Discuss Scratch

banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

Basically, my suggestion is studios, but as well as those, something new. This idea looks a lot like studios, but I'll explain the difference.

In reality, I'm talking about organisations. Studios contain projects by anyone, but collaborations only contain projects by it (at the very least its members). Remixing also works differently. When you click remix, a blackout will occur and a box will pop up asking where you want to remix the project into. Click on the collaboration you want to remix into or your account and press remix. If an inappropriate project is found and gets reported, then is dealt with, the Scratch team will send an alert to every member of the collaboration, or an alerts tab could be added, that is confidential to owners. Here's a quick mock-up of the projects page.

Here is also a quick mock-up of the members page.

So yeah, that's it.

Banana

EDIT: This is branching off organisations.

Last edited by banana439monkey (Feb. 20, 2017 17:00:43)

MopedenTobias
New Scratcher
19 posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

No support, just make the studio yourself.
banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

MopedenTobias wrote:

No support, just make the studio yourself.
Did you read the whole post? I doubt it.

Banana
scrooge100
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

If an inappropriate project is found and gets reported, then is dealt with, the Scratch team will send an alert to every member of the collaboration

I'm gonna have to no support, what if you have a troll friend or somebody who adds that? What if you have somebody who adds something that thinks something is a joke but gets false reported? I don't want to get banned because of somebody else's mistake.
Sigton
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

Can't everything here be achieved through studios? I don't see why this would be necessary…

Sigton
banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

Sigton wrote:

Can't everything here be achieved through studios? I don't see why this would be necessary…

Sigton
Collaboration accounts aren't allowed…

scrooge100 wrote:

If an inappropriate project is found and gets reported, then is dealt with, the Scratch team will send an alert to every member of the collaboration

I'm gonna have to no support, what if you have a troll friend or somebody who adds that? What if you have somebody who adds something that thinks something is a joke but gets false reported? I don't want to get banned because of somebody else's mistake.
True, but maybe the people who worked on the project?

Banana
Sigton
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

Can't everything here be achieved through studios? I don't see why this would be necessary…

Sigton
Collaboration accounts aren't allowed…

Banana
You didn't mention anything about accounts in the OP.

Sigton
banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

Sigton wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

Can't everything here be achieved through studios? I don't see why this would be necessary…

Sigton
Collaboration accounts aren't allowed…

Banana
You didn't mention anything about accounts in the OP.

Sigton
No, but the purpose of the suggestion is that collab accounts aren't allowed.

Banana
MathlyCat
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

Can't everything here be achieved through studios? I don't see why this would be necessary…

Sigton
Collaboration accounts aren't allowed…

Banana
You didn't mention anything about accounts in the OP.

Sigton
No, but the purpose of the suggestion is that collab accounts aren't allowed.

Banana
Okay…?

Couldn't there just be a feature to produce a project by the Studio Name and therefore automatically giving support to everyone in the studio?
banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

MathlyCat wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

Can't everything here be achieved through studios? I don't see why this would be necessary…

Sigton
Collaboration accounts aren't allowed…

Banana
You didn't mention anything about accounts in the OP.

Sigton
No, but the purpose of the suggestion is that collab accounts aren't allowed.

Banana
Okay…?

Couldn't there just be a feature to produce a project by the Studio Name and therefore automatically giving support to everyone in the studio?
What do you mean?

Banana
MathlyCat
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

banana439monkey wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

Can't everything here be achieved through studios? I don't see why this would be necessary…

Sigton
Collaboration accounts aren't allowed…

Banana
You didn't mention anything about accounts in the OP.

Sigton
No, but the purpose of the suggestion is that collab accounts aren't allowed.

Banana
Okay…?

Couldn't there just be a feature to produce a project by the Studio Name and therefore automatically giving support to everyone in the studio?
What do you mean?

Banana
You know how a project has the title and then “By: <Name>”

I'm saying you could publish a project under a studio's name, instead of as a remix; like you wanted I presume.
banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

MathlyCat wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

Can't everything here be achieved through studios? I don't see why this would be necessary…

Sigton
Collaboration accounts aren't allowed…

Banana
You didn't mention anything about accounts in the OP.

Sigton
No, but the purpose of the suggestion is that collab accounts aren't allowed.

Banana
Okay…?

Couldn't there just be a feature to produce a project by the Studio Name and therefore automatically giving support to everyone in the studio?
What do you mean?

Banana
You know how a project has the title and then “By: <Name>”

I'm saying you could publish a project under a studio's name, instead of as a remix; like you wanted I presume.
I'm too sick to know what you mean.

Banana
yoshifan509
Scratcher
100+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

I don't know if this would work, but you may be able to use GitHub and collab there. I haven't personally tried it but i think it would work. Plus, if anything happens, such as a troll friend, you can go back and revert it. All you have to do is un-.sb2 the project by renaming the project to
project.zip
then upload the contents to GitHub.

Bitbucket and GitLab work too.
banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

yoshifan509 wrote:

I don't know if this would work, but you may be able to use GitHub and collab there. I haven't personally tried it but i think it would work. Plus, if anything happens, such as a troll friend, you can go back and revert it. All you have to do is un-.sb2 the project by renaming the project to
project.zip
then upload the contents to GitHub.

Bitbucket and GitLab work too.
True, but collab accounts would still be used more and not everyone has GitHub.

Banana
Sigton
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

banana439monkey wrote:

No, but the purpose of the suggestion is that collab accounts aren't allowed.

Banana
That doesn't take away from the fact that everything you're suggesting can be achieved from studios.

Sigton

Last edited by Sigton (Feb. 21, 2017 20:13:22)

banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

Sigton wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

No, but the purpose of the suggestion is that collab accounts aren't allowed.

Banana
That doesn't take away from the fact that everything you're suggesting can be achieved from studios.

Sigton
Studios contain projects by other people including its projects. Collabs only contain projects by it.

Banana
Sigton
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

No, but the purpose of the suggestion is that collab accounts aren't allowed.

Banana
That doesn't take away from the fact that everything you're suggesting can be achieved from studios.

Sigton
Studios contain projects by other people including its projects. Collabs only contain projects by it.

Banana
Only invite the members of your collab to curate then?

Sigton
banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

Sigton wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

Sigton wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

No, but the purpose of the suggestion is that collab accounts aren't allowed.

Banana
That doesn't take away from the fact that everything you're suggesting can be achieved from studios.

Sigton
Studios contain projects by other people including its projects. Collabs only contain projects by it.

Banana
Only invite the members of your collab to curate then?

Sigton
Ye

Banana
Sigton
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

banana439monkey wrote:

Ye

Banana
So you can just use studios?

Sigton
banana439monkey
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Collaborations - A better way to collaborate

Sigton wrote:

banana439monkey wrote:

Ye

Banana
So you can just use studios?

Sigton
No. Studios require a shared account.

Banana

Powered by DjangoBB