The 5Mb project.json limit should be increased

17Domin0

cookedasparagus8 wrote:
17Domin0 wrote:
cookedasparagus8 wrote:
SicknessGradient5 wrote:
I agree.
Please explain why you support
See Post 270
That's my post

No its not

17Domin0

Star050602 wrote:
AGREE. This is horrible. Creativity should have no limits. Many great creators cant share their projects because of this limit. #increasejsonsize

Nebyx wrote:
Creativity should have no limits!!!!

Agree.

IloveRoblox003

cookedasparagus8 wrote:
17Domin0 wrote:
cookedasparagus8 wrote:
SicknessGradient5 wrote:
I agree.
Please explain why you support
See Post 270
That's my post

Ah this is a mixup

ametrine_

17Domin0 wrote:
See Post 270

on the forums, instead of just saying “support” to a topic you are meant to give a reason why you support as well. simply linking to another person's reason does not count.

cookedasparagus8

17Domin0 wrote:
No its not

That's literally not even the same poster as the person who said “Agree”

IloveRoblox003

17Domin0 wrote:
w i d e s n i p !

The quote

Agreed, It would make technical projects and 3D less limited if intended to be compatible with normal scratch.

is not the same thing as

I agree.

Last edited by IloveRoblox003 (Jan. 17, 2026 04:36:44)

pippy2011eight

I found something sort of bad: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/343602/?page=15 , it seems like the only reason why it was removed was because of lack of suggestion, not because it was “unrejected”

Last edited by pippy2011eight (Jan. 20, 2026 04:47:06)

Apfellord

pippy2011eight wrote:
I found something sort of bad: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/343602/?page=15 , it seems like the only reason why it was removed was because of lack of suggestion, not because it was “unrejected”

Just to be sure I'm not missing anything, what are you referring to here? I don't see Za-Chary mentioning anything about the json limit in this thread you linked, just the general size limit of 50mb for a scratch project back in the Scratch 2.0 days and that being lifted since 3.0. (Which unfortunately, came with the change that the json has a 5mb limit now.)

pippy2011eight

Apfellord wrote:
pippy2011eight wrote:
I found something sort of bad: https://scratch.mit.edu/discuss/topic/343602/?page=15 , it seems like the only reason why it was removed was because of lack of suggestion, not because it was “unrejected”
Just to be sure I'm not missing anything, what are you referring to here? I don't see Za-Chary mentioning anything about the json limit in this thread you linked, just the general size limit of 50mb for a scratch project back in the Scratch 2.0 days and that being lifted since 3.0. (Which unfortunately, came with the change that the json has a 5mb limit now.)

Oh, I must have misunderstood

wingrabbelgriebus

Why is this forum still here if it doesnt change, just message the curator of Turbowarp, maybe that will help

@wingrabbelgriebus

ametrine_

wingrabbelgriebus wrote:
Why is this forum still here if it doesnt change, just message the curator of Turbowarp, maybe that will help

@wingrabbelgriebus

the creator of turbowarp has no control of what gets added to scratch

17Domin0

wingrabbelgriebus wrote:
Why is this forum still here if it doesnt change, just message the curator of Turbowarp, maybe that will help

No it wont

Wifisurfer1

i want higher upload size to 10MB

GUZEGGAMERGUY

agreed

SkyCedar

Bump! I think this topic is pretty important, people could do a lot more on scratch if the limit was increased!

FantasticDolphin44

Support! Would make textures easier to upload to Scratch, and games could be bigger and more fun, not to mention more realistic (bigger texture files).

Thethree13

FantasticDolphin44 wrote:
Support! Would make textures easier to upload to Scratch, and games could be bigger and more fun, not to mention more realistic (bigger texture files).

It would help to make projects bigger, but not for textures. The 5mb limit isn't for assets (like images/music) but for code. So textures would be the same.

Zippy02

Thethree13 wrote:
FantasticDolphin44 wrote:
Support! Would make textures easier to upload to Scratch, and games could be bigger and more fun, not to mention more realistic (bigger texture files).
It would help to make projects bigger, but not for textures. The 5mb limit isn't for assets (like images/music) but for code. So textures would be the same.

I think he is talking about textures for 3D projects which are stored in lists. But I don't think this is a problem as creating image scanners and storing lists in separate projects for users to export/import might be solutions.

FantasticDolphin44

Zippy02 wrote:
Thethree13 wrote:
FantasticDolphin44 wrote:
Support! Would make textures easier to upload to Scratch, and games could be bigger and more fun, not to mention more realistic (bigger texture files).
It would help to make projects bigger, but not for textures. The 5mb limit isn't for assets (like images/music) but for code. So textures would be the same.
I think he is talking about textures for 3D projects which are stored in lists. But I don't think this is a problem as creating image scanners and storing lists in separate projects for users to export/import might be solutions.

Yes, I am talking about 3D textures. Lists are ideal, if there wasn't a project limit. Images are what I have to use for bigger projects. It would be very convenient to be able to use lists.

MisterB34U

increase increase increase

Discuss Scratch