Discuss Scratch
- Discussion Forums
- » Collaboration
- » OS Wars III
![[RSS Feed]](//cdn.scratch.mit.edu/scratchr2/static/__f17a70240ea1b997b429416c7f10eabf__//djangobb_forum/img/feed-icon-small.png "[RSS Feed]")
![[RSS Feed]](http://cdn.scratch.mit.edu/scratchr2/static/__f17a70240ea1b997b429416c7f10eabf__//djangobb_forum/img/feed-icon-small.png "[RSS Feed]"){kind=icon}
- above
-
Scratcher
38 posts
OS Wars III
I moved on from scratch, but it's still nice that OS wars is still continuing. Been in the first and second Os wars. 
EDIT:I just realized I had the 2nd OS wars thing as my sig lol
EDIT:I just realized I had the 2nd OS wars thing as my sig lolLast edited by above (Jan. 11, 2017 04:10:48)
Hello, If you see this, you have spent way too long on the internet. Go outside for a breath of fresh air.
so I can gotside
- IcyCoder
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
OS Wars III
I am starting to judge 
I promise I will not be biased in my judging. If you forgot this is how we score:
Design: ?/100
Content: ?/100
How good have they completed the round''s requirements: ?/100
Good luck!
I promise I will not be biased in my judging. If you forgot this is how we score:Design: ?/100
Content: ?/100
How good have they completed the round''s requirements: ?/100
Good luck!
Because JS is the future (echos) future future futur futu fut fu f
- IcyCoder
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
OS Wars III
Note I scored this out of 10 points and then converted it into the 100 points system.
Green OS:
Design: 70/100
I did not really like the green color kind of hurt my eyes but I liked the grey color that Green OS had. The + button seemed oddly placed. Loved the place were the power button is but the bell seems like I am opening up a notification center but I am actually opening up a place with the power button. Really like the login screen nothing bad to say about it but the fact that the text took a while (about 2 seconds) to render on my mac even though there is really not much text to render… you probably need a new text engine.
Content: 95/100
You guys had everything we wanted even some stuff we did not ask for but sadly no thumbnail.
How good have they completed the round's requirements: 100/100
You guys have all the required elements and more.
Total: 265/300
Red OS:
Design: 85/100
I loved loved LOVED the live wallpaper and the image you chose fit well with the overall theme of a Red OS and no matter how I moved the wall paper I could still read the click to authenticate button though it is jumping. The transition from live to still was very smooth. I did not like the authentication method
and I could not figure out how to really use it… also on the create account screen the lock went over the text a little bit. All the transitions were a nice touch to the OS.
Content: 80/100
I would have liked if everything was completed and if there was a thumbnail but that was not the case with this OS.
How good have they completed the round''s requirements: 80/100
The OS was not completed as far as I know (correct me if I am wrong) with things such as the lock not being able to unlock and you cannot create an account.
Total: 245/300
Blue OS:
Design: 60/100
I liked the blue background and the icons. But there was not much added to the different screens which was a big disappointment for me. The rolling Icon start was pretty cool. Because lack of content such as a non automatic authentication that is the biggest thing to judge on took a hit on this.
Content: 80/100
Good job being the only ones to implement cloud data to the OS I would have liked an authentication system but the auto login is actually a pretty cool idea. I do not think the terms are necessary but they are a creative touch.
How good have they completed the round's requirements: 90/100
I am not really that sure because they did a lot of stuff differently than expected from them. So I am just gonna give a 90 though they may have done everything.
Total: 230/300
I think I am not the only judge so these may not be the final results. Good job you guys but next round PLEASE be more active because a lot of these things could have been fixed easily. If you have any questions please ask me on my profile so I can respond quicker
If this is the final results then these are the results for the first round:
1. Green OS 265/300
2. Red OS 245/300
3. Blue OS 230/300
Green OS:
Design: 70/100
I did not really like the green color kind of hurt my eyes but I liked the grey color that Green OS had. The + button seemed oddly placed. Loved the place were the power button is but the bell seems like I am opening up a notification center but I am actually opening up a place with the power button. Really like the login screen nothing bad to say about it but the fact that the text took a while (about 2 seconds) to render on my mac even though there is really not much text to render… you probably need a new text engine.
Content: 95/100
You guys had everything we wanted even some stuff we did not ask for but sadly no thumbnail.
How good have they completed the round's requirements: 100/100
You guys have all the required elements and more.
Total: 265/300
Red OS:
Design: 85/100
I loved loved LOVED the live wallpaper and the image you chose fit well with the overall theme of a Red OS and no matter how I moved the wall paper I could still read the click to authenticate button though it is jumping. The transition from live to still was very smooth. I did not like the authentication method
and I could not figure out how to really use it… also on the create account screen the lock went over the text a little bit. All the transitions were a nice touch to the OS.Content: 80/100
I would have liked if everything was completed and if there was a thumbnail
but that was not the case with this OS.How good have they completed the round''s requirements: 80/100
The OS was not completed as far as I know (correct me if I am wrong) with things such as the lock not being able to unlock and you cannot create an account.
Total: 245/300
Blue OS:
Design: 60/100
I liked the blue background and the icons. But there was not much added to the different screens which was a big disappointment for me. The rolling Icon start was pretty cool. Because lack of content such as a non automatic authentication that is the biggest thing to judge on took a hit on this.
Content: 80/100
Good job being the only ones to implement cloud data to the OS
I would have liked an authentication system but the auto login is actually a pretty cool idea. I do not think the terms are necessary but they are a creative touch.How good have they completed the round's requirements: 90/100
I am not really that sure because they did a lot of stuff differently than expected from them. So I am just gonna give a 90 though they may have done everything.
Total: 230/300
I think I am not the only judge so these may not be the final results. Good job you guys
but next round PLEASE be more active because a lot of these things could have been fixed easily. If you have any questions please ask me on my profile so I can respond quicker If this is the final results then these are the results for the first round:
1. Green OS 265/300
2. Red OS 245/300
3. Blue OS 230/300
Because JS is the future (echos) future future futur futu fut fu f
- pixelFlow
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
OS Wars III
Note I scored this out of 10 points and then converted it into the 100 points system.IvyUI is also judging.
Green OS:
Design: 70/100
I did not really like the green color kind of hurt my eyes but I liked the grey color that Green OS had. The + button seemed oddly placed. Loved the place were the power button is but the bell seems like I am opening up a notification center but I am actually opening up a place with the power button. Really like the login screen nothing bad to say about it but the fact that the text took a while (about 2 seconds) to render on my mac even though there is really not much text to render… you probably need a new text engine.
Content: 95/100
You guys had everything we wanted even some stuff we did not ask for but sadly no thumbnail.
How good have they completed the round's requirements: 100/100
You guys have all the required elements and more.
Total: 265/300
Red OS:
Design: 85/100
I loved loved LOVED the live wallpaper and the image you chose fit well with the overall theme of a Red OS and no matter how I moved the wall paper I could still read the click to authenticate button though it is jumping. The transition from live to still was very smooth. I did not like the authentication method
Content: 80/100
I would have liked if everything was completed and if there was a thumbnail
How good have they completed the round''s requirements: 80/100
The OS was not completed as far as I know (correct me if I am wrong) with things such as the lock not being able to unlock and you cannot create an account.
Total: 245/300
Blue OS:
Design: 60/100
I liked the blue background and the icons. But there was not much added to the different screens which was a big disappointment for me. The rolling Icon start was pretty cool. Because lack of content such as a non automatic authentication that is the biggest thing to judge on took a hit on this.
Content: 80/100
Good job being the only ones to implement cloud data to the OS
How good have they completed the round's requirements: 90/100
I am not really that sure because they did a lot of stuff differently than expected from them. So I am just gonna give a 90 though they may have done everything.
Total: 230/300
I think I am not the only judge so these may not be the final results. Good job you guys
If this is the final results then these are the results for the first round:
1. Green OS 265/300
2. Red OS 245/300
3. Blue OS 230/300
What's up Scratchers, I'm @pixelFlow, and I love Scratch. The community, the projects, the idea. It's all amazing. It's so cool.
ヅ // This is Flo - She protects my signature from the evil, evil kumquats.
- IcyCoder
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
OS Wars III
-snip-IvyUI is also judging.
OK thought so.
Because JS is the future (echos) future future futur futu fut fu f
- -FrozenFlame-
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
OS Wars III
hey what we didn't even finish but we surprisingly get more than blue? interesting
Hi! Bonjour! 你好！
(Kumquat) //This is Kumquat, my kumquat protector... wait what?
^^^ click that to join the competition! Hosted by me and co-hosted by Amazeheartsoflove
- pixelFlow
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
OS Wars III
/\/\
ahah!
ahah!
Well…
What's up Scratchers, I'm @pixelFlow, and I love Scratch. The community, the projects, the idea. It's all amazing. It's so cool.
ヅ // This is Flo - She protects my signature from the evil, evil kumquats.
- IvyUI
-
Scratcher
17 posts
OS Wars III
ROUND 1 JUDGING (Flow-)
Note: My judging is based on an assessment rubric. If a team was able to complete the requirements, they get the most points. Adding optional features would give you more points too.
Team Green OS
Design: 70/100.
A neat, functional design worked well for the OS.
Following rules: 58/100.
Out of all the OS's, Green OS by far accomplished most of the rules.
Content: 79/100.
Green OS had some nice features that other OS's lacked.
Team Red OS
Design: 82/100.
Red OS had an outstanding design. The animations were very nice.
Following rules: 30/100.
I could not get passed the lock screen. No evidence of multiple accounts.
Content: 40/100
Some nice features, but they aren't working.
Team Blue OS
Unfortunately, Blue OS did not follow the rules at all. This resulted in a low score.
Design: 71/100
Boot animation and colours were nice. Slight inconsistency with some design elements.
Following rules: 5/100
No evidence of a lock screen. This is essential.
Content: 10/100
The addition of a Terms and Conditions was nice.
Note: My judging is based on an assessment rubric. If a team was able to complete the requirements, they get the most points. Adding optional features would give you more points too.
Team Green OS
Design: 70/100.
A neat, functional design worked well for the OS.
Following rules: 58/100.
Out of all the OS's, Green OS by far accomplished most of the rules.
Content: 79/100.
Green OS had some nice features that other OS's lacked.
Team Red OS
Design: 82/100.
Red OS had an outstanding design. The animations were very nice.
Following rules: 30/100.
I could not get passed the lock screen. No evidence of multiple accounts.
Content: 40/100
Some nice features, but they aren't working.
Team Blue OS
Unfortunately, Blue OS did not follow the rules at all. This resulted in a low score.
Design: 71/100
Boot animation and colours were nice. Slight inconsistency with some design elements.
Following rules: 5/100
No evidence of a lock screen. This is essential.
Content: 10/100
The addition of a Terms and Conditions was nice.
- IcyCoder
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
OS Wars III
So Round 1 is over! The total points is:
#1 Green OS: 472/600
#2 Red OS: 397/600
#3 Blue OS: 316/600
Round 2 will be announced soon!
The total points is:#1 Green OS: 472/600
#2 Red OS: 397/600
#3 Blue OS: 316/600
Round 2 will be announced soon!
Because JS is the future (echos) future future futur futu fut fu f
- Sheep_maker
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
OS Wars III
Round 2 will be announced soon!It already has.
- Sheep_maker This is a kumquat-free signature. :P
This is my signature. It appears below all my posts. Discuss it on my profile, not the forums. Here's how to make your own.
.postsignature { overflow: auto; } .scratchblocks { overflow-x: auto; overflow-y: hidden; }
- pixelFlow
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
OS Wars III
Ohai!Round 2 will be announced soon!It already has.
What's up Scratchers, I'm @pixelFlow, and I love Scratch. The community, the projects, the idea. It's all amazing. It's so cool.
ヅ // This is Flo - She protects my signature from the evil, evil kumquats.
- pixelFlow
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
OS Wars III
THE OFFICAL RESULTS:
Green: 472/600
Blue: 397/600
Red: 316/600
Green: 472/600
Blue: 397/600
Red: 316/600
The next round ends on 28th February 2017 and is Here!
Wishing you all the best,
-pixelFlow
You may now add people who WANT to join your team BY YOURSELF. Some teams are dying. Drink an ‘Add Member’ potion and.. add members. (lol!) Judges, you will be judging on the same principles, but this time, I am judging with you. Co's: You have permission to kick inactive members. Please do!Keep OS-ing!
Last edited by pixelFlow (Jan. 24, 2017 13:29:31)
What's up Scratchers, I'm @pixelFlow, and I love Scratch. The community, the projects, the idea. It's all amazing. It's so cool.
ヅ // This is Flo - She protects my signature from the evil, evil kumquats.
- -PixelByte-
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
OS Wars III
Green OS might have scored higher if we had something to do with cloud data.. we did have a triple cloud list made by @ultimate9 for logins and stuff, but it was glitching so we had to remove it. @IcyCoder and @IvyUI - thanks for scoring us so well
I'm just a forum helper looking to code, write, produce, record, rap, and design. I'm also Christian and conservative.
Looking forward to using 3.0 on mobile
- IcyCoder
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
OS Wars III
Green OS might have scored higher if we had something to do with cloud data.. we did have a triple cloud list made by @ultimate9 for logins and stuff, but it was glitching so we had to remove it. @IcyCoder and @IvyUI - thanks for scoring us so wellThat is very true unforchantly Blue OS would have also scored higher if they focused more on design rather than the backend stuff such as cloud data.
Because JS is the future (echos) future future futur futu fut fu f
- Discussion Forums
- » Collaboration
-
» OS Wars III