Discuss Scratch
- Discussion Forums
- » Things I'm Reading and Playing
- » The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
![[RSS Feed]](//cdn.scratch.mit.edu/scratchr2/static/__5f750b17a17db0b5d7ffaf5afb2e7e2b__//djangobb_forum/img/feed-icon-small.png "[RSS Feed]")
![[RSS Feed]](http://cdn.scratch.mit.edu/scratchr2/static/__5f750b17a17db0b5d7ffaf5afb2e7e2b__//djangobb_forum/img/feed-icon-small.png "[RSS Feed]"){kind=icon}
- keyboardyaycat
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
I like how technically only 1 out of 3 of these is true in Frontiers.and you would play levels =OHey, what if they made a Sonic game… where you played as Sonic???
and the main villain would be eggman :0
- sonic__fan
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
sounds like a pretty bad gameand you would play levels =OHey, what if they made a Sonic game… where you played as Sonic???and the main villain would be eggman :0
- hashdashpotato
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
I mean, who would ever want to play that? Definitely not me.sounds like a pretty bad gameand you would play levels =OHey, what if they made a Sonic game… where you played as Sonic???and the main villain would be eggman :0
- Comix_2
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
Sonic games I've played ranked best to worst:HOW in the world is sonic CD so low? It's REALLY good. No wonder the OST is my #1 album on spotify
Sonic Mania
Sonic Unleashed
Sonic Colors (Ultimate)
Sonic X Shadow Generations
Sonic Adventure 2
Sonic Adventure
Sonic 3&k
Sonic Advance 2
Sonic 2
Team Sonic Racing
Sonic Racing Crossworlds
Sonic Advance
Sonic Advance 3
Sonic 4 Episode 3 By Scratch
Sonic 4 Episode 2
Sonic 1
Sonic CD
Sonic Supersouls
Sonic 4 Episode 1
The Game Gear games
- -ThatOneGuitarist-
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
I hear a remake of SA1, SA2, or Heroes is coming out for 35th Sonic Anniversary:
Which one is currently not available on modern hardware?
Which one doesn't have a remake?
Which one doesn't have a Chao garden?
Sonic Heroes.
In all honesty, Sonic Adventure needs a remake the most, but Sonic Adventure 2 would be a better choice.
Possible changes for each game:
Sonic Adventure:
Fixed animation and voice acting line-up
New voice acting
Remastered music
Some side campaign probably
Sonic Adventure 2:
Remastered music
More clean Rouge model
New levels (a new side campaign, a few more 180 emblem levels, or both)
Open world option for level select
Characters won't interrupt each other any more
Mad Space and Meteor Herd made smaller and easier
Sonic Heroes:
Smoother gameplay at 60 fps
Chao Gardens
HD
Level select for levels you have completed
Which one is currently not available on modern hardware?
Which one doesn't have a remake?
Which one doesn't have a Chao garden?
Sonic Heroes.
In all honesty, Sonic Adventure needs a remake the most, but Sonic Adventure 2 would be a better choice.
Possible changes for each game:
Sonic Adventure:
Fixed animation and voice acting line-up
New voice acting
Remastered music
Some side campaign probably
Sonic Adventure 2:
Remastered music
More clean Rouge model
New levels (a new side campaign, a few more 180 emblem levels, or both)
Open world option for level select
Characters won't interrupt each other any more
Mad Space and Meteor Herd made smaller and easier
Sonic Heroes:
Smoother gameplay at 60 fps
Chao Gardens
HD
Level select for levels you have completed
Last edited by -ThatOneGuitarist- (Dec. 10, 2025 23:27:10)
- keyboardyaycat
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
They should make SA3 fill the gap between Sonic Heroes and Sonic RushEverybody knows that Eraser canonically fills that gap, though… /j
Last edited by keyboardyaycat (Dec. 10, 2025 23:26:50)
- rexygames13
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
Yeah sounds like a pretty bad idea, I don't think that will sell 15 million copies and become one of the highest selling platformer games of all time,I mean, who would ever want to play that? Definitely not me.sounds like a pretty bad gameand you would play levels =OHey, what if they made a Sonic game… where you played as Sonic???and the main villain would be eggman :0
(No actually highest selling platformer game belongs to Mario, which we probably all knew by now)- sonic__fan
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
I hear a remake of SA1, SA2, or Heroes is coming out for 35th Sonic Anniversary:You got a source for this?
Which one is currently not available on modern hardware?Actually, SA1 and SA2 fit the first two criteria. Neither game is on modern hardware (besides Steam and Xbox via backwards compatibility), and neither game has a remake.
Which one doesn't have a remake?
Which one doesn't have a Chao garden?
Sonic Heroes.
In all honesty, Sonic Adventure needs a remake the most, but Sonic Adventure 2 would be a better choice.Why? SA1 needs a remake, SA2 doesn't.
Possible changes for each game:Why does the music need to be remastered???????? The music is already the best part of the game, no need to touch it up!
Sonic Adventure:
Fixed animation and voice acting line-up
New voice acting
Remastered music
Some side campaign probably
The game also does not need any sort of side campaign. I really do not understand this topic's tendency to try to add one to every previous Sonic game; I swear I saw a “Sonic X Blaze Frontiers” earlier today. All that's needed from a gameplay perspective is the ranking system. That's all.
Sonic Adventure 2:Again, we do not need remastered music. SA2's OST is already one of the best in the series, a clear S tier; do not mess with it.
Remastered music
More clean Rouge model
New levels (a new side campaign, a few more 180 emblem levels, or both)
Open world option for level select
Characters won't interrupt each other any more
Mad Space and Meteor Herd made smaller and easier
As for Rouge's model, yeah, please, tone it down a bit.
I don't think the game needs new levels; there's already thirty of them (thirty-one, technically). However, I do have two ideas for emblems.
- When you beat all of a character's missions, you unlock their alt costume (for example, you unlock Jumpsuit Sonic)
- When you S Rank all of a character's missions, you unlock their alt character (for example, you'll unlock Amy by S Ranking all of Sonic's missions)
As for Mad Space and Meteor Herd… I dunno, it would be cool to have an actually fun version of Mad Space, but at the same time, those two stages are known for being so hard and so big.
Sonic Heroes:No complaints here.
Smoother gameplay at 60 fps
Chao Gardens
HD
Level select for levels you have completed
- -ThatOneGuitarist-
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
Stuff1. Dude, I literally said in a previous post about the jumpsuits and beneficial alts.
2. I was talking about probable changes, not wanted changes
- Magudragon
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
- -ThatOneGuitarist-
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
TODAYWhen is game awards
- Magudragon
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
7:30 PM ETTODAYWhen is game awards
- -ThatOneGuitarist-
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
How Many Sonic Games Included Level Remakes?
Sonic Generations (dont even)
Shadow Generations (ditto)
Sonic Generations 3DS (ditto)
Sonic Adventure 2 (green hill)
Sonic Advance (angel island)
Sonic Forces (green hill, chemical plant, death egg)
Sonic Frontiers (heck the whole game has like 4 unique levels
Sonic Mania (all but 4 levels are remade)
For reference, I believe that Sonic Colors splits a timeline. One is Colors DS and one for Console.
The console goes on…Generations Console, Lost World, Forces, Frontiers
The DS goes on…Generations 3DS, Lost World 3DS, Sonic Boom
Sonic Generations (dont even)
Shadow Generations (ditto)
Sonic Generations 3DS (ditto)
Sonic Adventure 2 (green hill)
Sonic Advance (angel island)
Sonic Forces (green hill, chemical plant, death egg)
Sonic Frontiers (heck the whole game has like 4 unique levels
Sonic Mania (all but 4 levels are remade)
For reference, I believe that Sonic Colors splits a timeline. One is Colors DS and one for Console.
The console goes on…Generations Console, Lost World, Forces, Frontiers
The DS goes on…Generations 3DS, Lost World 3DS, Sonic Boom
Last edited by -ThatOneGuitarist- (Dec. 11, 2025 13:07:20)
- sonic__fan
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
1. Dude, I literally said in a previous post about the jumpsuits and beneficial alts.I never saw that.
2. I was talking about probable changes, not wanted changesLOL. I do not believe that Sega is gonna change that much.
- In Colors Ultimate, they made one gameplay change
- In SXSG, they made absolutely zero gameplay changes and instead just added a new campaign
Last edited by sonic__fan (Dec. 11, 2025 15:21:35)
- qqjonson1234
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
- 1000metalpipes
-
Scratcher
100+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
I'm unegging your Man.
- -ThatOneGuitarist-
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
In SXSG, they made absolutely zero gameplay changes and instead just added a new campaignThey added Drop Dash to both characters, and I think the stomp for modern.
And these are needed to not literally be the same game as the HD version from 2012 (for SA1/SA2), and the original release of Heroes. (alright maybe not the new voice lines though…that's a stretch)
Last edited by -ThatOneGuitarist- (Dec. 11, 2025 17:06:14)
- -ThatOneGuitarist-
-
Scratcher
500+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
Sonic Origins 2:
Knuckles' Chaotix
Sonic 3D Blast
Sonic Advance
Sonic Adventure
Sonic Shuffle
Sonic Advance 2
Sonic Battle
Sonic Advance 3
Sonic Adventure 2
Knuckles' Chaotix
Sonic 3D Blast
Sonic Advance
Sonic Adventure
Sonic Shuffle
Sonic Advance 2
Sonic Battle
Sonic Advance 3
Sonic Adventure 2
- keyboardyaycat
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
Sonic Origins 2:Actually, that sounds pretty stacked. I'd definitely buy that.
Knuckles' Chaotix
Sonic 3D Blast
Sonic Advance
Sonic Adventure
Sonic Shuffle
Sonic Advance 2
Sonic Battle
Sonic Advance 3
Sonic Adventure 2
- Magudragon
-
Scratcher
1000+ posts
The Sonic the Hedgehog Topic VII: Arguing About Knuckles Since 2013
I would have sacrificed the new voice lines for 3 new classic stages, not that the new voice lines were a bad choice.In SXSG, they made absolutely zero gameplay changes and instead just added a new campaignThey added Drop Dash to both characters, and I think the stomp for modern.
And these are needed to not literally be the same game as the HD version from 2012 (for SA1/SA2), and the original release of Heroes. (alright maybe not the new voice lines though…that's a stretch)