ 7 for URA1
Go to Show&Tell -> User’s Roblox Account
50_scratch_tabs
Scratcher
500+ posts

The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

8to16 wrote:

(#9001)
King of the page
Is it allowed to do that? I know if you have something constructive to say, no one cares, but just saying king of the page is just kind of spammy.

See, when I'm about to be king of the page (or 9000th post, check my siggy) I think of something constructive to say so that I can be king of the page.

Shoot, I'm kind of derailing, but my time machine's batteries just died.

Last edited by 50_scratch_tabs (Oct. 11, 2024 11:58:22)


Highlight this text and Shift+Down for more fun!

I don't mind if you post off-topic replies on my profile, but please don't post links to posts you think I missed. I follow every topic I post in, and I'm often too busy to be on Scratch.

He/Him | ATer? | I like Scratch API projects like this one, which usually knows it's own stats!

Scratch (obviously) | Python | HTML/CSS/JS | PHP | Minecraft | Slightly C/C++ | One of these days I'll learn Java.

I used to have the 9000th post on TOLORS | My first post was an accident | Interesting comment thread

Tic-tac-toe :: events hat
(1::grey) (X:: variables) (3::grey):: stack grey
(4::grey) (O:: sensing) (6::grey):: stack grey
(X:: variables) (O:: control) (X :: variables):: stack grey

Colors :: events hat
50_scratch_tabs \(me) :: variables
8to16 :: sensing
SaberDragon73 :: control
Comment a move on my profile and I will add it.




If you have a signature that requires Shift+down, paste this at the bottom of it. If you actually read this far, you deserve my respect. -50_scratch_tabs

Powered by DjangoBB