Discuss Scratch

Top-notch-Games
Scratcher
6 posts

Upload Video Extension

This “Upload Video” extension will work when you have/want to upload a video.

Flie Type
● .MP4,MOV or WebM can be supported in this extension.
Or for more video file types:
New video file types:
WMV,MKV

Older but still supported:
AVI,VOB

Video Size
This restricts on how much a video size can be avoiding lag.
●700 MB or 1GB

For bigger sizes:
1.5 GB or 2.5 GB

At max:
3 GB

How to upload?
1. Copy-paste the video URL
2.Upload a video from File Explorer/Finder like how you can upload a sound.

Purpose:
The purpose of this “Upload Video” is that you upload a video to show information/content easily instead of making it by code and costumes.
(Great for new scratchers or scratchers who don't want to code to much.)


Overall,this shoundn't replace the coding in Scratch.
Alex5002
Scratcher
86 posts

Upload Video Extension

Reported to be moved to Suggestions.
mtaka4
Scratcher
100+ posts

Upload Video Extension

Support, if it has a message like this.
Please make sure anyone's face is not included in the video.
_Paymer
Scratcher
30 posts

Upload Video Extension

Interesting idea. Need clarification:
1. Wouldn't 1 GB, let alone 3 GB be too big to store in a scratch project?(Some projects already struggle with only around 2-10mb)
2. Would it need a new blocks category?(Could be hard to make for scratch team)
3. Would it work like a video player or just display the video?
Partial support
763869
Scratcher
36 posts

Upload Video Extension

This is a great idea. I support this. But like the post above, this needs additional clarification. Short answer: Main issues are Functionality, Moderation, and File Storage.

Long answer (This was long when I finished writing this. It is shortened for the sake of your time.):
1. Functionality
It is not clear how the video will get processed and played. Will it be imported as a sprite or embedded in a video player? If it's uploaded as a sprite, then how will it get converted? If it's embedded, then where will the video be hosted? Please edit your post to explain this.

2. Moderation

mtaka4 wrote:

Support, if it has a message like this.
Please make sure anyone's face is not included in the video.
It would be more than just anyone's face. Anything could be uploaded that goes against the guidelines, and would be visible to anyone. This includes excessive profanity, mild violence and sexual content (This is not a full list). This requires a large moderation team which is not available right now.

3. Cloud Storage

_Paymer wrote:

1. Wouldn't 1 GB, let alone 3 GB be too big to store in a scratch project?(Some projects already struggle with only around 2-10mb)
Right now, 10 MB is the maximum size for a single project. Most videos are larger than this. Which means most projects that make use of this will be larger than 10 MB. The rest will be larger than 1 MB. This is above the ST's limits, and they would need large amounts of data storage. It will also increase project load times, even for bad connections.

Powered by DjangoBB