Ionosphere wrote:

Okay so have we decided?

No idea, I've just done what I've been told to do

Ionosphere wrote:

Okay so have we decided?

I think so. I'll try to start on my Round 2 project soon. Ionosphere (you) , The_Icecream_girl, and Ipzy (guest judge) will be judging that round.

What about LMB?

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

Okay so have we decided?

I think so. I'll try to start on my Round 2 project soon. Ionosphere (you) , The_Icecream_girl, and Ipzy (guest judge) will be judging that round.

How 'bout LMB♥?

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

Okay so have we decided?

I think so. I'll try to start on my Round 2 project soon. Ionosphere (you) , The_Icecream_girl, and Ipzy (guest judge) will be judging that round.

How 'bout LMB♥?

LMB was the guest judge for Round 1, which is why it was themed about her. Round 2 will have ipzy's theme.

Ageren wrote:

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

Okay so have we decided?

I think so. I'll try to start on my Round 2 project soon. Ionosphere (you) , The_Icecream_girl, and Ipzy (guest judge) will be judging that round.

How 'bout LMB♥?

LMB was the guest judge for Round 1, which is why it was themed about her. Round 2 will have ipzy's theme.

Oh, gotcha :3 Do you know who could be guest judge for Round 3? I have ideas….

Okay. I understand. I have ideas for Round 3's guest judge as well.

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

Okay so have we decided?

I think so. I'll try to start on my Round 2 project soon. Ionosphere (you) , The_Icecream_girl, and Ipzy (guest judge) will be judging that round.

How 'bout LMB♥?

LMB was the guest judge for Round 1, which is why it was themed about her. Round 2 will have ipzy's theme.

Oh, gotcha :3 Do you know who could be guest judge for Round 3? I have ideas….

I already have @GreenIeaf as guest judge, but if there's a tie for 1st, 2nd, or 3rd, I'll probably do another round, so who's your choice?

Ageren wrote:

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

Okay so have we decided?

I think so. I'll try to start on my Round 2 project soon. Ionosphere (you) , The_Icecream_girl, and Ipzy (guest judge) will be judging that round.

How 'bout LMB♥?

LMB was the guest judge for Round 1, which is why it was themed about her. Round 2 will have ipzy's theme.

Oh, gotcha :3 Do you know who could be guest judge for Round 3? I have ideas….

I already have @GreenIeaf as guest judge, but if there's a tie for 1st, 2nd, or 3rd, I'll probably do another round, so who's your choice?

LOL, actually GreenIeaf was actually one of my ideas. I think CrazyNimbus or Buttons27 are also great Maybe if the competition is intense we can invite 2 guest judges!?!?

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

Those are good, but maybe Fanta is busy with her Chopped thing…

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

Okay so have we decided?

I think so. I'll try to start on my Round 2 project soon. Ionosphere (you) , The_Icecream_girl, and Ipzy (guest judge) will be judging that round.

How 'bout LMB♥?

LMB was the guest judge for Round 1, which is why it was themed about her. Round 2 will have ipzy's theme.

Oh, gotcha :3 Do you know who could be guest judge for Round 3? I have ideas….

I already have @GreenIeaf as guest judge, but if there's a tie for 1st, 2nd, or 3rd, I'll probably do another round, so who's your choice?

LOL, actually GreenIeaf was actually one of my ideas. I think CrazyNimbus or Buttons27 are also great Maybe if the competition is intense we can invite 2 guest judges!?!?

Oooh, good idea. I might invite CrazyNimbus for the 3rd round for more judges, but if I do, I'll wait a little, since I'm only on the 2nd round.

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

If I need an extra judge, I'm probably going to do Crazy.

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

If I need an extra judge, I'm probably going to do Crazy.

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

If I need an extra judge, I'm probably going to do Crazy.

Good idea She was my surprise judge for my Popsicle CC; she's a good judge

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

If I need an extra judge, I'm probably going to do Crazy.

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

If I need an extra judge, I'm probably going to do Crazy.

Good idea She was my surprise judge for my Popsicle CC; she's a good judge

Okie, great! I'm asking ipzy if she's still interested in guest judging Round 2 (just to make sure), and I'm starting to make the project.

Ageren wrote:

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

If I need an extra judge, I'm probably going to do Crazy.

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

If I need an extra judge, I'm probably going to do Crazy.

Good idea She was my surprise judge for my Popsicle CC; she's a good judge

Okie, great! I'm asking ipzy if she's still interested in guest judging Round 2 (just to make sure), and I'm starting to make the project.

Okies ♥ She probably will, unless she's too busy with her new RP thing or something else ^U^

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

If I need an extra judge, I'm probably going to do Crazy.

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

If I need an extra judge, I'm probably going to do Crazy.

Good idea She was my surprise judge for my Popsicle CC; she's a good judge

Okie, great! I'm asking ipzy if she's still interested in guest judging Round 2 (just to make sure), and I'm starting to make the project.

Okies ♥ She probably will, unless she's too busy with her new RP thing or something else ^U^

Ya, she said yes. I'm making the 2nd project.

Ageren wrote:

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

If I need an extra judge, I'm probably going to do Crazy.

Ageren wrote:

Ionosphere wrote:

@Fantasmalistic or @CrazyNimbus

If I need an extra judge, I'm probably going to do Crazy.

Good idea She was my surprise judge for my Popsicle CC; she's a good judge

Okie, great! I'm asking ipzy if she's still interested in guest judging Round 2 (just to make sure), and I'm starting to make the project.

Okies ♥ She probably will, unless she's too busy with her new RP thing or something else ^U^

Ya, she said yes. I'm making the 2nd project.

Yayay! Woohoo~ Can't wait to see it

Ageren wrote:

Hi, judges! I have just gotten 23 entries on my project Cupcake Wars. I would love it if you helped me judge. Out of the 23 entries, 3 are just remixes of the project, and 20 are entries. At the end of this round's discussion, we'll have 13 people going on to the next round. I'm going to say that Room2pass and CutePavo should not be voted out, because their entries are really good. Please tell me who you think should stay in right now, and Round 1 closes, we'll decide who should be out.
~ Ageren

For Round 2, if we can start judging, I checked out the entries. I dunno how many people you want eliminated, but I just picked out the ones I thought could be improved. If were to eliminate, I would eliminate these first:
Humann
Supersmart1
krlkrl
mamjunet
rblz

These were pretty good but if you had to eliminate more, here are the choices:
Cutepavo
mallow-cupcakes

They all did a wonderful job, but I deducted points for sloppy art or if they used niubun's icon because that's not as original…?
Reply if you agree or don't agree with my choices; thanks for hosting, it's a lot of fun

The_Icecream_Girl wrote:

Ageren wrote:

Hi, judges! I have just gotten 23 entries on my project Cupcake Wars. I would love it if you helped me judge. Out of the 23 entries, 3 are just remixes of the project, and 20 are entries. At the end of this round's discussion, we'll have 13 people going on to the next round. I'm going to say that Room2pass and CutePavo should not be voted out, because their entries are really good. Please tell me who you think should stay in right now, and Round 1 closes, we'll decide who should be out.
~ Ageren

For Round 2, if we can start judging, I checked out the entries. I dunno how many people you want eliminated, but I just picked out the ones I thought could be improved. If were to eliminate, I would eliminate these first:
Humann
Supersmart1
krlkrl
mamjunet
rblz

These were pretty good but if you had to eliminate more, here are the choices:
Cutepavo
mallow-cupcakes

They all did a wonderful job, but I deducted points for sloppy art or if they used niubun's icon because that's not as original…?
Reply if you agree or don't agree with my choices; thanks for hosting, it's a lot of fun

I definitely agree with the ones you'd eliminate first. I might need another one to eliminate. Also, I agree about using Niu's icon, because some people took the time to draw it while others didn't. And I'm glad you like Cupcake Wars!