Discuss Scratch

BookOwl
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

Yes Firedrake, this is what my bot has been doing!

A long time ago in an ATer's profile far, far away I forget whose, somebody asked what would happen if a bot was to start posting on the suggestions forum. I decided to find out!
My bot has been posting 10 times a day during the morning on suggestion topics. It was programmed to be biased towards topics on the front page, but it could pick one from farther back.

How did my bot work?
It was actually quite simple. I made a list of possible responses, and had the bot use the selenium module to post a response chosen from random on that topic. You can find the source code here.

What were the results?
For the most part, nothing happened. People treated my bot's posts just like all the others. There were a couple incidents, however.
The first one was a suggestion for a better forum system, and my bot posted
workaroundable, no support.
That got people riled up!

My bot also posted
add [me] to [supporters  v]
on a spam topic, which made Zro tell my bot to stop being funny

So what do you think of this?
Oh, and in case you were wondering, the bot's username is Sparkfunny
BookOwl
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

Here is a list of all the topics my bot posted on:
'173464',
'173749',
'173757',
'28755',
'171790',
'173435',
'9907',
'90512',
'173769',
'173069',
'31540',
'46888',
'173288',
'173891',
'107668',
'86622',
'130340',
'144042',
'169553',
'80964',
'155900',
'174430',
'174403',
'174273',
'174483',
'174307',
'21592',
'174364',
'19403',
'174434',
'159832',
'60776',
'174560',
'174580',
'174642',
'10579',
'174567',
'174654',
'174629',
'174283',
'174705',
'120538',
'174825',
'17298',
'3930',
'174765',
'174855',
'47360',
'174791',
'174812'
Dylan5797
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

BookOwl wrote:

Yes Firedrake, this is what my bot has been doing!

A long time ago in an ATer's profile far, far away I forget whose, somebody asked what would happen if a bot was to start posting on the suggestions forum. I decided to find out!
My bot has been posting 10 times a day during the morning on suggestion topics. It was programmed to be biased towards topics on the front page, but it could pick one from farther back.

How did my bot work?
It was actually quite simple. I made a list of possible responses, and had the bot use the selenium module to post a response chosen from random on that topic. You can find the source code here.

What were the results?
For the most part, nothing happened. People treated my bot's posts just like all the others. There were a couple incidents, however.
The first one was a suggestion for a better forum system, and my bot posted
workaroundable, no support.
That got people riled up!

My bot also posted
add [me] to [supporters  v]
on a spam topic, which made Zro tell my bot to stop being funny

So what do you think of this?
Oh, and in case you were wondering, the bot's username is Sparkfunny
Selenium is awesome, I use it all the time!
Dylan5797
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

Firedrake969
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

You horrible person. (jk)

It would be interesting if you could analyze the sentiment of posts and determine what the crowd is saying, and then post something similar.

Last edited by Firedrake969 (Dec. 23, 2015 16:16:38)

Dylan5797
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

Firedrake969 wrote:

You horrible person. (jk)

It would be interesting if you could analyze the sentiment of posts and determine what the crowd is saying, and then post something similar.
I might make a bot to reply to your posts and say “don't listen to them, they are a bot”
DigiTechs
Scratcher
500+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

Dylan5797 wrote:

Firedrake969 wrote:

You horrible person. (jk)

It would be interesting if you could analyze the sentiment of posts and determine what the crowd is saying, and then post something similar.
I might make a bot to reply to your posts and say “don't listen to them, they are a bot”

And then replies with a similar random statement out of a randomly generated list.

Muhahahahahaha.
Firedrake969
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

Then the forums will be run by bots….
Thepuzzlegame
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

Dylan5797 wrote:

Also https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/post/1684518/
https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/174580/?page=1#post-1682009 hehe

Now here's an idea. Create a bot which reads the information in the topic post and then attempts to generate a reason for supporting/not supporting.
tiger75
Scratcher
100+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

Your bot posted 50% support on one of my suggestions! I though it was a regular user, until I saw this topic.
liam48D
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

hehe
ChocolatePi
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

I knew it was a bot the whole time. little nod to you

also it was my profile. i had this idea for a long time but i thought it would get banned quickly. great implementation!

Last edited by ChocolatePi (Dec. 23, 2015 19:28:55)

DaSpudLord
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

Well.

I actually don't know what to do with this information.

Well played, BookOwl. Well played.

Last edited by DaSpudLord (Dec. 23, 2015 19:33:01)

IronBit_Studios
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

I knew something was fishy about sparkfunny.
One does not simply support a topic that wants to fine people for having 50MB projects
Scratcher1002
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

IronBit_Studios wrote:

I knew something was fishy about sparkfunny.
One does not simply support a topic that wants to fine people for having 50MB projects
True.

DaSpudLord wrote:

Well.

I actually don't know what to do with this information.

Well played, BookOwl. Well played.
Yup. ^^

no support, workaroundable.
Rumanti
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?



Anyway - I am quite clueless here - is the goal to make a bot that behaves like a human, or annoy people? “What would happen if a bot was to start posting on the suggestions forum” doesn't give much information
BookOwl
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

Rumanti wrote:



Anyway - I am quite clueless here - is the goal to make a bot that behaves like a human, or annoy people? “What would happen if a bot was to start posting on the suggestions forum” doesn't give much information
Basically, it was an experiment to see if a bot could get away with posting on the suggestions forum for a long-ish period of time (5 days). It also turned out to be a good protest against bad quality posts.

IronBit_Studios wrote:

I knew something was fishy about sparkfunny.
One does not simply support a topic that wants to fine people for having 50MB projects
Maybe Sparkfunny likes making people spend money!

DaSpudLord wrote:

Well.

I actually don't know what to do with this information.

Well played, BookOwl. Well played.

ChocolatePi wrote:

I knew it was a bot the whole time. little nod to you

also it was my profile. i had this idea for a long time but i thought it would get banned quickly. great implementation!
Thanks!

liam48D wrote:

hehe
BookOwl
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

I found a new hobby: read all the reactions to my bot's posts!
Tropic
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

BookOwl wrote:

I found a new hobby: read all the reactions to my bot's posts!
Really I thought that bot was a real person too xD
IronBit_Studios
Scratcher
1000+ posts

What would happen if a bot was let loose on the Suggestions forum?

So should the post be valid or sodium hydrogen?

Last edited by IronBit_Studios (Dec. 23, 2015 22:32:28)

Powered by DjangoBB