✰ ITopic: Complete List of Rejected Suggestions ✰

red_king_cyclops

Of the 30 rejected suggestions stated in this thread, only 25 of them are explained why they are rejected, when all of they could have been explained. This thread seems somewhat underdone.

Edit: The explanations section is also not organized in the same way as the list of rejected suggestions. And also, I don't mean to be condescending or insensitive to the fact that customhacker is extremely busy.

Last edited by red_king_cyclops (May 20, 2018 12:37:57)

technoboy1

There needs to be a sort by: newest to oldest for people's projects. If someone's looking for an old project, they'll find it to be easier to find that project. I find the sorting systems on scratch to be inconvenient.

Last edited by technoboy1 (May 21, 2018 04:14:11)

miniepicness

customhacker wrote:

all at once{...}:: control // Replaced with 'run without screen refresh' in custom blocks.

This still exists, it just does nothing. It has also been added to 3.0, also doing nothing.

customhacker

red_king_cyclops wrote:
Of the 30 rejected suggestions stated in this thread, only 25 of them are explained why they are rejected, when all of they could have been explained. This thread seems somewhat underdone.

Edit: The explanations section is also not organized in the same way as the list of rejected suggestions. And also, I don't mean to be condescending or insensitive to the fact that customhacker is extremely busy.

Literally just saw this. Will fix in the summer.

customhacker

miniepicness wrote:
customhacker wrote:
all at once{...}:: control // Replaced with 'run without screen refresh' in custom blocks.
This still exists, it just does nothing. It has also been added to 3.0, also doing nothing.

!
Source?

:P …When youve been away from Scratch so long you forget that there is a 60 second rule!

gdpr0000067

They should do studios of studios.

MissPikachu78

I want Scratch to get the feature to change usernames. Say you had a really bad username (like one you made when you were six) and you have to make a new account to change it! #AddChangingUsernames

78ch3

MissPikachu78 wrote:
I want Scratch to get the feature to change usernames. Say you had a really bad username (like one you made when you were six) and you have to make a new account to change it! #AddChangingUsernames

That is a rejected suggestion. Also, please do not post suggestions here

Tymewalk

Was #26 actually rejected? I remember making a post about bringing back Community Mods a while back, and it wasn't rejected (unless #26 deals with something different.)

designsquadlover

I know how you all feel! If you go to “Suggestions” then go to the discussion “Making the Report system better”, you will see that my idea has been rejected and people apparently hate me and my dumb-ish ideas. XD

designsquadlover

What the heck! #SupportNetNeutrality

Wahsp

customhacker wrote:
red_king_cyclops wrote:
Of the 30 rejected suggestions stated in this thread, only 25 of them are explained why they are rejected, when all of they could have been explained. This thread seems somewhat underdone.

Edit: The explanations section is also not organized in the same way as the list of rejected suggestions. And also, I don't mean to be condescending or insensitive to the fact that customhacker is extremely busy.

Literally just saw this. Will fix in the summer.

Some evidence for number 28
Came here after I saw that posted to see if it was already rejected

Ryrie36

customhacker wrote:
Welcome to the ✰ Complete List of Rejected Suggestions ✰! Here is where I will list any rejected suggestions. I will not provide workarounds, as there is already a sticky for that. I ask that you not suggest new features here. If you do, it will just be ignored, and possibly reported. Click the links below to go to the different lists.

Rejected Features
Rejected Features Explained
Rejected Blocks
Removed Features and Blocks
Coming Soon

Note: I have now noticed that this has become a sticky. I have been working on a replacement, as this has been getting old and not edited. I have conflicts with school, but during school breaks I can work to edit and put this back up to standard.

Wouldn't this be better in a blog post?

TheAdriCoolManDude

Ryrie36 wrote:
customhacker wrote:
Welcome to the ✰ Complete List of Rejected Suggestions ✰! Here is where I will list any rejected suggestions. I will not provide workarounds, as there is already a sticky for that. I ask that you not suggest new features here. If you do, it will just be ignored, and possibly reported. Click the links below to go to the different lists.

Rejected Features
Rejected Features Explained
Rejected Blocks
Removed Features and Blocks
Coming Soon

Note: I have now noticed that this has become a sticky. I have been working on a replacement, as this has been getting old and not edited. I have conflicts with school, but during school breaks I can work to edit and put this back up to standard.
Wouldn't this be better in a blog post?

This is a sticky on the suggestions forum…

Addust

3D scratch was already made. Someone made a SGE ( Scratch Game Engine ) so if you insert it the game is 3D.

reallyharduser

Great job! The random sprite button is making a return in 3.0.

Last edited by reallyharduser (July 2, 2018 18:21:08)

AmazingMech2418

3D Scratch could just be added in an premade extension…

Ryrie36

customhacker wrote:
Rejected Features

The following are rejected features for the website. Explanations are included in a different post.

Cloud Chats
Private Messages
Restricting Sharing/See Inside
Rating Projects
Removing 60/120 Second Rule
Removing Restricted Image Hosts/Adding your own sites
Deleting comments on other profiles/Deleting Forum Posts
3D Scratch
<broadcast received> block
Game Badges/Achievements
Changing Usernames
Off-Topic/Miscellaneous Forum
13+ Site
Removing Add Everything Studios
Scratch Money
Remove Phone # Sensor
Text Based Games
Banning Minor Remixes
Banning Follow For Follow
Ignore List (Blocking Users)
When Stop Sign Clicked
Live Editing
Banning Projects with No Programming
Showing When Users Are Banned
Ranks Above Scratcher
Moderating Mini-Mods
Removing Studio Activity Messages
Scratch Team Cannot Post Political Views
Bringing Back the Discuss Button
Removing the Suggestions Forum

But there's already a bunch of 3D projects on Scratch!
Also, who the heck asked for a 13+ site?

PhantomForcesX

I think a variable reference would be great, like if you right click a variable and highlight all uses of said variable so you know where to continue on where you left off. kind of like Show recievers Show broadcasters in broadcast.

ScratchDiogoh

The last 5 suggestions (25-30) have no reason!

Discuss Scratch