The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013

-ThatOneGuitarist-

Hot Takes!! (Intense music) Assemble.
Graaaaaah

Generations 3DS is better than Generations console
Sonic Forces' modern levels are great
Mystic Cave zone kinda sucks (it's so slow)
Spring Yard is the second best Sonic 1 stage
Sonic Rush is udder garbage
Sonic Colors DS is better than Sonic Colors Wii
Sonic Advance is the worst of the trilogy
Wing Fortress is great (there are skips, high speed parts, etc)
Sonic Adventure 2 is mean (why did they lock Green Hill behind 180 emblems?

)

Comix_2

Comix_2

-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
Hot Takes!! (Intense music) Assemble.
Graaaaaah

Generations 3DS is better than Generations console
Sonic Forces' modern levels are great
Mystic Cave zone kinda sucks (it's so slow)
Spring Yard is the second best Sonic 1 stage
Sonic Rush is udder garbage
Sonic Colors DS is better than Sonic Colors Wii
Sonic Advance is the worst of the trilogy
Wing Fortress is great (there are skips, high speed parts, etc)
Sonic Adventure 2 is mean (why did they lock Green Hill behind 180 emblems? )

what
huh
true
what
what
true
what
true
skill issue

sonic__fan

-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
Generations 3DS is better than Generations console

LOL, this is actually a hot take, cause Generations 3DS is kinda bad.

-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
Sonic Forces' modern levels are great

You enjoy running in a straight line for 30 seconds to then go into a 2D section?

-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
Spring Yard is the second best Sonic 1 stage

3rd best, but still a really good stage.

-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
Wing Fortress is great (there are skips, high speed parts, etc)

Agreed.

-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
Sonic Adventure 2 is mean (why did they lock Green Hill behind 180 emblems? )

This one isn't something I disagree with; it's just stupid. This was Sonic's 10th anniversary and last game on a Sega platform. They wanted to do something cool to celebrate, so they decided to give you a neat little unlockable. It's not like the stage itself is really cool or anything, it's literally the original stage in 3D now, but it's the fact it's there at all.

sonic__fan

Comix_2 wrote:

Hold up, how is SA2 over SA2 Battle? And how is 06 a B-tier game?

Comix_2

sonic__fan wrote:
Comix_2 wrote:

Hold up, how is SA2 over SA2 Battle? And how is 06 a B-tier game?

sa2 battle has a bunch of glitches and i like the gameplay of P06

hashdashpotato

Comix_2 wrote:

Sonic 3D Blast does not deserve that low of a ranking.

-ThatOneGuitarist-

Comix_2 wrote:

How did Unwiished get so low

sonic__fan

Comix_2 wrote:
sonic__fan wrote:
Comix_2 wrote:

Hold up, how is SA2 over SA2 Battle? And how is 06 a B-tier game?
sa2 battle has a bunch of glitches and i like the gameplay of P06

I haven't experienced many glitches in SA2 Battle, so now I'm curious.
As for 06 and P-06, those are two very different beasts.

-ThatOneGuitarist-

Edit: For context these are all mainline 2d games

Last edited by -ThatOneGuitarist- (Dec. 24, 2025 01:10:30)

hashdashpotato

-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:

Edit: For context these are all mainline 2d games

Okay, while Sonic Colors DS is good, it's not that good. Sonic Mania is way better too.

-ThatOneGuitarist-

hashdashpotato wrote:
-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:

Edit: For context these are all mainline 2d games
Okay, while Sonic Colors DS is good, it's not that good. Sonic Mania is way better too.

I think it perfected boosting in 2D. I like Mania, but not as much. (I think personally Sonic Colors DS is the best video game of all time)

Comix_2

-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
Comix_2 wrote:
-snip-
How did Unwiished get so low

I just don't like it

-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
hashdashpotato wrote:
-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
-snip-

Edit: For context these are all mainline 2d games
Okay, while Sonic Colors DS is good, it's not that good. Sonic Mania is way better too.
I think it perfected boosting in 2D. I like Mania, but not as much. (I think personally Sonic Colors DS is the best video game of all time)

You need to play more video games, also why is Gens 3DS so high up

-ThatOneGuitarist-

Comix_2 wrote:
-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
Comix_2 wrote:
-snip-
How did Unwiished get so low
I just don't like it
-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
hashdashpotato wrote:
-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
-snip-

Edit: For context these are all mainline 2d games
Okay, while Sonic Colors DS is good, it's not that good. Sonic Mania is way better too.
I think it perfected boosting in 2D. I like Mania, but not as much. (I think personally Sonic Colors DS is the best video game of all time)
You need to play more video games, also why is Gens 3DS so high up

Ok in all honesty,

Ive basically played like 4 franchises and then Minecraft.
(Mario, Rayman, Sonic, Pokemon)

Comix_2

Merry Christmas Eve

-ThatOneGuitarist-

Comix_2 wrote:

Merry Christmas Eve

Stalker ahh

SPIKEdahedgeboi

Comix_2 wrote:

Merry Christmas Eve

never knew sonic liked champagne..

-ThatOneGuitarist-

SPIKEdahedgeboi wrote:
Comix_2 wrote:

Merry Christmas Eve

never knew sonic liked champagne..

i didnt notice that but that is wild

hashdashpotato

-ThatOneGuitarist- wrote:
SPIKEdahedgeboi wrote:
Comix_2 wrote:
Snip?

never knew sonic liked champagne..
i didnt notice that but that is wild

Wait, does that mean that sonic is a….

1000metalpipes

Eggman can easily defeat Sonic and possibly even kill him, yet he chooses not to.

Last edited by 1000metalpipes (Dec. 24, 2025 18:58:19)

Discuss Scratch